Tonight’s guest Sue Wilson is a firebrand – smart, driven and articulate. A longtime journalist, she got fired up about how the public airways, which belong to the citizens, are controlled by mega-corps which do not act in the public interest. Broadcast Blues, which she wrote, directed and narrates traces the history of the airwaves, the gutting of the Fairness Doctrine, and explains how the consolidation of stations has limited Americans access to a wide range of voices and views—and has actually put citizens at physical risk during emergencies.
As I write this I am watching a cable infomerical from the National Rifle Association, a pitch to join and “stand with the NRA,” essentially a half-hour long anti-Obama election message, gussied up with fear-mongering against the United Nations and footage of the London riots. In Broadcast Blues Wilson demonstrates that now the airwaves belong to those who can pay for them, and with the elimination of the Fairness Doctrine, there is no requirement for broadcasters to present opposing views.
Broadcast Blues lays out how we got to this point of corporate monopolies in news, how it affects the information we hear and see, and what we can do about it. How can we ensure that the news informs rather than deforms our opinions? Why isn’t the FCC more responsive to citizens’ complaints, unless they have to do with the F-word or wardrobe malfunction? These questions and many more about the ineffectiveness of the FCC come to light as Wilson goes head to head with the agency under the Freedom of Information Act.
Since the film has been made, Sue Wilson has been doing plenty to stir things up—and she’ll be filling us in on her efforts and what we can do to return to the airwaves to us.




71 Comments





Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Sue, Welcome to the Lake.
Before we start, just a couple quick notes:
Make sure you are logged in to comment. Please refresh your browser every minute or so to see new comments, questions and answers.
Please be respectful of each other and our guest.
To reply to specific comment, hit the reply button underneath it and then type away. Always hit “send comment.” Thanks!
Please stay on topic/s–in this case tonight’s guest Sue Wilson and the reality show Broadcast Blues, the Foarness Doctrine, the FCC, and related issues If you’d like to discuss today’s other newsworthy matters, please find a post elsewhere on FDL to do so. Thank you. And yeah, I tpye badly…
Welcome to Firedoglake Movie Night, Sue and thank you so very much for being here tonight!
Hi, Lisa, it’s a great place to be on a hot summer’s day!
Sue, was their one specific incident that inspired Braidcast Blues, or a slow build up?
I think you mean me, Sue Wilson. :-)
Thank you for a great film and all your work on media. I look forward to hear what you have been up to since the end of the film.
Lisa, I worked as a broadcast journalist starting at KCBS, CBS’s local TV Channel 2 in L.A>. That was 1987, and I was there the day the Fairness Doctrine went away. I remember management saying that at CBS, they would always do the issue oriented programming I had been producing, bnot because they were requiered to do it but because it was the right thing to do.
Five years later, KCBS disbanded the entire community programming department.
Ah templates! Thanks, and fixed! Sue, I pretty disturbed to learn from Broadcast Blues that it’s legal to lie in a news story!
It’s a terrific film and everyone should watch it.
What can we do to get our airwaves back?
I remember the public interest programming, usually it was early Sunday mornings, cultural shows etc. and also editorials at the end of news programs, and the opposing view editorials they;dhave on in response.
Yes, it is legal for news stations to lie to the public. It is not illegal to make mistakes. And owning up to any mistake is the hallmark of a good journailist! :-)
Yes. I produced a show called At Issue – it ran about 6:00 Sunday mornings. We covered controverial issues of interest to the local community. We got about a 2 rating on a good day – but that meant those shows were seen by about 200,000 people, a lot of people became educated.
Thanks, Elliott! We have started a new action group called Media Action Center to get folks to put boots on the ground and take back our broadcast airwaves.
I miss the “local news” I grew up with. What is happening in your city/county/state. Is there any push-back now to get local programming back?
But if reporters can lie, then how will the public learn what’s going on in the world? Basically this lays open a whole “War of the Wars” scenario with no consequences.
What does Media Action Center do?
This is scary stuff.
David Brock of Media Matters told me for Broadcast Blues that studies going back a generation show the “Conservative Movement” has deliberately been lying to the public and trying to overtake journalism. (I don;t think that all made it into the final cut btw)
So how, then, do we get any modicum of trust? This answers Bev’s q and Eliott’s too -
It starts by understanding that WE own the local and TV airwaves.
We are physical owners, and we have joined in partnership with the big media corps who own all the microphones and technology. It is a public provate partnership.
And the local stations get licensed to operate – like we get licensed to drive a car – ONLY IF they “Serve the public interest.”
but they radio stations have been telling people for a generation that only they have First Amendment rights. But guess what? In Red Lion V FCC, SCOTUS ruled made two significant rulings. First, that in broadcasting, the first amendment rights of the viewers and listeners are paramount over the broadcasters.
think about that one.
