In 1924, Congress passed a package of immigration laws — including the National Origins Act and the Asian Exclusion Act — establishing a quota system giving preferential treatment to European immigrants. Under these laws, the number of immigrants who could be admitted from a given country was capped at a percentage of the number of people from that nation who were living in the United States in 1890. Because Americans were overwhelmingly of European descent in 1890, the practical effect of these laws was an enormous thumb on the scale encouraging white immigration.
And here’s Michele Bachmann, exploiting Rick Perry’s Achilles’ heel of non-crazy:
The immigration system in the United States worked very, very well up until the mid-1960s when liberal members of Congress changed the immigration laws. What works is to have people come into the United States with a little bit of money in their pocket, legally, with sponsors so that if anything happens to them they don’t fall back on the taxpayers to take care of them.
This reminds me of nothing so much as Trent Lott’s comments about how America would have been better off if we had elected staunch segregationist Strom Thurmond president in 1948. Lott expressed nostalgia for an openly racist candidate, and Bachmann expresses nostalgia for an openly racist policy.
Maybe they’re just ignorant dumbasses, or maybe they’re dog-whistling to the racist/nativist elements of the Republican base. It’s a little hard for me to believe that Lott and his staff didn’t know anything about Thurmond’s history, or that whoever researched pre-1965 immigration policy for Bachmann didn’t notice or mention that little detail about racial quotas.
Trent Lott paid a price for his remarks, but I’m guessing the similarity will end there.



102 Comments





Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Eli!
Buzz!
ELI!
Well, I guess the front page had to follow up the story of the Good Minnesotan with one on the, ahem, Not-So-Good Minnesotan.
PW (apologizes for Michele Bachmann)
PW!
Well, current state gave us Rick Santorum, Arlen Specter and Ed Rendell.
And my original state gave us D’Amato, Moynihan, and Guiliani…
Hey, ELI! Let’s face it – the Rs are racists. It’s hard to ignore when they say things like this.
White Supremacism rides again. David Duke would be proud.
Maybe all Bachmann’s dumbassery about John Wayne vs. John Wayne Gacy and Elvis’ birthday vs. Elvis’ death day was just laying the groundwork for the ignorance defense.
The Golden State vomited up Richard Nixon and Ronald Reagan. And lesser lights lights like George Deukmejian and Pete Wilson. Bleah! But they were titans compared to the current crop of GOPers spreading the crazee. Which means we’re doomed, right?
I don’t think the GOP has ever had this much overt, naked, in-your-face spittle-flecked crazy. And it gets worse every year.
I wonder how they’re going to top Christine O’Donnell…
Will Michelle get into Perry’s closet?
Oh I’m sure they’ll come up with something…er…someone.
I mean, I’ve sort of joked about the crazy primary, but I think sanity really is a liability in GOP primaries now.
You know what’s scary about Bachman? She has her own world view and she believes it’s the real thing. I think she’s insane. She’s been indoctinated rather than taught and now she knows no other point of view. Her education wasn’t based on facts and now it’s so ingrained in her that she really, really believes that liberalism is going to destroy the U.S. and that Obamacare is evil etc. And if you point out the hypocrisy (such as her family getting subsidies) it doesn’t even regiser in that little brain of hers. The most infuriating is that these people run as Christians and they are the least Christian people I know. That doesn’t register in that little brain either.
You wanna know something scarier? We’re producing thousands more just like her. Home-schooled nitwits who use the old testament to determine how things should be.
Now THAT would be interesting. :-)
Republicans claiming the mantle of Christianity is a particular sore spot for me, and I’m not even Christian…
ELI!
The great debate between the batshit and the batsittier, only nobody knows which is which or wtf they are thinking when speaking.
MARGARET!
Kinda scary to think that Rick Perry is only the third or fourth craziest Republican running for president, isn’t it?
Indeed. So our politics is more like a state of open warfare, vulgar, mean and ugly, like pro-lifers cheering death, instead of a civil debate among responsible and sober adults.
But it doesn’t matter much if the skirmishing parties are the flip side of the same coin, that is, miscreants bought and sold by the same oligarchs/plutocrats who have brought us hell while ignoring the democratic will of the people.
Incredibly, unbelievably, he might not even be in the top five. Yikes!
Want to get really scared? PA might change their electoral college to split them rather than winner take all. The Repubs aren’t giving up and between all the voter suppression tactics and what PA might do, we could lose this thing big time.
Yes, unfortunately, sanity is the main difference between the two parties, not corruption.
So he’s, like, median crazy.
The “crazy” worries me, but the pure ignorance scares me even more.
