
NBC Anchorman Brian Williams
We can now add NBC and its anchor Brian Williams to the growing list of cable/broadcastnetworks and hosts who should never be allowed to handle a presidential debate. Williams’ cowardly performance last night at the latest GOP shamefest was beyond embarrassing; it should be career ending.
The execs at NBC had no doubt watched Newt Gingrich bully the hapless John King last week after the CNN host foolishly framed a question about Newt’s moral hypocrisy and lack of human empathy as though it were an opportunity for a serial wife beater to punish an exwife again. And despite David Gergen’s consoling, CNN still doesn’t get what he did wrong.
One lesson might have been, you’ll need to think harder than the goofs at CNN about what you’re trying to get at, rather than walk right into the predictable buzz saw of conservative victimhood. But you still have to get to the issue.
The belief that it’s the liberal media’s fault that today’s conservatism is terrible when put into practice and its advocates are worse defines the modern GOP’s reaction when presented with facts inconsistent with their alternate universe view of reality. Instead, NBC’s execs thought and thought and thought and concluded that the best policy would be to hide in the corner and hope the bully would not do what bullies do: humiliate their anchor (really!!) as much as Gingrich shamelessly humiliated CNN’s.
NBC’s cowardice was evident from Brian Williams’ first question to the last. Too many questions were at the intellectual level of, “why are you such a wonderful person?” or “list the things you’ve done to make the conservative movement so intellectually coherent.” That cowering was interrupted only briefly when reporters from NBC’s cohosts were allowed to ask a couple of questions about Cuba and immigration, but alas, neither questioner was allowed a follow up, so the topics were simply dismissed with fog and demagoguery. We never learned that the folks on that stage would happily dismantle Medicare and undermine Social Security, while cheerfully taking food stamps out of the hands to mouths of people otherwise in abject poverty.
Earth to media: you’re under assault. the bully and the people cheering on the bully are authoritarians who would smash the First Amendment in a heartbeat. The bully on that stage wants to blame you for the failures of their own policies, the viciousness of their own statements, the hypocrisy of their own lives and the dishonesty of their mind-numbing campaigns.
It’s not your job, NBC, to cower in the corner to avoid getting beat up by bullies. You represent the American people’s belief in democracy and accountability. It’s your job to confront the bullies with their lies, their hypocrisy, their viciousness and every other matter that might question their qualifications for office. And if you can’t do that, then you’re just the bully’s pimps.
Photo: lev radin / Shutterstock.com



53 Comments





Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Brian Williams always looks like he’s afraid of crapping his pants. The photo accompanying this post captures it perfectly.
Well said, Scarecrow.
What Scarecrow said.
While I’m mad as hell about us being raped by the right-wing’s bosses, I reserve a special hatred for the ones holding us down so they can do it.
It was a pitiful performance by Williams.
It will be interesting to see how the media covers the release of Romney’s tax returns.
Why would a big corporation like NBC want to make the folks who will transfer their tax burden to the 99% look foolish?
Either Williams is in on it or he followed orders.
or perhaps the GOPers have pre-debate agreements with NBC limiting the number of probing questions and followups. It wouldn’t shock me to find that Williams had a list of questions in Newt’s or Mitt’s handwriting.
Boxturtle (In the old days, such a deal would earn a response of “get bent” and the lead story at 6:30)
Just another network haircut pretending to be a journalist. Williams and his pals are more interested in being celebrities than newsmen. That’s why nobody watches these people anymore.
It will be interesting to see how Fox covers the tax returns. Trash Mitt and raise Newt or defend the returns as capitalism at it’s finest?
Boxturtle (Betting that Ruperts tax return looks more like Mitt’s than it does mine)
Anyone who graduated from kindergarten knows what to do in Williams’ position, without having to be told. It’s mostly unspoken understanding.
Ryan Grim at HuffPo:
Exactly. Just part of the gig. Play along or hit the bricks…
Scarecrow, if you think the media has some kind of an adversarial relationship with the political side of the machine, you are mistaken.
If this was true, politicians wouldn’t deliberately offend the media.
Brian Williams performed exactly as required.
I’d have hit the bricks. I’ll prostitute my talents, but my ethics are not for sale.
Boxturtle (And before you ask my talents are in computers. Dirty minded so-and-so’s!)
