Every once in a while there is a quote that crystallizes the sheer up-is-downism of American politics more perfectly than anything I could ever hope to write. The National Association of Manufacturers has helpfully provided one of those quotes in its response to a lawsuit by five California teenagers who are suing the federal government over carbon emissions:
“At issue is whether a small group of individuals and environmental organizations can dictate through private tort litigation the economic, energy, and environmental policies of the entire nation,” wrote National Association of Manufacturers spokesman Jeff Ostermeyer in an email.
Here we have an organization representing some of the wealthiest companies in America, wringing its hands about the unholy power being wielded against it by a handful of kids using – gasp! – the legal system. So, in other words:
A small group of individuals and corporations using the power of money to subvert democracy and dictate the economic, energy and environmental policies of the entire nation, not to mention the health of the entire planet and everyone on it = The American Way.
Ordinary citizens using the mechanisms of government to oppose unchecked corporate power = Undemocratic Oppression.
This is the core of what bugs me about the pro-corporate strain of conservatism and libertarianism: The claim that all of these immensely wealthy corporations and individuals are helpless little lambs at the mercy of the big bad government wolf. They’re not. They have resources we can only dream of: When they break a law, they can hire all the top attorneys and PR firms they want, then give millions to politicians who will repeal the law or castrate its enforcers. Just because the government can steamroll you and I and Bradley Manning, doesn’t mean it can or will steamroll its sugar daddies.
Moreover, I reject the premise that taking our money and playing God with our lives is somehow the exclusive province of the government. The profit motive drives corporations to gouge as much as they can get away with while providing as little as possible in return, even when they take over schools and prisons and juvenile detention facilities. And who can forget the perverse talk of “death panels” and “bureaucrats between you and your doctor” when private insurance companies with life-and-death power already do the exact same thing?
Like most progressives, I don’t want the government to wield excessive unaccountable power over us – I want it to prevent the moneyed elites from wielding excessive unaccountable power over us. And the number one reason why it doesn’t is that all those one-percenters who pretend to be the government’s victims, are really its owners.




57 Comments





Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Eli!
Buzz!
Eli!
EvilDrPuma!
This post bugs me a lot–enough to have made me set up an account.
Your problem is not with “conservatism” or “libertarianism”, because both of those political philosophies find the union of state and corporate power to be abhorrent. Your issue is with Fascism. I know that the corporate media tries to obscure and confuse these -isms, but if we can’t even get straight what we’re supposed to be upset about, we have little hope of succeeding against the corporate state.
Then I guess my problem is with conservatives and libertarians, because they are all about protecting those helpless corporations from the job-killing government bullies.
They also seem to be totally opposed to any kind of campaign finance reform, which is the principal mechanism for uniting state and corporate power.
(Well, unless you consider repealing all disclosure requirements and restrictions on contributions as “reform”…)
I think that makes you a proud member of the “Professional Left.”
Yes it is. They’re both bullshit practiced by bigoted, racist hypocrites.
Leave corporations aloooone!
/s
ELI!
CLEARLY they have standing to sue. I mean they, like breathe, ya know?
Hey Ya, Eli!
Watery Tort, is it?
Glad to see you brought another new person to sign up!
(You’d have to know me to understand my sincerity.
Eli knows me.)
MARGARET!
Hey Ya, demi!
I know what you mean…
Standing usually requires a something more than breathing…..
I’d also like to correct the grammar in the Bradley paragraph. Just love seeing that sort of thing; brings out an old English Prof…Thanks;)
Oops, completely missed that. Fixed now…
Hopefully municipality citizens can have the fluoridation of their water removed by suing. It’s the converse of this suit since the putative basis for fluoridation is futuristic effects, which have yet to be shown to be effective.
Abso-fucking-lutely, Eli.
There’s also “a problem” with Eli’s grammar — can you find it?
;) Thanks for being a good sport….Just a tic, I guess.
No, it’s fine – I’m really nitpicky about that stuff too, I hate to have it in my own posts.