Oh no, he’s still a bugshit, addle brained, teabag wearing, screaming, ranting secessionist sociopath from
HellSan Antonio. It’s just that it’s tough to grade such tiny increments of insanity.Not to be the Tootsie-Roll in the punch bowl, but the Democrats aren’t so ‘sane’ either. (Obama, anyone?)
I don’t think he’s crazy, just a corporate tool.
Good Evening.
Wow, most of you are really on it tonight. Great stuff.
PS, I’m not into punch that much, or tootsie rolls, so I guess I’m safe.
Obama isn’t insane. I agree with Eli@21 but I’ll go one further: The Republicans are no match for the Democrats when it comes to corruption and never have been but Republicans have a hands down near monopoly on insanity.
(((demi)))
Taking care of that ankle, I hope?
Evening, demi.
It’s really a shame, too, because I remember during the Watergate hearings there were some really good Republicans. They did what they had to do and destroyed their own president.
The Republicans are deeper in the pockets of the corporations and the wealthy, but for them it doesn’t entail a betrayal of their (supposed) core principles.
The GOP is now the political party of “The Lord of the Flies”.
I’m pretty sure the current crop of Republicans would do that too if Nixon were president, but it would only be because he was too liberal.
it’s fucking frightening
Yep. Spot on. This is why I voted Republican, (Reagan, yep), the first cycle I was able to vote. Back then they pretended they had principles and the Dems were just eaten up with graft. I only took a few years to wise up about where they were heading though. Then I heard Newty speak and I’ve never looked back.
Yes. I actually felt very much better today. Actually got some stuff done around the house. Still on the meds and following orders. Except, for getting up and doing some things around here that Really Really needed done. :)
Thanks for asking.
(Only four more days of drugs that make me feel weirder than I already am.)
I wish Michele had to stay in bed for 10 days. She freaks me out. I have a hard time, being the naive pollyanna believer that I am, imagining that she actually says this shit!).
“Maybe they’re just ignorant dumbasses, or maybe they’re dog-whistling to the racist/nativist elements of the Republican base.”
Put more generally: “Is ‘so-and-so’ stupid, or clever?”
That conundrum can be applied, basically, to every nationally prominent conservative in my lifetime (born 1963). And I say that having been raised in the south by hard-core southern Republicans, so it’s not like I’m making a judgment like that from an inexperienced point of view.
But that being said, these talking points that Bachmann and Perry trot out (no pun intended) are all conceived and vetted by handlers. Bachmann has no earthly idea what the U.S. Immigration policy was in 1890. I guarantee you that. But those who conceive her policy stances—and tell her what to say—are VERY aware indeed. And so is the audience.
Hey Good Lookin’.
You are spot on. The ones who think believe it. Th ones who go to real schools become liberals and Democrats.
Those who find thinking tiresome vote for the Christian first and foremost.
Indeed, Margaret, I think you are correct. That’s why Barack Obama unnerves me so. He’s not insane, in fact, he seems to feel he’s pretty much on his game, even somewhat smug and satisfied. Imagine! What can I say? Ye gods! This isn’t what I pinned my hopes on almost four years ago.
Glad to hear it but don’t push yourself too fast and hurt it all over again.
Maybe they’re just ignorant dumbasses….
Occam’s Razor?
Unfortunately, this may be one of those times when it does not apply.
I don’t think that that theory takes into account plain old meanness, and/or the active desire to actually hurt other humans.
ohmygod, did I just bring science into a discussion of republicans?
ferchrissakes, self.
Hey Eli!
on edit: er, now I’m talking to myself on-line.
my shrink will be thrilled – oughta be worth a few more sessions….
Hey BFL. Hope all is happy in your world. I like you.
Hey kids, the facts are on our side. How come it’s not working?
I know, I know. I’ll try to stay down more tomorrow.
The redness is almost completely gone and so’s the pain.
It’s easier to stay down knowing that things are a bit in order here.
You know what I mean, don’t you?
Hey jayt!
What works is to have people come into the United States with a little bit of money in their pocket, legally, with sponsors so that if anything happens to them they don’t fall back on the taxpayers to take care of them.
Michelle in the words of Tom Petty the guy who does not want you using his song “everybody has had to fight to be free” Haymarket riot Chicago German Lefties, The Irish threatened to burn down New York. The Italians turned to the Mob for protection and to get things done.
Immigrants is GOP code for hispanics these days but once it was code for you Michelle.
If you had no money chances are you came to America as a slave an indentured servant and or a crook those were the founding fathers.
Immigrants chose to come here.
