Even though the automatic recount had cut Bush’s lead dramatically in the previous three days, Christopher and Daley offered little hope that the margin could be eliminated completely. “Look you got screwed,” said Daley, “but people get screwed every day. They don’t have a remedy. Black people get screwed all the time. They don’t have a remedy. Sometimes there’s no remedy. There’s nothing you can do about it…
Which is a Thing for me, a little bit, the giving up, because I feel like in the last 20 years or so we’ve really made an art of it, as a country. How often do we see this in politics? How often do we hear this? “We can’t do that.” “We can’t afford that.” “We can’t win on that.” “We can’t make that happen.” “We can’t do that anymore.”
All of this acting like the inevitable just happens, like none of these things are choices. We can’t afford Social Security and Medicare … because we’d rather have two unwinnable wars and a bunch of people paying their yacht club dues. We can’t get single payer health care through Congress … because we elected people who call themselves Democrats through a mouthful of corporate junk. We can’t rebuild our roads and schools … because we’re too busy worrying about the latest missing white lady.
None of these inevitabilities, none of these political realities, is a naturally occurring phenomenon. We didn’t wake up one day to a world in which this is the case. It’s not some kind of Politics Pandemic where people touch each other and get infected, and therefore talking about it requires something more than a Daley-esque shrug about getting screwed and oh well gosh darn life sucks. It requires being willing to say okay, but there has to be something that can be DONE about it. There’s always something to be done. There’s always a way out.
It’s frustrating, because sometimes it seems like we have tried everything. Republicans were in charge? Fine, we’ll elect a Democratic president and Democratic legislature. Our media suck? Fine, we’ll build our own alternative networks and ways of communicating. The right’s outspending us? Fine, we’ll just work harder. And the fact that none of this is enough to turn the country around, I mean, I don’t know about you but my second-worst fear is that people like Bill Daley are right and we’re all crazy for thinking we can be better than this and we should be using our limited time on this planet to watch TV and sleep.
My worst fear, though? That we’re right. That we are better than this. That we can do more. That we can give more. That political reality is what we make it, that inevitability is nothing but the limit of our sight, and that we are allowing ourselves to be talked out of all our glorious possibilities by people whose interests lie in convincing us that this is the best we can do.
A.
x-posted to First Draft, where we’re having a little fundraiser this week to take care of frivolous things like keeping the lights on and stockpiling flour and canned goods for the coming zombie apocalypse. Don’t worry, you’ll all be invited to the compound should shit get really real.



60 Comments












Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
never give up
As I tell my six year old daughter, “Can’t never does anything.”
2 unwinnable wars?…better sharpen your pencil there
another small expense
oy caramba
http://gizmodo.com/5813257/air-conditioning-our-military-costs-more-than-nasas-entire-budget
Allison!
The Democratic establishment has become expert at justifying inaction in order to keep the gravy train corporate donations flowing. This started in the late 70s and blossomed in the 80s. We cannot possibly fight for actual progressive causes of the interests of working Americans as it might offend our corporate sponsors.
It’s kinda disheartening. Obama never tried……whether spineless or the Trojan Horse. I finally told my Democratic Representative, “You’re dead to me.” because she folded, got bought, whatever.
But many (most?) Democrats don’t really get it. I told a young friend that Obama was the most disappointing president I’ve experienced in a long voting life. His response, “Really?”
I kinda think it’s a done deal. I’m hoping to find a way to snag a passport to another country. Don’t even much care which one at this point. We are screwed.
Beware the word “can’t.” Too often it’s code for “don’t wanna.”
The Party establishment was bought off buy the corporate interests decades ago. Clinton was their apogee. They no longer represent the interests and views of the membership.
I’ve been here at firedoglake for some years now, and I don’t know of anyone who posts comments here morning, afternoon, evening, late night, or late late night that thinks at all like whoever Allison seems to be addressing as her audience.
WH suggests : “Requiring $100 co-payments for home health care visits”
Edited on Mon Sep-19-11 10:24 PM by madfloridian
The White House suggests that might be one way of saving on Medicare and Medicaid.
Line up and defend that, please.
But the cuts that are most likely to spark the loudest cries are those targeting future Medicare beneficiaries.
The White House insists none of the changes will affect people already in the program, and will largely kick in during 2017.
Among the hikes under consideration are:
Increasing the deductible for doctors’ services (part B of Medicare) by $25 in 2017, 2019 and 2021,
Requiring $100 co-payments for home health care visits,
Charging an extra 15 percent premium on people who have especially generous Medi-gap plans,
Hiking the premiums by 15 percent for Medicare recipients who earn from $85,000 to about $210,000, to raise about $20 billion.
$100 co-pay for home health care visits?
From the pdf link it appears to be for each series of home visits, so that could be several a year for many people on Medicare. A very painful thing for so many…many who are very ill and can least afford it.
