
Gandhi at the SF Ferry Building
On the eve of the tenth anniversary of 9/11, my thoughts turn to peace. It’s hard to keep them there, though, because of the chorus of voices that scream for violence and war.
As Autumn Sandeen noted on Wednesday, there is something truly ghastly when one of the biggest cheers at the recent GOP presidential candidate debate at the Reagan Library went up when Brian Williams made reference to the high number of executions in Texas under Rick Perry.
“What do you make of that dynamic that just happened here?” Williams asked. “The mention of the execution of 234 people drew applause?”
“I think Americans understand justice,” Perry replied.
To borrow from Inigo Montoya, I do not think that word means what he thinks it means. To Perry — and to the folks that applauded — what they applaud, what they want, what they lust for is not justice, but vengeance.
There is a difference.
Faced with violence, too many voices are raised that call for vengeance. All too often, though, we become that which we attack. They send planes into our buildings, and we send predator drones into theirs. As the media embraces a huge 9/11 retrospective, my thoughts turn not to wars (Iraq, Afghanistan, “terror”, “drugs”, Libya . . . oh, wait, that’s not a war, and not even “hostilities”, right?), but to peace.
Blessed are the peacemakers . . .
At the top of the plaque attached to the Gandhi statue at the San Francisco Ferry Building pictured above is this quote from Gandhi:
Non-Violence is the greatest force at the disposal of Mankind. It is the supreme law. By it alone can mankind be saved.
I can think of thousands of monuments and statues dedicated to those who fight with guns and bombs and violence. Statues to those who fight non-violently, though, are few and far between. Gandhi and Martin Luther King Jr. have their statues, sure — but for every one depicting these two giants, there are hundreds devoted to military figures, great and small.
Where are the statues to peacemakers?
Instead of statues to peacemakers like these, Congress wants to cut their budget.
I grieve for those who died ten years ago in New York, DC, and Pennsylvania, as well as all who have died — and continue to die — in the wars spawned out of that attack. I long for the day when military fly-overs at football games become a thing of the past, and our cities have more statues to teachers than generals.
But the cheers for executions, and the willingness to spend billions of dollars on weapons to dole out death but mere pennies on social services that preserve life in one way or another for the most needy among us tell me that the day I long for is quite a ways off.
Obviously, then, the work of peacemaking must go on . . .
___________
Photo h/t to Elaine with Gray Cats. If you know of other good statues to peacemakers, please put them in the comments.
If you think the work of FDL helps in the task of peacemaking, becoming a member of FDL can help that work continue and grow stronger. Click here and check out the details.



36 Comments





Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
That other peacemaker (to whom I will implicitly defer) had one more for law us: that we should carry each others troubles. And we won’t need any weapons to love one another, to fulfill the only law that will lead to social justice.
“Swords into plowshares” has a nice ring to it, don’t you think?
Good stuff, Pete.
Something hateful is rearing it’s head in america.
I have difficulty remembering the last time we had peace and as a result, we have very little peace in our hearts. Hate and fear are the order of the day.
Thanks, Peterr, for reminding us of the peacemakers.
Sadly, it’s not the first time. The Know-Nothings, Jim Crow, the internment of Japanese-Americans, . . .
Almost makes you think that hatefulness is a hydra. Cut off one head, and two more grow back.
Fuck 9/11. I’m sick of hearing about it. It’s just become a diversion tool for the elites, as well as their excuse to put in place a vast snooping network to keep track of us, not our “enemies”.
John Kennedy
Robert Kennedy
Dr. Martin Luther King
Paul Wellstone
Pat Tillman
JFK jr
Those potential peace giants travel a very hazardous road to reach their destiny and we suffer because of their absence caused by accidents.
Who benefits from wars? And who builds the monuments?
Hint: there are big bank accounts behind both.
Look: its time to get over certain basic realities. If you are aware of just how cynical and ultimately evil the political class is, and just how greedy and terrible the plutocracy is, and just how much history can be seen as the continued struggle of non-elites to live and try to thrive despite the control and agenda of wealthy elites, then you’ll have to conclude that you are alone in the wilderness.
The monuments, yes, are largely monuments to ultimately negative things. This is because they are not being built to uphold things you find great. They are being built to uphold things wealthy elites find great. You’re in the wilderness. Get over the outrage, and decide what you intend to do as a consequence.
Frankly, we need more monuments to class warriors, to intransigent labor leaders, socialist martyrs, Western state anarcho-syndicalists, and pro-civil rights before the civil rights era communists.
But the greatest monument would be the simple town square. If more American towns and cities were centered around public spaces, it would have a tangible effect on the level of civic life in this country.
This monument to Mother Jones comes to mind.
