Wow, just wow. The sheer balls of this documentary. Shane Smith and his unseen buddy cameraman Jamie back-doored themselves into North Korea with point-and-shoot cameras, and proceeded to make a very jaw-dropping, ballsy documentary / travelogue that culminates with the Mass Games. The Arirang Festival: 120,000 people in a choreographed show which Smith explains is
The only reason tourists are allowed into North Korea.
As official tourists, Shane and Jamie are assigned guards who frequently admonish them not to film and threaten them with jail. Despite that–and at one point having their camera memory card confiscated–the daring duo compile a look at what Smith calls “The land that time forgot.”
The tour begins with a banquet where Smith and Jamie, (Vice, VBS.tv), are the only guests. Course after course of food is laid at every table setting, and then removed, Smith speculates, it is in order to prove that the country does not have a famine. The next morning, they travel to a tea house in the mountains where a lone maiden in traditional garb waits for visitors to buy refreshments and play pool.
Part of the
tour of boredom and propaganda
involves demonstrating how America and the imperialist West are inferior to North Korea, and that North Korea is the greatest, most brilliant country in the world, thanks to the courage and vision of Kim il Sung and his son Kim Jong il. They visit the captured U.S.S. Pueblo and the International Friendship Exhibition, a vast storehouse deep in the side of a mountain where gifts to Dear Leader from around the world are warehoused. Vintage luxury automobiles, portraits, and gemstone encrusted baubles rest next to a kitchy taxidermy alligator holding a wooden tray and glasses, grotesque porcelain figurines, tacky clocks, and ivory sculptures. It is a place of pilgrimage for North Koreans who wear their best clothes and uniforms to see how beloved Dear Leader is “revered and loved” by the rest of the world.
Another day trip takes Smith and Jamie to the Barrage, a huge hydroelectric dam and power plant called by North Korean propagandists a stunning achievement in technology, but which actually is responsible for the massive floods which have destroyed most of the country’s arable land.
Vice shows us a country isolated from much of the world, always putting their best foot forward, driven by group-think and a cult of personality. Where the best and brightest children are put into special schools where they work only on their skill–needlepoint, music or dance– in order to create greater glories for the State and Dear Leader who loves his spectacle.
And what a spectacle the Mass Games makes as the 120, 000 people flip cards, dance, and twirl batons, playing out in massive pantomime the story of the Korean Revolution as they know it. This wide-eyed incredulous documentary, inter-cut with a Korean propaganda film, is a stunning one-of-a-kind look at a North Korea as it was under Kim Jong il; and we wait now to see what changes his son Kim Jong-un will make.



71 Comments





Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Before we start, just a couple quick notes:
Please refresh your browser every minute or so to see new comments, questions and answers.
To reply to specific comment, hit the reply button underneath it and then type away. Always hit “send comment.” Thanks!
Please stay on topic/s–in this case tonight’s film Vice Guide to North Korea, Kim Jung il and Kin il Sung, propaganda and so on…If you’d like to type about other newsworthy issues please find a post elsewhere on FDL to do so. Thank you.
Please be respectful of each other. And yeah, I tpye badly…
Welcome to Firedoglake Movie Night and thank you for being here tonight!
This is one of my all time favorite documentaries, and very timely. My roommate is obsessed with with North Korea, and dreams of going there one day.
Lisa, When was this video made?
This looks unbelievable
and incredible
How did you hear about it?
Your roommate is a masochist?
2009, form what I can tell. I saw part of it on CNN late one night (insomnia is your friend).
She is fascinated by Dear Leader and the Mass Games. From this doc it looks like you get to saty about 5 days.
After watching the documentary, I am left wondering three things: 1. How did he get the people to talk so openly (i.e. the Tea girl to admit that they had not had another visitor in 10 months). 2. Does Shane believe that the guards/guides were genuinely offended or were they attempting to extract some graft from the two visitors? 3. What did everything cost? bribes into Korea, hotel, restaurants, etc.?
