The Romney high command had cloaked the system in secrecy to maintain what it hoped would be a true competitive turnout advantage. But by limiting the number of people with access to Orca, the campaign was not able to train its field operatives to use it or do the necessary beta-testing to work out the kinks that typically plague new software.
“It did not work perfectly,” said Rich Beeson, the Romney campaign’s political director, in an interview. He acknowledged that Orca crashed in the morning on Election Day. At first the campaign thought the system had been hacked, he said. Passwords and user names for the 34,000 volunteers using the program had to be reset.
I once started a job at a florist’s shop on Valentine’s Day. I was in high school, there was no Internet, and I didn’t know a Peruvian lily from a bromeliad. It was a fucking disaster. My training consisted of being taught how to open the register drawer. The phone never stopped ringing. People were coming in asking for things I had no idea if we could give them. Clueless assholes who apparently never HEARD of Valentine’s Day were begging us to make arrangements with the “my wife’s gonna kill me” plea and I wanted to brand a calendar onto their arms, like it’s the same day every year, geniuses. We ran out of roses and then we ran out of everything else, to the point where the last guy who wandered in at 9 p.m. looking like he’d been run over by a bus got a green plant for which we charged him $50 and I wanted to include a card for a relationship counselor.
You know what I learned from that experience? Ninety percent of emergencies are the result of piss-poor planning and managerial laziness. Who the fuck starts a high school kid employee with no training at a florist on Valentine’s Day? It irritates me just thinking about it now, like there was no reason that day had to be that stressful for everyone involved. I thought of that when I read this:
But Beeson also said Orca was able to provide voting data on 91 percent of the precincts and accounted for turning out some 14.3 million voters. “At the end of the day I can look any donor in the eye and say we used our resources effectively,” he said. “This is the first time we have attempted to do anything on this scale. By no means was it an abject failure.”
Actually, it kind of was, given that your candidate lost resoundingly. A victory is not that your program is shiny. A victory is that it does what it’s supposed to do.
Who the fuck rolls out a brand-new operation on fucking ELECTION DAY? Who does this? This is the world’s most easily preventable clusterfuck, and they managed not to prevent it. Was there nobody in the room screaming that “let’s take a bash at this and see if it works, Biff” is a terrible way to handle the days when things matter?
After watching the RNC I’m not surprised things went down this way, but if I was a donor and this guy looked me in the eye and said they used their resources effectively, I’d kick him in the dick. You’ve got to be kidding me. Mr. A and I rehearsed our wedding more seriously than this, and neither of us was in the running for leadership of the free world at the end of that day.
A.



55 Comments





Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Allison!
A truly lovely rant and spot on. You have also identified the central flaw of both capitalism and conservatism.
HAHAAAHAAA.
I think Karl may be laying low right now for just that reason.
One of the more absurd things in Star Trek episodes was how they never had time to test anything. They were always about to be blown out of the sky, smack into a planet or have their engines explode so they had to come up with an ingenious solution by the seats of their collective pants and hey, presto! It always worked, leaving Kirk, Picard, Janeway and Archer to warp away into the sunset, telling wry jokes and no worse for the wear. Guess what Willard? Life isn’t Star Trek. It just isn’t.
I wish I could say this was surprising but unfortunately is is common practice in the corporate world right now and yes this also includes the public sector.
Somehow a total lack of common sense and intuitive thought has crept into our culture especially those who have had some higher education.
This and the fact that ladders need stickers that tell you not to use the second to the top or top step lest you fall and break you sorry neck. Or that electronic equipment that is specifically designed for and targeted to a high tech FCC licensed community has to have a sticker that tells the user that 200 volts will electrocute him/her should tell you the level of individual we are talking about.
America is getting stupid.
I’ll bet Karl’s at The Hair Club for Men, getting a disguise together…
Good bet. I do not think that the Koch brothers deal well with rejection, or being taken for a ride.
They have always been that stupid, we just acknowledge it now and take measures to minimize the damage.
Yeah, about that Raw Story piece, I don’t know what that clown is doing but he didn’t say “America” and it’s not science.
Rove needs a disguise lest the Kochs take HIM for a ride.
The Romney campaign really was an exercise in stupidity and incompetence. It’s a sad comment on the state of this country that he could even come close in the popular vote.
Once again, the Democrats try to rescue the Republicans from themselves. This election would have never been close had Obama not been a really crappy Democrat.
The bad news for the Kochs is that they’d have to get extra concrete for Rove’s shoes. I’m pretty sure that the man’s ass could be used as an emergency flotation device.
No, it is not science at all. It is pure bullshit. If anything, there is more selective pressure for intelligence now than there was in the paleolithic. It is also the case that intelligence is not just about genes. Diet, intellectual stimulation during brain development, disease, exposure to environmental toxins, and many other factors have a profound impact on the development and functioning of the brain.