And also, because radio airwaves are so scarce, (there are only a few in any one town,) SCOTUS said that stations may not engage in “Private Censorship” – not permitting people to access the microphones.
It’s amazing how quickly the FCC acts on a wardrobe malfunction or f-bomb, but what about lies, inaccuracies, etc?
Have you researched the increase in corporations/businesses that now “do the paperwork” (lobby for) for the radio station to get frequencies?
[disclaimer - I was a federal/agency frequency manager]
Who is beyond Clear Channel?
The new 10w (?) stations do not need licenses and would cover a small town. Are there more low-watt stations going in now?
So – Media Action Center is the grassroots org that came from Broadcast Blues screenings across the country. We did an 11 city tour of Florida last year, and eight city tour of Wisconsin. We screened at a few Occupy camps, and at individual cities across the country.
The thing wee learned was after seeing Broadcast Blues, after really getting it that we have OWNERSHIP RIGHTS, everybody wanted to know what to do!
And so we started MAC to be boots on the ground. We snet in dozens of people last December into Clear Channel stations to physically inspect their public files. Once pepople walked trhough those doors and were escorted to a computer or file cabinets and allowed to rummage through, they got it. And SO much more ……
For our new readers/commenters:
To follow along, you will have to refresh your browser: PC = F5 key, MAC = Command+R keys
If you want to ask a question – just type it in the Leave Your Response box & Submit Comment.
If you are responding to a comment – use the Reply button under the number, then type your response in the box, Submit Comment.
What was found?
Lisa, in Broadcast Blues, I show the stroy of Jane Akre, an investigative reporter who was prevented by Roger Ailes from reporting the facts about Bovine Growth Hormone in milk.
Long story – you gotta see the film for the rst – she proved in a court that WTVT FOX intentionally tried to distort the news.
The FCC has a rule agasint news distortion – so she petitioed to deny the station’s license. (We can do that – they’re like drivers’ licenses, ya know? But the FCC did not take that license away.
Golly, the FCC did nothing. That’s kinda rotten. ow many complaints does the FCC get annually? And how many do they act on?
Hi Sue, i’m a fan.
Could you talk a bit about the methods used to economically support the RW media?
And how it is self reinforcing?
Next year, Media Action Center will petition to deny the license of KDND, the station featured in Broadcast Blues that killed a woman at a water drinking contest. I covered the trial at SueWilsonReports.com , and the jury found the Entercom station liable for her death.
So the question for the FCC: if they will not take away a licesne for murder by radio, when will they?
And we will ratchet up publicity on this one, folks. The way to move any agency is by embarrassing them if necessary . (I learned that at FOX. Worked at PBS and NPR too,)
There is a huge opportunity overr the next year to apply for more LPFM licenses. Contact me – sue@mediaactioncenter.net , we are working on a plan to help finance some of these stations in exchange for running programming.
Entercom actually was granted MORE licenses weren’t they?
I don’t know that, Lisa, I can just say that Jane never even got a postcard back from them.
BUT! The FCC has been really good to work with on MAC’s latest action, we have made a formal complaint to them citing the little known “Zapple Doctrine.” That syas if one broadcaster provides time to supporters of a candidatem it must provide time to supporters of the other candidate. On the five local Conservative talk shows in Milwaukee, they gave away 160 minutes every day of free airtime promoting Scott Walker and the GOP, but denied the Dems any access to the microphones at all. That time was worth about a million bucks.
I wondered about KdND. The station tried to avoid losing the license by firing almost everyone, is that the line that they will use? “hey we fired all the people and we changed our policies, why should you punish us more?”
Also, it would be interesting to know how the people who set this up and were fired are doing now, how the family of the dead woman is doing too. What bothered me about that case were all the people who blamed the woman. I saw a lot of comments from people who believed she was stupid and deserved what she got. It made me ill to see so many heartless people.
So we have made a complaint, find it at MediaActionCenter.net – that we think could go to SCOTUS. We are pitting the First Amendment Rights of We the People v Big Media Corporations.
And we need help! Please sign our petition and donate if you can!
This may be Off Topic….I wonder what may be best ways to get the jerks off radio..Rush would be the biggie…but others, Tammy Bruce, Sean, etc….Are there game plans to move some of these folks elsewhere?
Yes, this is in Broadcast Blues also. A major corporate player kills somebody, then gets rewarded with more station licenses.
AAnd you wonder why people wnat to know what to do.
How was the airtime given away? By positive stories, or discussing Walker being a great guy on talk shows etc?