*heh* Having been to Panmunjom, personally…! Your roomie might just want to reconsider it…! ;-)
Shane, who we nearly scored as a guest about a dozen times, but he travels, a lot, to places with marginal internets, seems to feel that the guards were very serious about the “crimes” they guys were committing by filming. Keep in mind that if the tourists do something wrong, the guards/guides cna be held responsible.
It appears as well that the tea girl is failry guiless, most likely it doesnt occur to people to lie.
Do tell! Fill us in!
She’s a little late for the Dear Leader, isn’t she?
Keep in mind that if the tourists do something wrong, the guards/guides cna be held responsible.
They are very mindful of that fact…! Punishment is swift and merciless…! 8-(
Which raises the question of what cognomen Kim Jong Un is going to take?
I’d like to offer up Last Leader for the consideration of the denizens of NK.
Sadly yes, now she’ll have to see Newest Dear Leader. Though I just heard a news report form some US military guy that says basically KJu doesn’t have the gravitas to control the military nd may lack a great deal of support.
good questions
The hubris and meglomania of building the Rammage which destroyed most of the rice growing areas by backing up a river….
Captain Countertenor has some contacts into Korea. According to him the word is that Latest Leader is a seriously bad piece of work — like, making people miss the Late Leader bad.
I hope not. But I suspect he is right.
I wll say though that the majority of people in the doc, evne people on the streets seemed well dressed. But no doubt the outlying areas are a tragedy. I was wondering if the children who are part of the special talent corps are fed better–same with the Mass games participants.
The country is such a tragedy, and it doesn’t have to be that way
I had the good fortune to be stationed in Korea during the first Gulf War, and visited the Armistice Village…! I loved the Korean people, hated the country tho…! Those Siberian gales are brutal and the Govt’s on both sides, are extremely brutal on their populaces…! 8-(
Yeah, that qualifies as simply stupid inability to read a topographic map.
and there is more intrigue with the eldest son of Kim Jong Il
http://newsfeed.time.com/2011/12/27/where-in-the-world-is-kim-jong-nam/#ixzz1iM1wzpzS
I wonder what Kim Jong -un’s world view is, given he lived abroad for school.
Privilege. Marinade, rinse and repeat.
I also saw another recent article that said both of the elder bros are ‘under Chinese protection’ in Beijing…! 8-(
I think KJ-il’s brother is a cab driver in ?San Diego, has been in the US for 20+ years
The documentary is really interesting and very sad. The control of everything is stunning and scary. I spent 3 weeks in China many years ago and had the same feeling that someone was watching every move we made. Those poor North Koreans will probably never know a day of freedom. I also remember reading a number of years ago that the the new leader was given to temper tantrums and really bad behavior. Thanks, Lisa, for bringing this to us.
oh wow
The tour now costs about 1200 Euros/person to travel to Pyongyang. The Mas Games are Aug through Oct. And mid-Sept is the also 13th Pyongyang International Film Festival (PIFF).
I suppose that if you are American they don;t stamp your passport…much like in Cuba if you arrive from Mexico
So you enter through China?
Yes. That’s what the Vice guys did. They had a travel agency that managed ot hustle them on a flight to northern china and there into DPRK.
Madelaine Albright also visited. But then again, she’s got diplomatic privilege.
North Korea rarely lets any tourists in from South Korea…! 8-(
In January 2010, North Korea lifted the restrictions on American citizens who are now free to visit at anytime of the year – but they are not allowed to travel by train (especially the train to Beijing) and to participate at homestay-programs. Contrary to rumor, Israelis and Jewish citizens of other countries do not face any additional restrictions. Citizens of all countries will need a visa, which will only be issued after your tour has been booked, approved by the North Korean authorities and paid for. Journalists (or those suspected of being journalists) require special permission, which is quite difficult to obtain. The North Koreans do not allow journalists to visit the country on tourist visas. A specialist North Korean travel agency can help you sort out the complex and ever-changing regulations. North Korea will rarely in practice refuse a visa to a tourist who meets the various requirements. http://wikitravel.org/en/North_Korea
I guess I could see about attending the film festival. But considering that bloggers are not considered journalists by a recent court ruling, my profession should not be a problem…
That ruling is form Oregon. http://techland.time.com/2011/12/07/oregon-court-rules-blogging-isnt-journalism/
I’m sure it’s just tit-for-tat: the Southerners don’t let many in from the North, either.