You’re right, I think. Several years ago I read an article about how we have closed ourselves off from each other even in the construction of our buildings. Many look like prisons all in the name of privacy and security. People look at you in a strange way if you speak to them on the street. We have turned inward and I suspect we don’t like what we see.
Howard Zinn references this quote in “A power governments cannot suppress” He says that non violent peaceful disobedience is the key to social change. Zinn says if all the people in the military chose not to fight there would not be war. There would be no one to fight. That thought I am sure scares the elites more than anything. IMHO
Aristophanes might agree with Zinn. It may have been a work of fiction, but talk about non-violent peaceful disobedience in a time of war . . .
I think it’s partly the media excesses.
The preoccupation with violence is self-perpetuating; literally, a vicious circle.
I don’t know how you can “legislate” that away, without opening the door for an unwanted level of censorship in other areas. I think it’s up to parents and educators to shine the light of common decency and human kindness on the worse angels of our nature, AND on the willingness to exploit it for money, that so much of our corporate culture exhibits.
You left out Medgar Evers and Malcolm, among others.
I just finished Gandhi by Louis Fischer. I’m 61 and, although I’m not the most violence-prone guy, it changed the way I think.
Gandhi not Ghandi
Very quick list off the top of my head. It’s more important to show the span of generations.
Acckk!
Corrected — and thanks.
*shuffling off to get more coffee*
popeye99 @ #12:
2/3 mercenaries and 1/3 drones “fight” our current “wars” — look for a reversed ratio in future: and soon corps will cut out the middleman (gov’ts). The sociopaths are proliferating.
Hard times for humans these days; hopefully, Mother nature will continue to foil the PTB’s and let the humans that survive build a kinder community.
Q: Why do religions, govts, celebrate their great humiliations (Easter, Ashura, 9/11 to name 3)?
A: To keep the revenge emotion running high so that people’s anger is directed at the other rather than where it should be, at the people’s own leaders.
Analogously, war monuments spur patriotism and keep the people on the side of their incompetent leaders. Monuments to peace would serve no useful purpose in an alpha male society.
I hope that people soon will discover that they have a power to change society. The PTB have keep us fighting among ourselves and the sooner we can join forces we can change our society. Sorry if I seem naive but I am late to the game. I know the current political system can not change our situation we must engage ourselves.
Yesterday, I heard the comments of TSA head on radio who says that his agency has lots of work left to be done. His vision is something like in movie “Total Recall” just stating his illogical short-sighted comments in verbatim. After hearing that all that I can conclude is he is really asking for Americans to vote for Small Government which some advocates say is needed and he might get it sooner than he imagines.
All of our issues are resolvable just with peaceful conservations in line with traditions set by Thoreau, Gandhi, MLK, Mandela, Dalai Lama, Einstein etc. But no that is not the way it happens because the people like TSA head are heading departments who think short-term, childish way, our executive branch wants to remove the safety from our economic system trying to get a short-term mileage or who knows what for, our leadership choosing illogical quixotic un-asked for wars like in Iraq where people are displaced, hurt and probably the whole world is looking with disgust on what the country founded by noble goals of Pres. Jefferson, Pres. Washington and Pres. Adams has turned into. All of this creation of strife and hatred is to get illusory visions of power on others, personal goals and monetary greed and pushing pendulum sadly other way and getting huge push-back in return.
We are really at a point in Civilization where we can have Utopia if we want to without strife and violence where everyone has a fulfilling life pursing their own visions of happiness and everyone is given ample opportunities to be highly educated and participate in how they resolve the shared resources allocation and really think long term consequences of their choices. I am almost sure if everyone is given opportunities to be well educated they will have make choices always thinking long term (because no one wants a worse future for anybody) and all the issues we have currently get resolved just by itself due to those well thought of choices.
That is the money quote. The hardest to deal with. If we truly want to change this it starts inside-duh. We all struggle with this incomprehensible darkness that evokes the worst in us. Something this old man fights daily. If we were to achieve some kind of victory within TPTB would fall. It is not easy to do, that looking at your own shit.
This may sound ridiculous but give it some thought. There are dark forces afoot that feed, feast on our hate and violence. It is either from without or within, it really matters not for the purpose of what I am saying. I won’t boor you with the whole rap. We have a choice in how we react. The right choice is humanity but I fear many are too brainwashed, captured by the false illusion of things,so dumbed by design and soporific that they won’t know what hit them. Much less have this thought of choice of light or dark.
All I really know is that we are at the end of one way and the beginning of another. I am mystified that more don’t see what I see, so maybe these words are written by an insane nut case.