Who needs foodstamps when there’s EBT?
Who died and left us in charge?
NBC is a corporation, and by law is the fiscal responsibility of its directors to do the bidding of its stockholders, who seem to prefer making Republicans look good. Hmmmm.
Why blame Williams for the clowns on full display. Both parties oversee these meaningless circus shows. They are designed to be a high school like pageants, a mock democracy for the peasants.
Brian Williams? This Brian Williams?
NBC Nightly News anchor Brian Williams thinks Limbaugh should get more credit
I still remember Gwen Ifill cowering before the towering
intelligenceidiocy of the Snowbilly Grifter in her so-called “debate” with Joe Biden.I gave up a looooooong time ago having one iota of an “expectation” that political “debates” will actually, you know, be “debates” with anything approaching relevance or intelligence, much less – heaven forfend – honesty, transparancey, factualness or intelligent follow up questions.
Ain’t gonna happen…
I didn’t watch the “debate/show”, but then again, I’ve always been lucky when it comes to….not watching propaganda.
Political parsing undeserving of attention. Nothing addressing the real issues facing Americans and the republic. Just another “corporate media” event spewing garbage for the taker.
Okay, just for the sake of debate (heh), I would argue it’s not really fair to hold Williams responsible for (for the lack of) deep, probing questions that illuminate the candidates’ policy positions. Anchors today are just cogs in the wheel with very little to no journalistic freedom. The days of Cronkite, Huntley, and Brinkley are long gone. We remember what was done to Dan Rather, the last anchor to have any balls. No wonder the networks keep their newsguys and gals on tethers.
Instead, anchors are encouraged to set up the moment when a candidate says something outrageous that will eventually turn into website clicks and increased ad revenue.
I wonder if Jon Stewart will have anything to say about his friend, Brian Williams.
And last night’s “Republican Primary” Kabuki Show was entitled:
Wherein empty-headed empty-suit Brian Williams kowtows & sucks up to the so-called “Republican Primary” contenders, all of whom are pretending to “debate” one another. Enjoy the circus; too bad there’s no bread to pass around.
I’m right there with you. I’d have badly sprained both middle fingers by now…
The corporations own the media, and the corporations own the politicians. That’s really all you need to know. But Scarecrow has done a great job of describing what it looks like.
I didn’t watch it because I didn’t expect anything other than what I’m learning transpired. This entire election cycle is a mockery of America and democracy. The pathos I sense is a resignation that no one who would rescue this country from its downward spiral into plutocracy and authoritarianism can even be considered for the Presidency, so we must merely sit and watch as the predators fight over the coveted carcass. As far as Williams goes, he merely represents the change of the fourth estate into the fifth column.If you’re waiting for someone to stop asking why the poor hate the wealthy and envy their idle and wretched excess, and instead ask why the rich despise the poor and jealously resent their hard-earned crumbs, forget it. The poor are poor and the rich are rich because they deserve it has been the accepted answer since Livy. And that’s all the history a fool like Gingrich has to know.
Maybe time for “it gets better” in re: talking heads and bullies? That would be some fun. Either that or “shit pundits say.”
As are endless wars. Both parties love war, torture, blood and death – AKA video games for the masses. Bread, blood and circuses. Ancient Rome anyone?
I haven’t watched in a while, but I always thought Jon was stringing Williams along, basically showing how dumb the guy actually is. If that wasn’t intentional, that is still how Williams come off. It consistently looked like every thing Stewart said went right over Williams’ head.
Especially since the Democrats don’t even have the balls to put up a primary contender (or two or three) against the “Peace Prize Winner.” Yup, the Republicans may have a stuffed clown car, but the democrats don’t even have a car, just one clown.
Ditto what you said.
To be honest, I really don’t expect any pushback from Stewart (though I haven’t watched in awhile, either). He and Williams genuinely seem to like each other. But, yeah, I suppose it could all be an act.
If anyone needed a reminder, amidst the sound and fury we had the passage of the Defense Act, and it was revealed that (big surprise) the White House was pressuring scientists to low-ball the BP gulf spill. But let me go out on a limb here, and predict the State of the Union rebuttal will say Obama’s taking this country too far left. And the media will accept that as unbiased criticism. And Brian Wiliams will humbly accept his Walter Lippman award.