Just because the government can steamroll you and I and Bradley Manning, doesn’t mean it can or will steamroll its sugar daddies.
There are inherent dangers in anything big. It’s as true for stovepipe Fed regulatory agencies as it is for predatory corporations. There is too little accountability in both.
It’s more about power than money, I think.
The government is a lot more accountable to corporations than vice versa.
Hey, Peg!
I’m in the middle of dinner, but trying to peek in.
See you in the morning.
I haven’t been fucked by any regulatory agencies lately — except those captured by greedy corporatist assholes.
No correction after ten minutes.
Eli was using the royal “I” — LOLOL
You got a badge?
Sheesh.
Let’s talk about what the Ordinary citizen can do.
:)
ELI!!! I have no pity for the corporations nor their defenders on the right. They are enemies of the people and of humanity. Traitors to the American people and deserving of a traitors fate.
BLUETOE!!!
You’re lucky, or may have been asleep when it happened and unawares. They’re in bed together, I think, most of the time.
Libertarians and conservatives are nothing more than fascists that try and hide behind the mask of legitimacy of two failed ideologies.
Hi Hi demi. Didn’t know you were here.
x2, BT2
Hi Hi Back.
I’m here alright. :)
How are ya on this Friday night?
No, you’re right about the need to get the money out of politics and to bring integrity back to the system–if such things were possible. For various reasons I no longer believe that such systemic solutions are feasible; trying to pursue them will only lead to wasted energy and effort.
When the Roman Empire fell apart, many people survived and even thrived during the decay. The same array of possibilities are already presenting themselves to forward-thinking and optimistic people today, during the on-going collapse of our current empire.
Not bad, not bad and you? I’ve thought about that hi hi greeting. We often say bye bye so why not hi hi? I like it.
Everything’s groovy.
I accomplished alot today, so I’m satisfied. And, that ain’t bad.
Speaking of Perspective….not bad ain’t bad neither.
Good for you, Bless Your Heart, Blue.
The clarity of the problem makes it very hard to envision solutions. Public campaign financing would fix a lot (but not all) of it, but it’s hard to see how a majority of incumbents would ever vote for it.
Right ON, ELI!
They do that in France, right cheek first then left.
Care to elaborate?
BGROTHUS! Thanks!
Is America collapsing? Hmm. I would say it is. At least, as a nominal representative democracy. What’s emerging in its place is rather scary: a rogue military state. No rule or law tethers America now, and so, let the heavens fall.
I’m off to the land of nod. Feeling sleepy after a busy day. Sleep well and pleasant dreams. Bonsoir mes amis. Bye bye.
Night Night.
Ha!, friend.
Really, kind of like David and Goliath?
Eli, I’m taking off, but thank you so much for educating us. Making things clear. That’s what citizens can do. Pay attention to what’s happening, why, and share that information with others.
I was thinking more like Mitt Romney and John Lauber…
I’ll butt in if I may?
In 1970 Charles Reich published The Greening Of America, which had been earlier published in The New Yorker. He suggested that a ‘new’ consciousness was afoot in the land, a third kind after the nation’s founding kind, ‘rugged individualism’, which was supplanted by the rise of the corporate state, which the ‘new’ consciousness was revolting against or dropping out of.
Evidently Lewis Powell read Reich studiously and composed his now-famous counterinsurgency memo on behalf of the then-threatened corporate state.
Thanks, demi, I try. I think we all already knew all this, I’m just trying to put it into words.
The right has expanded the “rugged individualism” and “Don’t Tread On Me” mythology to include corporations and everyone else with enough money to look after themselves.
And, you do it well, and I appreciate that.
sorry I missed this post, excellent, spot on analysis eli
it’s really funny, the real conservatives are the liberals, trying to conserve the envirnment, the democracy, the future for our kids
the meaning of the word “conservative” is the antithesis to the agenda of the party who has highjacked the word
“it’s really funny, the real conservatives are the liberals, trying to conserve the envirnment, the democracy, the future for our kids”
This is true. Liberals are generally far more conservative than modern American “conservatives”, who are in fact misnamed radicals.