For the White House to suggest such is beyond reality.
agreed!
http://www.bgladd.com/PoorJohnFleming.jpg
The Party and the Opposition have always been bought and paid for, but they used to be regional and bartered their strengths from their geographic and demographic bases. When the primary campaigns became de facto national campaigns (beginning in 1972), the power became centralized and easy to manipulate and control the national politicians. And the politics.
http://my.firedoglake.com/somethingthedogsaid/2011/09/19/water-cooler-can-republicans-be-any-more-clueless-how-they-look/
good diary
Obama did not want to make that speech today!
However, the DEM ELITE look around and saw their political party going up in flames, and force OBAMA to make this speech.
WHY?
every DEM congress person knows the following!
UNION membership hates OBAMA, “Union Leadership is just putting a happy face on this problem”
Progressives hate OBAMA!
the intelligent left, knows that OBAMA gave the banks 16 trillion, and OBAMA wants to cut services for the poor by 3 trillion?
Dem elite also saw these polls
White College Educated voters have dump OBAMA
Hispanics have dumped OBAMA
and they are not coming back, YES!!! the WEINER seat went GOP?
the DC DEM ELITES made OBAMA change course
Why? the DEM PARTY is coming a part, and the very, very, large and most important parts are leaving the DEM party
Obama is being pushed out of the way
I’d be out of here in a heart beat, too, if it was really feasible. I’m eligible for Irish citizenship, as my grandparents were right off the boat, but Ireland and the rest of the EU, is a mess. I took the test to get into Canada, and passed (they like college educated with passable French) but I’m not much into the weather. Argentina might work, but I don’t know a lick of Portuguese (this could be remedied though). Sydney, is great, but one needs a couple hundred thousand bond to move to Australia, without a corporate sponsor (or one did when I last checked about 12 years ago).
Sounds like Medicare Part E will be HHC Supplemental Insurance to avoid the $100 copays.
Also, Medicare Part F for those (most) who can’t afford Hypothetical Part E or the copays: Automatic reverse mortgage will kick in if you can’t pay the $100.
reality is this!
this WH gave BANKS 16 trillion dollars, just like Dennis K, Bernie S, Ron Paul and others are saying
and this same WH wants to cut services for the poor by 3 trillion
everyone in this WH needs to be DRUG tested
How many Dems in 2012, are going to ask OBAMA to campaign for them? 0
Mmmmm. Argentina speaks Spanish like almost all South American Countries. Brazil speaks Portuguese (Guyana speaks English, French Guiana speaks French, and Suriname speaks Taki-Taki).
cant stay in the hospital,till your well,so youll pay more at home
great idea
I keep asking people what makes OBAMA a better human being than Rick Perry, Mitt Romney, Michelle Bachman
Obama = Rick Perry
You’re right, I’ve got my countries confused. I don’t speak Spanish either. But that can be remedied post haste.
Home Health Care and Long Term Care insurance policies are big sellers.
he is souless…imo
Actually, this is mostly about moving them into nursing homes. The home healthcare visits allow people with severe/chronic medical conditions to remain at home rather than gong to a nursing home. There are some serious arguments about the relative cost effectiveness of each and it is clear which side the administration has come down on.
nother gift to the paper pushers
united healthcare ceo package for retirement was 1.6..BILLION BUX
one man
nursing homes are astronomically expensive…maybe they should send them to prison
Time for me to toddle off. More young minds to corrupt in the morning and my graduate students are starting to get demanding (I am now up to 5 PhD’s and three MAs that I am advising). Little bastards actually expect me to do something. Take care all.
That is the Republican plan.
20 years ago, in B school, we were told that if we wanted to be millionaires, get into the nursing home business. I guess since I wasn’t attending Ivy League, nursing homes were the next best thing to Wall Street.
I just wrote my first diary at myFDL…observational about how my community is closing up shop, little by little. If you get a chance, check it out. What are you seeing in your community?
I agree with you!
I will read it,
I’ve often wondered why the homeless don’t just camp outside police stations or fire stations. I think that’s what I would do. Or get arrested….and get a hot meal.
nite dicdoc
thanks!
tis the pity….saw an article in Chicago ALONE there are 70,000VACANT houses
me too
Wait ’til we get the Paul Ryan Medicare Part FU Plan.
I also live in a nice weather zone….where we have people with cardboard signs asking for work or a donation…..people at every stop light and at every exit from a shopping center. I thought of making signs for them to hold: I’ll Primary Obama!…… would like to think that the sign would get them some substantial donations.
I’ll check it out. I grew up in the Rust Belt of Pittsburgh, the city itself. The county comprised over 100 townships. The malls devastated the neighborhood merchants starting in the 1960′s. Rust Never Sleeps.
