And our collective national remembrance, summary of lessons learned and wrong paths taken, moments of silence for the victims and fond memories of an America that was and shall not be — is all done for another year, and without an echo-event to further traumatize a fearful people.
Behind us, then, this last and greatest anniversary: perhaps? Without forgetting the victims or disrespecting their loved ones — might it be? Can we now move on? Will it be possible now to dial back the public, national paroxysm of grief to allow private mourning, personal reflection, and public accountability? All of which, I submit, have been obscured by our media and political elites’ co-option of this anniversary.
Everyone mourns differently because everyone’s experience of that day is different. Acknowledging that uniqueness, though, I submit that this weeks-long media celebration (for that’s what it was), the repetition of painful images and recitation of mistakes made and opportunities lost helps no one. I simply do not believe that continued escalation of the public, national, communal nature of this commemoration will help any one individual — or our nation — heal.
And we favor healing, do we not?
Honoring the victims, remembering — and caring for — the heroes, comforting the grieving survivors, mourning actual loss: can we make this anniversary about that as we go forward? Let’s excuse our political and military leaders (who failed us all that day) from their pompous displays of jingoism, while we prevail upon our orgiastic media to lock away in their vaults the ghastly images they use to claim our eyeballs and then sell us stuff.
Media alert: We know what that day looked like. You needn’t remind us.
Let’s not glorify this awful wound so publicly again. Let’s heal. Let’s help America heal.




88 Comments





Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
yes
There is a difference between grieving and wallowing. The sad faces at ground zero today could not be avoided because they were everywhere. I feel so sorry for those who lost loved ones but it’s time to move on now.
well said teddy *standing on chair clapping wildly* well said
Teddy!
I have to say that all this 9/11 fetishism is highly disturbing. There is nothing comparable for Oklahoma City or any of a number of other equally devastating events. Even Pearl Harbor Day is much more restrained.
Good evening, all.
Sadly, yes — indeed.
I just don’t think we who were, frankly, less affected by the horror of that day can help those who were directly affected by steeping in their well-deserved grief. Part of healing is seeing others move on into the world and the future.
If we all hang back in the griefatorium with those directly affected, how will they heal? How will they see life go on if we don’t go on with life?
Thank you, Suz
Can we now move on?
Amen, Teddy…!
Worse, all this wallowing in the pain and sorrow feeds the anger, hatred, and xenophobia that besets our country now.
Someone checked, and on December 7, 1951, there was a small article on page nine of the Washington Post commemorating Pearl Harbor. Of course by then we’d vanquished those evildoers and were well into the next Asian land war against another enemy.
I agree and perhaps these yearly grief-a-thons are enabling.
I don’t expect people who lost loved ones to ever move on.
But I think the rest of us can provide a better example of how to heal than we have done these past ten years.
So is the 911 joy-gasm over yet?
Can’t wait for this day to be over.
What this country has become is a travesty and insult to everyone who died that day. Killing and maiming 1 million +++ brownies … well FUCK, we are so FUCKed.
That is the critical point. Those who lost someone have a right and a need to grieve that loss. The rest of us do not have such a need and all these celebrations (that is what they are) simple feeds the anger.
Thanks Teddy,
What you said.
The near red alert crap about potential terrorist threats, 14,000 rounds of ammo missing from an army base, keep the fear ramped up to max, the brown Americans are still suspect, heard it all, I heard it all ten years ago and I still don’t believe a word of it.
9/11 with the first news reports the former spouse was crying and I just said, Bush Cheney you f##kers.
Don’t forget that politicians get to make gaudy speeches as well.
I don’t expect people who lost loved ones to ever move on.
Nor do I, Teddy…! *g*
I have specifically avoided 9/11 threads, but I’ll opine on this one.
People who haven’t learned, are learning the difference between what is a difference, what is a threat, and what is an existential threat.
Just about everything since 9/11 has been presented as an existential threat, where that really isn’t true. These are distinctions with real differences.
True understanding the spectrum of this is required to deal with all the problems we have, otherwise what happens is ultra-force is applied to every difference, threat, or existential threat. And when what solution is applied is beyond what is required to fix a problem, new problems are created.
I can’t imagine they help anyone except the media and the politicos.
I’ve avoided everything all weekend, even the lauded Paul Krugman column.
And when I asked myself why, I wrote this post.
Thanks, Kelly.
Our illustrious Gov Walker got his face screened enough today, but he just can’t conjure the look that says, “I truly feel your loss.”
