Mitt Romney better be prepared for headlines like this:
Special Report: Romney’s Steel Skeleton in the Bain Closet (Reuters)
Bain Capital Tied to Bankruptcy, Closing of KC Steel Plant (KC Star)
Another Romney Layoff Victim, this one a Conservative, Speaks Out (Washington Post)
Paul Krugman, ahead of the curve (as usual), parsed Romney’s comments on job creation and the lack thereof. After noting that Romney wants to take credit for every job created by a company Bain took over but denies responsibility for any losses, Krugman sums up the basic problem with Romney’s record at Bain:
When the dust settled after the companies that Bain restructured were downsized — or, as happened all too often, went bankrupt — total U.S. employment was probably about the same as it would have been in any case. But the jobs that were lost paid more and had better benefits than the jobs that replaced them. Mr. Romney and those like him didn’t destroy jobs, but they did enrich themselves while helping to destroy the American middle class.
That’s the macro picture. For the micro, check out the Reuters piece about Bain’s purchase of a Kansas City steel mill. Do go read the whole piece, but these two paragraphs give you the bottom line at the end of the day:
. . . the mill was padlocked and some 750 people lost their jobs. Workers were denied the severance pay and health insurance they’d been promised, and their pension benefits were cut by as much as $400 a month.
What’s more, a federal government insurance agency had to pony up $44 million to bail out the company’s underfunded pension plan. Nevertheless, Bain profited on the deal, receiving $12 million on its $8 million initial investment and at least $4.5 million in consulting fees.
That’s what Krugman is talking about. Bain — under Romney’s direction — bought Armco, loaded it up with debt, paid itself some handsome dividends, and charged some hefty consulting fees. They played bookkeeping games, while not adequately managing the company itself, and ultimately Armco went belly up in 2001. That was two years after Romney stepped down from Bain, but it was what Bain did to Armco from the time they bought it in 1993 that put it in this position.
But that’s still a pretty abstract picture. To see what “destroying the middle class” looks like on the personal level, Greg Sargent introduces us to one of the Armco workers affected by the looting and layoffs. Glen Patrick Wells worked at Armco for 34 years, and describes himself as a staunch conservative. Says Sargent:
Wells says he’s so furious with Romney that he says he’s open to appearing in TV spots against him in order to make the case he makes in the above video — even if it would mean helping Obama.
“Right now, if Romney gets in, I am so disgusted that I will probably vote for Obama and I detest him,” Wells says. “Anyone who is willing to put a predatory capitalist in office deserves to get Obama.”
Coming from someone who says he voted for George W. Bush twice and McCain once, that’s harsh. That’s the video up above, and it’s very well done. “They [Bain] walked out of here with millions. They left us with nothing.”
Looting and layoffs may look good to Wall Street, but not so good to Main Street. With a record like that, good luck reaching the conservatives in the middle class, Mitt.




34 Comments





Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Missouri is not looking terribly hospitable to Obama this year, but if Romney gets the GOP nod, commercials like this may turn Missouri away from Mitt.
Krugman tells it like it is as well as anyone.
Underfunding the pension plan while paying off Bain is sickening: it put the losses in the pension fund on the Pension Benefit Guarantee Corporation. What a bunch of pigs.
Off topic – here are the signs I hung in LA – there’s some really good ones:
http://freewayblogger.blogspot.com/2012/01/laroad-trip.html
now heading north – how far, I don’t know…
Sick shit. But Romney and Obama work for the same people. They are both cogs in a psychopathic system run amok.
Good job . . . and Good luck!
At some point the “vulture” in “venture” has to come out. Many mergers have very dark outcomes for the workers while the new owners plunder and profit. This is not a new story. WE have to find out this shit because the MSM has no clue and no interest in such accurate reporting. What I would like to know is: “How many actual workers did Romney hire and supervise at Bain? Who did he actually employ? What exactly was the nature experience at “running a business”? This writer actually ran a business, interviewed and hired, trained and supervised people, created actual jobs. I do not get the impression the Romney’s experience at Bain involved such “job creation”. Will the Dems be able or willing to dig into that kind of detail on Romney? Don”t count on it. It’s up to the blogosphere.
Great signs and so many of them. Do you have any idea how long they usually stay up? Thanks for all your good work.
I’ve been keeping an eye out for whether this ever becomes a campaign issue. Doesn’t seem likely as 1%ers won’t tolerate it.
signs are staying up now for days and weeks, so I’m pretty sure Caltrans has either been given a cease-and-desist order about taking them down (thanks Gov. Brown!) or they just don’t have the budget or manpower anymore.
in general, the smaller signs placed along the sides of the freeways are good for several days – with LA metro freeways averaging some 100,000 cars per day – per direction – that’s a lot of bang for the buck. (or the nickel, which is about what each of these babies cost.)
Love your work and your dedication.
Economic rapists run the world!
Always have.
The meme has been that companies like Bain Capital are a benign and necessary part of the free market system, a kind of recycling procedure . They search out inefficient companies, buy them up then straighten them out. Kind of like putting them through rehab. With lots and lots of profits to be made and the companies then returned to the free market in a streamlined form (or consigned to the trash heap) to become even more profitable for their stockholders or owners.
The new meme has got to focus on the pain, despair and destitution the Bains of the world wreak on the employees, their families and their communities. They wage a brand of economic warfare, pin- stripe-suited condottieri rampaging through vulnerable companies, leaving trails of destruction and broken lives.
Yeah, Romney is a bad ‘un, but worse is the system that supports and approves of such mercenaries.