One’s response to this existential quandary of wether to give in to inevitability and just watch TV or to do something largely depends on what one identifies with. What the US can do–what it does as a defining characteristic–is make war; on itself and on other nation states who have things it wants. If the identification is primarily with the granfalloon that is the US and at the same time one is opposed to its essential war-making function, then surrendering to the inevitability that “we” can’t do anything is perhaps a logical conclusion. However, if one identifies with people, regardless of what end of the egg they open or which Humpty-Dumpty gets propped up on a wall, then one is only limited by their work and imagination. The Fascists who project the two-dimensional visage of the granfalloon hope that those who feel powerless will shackle themselves with the former.
after 12 here,ill bid goodnites
Sweet dreams darlin
Replied to your MyFDL…
Saw it. Hey CE! Are those shops among the trendy ‘waterfront’ digs that replaced long-gone industrial facory and warehouse sites? Quite a few of those sprung up in Pgh along the rivers.
No, not at all. You are thinking of the “Flats” and the lower industrial origins of Cleveland. I live in the “Heights” known as the first trolly car community. It rises above the city and sits high from downtown
Thanks, Sweetie. And I’m thrilled that you are still groovin’ on wedding. Makes me smile. I’m still groovin’ on wedding in Italy years and years ago. My daughter is happier with her husband than even then. JOY!
Saw 1500 photos this weekend — goodness! Speaking of weddings, ours was in the same place as our son’s, just in a different season and building.
How wonderful! This summer I had the amazing privilege of officiating at the wedding of my best friend and her amazing guy. I’m still blissing. My twin brother and his wife were there as well as my daughter and her husband and twin sons. I adore my friend and her guy….they are like family. I’m so grateful to them for asking me to share this with them.
Giving up is accepting Obama as the inevitable nominee in 2012, and there aren’t many bloggers who’ve done more to pimp that idea than Digby.
Generally speaking she’s made a cottage industry out of basically ignoring the fact that he’s sustained some of the worst republican policies. She’s blogging proof that too many democrats are willing to continue to get hosed because “the republicans are worse”.
I think that Obama’s ratings are going to bottom out in the mid-30′s and if that happens, the party, itself will bail on him. It’ll be interesting to see how much longer Digby is willing to clap for Mr. Centrist.
What’s amazing to me, tanbark, is that so many just regular Democrats still think that Obama is just fine. I don’t get it.
Okay, just wondered, never been to Cleveland though I lived near enough for 40 years.
Are there still trolleys in Cleveland Heights? There’s like only one left in Pittsburgh, as a token mummy.
Deanie, I think the scales are falling from their eyes. There is a consensus developing as we speak, that Obama is an abject failure, and he’s that after we gave him the tools and the clout to be Captain America. He just turned around and gave all that to the republicans.
The crunch for keeping all this GOP shit going is already coming down the pike and it’s going to pick up speed in the next 6 months or so. I hope that Obama has enough decency left that he will pass on a second term, for the good of the democratic party. It would be the most constructive decision he could make in his one term in office. If he doesn’t make it, the democrats risk going the way of the Whigs in 1860. We will get hammered in 2008.
Gary Hart engineered the 1972 McGovern primary victory, and later credited himself with the successful strategy of ‘running against expectations’, which he parlayed in Iowa in 1984, coming in a ‘surprising’ third, which got him enough media face time to carry to New Hampshire the following week or so and a first-place finish there. (Mondale & Wendy’s “Where’s the beef?” destroyed him, of course.)
Running against expectations still seems to trump every other strategy except electronic vote flipping.
That’s why the Democrats are the Washington Generals of American politics. Unless you believe they’re the 1919 Chicago Black Sox of American politics. Either way, the party has negative value.
Obama’s offered some right ideas for someone
else to run with.
Beyond that I think this is the launching of
another campaign of bullshit.
It’s already obviously an end run to cut Medicare
and Social Security.
The part about offering the Tea Party an end to
no-bid drugs / Medicare in exchange for lapsing
Bush’s millionaire’s tax cuts simply looks beyond
cynical to nonsensical as the Tea Party obviously
wants to keep no-bid drugs.
http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/topsecretamerica/
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/film/cannes-film-festival/8521496/Cannes-2011-Peter-Fonda-calls-Obama-a-traitor.html
How does the US plan to make the “War on Terrorists” Perpetual or never-ending?
by building that terrorist training camp, no problem finding 100 million plus the cost overrun.
U.S. to build new massive prison in Bagram, Afghanistan.
https://www.fbo.gov/?s=opportunity&mode=form&id=8823422cb26e9acd8a65722bec183b6d&tab=core&_cview=0
I personally know of several people where I grew up that do just that. Every fall they get themselves arrested for something so they have a place to sleep, medical care and food through the winter…Very Sad Our Country has allowed this to happen! In the 80′s, a man went into the Yellowstone County sheriffs dept and asked to be put in jail. He was told he didn’t do anything to be put in jail for. He immediately went outside and stole a cruiser. He drove it three blocks or something like that, stopped and said to the pursuing officers, “Now can I go to jail?”
I wish it was the Zombie Apocalypse, because we would have an enemy that we could shoot, and count, and know that we had vanquished at the end of the war.