Oh yeah. You’re talking to the lady that had a thin coating of white dust all over everything last week.
We are especially grateful for your opinion of us.
Thank you and goodnight.
The GOP is forgetting Reagan messages of hate like this should only be spoken to Southern Audiences they should not be reported by the Press to Northern States.
You poor fools are the very definition of useful idiot.
that’s idiots (plural) to you.
thanks for stopping by.
Neko’s settled down?
You’re such a good mommy, I’m sure she’s adjusted.
*
Btw, Have you read the Highlander series by Diana Gabaldon? I’m reading the fifth one – The Fiery Cross. Right up your alley, I think. Historical fiction with time travelers.
Helping to keep me sane right now. Well relatively so.
Reagan always appeared the Moderate and spoke in better code than Michelle and to be fair the rest of the GOP does these days.
The trick is your racist audience knows who you mean nobody else. You don’t say anything to scare Moderate voters especially not when your Tea Baggers are less popular than Muslims are. Now if they had a brain would be the time to be all smiles, hope, etc.
Somewhat. And thanks! :)
Nope but it sounds great! I’ll look for it when I’ve finished my new book “Against All Things Ending”.
Dunno why conservative asshats criminalize labor. The lines of a nation-state on a map or globe? Puh-lease! Labor follows work. It’s as simple as that. Always has been, always will.
They criminalize labor, and mix in insane racism to boot.
Just looked up yours. Sounds good too.
And poverty, ethnicity, sexuality, gender identity, addiction, certain religious points of view, etc…
LOL. I have been thinking why all the !Shock! Shock. Limbaugh has been calling SS a Ponzi scheme for at least 15 years and I get stuff in my inbox about “government injections.” and similar paranoid delusions daily. Just last week was one proving Obama is a Muslim because he was not wearing a ring or watch during Ramadan.
But to be serious. I am so glad to see it getting National exposure. If the Democrats just run tapes of that debate yesterday for the campaign (and he keeps his mouth shut and doesn’t reveal his own delusional state hidden) Obama will win in a walk. ..
Oh yeah. Sorry I didn’t describe it to you. I’ve been reading this series for over thirty years and I sometimes forget that not everybody knows wtf I’m talking about.
They need to keep the poor divided or else we will get smart and go after them. They need scapegoats for their bad economic decisions that destroyed the economy.
but sadly a loss for us
and I get stuff in my inbox about “government injections.”
Perry’s forced cancer vaccine of dubious merit? But cash for his friend. Oh wait thats Tea Bagger projection on us we want government regulation to keep vaccines safe and yes we want kids vaccinated. I think we can now micotarget Tea Bagger neighborhoods by looking for outbreaks in private schools for diseases we have vaccines for
. This would save Dems work if we just avoid spending in those districts.
Demi, glad that you are better. Take care and don’t step backward without looking, please.
But to be serious. I am so glad to see it getting National exposure. If the Democrats just run tapes of that debate yesterday for the campaign (and he keeps his mouth shut and doesn’t reveal his own delusional state hidden) Obama will win in a walk. ..
Yes I think this would make a great Dem TV ad!
Spanish, Korean, Polish etc newspapers run this in their ads microtarget!
Well, that happens. Sometimes. Hardeeharhar.
Thanks, Twain. I’ll try. I really will.
My friends were legal but all went to Chicago 50 miles away to learn Polish its not only the illegals who read the foreign language papers plus ad buys would be much cheaper!
Let’s explore that, shall we?
There’s the intro:
And then it gets right to the
meatmoney of the matter:KA-CHING! Who used to be a Democrat? Perry used to be a Democrat….
This is great except for the part where Perry used to be a democrat.
Just pointing out that it supports my argument above that Democrats are much better at graft than Republicans. Perry, having been a Dem, has got all the moves down.
Ok still we got dirt on Perry Dirt the Tea Baggers care about. They don’t care about facts only belief and they believe Perry is wrong on this issue they care about a bunch.
I haven’t seen any polls to back this up, but if Rick Perry is the Republican nominee, then I think the GOP has written off what Ronald Reagan used to call ‘The Big Casino’ (that is, California) with all its electoral votes. Yeah.
Was it Michele Bachmann who would not denounce slavery bc slavery is mentioned in the Bible?
P.S. Texas isn’t big enough.
I’m not sure, but that would actually be an improvement…
Bachmann may be a racist Tea Partier, but she was absolutely correct in calling out Perry on Gardasil.
By golly, then, all we’d have to do is ask her to denounce incest and we’ll have pretty much taken Crazy Mishie out of the running.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gardasil#Safety
I wish America had Spain’s rules about drug safety.