T/U for the post
Good post, peterr. I had similar thoughts visiting the new MLK memorial 2 weeks ago and going to see the Dalai Lama’s Buddhist training teachings here in DC in July, and your post reminded me of Kucinich’s call to establish a Dept. of Peace. To get to the MLK memorial, you have to pass all the war memorials en route to see the quotes/statue of someone assassinated who was pushing us to transcend war/national divisions. Two of the quotes at the memorial:
“It is not enough to say, ‘We must not wage war.’ It is necessary to love peace and sacrifice for it. We must concentrate not merely on the negative expulsion of war, but on the positive affirmation of peace.”
“True peace is not merely the absence of tension: it is the presence of justice.”
I had already been thinking about what you’ve written here, Peterr. I guess statuary honoring saints who were martyred as peacemakers could qualify. There are probably more MLK statues in the USA than there are for all other peacemakers combined. I can think of no statues at all in Alaska honoring a person of peace.
Tomorrow, September 11th, there will be ceremonies all around Alaska, commemorating the 10th anniversary of a huge lie. I was asked yesterday to play Taps on the bugle at a ceremony at our local Veterans Wall of Honor. I was reluctant, as it will be just one more series of genuflections in the direction of military fascism. But I decided to play, so that the notes they hear will come fro someone who earnestly believes that we need to stop our wars – NOW!
I liked that
I think that’s what Zinn tries to drive home. That the way we react has an effect that ripples through society. I think your post is right on and I guess that would make me an insane nutcase as well. :) Just my observation.
James Hinton, Philosophy and Religion: Selections the Manuscripts of the Late
James Hinton, ed. Caroline Haddon, (2nd ed., London: 1884)
yes, and surprisigly it takes only a fraction of all to start it. my head is hard and it is just dawning on me what I have done and I shiver that I could be so ignorant and most likely still am. We see what is possible, the beauty before our eyes.
I understand that as I myself have been ignorant for a long time. Thanks to the fine folks here my eyes have been opened and I am learning all the time. Let’s hope other will arrive in their own time and get them to join in a movement that can’t be stopped. All is possible.
That is such a profound statement for me. I had to reread that paragraph, and take a minute to think about it. Then then I googled “teachers statue”.
I got a lousy 294 hits. This first page has 2 asianwholesaleimports, Chinese scholar Ass., Statue of Liberty, where is a website for teachers statues? So I go to google images looking for it, the first pic is a teachers statue in Toronto, then pics of Statue of Liberty, furniture, people, but no Statue for Teachers. I am dumbfounded. Not only because I could not find one, but because you are the first and only person I have ever heard or read that was smart enough to think of such a thing. I hope that changes and soon. What a conparison, the number of military/war statues vs the number of Teacher statues?
http://www.google.com/search?q=%22teachers+statue%22&sourceid=ie7&rls=com.microsoft:en-US&ie=utf8&oe=utf8&rlz=1I7GGLL_en
Our capitalistic notion of our society/economy refutes cooperation. The myth of competition is the best form of allocating scarce resources in ingrained in us sometime after childhood. Even as our environment deteriorates to the point where it won’t be surprising that you will see people walking around with small tanks of oxygen to breath clean air as we do today to buy a bottle of clean water to drink today at a convenience store . American culture is being desensitized to violence, through films, television, and video games furthermore it is now considered patriotic to believe in the security state that we created in this country.
I can’t stand the worship of violence anymore. When I heard the beginning of a speech on the radio that started with something like –it was a lovely day and three thousand people died who just wanted to have a normal day at work and were totally innocent — I ran over and shut it off as fast as I could –finishing my internal speech with: Yes, 18 hateful idiots killed three thousand in the US for which we killed hundreds of thousand in return – what does that make us?
I agree 100%!
Sometimes we forget how good progressive taxation and affordable higher education results in a better society and thereby peace and prosperity for all.
Let me take an example:
Andy Griffith Show was a by-product of progressive taxation and affordable higher education in 1950s. At the moment in time society was a pretty much in a state to transform to a even better society if it had right leadership and by now we might not have need for Police State.
Andy was a sheriff without a gun and Barney was the one who always wanted to carry a bullet with gun around and write tickets. It was Andy who kept order in the town just by talking to folks, understanding them and Barney was the one who messed up everybody’s time trying to keep order writing tickets etc. just like our TSA which really is relishing at the thought of creating a police state and our executive branch with mandates for private for profit medical institutions. All those Andy Griffith Show episodes had a moral on how to make the society better and make life more peaceful.
None of the tv series or movies now-a-days have those morals nor the thought process going into it because of lack of progressive taxation and none of us realize it. Even advanced countries once they introduced VAT taxation with in place of progressive taxation have people behaving more violently due to reduced opportunities. People by nature want to be better and it is the system which drags them down and the sad part we make the system and we not realize how the violence and hatred is being generated because of the structure when if we just make some changes we can create paradise on this planet.