No, I didn’t mean to imply that you did.
But I feel that I have a responsibility to move on. By disengaging from the media and political/security hoopla surrounding the anniversary, I can leave the space for those who are truly mourning.
And those who’d like to exploit their grief.
I don’t think it’s possible to feel the pain of someone else. Grief is a very private thing – at least I think so.
The real existential threat has always been our (over)reaction to these events and our transformation into something dark, ugly, and fearful.
Thanks for better stating what I was trying to say. These guys all appeared to be performing an unwanted duty or obligation.
And those who’d like to exploit their grief.
The sorriest of the lot…! 8-(
Tragedy happens. People die…..sometimes violently and often without any reason. People do move on. The alternative is creepy. It doesn’t mean that you forget your loss or even get ‘closure’…..but you move on. Life is a one-time deal, and I doubt that those who died on September 11, 2001 would wish for their family members to be stuck in time and grief. Leave those folks alone!
The real tragedy of 9/11 is what happened to this country AFTER the towers fell.
I have thought a lot today about the children – especially young ones – of those who died. Have the remaining parents overwhelmed them with grief? I hope not. Children don’t grieve like adults and they can’t understand or help.
Indeed. Well said. It is now about 10 years since my father died and twenty since my mother did. I still remember and miss them, but life goes on and I do not obsess about it and it does not rule my life.
Are you a bunch of suckers? 9/11 is not a memorial, it’s a celebration of the rich and powerful. They used it to screw the middle class and poor throughout the world.
There were not big sloppy events for the Murrah Building, Colombine, the soldiers who got blown away at that base, etc., etc. This was a ghoulish attempt to make the warz in Afghan/Iraq palatable to the populace. I say, Just Say No to such manipulation. Crap, America, Get a Damned Grip!!
My thoughts exactly.
Very well put.
Indeed, as I indicated above.
I have come to wonder if this day is believed and celebrated by some as a Shock Doctrine high water mark. Certainly this decade has created even more millionaires and billionaires not just in the US but in India and China.
Germany has smart laws against using Nazi imagery in public.
I wonder if we could pass a law like that about the towers.
It’s porn, and people are drawn to it. But it could also be banned.
Walker in Wisconsin? When he says that he feels others’ loss, it’s because he has his hand in his pocket, lined with Koch cash.
Nah, it is war porn. It is designed to justify our endless wars and the security state theater and keep people from asking about their steadily eroding rights. It does not hurt that it makes some very influential people very rich along the way.
There’s a lot of porn (figuratively speaking) coming from our MSM every day.
MSNBC usually has “prison porn” every weekend instead of covering actual news. This weekend they made an exception. But next weekend, back to the porn.
Right.
Yes, like Michael (Nosferatu) Chertoff with his airport machines.
Thank you Teddy, you said what I’ve been thinking all day.
I think that Pearl Harbor Day was eased for our grandparents by V-J Day four years later. But any victories we’ve had in our ill-advised “war on terror” have been hollow. Bill Clinton treated the first terror attacks on the WTC not as excuses to go to war, but as crimes — and caught and brought the perps to justice in a couple of years, all without damaging our international ties or our international status. Bush and Cheney and their fellow PNACers used 9/11 as the excuse to invade Iraq as well as Afghanistan, a decision which may yet do to America what invading Afghanistan did to the old Soviet Union.
Actually, I had Northrup Grumman, KBR, GE, Bechtel, and the like in mind.
Let us just be done with this.
Time for me to toddle off. The corrupting of the nation’s youth continues in the morning. Take care all.
Teach them to be real, Dr. Dick…..teach them to be real!
endless wars,and endless profits for the few well connected
This.
Jumping in without reading at all at 49 – hey everyone. I spent the day driving from Wilmington DE to Cleveland, thinking about everything 9/11. I don’t want to watch any tv, but I want to feel free again.
Youth, be afraid!
G’nite, doctor.
Hey Teddy,
I met a wonderful couple at Jack’s wedding, recently moved to Portland. They love it there!
perspective,and niters dicDoc
http://www.icelandreview.com/icelandreview/daily_news/Noam_Chomsky_in_Iceland_Compares_Nixon_and_Kissinger_to_bin_Laden_0_382043.news.aspx
hiya CE — what’s the latest in DE?
Fab wedding, more than I could ever imagine.