But given the mishegass that was the result of the last open-border policy I don’t think we can blame them for that. Come to think of it, the UN Security Council probably wouldn’t much favor it either.
*heh* But they’ll still watch ya like a hawk…! ;-)
Basically the entire border region is nothing but minefield after minefield, thirteen ‘belts’ of ‘em in some areas…! 8-(
It is stunning how badly these people live and, yet, believe they are the lucky ones. Aren’t people starving there? Or potentially starving.
The food thing could be problematic. I love Korean food, but I eat it here in LA, and my Korean friends who go to visit relatives in South Korea say the portions are lots smaller and ingredients somewhat less recognizable. Shane’s food in DPRK looked um…challenging.
crikey!
So my son told me. He said he played a hole of golf in the DMZ… it was the whole course. Drive into the minefield, do not take a second shot, and hope your partner got a picture of you on the tee.
Yes, in the rural areas, so reports say. Six million people were at risk of starvation last year, per UN
That chicken would have needed a hammer and a saw in order to eat it. Awful looking.
Shane points out that the DPRK has huge buildings on their side of DMZ loaded with dynamite which can be exploded to create tank barriers
Speaking of raging paranoia…
From several weeks ago – Tonight on AC360: Lisa and Laura Ling on Kim Jong Il’s death Remember Lisa Ling’s ordeal?
Dear Leader was a raging lunatic, IMO. N. Korea is not exactly a tourist attraction and I don’t suppose they have oil. Who would want the place?
Shane’s food in DPRK looked um…challenging.
*heh* Downtown Seoul’s food booths can present similar challenges…! *g*
I love Korean food too…! I didn’t notice any portion control tho, when I was there in the early ’90s…!
One thing that I did learn was that real Korean Kimchee does vary from ‘province to province’ and they’re extremely proud of their regional varieties…! The more southerly regions were typically hotter…! ;-)
Yes, I do recall that the Ling/Lee ordeal. And how basically KJi wanted to have a serious major US figure come to him.
I love kim chee. And all the pan chen youo get at bbq places. My step sister worked for the South Korean embassy here in LA (she was rather an oddity to them being Jewish, adopted and fond of wearing dress slacks). When Nixon;s funeral was held, she tried to arrange car service for the diplomas, but for some reasoan they felt the bus from the Omni Hotel for tourists was they way to go. Needless to say, they heeded her advice after that. And she became quite good at finding the most out of the way authentic Korean places to eat.
Btw, The Japanese were right in calling the Koreans ‘Garlic Eaters’…! Being a garlic lover myself, I was in Heaven…! ;-)
My point exactly.
If -un has any world view it will make not one whit of difference unless the military wants it to.
Sadly true.
Hilo town has some awesome Korean BBQs…! With great Kimchee…! ;-)
Sounds just like our World Trade Center!
All the South Korean bridges and road choke points, between Seoul and the DMZ are rigged to blow too, folks…! 8-(
Next week we bring you a visit to a different type of bleakness–the Salton Sea. Director Chris Metzler (who directed Everyday Sunshine, the Fishbone doc we had on in 2011) is back with Plagues and Pleasures on the Salton Sea, a festival award winner. You can read reviews here.
Wow, they are some scared people on both sides.
Just got through watching. Fucking incredible!
The folks in the south have somewhat more reason to be scared, Lisa.
what’s sad is the divided families
Thank you all for being here tonight and for watch and discussing this travelogue. And please join us next week for Plagues and Pleasures on the Salton Sea, which is narrated by cult idol John Waters and features the song stylings of Dean Martinez!
Thanks econobuzz, one of my all time fave docs.
Mahalo Nui Loa, Lisa…!
I’m fixing to head out for tonite’s General Assembly….! ;-)
Keep up the fight…! *g*
Thanks Lisa