GREAT FREEWAY SIGNS! You are my new hero. Keep it up. OCCUPY THE FREEWAYS!
One of the ways of changing the meme is to make it a campaign issue. But I’m not optimistic.
Obama’s got to be the luckiest fucker in politics. From his last-man-standing Senate win to his enough-of-Bush-and-Republicans-already Presidency. Too bad that does not translate to the 99%. 4 more years of this smooth talking proto-Fascist Oligarch Toady herding us down the slaughter chute is not what we need.
Serious question. I have for months tried to think of anyone, regardless of party, I could happily support for President. Do you have someone in mind because I can’t think of even one person?
From the Reuters article…
Gee, what a surprise.
No, not really. Not one that could even have a chance for winning, at least. So, I am taking the longer view. Get rid of Obama, he’s too smooth a Fascist Toady with a D after his name who’s wrecking the party as any semblance of what it was. He’s transforming it into the new Republicans.
Letting an assclown R take control should re-energize the liberals and progressives (ala Bus$itCo) and with Occupy going on start a real discussion just what the Dem party should stand for. Hopefully the Congress will stay D, or at least one chamber, to create some natural resistance, but the D party seems too willing to fold like a broken lawn chair on the Titanic so I am not sure it really matters.
It Obama is ejected, then let the R’s take the blame for the 99% destroying asshole policies that Obama would have instituted regardless, just more smoothly, and try to wake more sheeple up for 2014 and 2016. They will do it, Scott Walker, Ohio and Michigan governors certainly did!!
Krugman (cited by Peterr):
Sums up what I think OWS is all about. Americans need to take a stand against the a$$holes who keep enriching themselves while destroying the American middle class.
If there’s no middle class, then the deal’s off.
It doesn’t matter what the Dems do . They’re just as bad as the repugs. Until people get away from the dem – repug circus that both parties have become. there will be no change.Kudos to you for running a business and giving people work.
check out clearchannel before and after bain privatized it. ended local radio nationwide, and now we hear bain’s canned loops coast-to-coast on the “public airways.”
disgusting!
Bain were privateers: the untold story is how much money Romney continues to make every month from his severance agreement. They aren’t businessmen, and neither was he; he was a strip-and-extract pirate dressed up like a capitalist. he created wealth, sure — for his clients and fellow consultant/investors. But not for people, communities, or America.
Well, we can hope that Romney has to get used to headlines like this but I wouldn’t bet on it. If the word is going to get out, it will end up getting there via new media. Corporate media will just keep reporting irrelevancies and triva.
The Dog that Didn’t Bark:
Questions about job destruction caused by Bain have been around for 15 years, and no executive of the company (or anybody else, for that matter) has come forward with a convincing defense of the company’s job-creation record. There has to be a good reason for that.
Bain Capital and other pillage/plunder outfits like it are the story of our “times.” It’s all about MBAs – mostly gained at the Ivies – looting & plundering some company that is claimed to be failing. Somehow or another, the workers – so much the better if they’re despicable disgusting lazy *union* workers – get ripped off, the govt is on the hook (eg, the middle class pays for it via OUR taxes) to pick part of the tab, and already rich pig shits, like Romney, prance off into the sunset with bucket$$$ of ca$h for their alleged con$ulting to “improve” the business.
So many
stoogescitizens are endlessy FOOLED by this crapola that I doubt things will ever change much. It’s the same old same old as when GW Bush was lovingly touted as some *genius* “businessman” with his ‘Vard MBA & Yale undergrad. Yet the tiniest bit of research via teh googleitzer showed how W was HANDED businesses on a platter via Daddy’s connections, then W ran the businesses into the ground, yet W & his richy-rich pals pranced off into the sunset with bucket$ and bag$ of sweet sweet ca$h. The workers? Screwed over big-time; lost the farm; lost their pensions, etc. Just ask Ex-Enron workers… yes, I know W didn’t run Enron, but he profited handsomely from it.Far too many citizens willingly and eagerly drink the Kool Aid and will discuss endlessly what “great businessmen” toads like W and Romney are… and vote for them without a moment’s hesitation because of their alleged “business acumen.”
THIS is the legacy of such piracy…
That said, it don’t matter a tinker’s damn if Obama wins, either. Barry Zero didn’t engage in such activities, but he works for the same puppetmasters as W and Romney. Pick your poison, then bend over and get the KY ready….
Yes, and there is that, as well. Romney continues to handsomely benefit from the pain and privation he has inflicted on other citizens. You sure aren’t going to hear bupkiss about that in the so-called “mainstream” media.
Your standard MBA education at work. It’s what they teach. Nobody’s safe anymore. Did you see what the NYT did to their journalists’ pensions to pay severance to the outgoing senior editor?
They used to call it “vulture capitalism.” A term that you don’t hear anymore.
This is savvy business practice at work.
If person felt like spending some time on this, something like this could probably be found with any political figure. cheney…. didn’t he do business with Iran? and didn’t he oversee buying a business that was mired in huge liabilities, which his company became responsible for?
drug corps selling poisonous products, oil companies, blah blah,
pillaging and plundering…. it’s the American way.
Hey Glen, how is that “screw you, I got mine” working out for you now?
Sorry, I have zero sympathy for this guy.
Yeah, Romney is the one bad apple. Does he really think Bush or McCain would have done anything different at Bain?
Things won’t change until we implement an 18th century French “solution” to this problem.
@Surrt: Yeah, I have ZERO sympathy for him as well.
Lordy, do you people know that most businesses fail?
As for fees paid with financing, anyone who has rolled their closing costs into a mortgage refinance has done exactly the same thing.
Grow up and get a grip.