I have exhaled — thank you Teddy.
and this guy is batshit
Joint Chiefs chairman praises 10 years of war as America’s ‘vengeance’
Source: The Raw Story
WASHINGTON — US military and political leaders on Sunday paid solemn tribute to the victims of the 9/11 attack on the Pentagon and to troops who have waged a war of “vengeance” in the decade since.
“Lives ended in this place. Dreams were shattered. Futures were instantly altered. Hopes were tragically dashed,” Admiral Mike Mullen, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, said at a ceremony marking the day a hijacked airliner slammed into the Pentagon ten years ago.
Mullen, joined by Vice President Joe Biden and Defense Secretary Leon Panetta, said the attack inspired a new generation to join the armed forces as the country sought retribution against Al-Qaeda militants.
“From this place of wrath and tears, America’s military ventured forth as the long arm and clenched fist of an angry nation at war.
Read more: http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2011/09/11/joint-chiefs-chai… /
So great to hear everything went well.
sweet dreams pups,and a Buddhist prayer for living in the blissful moment
g nite
night, sadlyyes
Most beautiful wedding MrCE and I ever attended , including our own. Combine garden beauty, loved ones attending,and a family thrilled at this union. Perfect.
hello, Christine.
Hey Teddy! Sending love…
Portland is swell, but man is it HOT this time of year.
Bears don’t do so well in this heat.
I hope it breaks this week.
Oh man, it is so cool here in Cleveland — we love it here at 62! Can you believe this!
Sounds like the American Dream. I am happy for you and yours. Thanks for brightening the place up here a bit.
What happiness, CE, to enjoy such a wonderful wedding …. fabulous! And Suzanne says your shoes were great….and I remember her shoes from past wedding days. :)
Hey, nonquix, I tried to email you but my new computer is doing something really beyond the pale….my daughters say they are not getting any of my emails, either. I was off in Cartagena for 10 days, but I am determined to respond to you. Hope all went well.
It was so wonderful == I cried like a baby.
Sadly, take a gander at this RT interview today with Col. Wilkerson…!
Tis a shame David Gregory/Chris Matthews, et al, don’t ask the very same damn questions…!
Key: 15 is the worst. It gets better. Really, it does. :)
We’ll send some bay area fog in your direction, Teddy.
hiya CT
My shoes were FABULOUS, and I danced with them on for hours…
Oh, happy, rhythmic memories! Once in a lifetime. So glad you enjoyed every moment.
Aloha, PPD…!
I did. Thanks so much.
I’ve got LLN on tap…! Three Little Birds…
I do the same thing frequently with the slightest joyful noise or inspiration.
Thanks,
15 and 2 months is already revealing some big changes for the better. ;)
New computer here too, trying to turn off all the useless bells and whistles.
We already were something “dark, ugly and fearful,” or do the million or so killed by the U.S. in Indochina stand for nothing? The thousands killed by U.S. backed, if not trained, death squads in Central America? The tens of thousands missing, tortured or killed by the U.S. backed coup in Chile, and the continent-wide Operation Condor that followed? The hundreds of thousands of children who died because of the U.S. sanctions against Iraq?
So no, Teddy, it’s not time to move on. It’s time to call for a real, independent investigation into the events of 9/11 and the subsequent prosecution of the war in Iraq.
When you’ve got intelligence professionals telling you that something bad happened and there was a cover-up, and these aren’t retired cranks, but, in the case I’m thinking of, a working professional in the IC, who can provide the documentation of his claims, moreover, I can only ask, why aren’t people listening?
Today was a disgusting display of in your face propaganda. we cry while the perps laugh and have a cocktail. Perderasts and moonbeams
It was more MSM voyeurism for profit foisted upon a public which needs no reminders of this. We’re already way ahead of the MSM in that regard.
How about those specially withheld FAA tapes kept under wraps just for the occasion — just for the synergistic shock value of something “new” combined with a too magic increment of time, symbols and all?
The last event so exploited was the JFK assassination which caused me to abandon my TV for a couple of days each year as the repugnant storm went by. That ghoulish fascination petered out after about a decade, and I hope it will with 9/11 as well.
Thank goodness it’s 9/12 now and we are allowed to get back to normal lives.
Excellent article. I was thinking the very same things about this anniversary and how it was presented and represented.
Thank you.
This national pity party is brought to you by the corporate media. The same media that are complicit in the false flag attack that is nine eleven. It sickens me to see the sheeple led about by their nose. Our own government murdered three thousand of our own people and ten years later has us celebrating the event. There will be no healing until the truth is told.
Agreed, TeddyWan.