Aloha, Allison…! I think this post from the ‘belly of the beast’, Ace of Spades, best summed it up…! The Unmitigated Disaster Known As Project ORCA…
It was a major f*ckup from the get-go…! ;-)
I was going to say his swollen head but that’s probably been deflated a bit.
Oh well then. Can you explain Romney, the republicans, a large number of democrats…and actually most of congress any other way ?
That really is typical of conservatives. Pretty much everything they touch turns to shit.
Most indubitably, Dr. D…! Why would they expect any other outcome, these daze…? ;-)
Of course it’s bullshit and since a “theory” is an idea used to explain observed phenomena, and Crabtree doesn’t even have that, it’s right up there with creationism and intelligent design. To be honest when I read it, it reminded me of times when I would smoke pot and come up with some absurd notion and think, “Aha!” to myself and how this was going to change the world. The only difference is, when I came down, I laughed at myself and went about my day.
The fact that I can’t explain why those people you name act like self serving idiots to your satisfaction is not evidence that Crabtree is right.
Other than the ones whose mamas dropped them on their heads, for the Republicans much of it is their delusional belief system. For the Democrats, and the rest of the Republicans, it is simply the application of Upton Sinclair’s Law.
It was only a matter of time. When you start off with a flawed premise, everything that arises from it is also flawed. Eventually the failure becomes exponential.
Reminds me of much of the Evolutionary Psychology bullshit.
On the other hand…
The Obama campaign had something like this on e-day back in 2008, at least in VA, and, by hearsay, in at least a few other Atlantic states. We were supposed to key in ID for voters off the good guy list who had already voted, so that election day GOTV could be directed only at people on the list who hadn’t voted. What we keyed in was going to be processed by a central server, then spat back at the office cutting the GOTV turfs, so they would cut turfs that only had volunteers knocking doors or calling phones of people who hadn’t voted yet.
Directed e-day GOTV, known more colloquially as flushing (evoking gamebirds I hope, not toilets) is a great idea in theory, and we’ve tried it locally many times even without some computer solution to help implement it. But it just never works in practice. Too unwieldy, too many moving parts. The computer system didn’t work in 2008 either. Apparently thay hadn’t left enough ports open to accept the sheer size and number of the data dumps from the field, all arriving at the same time. The system just ground to a halt. We ended up having to flush blind, like we do every year. In 2008 it was multiple passes of the entire universe, because the volunteers were there in numbers sufficient to do that, so we really didn’t need directed flushing anyway.
Look, maybe you can get a single retail site like a florist’s right, maybe you can and should not make an essentially untrained newbie fly solo on her first day, that day being Valentine’s Day, because that work task is definable, and that solution is clearly inadequate. But directed flushing is just inherently undoable — too many actors needing to all mesh, on a task that can’tr be replicated on anything like the scale of e-day until e-day itself. Yet people on both sides, smart people as well as dunces, keep trying, because it seems like such a great idea in theory. The Romnney campaign is to be faulted for much that they did, but I’m not sure this particular failure wasn’t just a pretty standard and understandable screw-up.
Oh, and this year, in my part of VA at least, it was blind flushing on our side. We didn’t even try to do it smart — which was the smart move.
Whether he is right or wrong is to be determined by others, I should think. But to assume that humans have somehow arrived at some degree of intellectual superiority to me at any rate is rather arrogant at best.
Oh god, I’d forgotten about that! Just so, yep. Pretend a phenomenon exists and then build a ridiculous construct to explain it. I think he’s competing for some grant money. What gets me is how widely published this tripe is. NBC picked it up too.
It is equally stupid to think they have gotten dumber. There is simply no evidence, or any way to find any, either way. As I said above, if anything, the evidence suggests that there is actually more selective pressure to intelligence in the modern world than in the distant past. It really does not take a lot of intelligence to hunt (witness all the good old boys around here who fill the freezer every year) or to do simple agriculture. Driving a car or negotiating the social milieu of a major city requires much greater intellectual acuity.
No! That is a false premise. It CAN’T be determined whether he is right or wrong so it fails the test for being science. Science has to be predictable, testable and reproducible. Period. What this yahoo is proposing isn’t even an observed phenomenon. He is speculating that people were smarter 50,000 years ago because “adverse genetic mutations fail to be weeded out by evolutionary pressures”. That is an ASSUMPTION. That is NOT an observation. Science and what some joker thinks is a neat idea are not interchangeable. They just aren’t.
I have never understood this strain of elitism you espouse.
In my experience, collective humans are quite smart, while individuals can be quite wrong. Just for instance on war polling. 69% say “Blech” on Afghanistan since March of this year.
So, sometimes it takes people a while to come around, but come around they do.
Same/similar on SocSec, Medicare, and so on. People are not so dumb as others want to make them out, and I just don’t think blaming people is a good idea. Systems, rigged crap, yes. People, collectively? No. Just no evidence.