That’s fascinating. You think it’s NBC’s policy to make Republicans look good?
Their mission is to garner market share. To do that, they have to make a horse-race out of all these flea-bags.
Sorry Scarecrow. If you were looking for journalists to do their job, you should cast your gaze elsewhere, far beyond NBC. NBC and GE need the republicans to start more wars, so that they can sell more military hardware and powerplants to our frenemies in the middle east.
I understand. You thought he was there in a journalistic capacity. Easy mistake to make.
NBC tries to be unoffensive to both mainstream party. MSNBC is allowed to pick on Repbulicans but not democrats, e.g., they got rid of Cenk who criticized Obama. CNBC takes a very Republican line and constantly criticizes “liberals.” So they cover their bases.
Fool me once and you can’t fool me again!
Right, as usual.
Yes, GE owns NBC, GE is a giant defense contractor. Yes. Try watching CNBC if you think GE has a problem supporting Republicans.
Brilliant again! Thanks for the shrewd intelligence as always.
Blessings,
Williams has always been pretty open about being a conservative fanboy. He wasn’t cowering at all — he was just trembling in the presence of so much manly conservitude.
Does anyone here think the mainstream media will ask any questions that will expose the corruption in the system? The media in this country is owned by pro war corporations that only exist because the system is rigged in their favor. GE which owns NBC would never allow a ‘journalist’ to ask difficult questions. They will, however, give the candidates, with the exception of RP, the ability to use fear, to call for even more military. Three of the four candidates would love a war with Iran, Cuba, Nicuragua, Pakistan, Afganistan, and hey, why not round 3 in Iraq? Unfortunately, this is our choice in 2012. 4 candidates, R and D alike, just salivating to start even more war, regardless of the cost in blood and treasure.
In answer to your question: no. Actually, though, all the MSM would have to do is give RP a little more time in the discussion and put Buddy Roemer up on the stage. I disagree with much both have to say but they are both intellectually consistent/honest enough to whistle in the bullshit and add some pointedness/clarity to the discussion. We’ll have none of THAT!
Some 40 responses to this story and no one takes the situation to its logical conclusion: Boycott, boycott, boycott. Imagine what would happen if true liberals cancelled their subscriptions to the washington post or ny times or comcast for a few months. if done in mass it would cut their revenues and profits to a point that they would have to rethink their strategy of being propogandist with impunity for the corporate establishment to the point of killing the middle class
I don’t have subscriptions to major newspapers or cable tv. It hasn’t made any difference and probably very few would cancel subscriptions anyway.
That is a very good summary, except I would say that the First Amendment has already been gutted by judicial decisions, local rules and the two latest acts: disappearing legalized and citizenship stripping.
Indeed “We never learned that the folks on that stage would happily dismantle Medicare and undermine Social Security, while cheerfully taking food stamps out of the hands to mouths of people otherwise in abject poverty.” will be the comment on FDL after the three debates in the Fall with Obama since he is on the same page as his “opponents”.
Aren’t NBC, CNBC, MSNBC et al now owned by Comcast? If so, what are you saying?
Um, the “MSM” really has nothing to do with who is invited and how many questions are asked of whom. These arrangements and conditions were set up by those promoting the GOP Reality Show.
Also, why bring any sanity? Aren’t Romney and Gingrich and Santorum doing a fine job of illustrating why it’s not in the best interest of any sane US citizen to vote Republican.
The last thing Brian Williams wants is to be disinvited from all those White House parties under the Gingrich administration. Those appetizers are bitchin’! He cherishes all those Christmas cards too.
Comcast is as right wing as the Murdoch empire.
Yes, recent change, now GE only owns 49%, IIRC.
Bottom line, all the media are owned by 5 or 6 corporations, and all those corporations are decidedly right wing in their orientation.
This is already happening. The younger people are, the less they watch network or cable news. I still peruse the newspapers in the area where I live on line to keep an eye on what the local elites want (in Sacramento, this means the construction of a new arena for the Kings). Social media is going to be the next arena for struggle, because that’s where people have moved. People on facebook or Twitter will read and disseminate entertainment news about the Kardashians or sport news about the Super Bowl, but the challenge is to find a way to use it for the purpose of political indoctrination. Perhaps, the elite solution is to accept that the best they can do is overwhelm it with trivial noise, which may work well enough.