Lucifer could call out Perry.
Let’s not forget fratricide.
Perry gives evil a bad name. The devil use to stand for trickery which required cleverness. Perry and today’s GOP is Obvious in their lies and rely on belief and hatred of what the other side believes to get results.
The Trickster Pagan God’s all became devils to the church of One God One belief now the trickster God is being replaced by a devil who calls himself the one God and has one belief and only offers hope to his chosen people.
Hey Eli! Hope you forgive me for going off topic. I mean really how much can we say about Bachman, besides ptui, ptui, ptui.
Thanks for letting us ramble on….camerman. *g*
That was at best the right thing done for the wrong reason. The thing to call Perry on is the obvious corruption that surrounded that order (see Margaret @71). Crazy Mishie’s anecdotal accusations about Gardasil causing mental disability are ludicrous on their best day and in a just world they would chase her right out of the running.
Oh, I didn’t. It’s just that the incest would be a lot more damning.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gardasil
Gardasil’s risk vs benefit is not known so those 6th grade girls might not have any protection in their 30′s or maybe even their 20′s when they actually start having more sex?
It’s not a just world? You want to make me cry, don’t you?
Sweet dreams everyone.
My research has convinced me that the doubts and fears expressed by many about Gardasil are not ludicrous. The vaccine is still new, it was pushed into use very quickly, and its safety and value have not been effectively demonstrated. The many reports of extreme adverse effects need to be studied much more. I am also suspicious of the role of Merck and Co., producers of the vaccine, in persuading “august medical bodies” (as Nancy Snyderman terms them) to prematurely vouch for the vaccine’s safety.
Off-topic, perhaps? Please forgive me.
Pfc. Bradley Manning is still incarcerated as I type these letters. He hasn’t been found guilty of anything, but he has been tortured, and he’s still imprisoned waiting for his day in court.
All this, in America.
Good night, and good luck.
Thanks for reminding us
Is Obama a better human being than Michelle Bachman, Rick Perry, Ron Paul, Mitt Romney? NO
Obama is the one toturing Bradley Manning
Obama is the one who came up with the idea of killing Social Security
Obama loves the Bush Tax Cuts, they are now the OBAMA tax cuts
Obama loves the Bush Wars, now they are the OBAMA wars
When you wake up! you will see that the TEA PARTY already has thier GUY in the White House “OBAMA”
all war is base on Deception! SUN TZU
yes the rich are at war with middle class
Ignorant dumbasses OR dog whistling to racists? Can’t they be both?
Eli !
I wanna be the first to throw it down … Phillies take Yankees in 6 games to win the World Series !
*Ducks and runs*
It’s goes much deeper than all this and it boils down to one thesis I find quite compelling: in American politics, conservatism and racism are the same and always have been. Robert Smith makes the argument that…
Click here
Petro !
I don’t think the Yankees will make it to the World Series, not with that rotation.
Petro!! mon ami!
Under current conditions where medical care, especially pharmaceuticals are developed and marketed for profit we should be suspicious of all new products.
Obama is no more a tool of corporations than a mafia thug is a tool of the grocery store he shakes down. He favors some sectors with corrupt privilege, from whom he exacts tribute, while disfavoring others, from whom he can still exact tribute under the threat of honoring, capriciously, the solemn oath he made to take care that the laws are faithfully executed.
Again, for the sake of clarity: Obama is the patron, the corporations are his clients. Such an arrangement has existed since long before democracy was invented.
It plays well enough in northern states that Bachmann is a rep from Minnesota. I live up here.
This post reflects the typical misconception about how the politics of immigration works. The desire for more enforcement, not more immigration is not just about what the right wing wants, it’s about what most people want. That’s not to be confused with what most politicians want, or with what most elites want.
On Michelle Bachman, I think she is a smart person. I wouldn’t vote for her because I don’t agree with most of her positions, but she’s hardly the only pol out there that makes the occasional embarrassing mistake. V.P. Joe Biden is well known to make similar mistakes. For example, not long ago he talked to someone on the record about F.D.R. being on television even though the television hadn’t been invented yet.
Also, I think Bachman was just talking about how liberals, in the 1960s, opened up immigration again after it had been turned way down earlier in the century, after the great wave that had come earlier.
I know liberals are in love with immigration, for some reason. I for one don’t want 500 million people in this country, and I would prefer that it remain majority white, especially given how blacks treat some white people in Africa, and how horrible so much black “leadership” is there. As far as I’m concerned this country has been extremely successful with its white leadership, in spite of all the problems.