Here is a issue I have been thinking about.
We beat the Kochs, and Rove and Rommney and their money.
But does that mean that the funders on the left will now find In their wallets money for activist like us?
No. They will Not. The right pays for infrastructure and lost, the left doesn’t and wins. Why should they?
And the the supreme. Court will say, “See, you can’t buy an election!”
Touchy…touchy.
True. The biggest problem is ignorance and false knowledge, not stupidity.
Yep, that part sucks. I’m sure the Roberts court is feeling very smug about their Citizens United decision right about now. Also it might make people complacent. Just because it didn’t work this time doesn’t mean it won’t ever.
Not at all. I’m explaining the definition of science since you seem confused.
We need to banish all private money from elections and go to an entirely publicly financed system. Everyone who gets on the ballot gets the same amount of money to spend and the same amount of free airtime on TV and radio.
Spot on. An IQ test measures how somebody thinks, not what they know. Similarly opinion can’t be exchanged for empirical knowledge and be effective. That brings us back to our topic. You can’t just decide how something is because that suits your point of view. If I wanted all cows to be green, saying they are isn’t going to make them so.
There is a substantial body of research in political science that shows money has a strong, though not always determinant, effect on electoral outcomes. Other factors are also important and no amount of lipstick was going to make that particular pig look attractive.
LOVELY read, if there was a button I’d rcc’d it heartily.
Ya can’t fix stoopid.
He’s had a HUGE run for decades, but at this point, he should be checking his brake lines every time he drives. N that’s a good thing.
Of course and the money played an enormous role in making such a shitty candidate with such a crappy clown car campaign come so close. Almost nothing is so simple though. There were literally hundreds of factors that determined the outcome of the race. That money might have put a better candidate over the top.
Actually, a lot of what IQ tests measure is knowledge of various sorts. They are notoriously culture bound and misogynist, favoring professional class white American or European males.
This is how you ‘splain Wall Street, Citizens United and red states?
Diet? Climate change?
*G*
Loved the comment, honestly. Always enjoy when you share some of your expertise in your field with us . . .
Too much fun not to poke it some, tho . . . ;-)
I was speaking generally. I was going to add that many IQ tests presume that one can read and do arithmetic on at least a basic high school level but it seemed a bit long. Also yes, culturally many IQ tests, (most) are biased.
Upton Sinclair explained it better than I ever can.
“It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it!”
I should toddle off. Take care all.
I read that Scarborough went off on the right wing media. The same guy who, when it pointed out to him that the Republican party still views women as little more than incubators, began shouting “Benghazi” to drown that person out.
I don’t think conservatives get irony.
Good night. Me too I think. Tomorrow comes early.
It worked fine!
Citizens United bought the best possible corporate fascist stooge, just like the last time when there wasn’t any Citizens United.
Corps/billionaires, Obama, it’s a win/win!
And the dismantling of representative democracy along with the works of FDR and LBJ continues apace, a FEVERED pace, it seems, with Obama ALL IN for the rich, not so much for the rest of us.
Yeah, in a dream world long ago that was the case.
It’s long gone, and I see NO way of wresting the controls of these things from the one’s who own and operate it all, top to bottom.
It’s game over, dark ages upon us.
Now it’s only a matter of time when it all collapses. As it always does.
Yep.
Enjoy your nihilism. May it comfort you, mightily.
I first read about this from the right-wing blog Ace of Spades. Yeah, they had a neat, money-saving idea. 34,000+ stations would all print their own 60+ page voter lists so that volunteers could check off the names of those who had voted and then report back who needed to be contacted.
Volunteers received their emails with the 60+ page PDFs at 4:00pm of the day before they had to be on-station, up and ready. Great idea, for those with access to corporate laser printers that spit out 12 pages a minute. For volunteers with bubble-jet printers that do a perfectly adequate job of printing maybe half-a-dozen pages, ehhh, not so much.
This needs to be set up better. The subject of the article kind of goes missing. They devised a program to do what, etcetera. Needs a lead and a bit of explanation, then you can ridicule it.
Let me get this straight. The latest GOP excuse for losing so badly and wasting so much donor money is that new software failed!!?? Oh, brother!!!!
Let’s see how many real reasons I can list off. Extremely poor candidates. Extremely poor campaign. Extreme policies. Constantly shifting messages. Open distain for anyone other than wealthy white males and subserviant wealthy white females. Obvious lying. No connection with everyday Americans. No record of excellance to run on. Denial of statistical methods, global warming and changing demographics. Pandering to the sickies in our society. Disregard for our troops and their families. Openly working to deny Americans their right to vote. Obscene spending. Obnoxious advertising. Refusing to disclose taxes. A pet dancing horse. No military records for at least four generations through over a half dozen wars, yet the guy expected to be Commander In Chief. I’d go on but the above makes me wonder how Romney Ryan carried any state after Utah.