I gotta say this morning I was shocked ot see an informercial with the NRA campaigning against Obama, granted it was a paid ad, but still…
Interesting. Here is SF one broadcaster was Basically running infomercials for one republican running for a state office. The other republican Canidates were left out of any on air free air time. It was clear that the host was part of the campaign. I tried to get the other republicans to file an FEC complaint but they didn’t want to “talk bad about other republicans”
I contacted some folks at Free Press and talked to an FEC lawyer and was told the FEC is weak and the fines are tiny. Unless I have another canidate making a complaint I had no hope. Also this was pre-citizen united which changed things.
Spocko, I can tell you that we in the community of Sacramento will be making a lot of noise about this next fall. We only have one chance every eight years to challenge a license, and in CA the deadline is November 2013. We will make the station and the FCC justify themselves.
Lisa, we tried to narrow it down to specific statements, like Walker is a jedi! Barrett is a racist! I’m a supproter of Walker, he’s great. things like We need volunteers for Walker, here’s how you do that.
The FCC said we had to show political intent. I think we have done that. It’s 18 pages long at MediaActionCenter.net , and it’s good reading for the right wonk.
Yes, we had to do everything live time during the actual election, and had volunteers writing the stations daily demanding comparable time – that’s so we could get standing.
Where do I sign and donate? I loved the trailer. I don’t have much hope for anything anymore, but DAMN it’s beautiful to see you and somebody and anybody do this work. So many decades overdue, so much destructive hate poured into scared, malleable minds. (Even my beloved dad succumbed, it’s like freakin Scientology.) Why the heck wasn’t I out there fighting it like you are? (And good old Spocko and others too)
This is part of what our WI Zapple action is about. We can force Rush in teh 60 days before an election – to share his microphone with the other side. That at least evens the playing field during campaign seasons. That is IF we are successful.
Also Boycott! And more. I am developing a detailed training program now for boots on the ground action like the ones we’ve done and plan.
Media Action Center – website
This is an excellent strategy for any group who is concerned about political imbalance on the airwaves!
http://www.mediaactioncenter.net/
Sue,how can people get copies of Broadcast Blues as well as set up screenings in their area?
Good luck…love the idea of Rushbo sharing…doubt that he favors that;) Thanks.
You made my day with that one Sharkbabe! At MediaActionCenter.net you’ll see a donate button, and donors get a personally signed copy of Broadcast Blues. You’ll also see our petition, we have about 1120 signatures, I am hoping to 2500!
Also – you can get the DVD to screen at SueWilsonReports.com .
Sue, in Broadcast Blues, you show a local community setting up their own radio tower. How difficult is it for a local station to get permission, find airwaves etc?
Yep and it is boots on the ground. Emails do not work. But they can be employed.
Signed and donated. Thanks for the linkys everybody, I am really gonna spread this stuff around. Thank you again Sue.
Right now, there are NO new radio station licenses available at the FCC. Some may be for sale, but they are the tiny wattage stations that are difficult to make profits. The Big Media Corps do not want to let go of the 50,000 watt towers, they are an excellent tool for propaganda.
There will be LPFM licenses available next year we think, they will be under a 100 watts, and won’t be allowed to sell advertising.
How have podcasts, satellite radio and internet broadcasts affected infomation and public airwaves broadcasting?
Never forget, Citizens United is a broadcasting issue. One half of CU money goes into your local TV stations – the same stations that are legally bound to serve the public interest.
Gotta go meet the management, folks, and have alittle chat.
Good to remind them that if third party ads lie to the public, the stations can be held liable.
Yep. Smelling a class action lawsuit here.
New media is slowly chipping away at radio’s numbers, but radio is still the third most accessed media in the US. Talk Radio gets 50,000,000 listeners!
We are doing some screenings in Sarasota Florida in coming weeks – check my Facebook Page to details.
https://www.facebook.com/SueWilsonTV
And give Media Action Center a Like!
https://www.facebook.com/MediaActionCenter
Entercom was granted 14 new licenses after killing Jennifer Strange.
Plus for nest week’s film: Satan’s Angel: Queen of the Fire Tassles
You can view the trailer for Satan’s Angel:Queen of the Fire Tassles here:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qrCwRud-s7k
There’s just so much we can do. Make common sense demands of management. If they don’t respond, make them pay. Send people in daily to inspect files, mkae ‘em hire someone to supervise you. Hit them in the pocketbook with Boycotts. Make em hire lawyers to fight legal challenges and petitions to deny. Make the broadcasters understand that now that we know our rights, we are not backing down.
Remember all broadcsting is local. Act locally.
Sue, thank you for being here and giving us tool for activism and a blueprint for making positive changes to take back the public airwaves!
And please keep us updated on MyFDL. YOur latest diary was wonderful!
absolutely! – that can’t be emphasized loudly enough
This has been so much fun, big thanks to Lisa Derrick and Firedoglake for hosting this.