
(image: www.cbpp.org)
The URL for this Mary Williams Walsh article, “Panel to Scrutinize Causes Behind Weak State Budgets”, in the New York Times gives a big clue as to who will be blamed, yet again, for messing up the budgets of our states:
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/06/24/business/economy/24pension.html
Yup, it’s those greedy workers again, wanting not to frickin’ starve in their old age!
Amazingly enough, Walsh fails to mention the role played by the massive tax cuts that the vast majority of states pushed through in the 1990s. It was known, as far back as 2002, that these tax cuts were going to cause major problems down the road — in fact, they already were causing major problems in 2002, with the first Bush Recession having kicked the air, and much of the revenue production, out of the economy:
States now face a gigantic revenue problem. Total state tax revenue in fiscal year 2002 was some $38 billion lower than it was in the previous year after adjusting for inflation. Some 45 states lost revenue. Official forecasts released to date suggest that state revenues at best will hold steady after adjusting for inflation in fiscal year 2003, meaning that none of that $38 billion is likely to be recouped this year. Indeed, the revenue hole could get even deeper.
These revenue problems are taking a substantial toll on the services provided by state governments. Many states, for instance, are reducing health insurance benefits or eligibility for low-income families, or are increasing the amount that poor families must pay to access health insurance. Many states are reducing eligibility for child-care subsidies for working families; many are raising tuition for students at public colleges and universities. And further such cuts are likely to occur as states exhaust their rainy day funds and other one-time mechanisms for shoring up budgets.
Personally, here’s what I find to be really sick about this: The guy who in Minnesota was one of the main drivers to slash state taxes was the guy who was running the Minnesota House in the late 1990s — Tim Pawlenty. He then ran for governor on a platform of eliminating the very deficit he’d worked to create, artfully dodging (with local media assistance) all blame on his way to the Governor’s Mansion. Now he wants to be president.
As with the states, so it is with the nation: The Bush tax cuts are the single biggest set of factors driving up the nation’s debt. Period. Even the multiple wars aren’t as big a drain. But of course you won’t see this mentioned much on the evening TV news — they’re too busy telling us we must give up our retirements so that rich people don’t have to pay taxes.
Keep your eyes on Illinois. Its legislature and governor moved to reverse course, stop the insanity, and raise taxes as a part of the plan to get out of the hole dug by all the tax cuts of the past twenty years. I say to keep an eye on Illinois because chances are good that our corporate tax-cut-loving national media will not, especially if the state does well as a result of stopping the tax-cut insanity.



55 Comments












Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
And if you live in a state that has a balanced budget amendment, then they cut public school funding to balance the budget. Programs are cut, days are cut, but the teachers are still required to cover the same material when they had 20 more school.
Thank you, PW.
We all need to start writing letters to the editor, and commenting on “main stream” blogs, raising this point in response to every story about
a) the scary, scary deficit [whether state or national];
b) the need to cut workers’ benefits [but not those of executives];
c) the need to cut social security, Medicare & Medicaid.
I am so sick of the platitudes and flat-out untruths used to mezmerize this country into a hypnotized state of tax avoidance and budget cutting. This is just sick, and someone needs to start combatting this crap.
morning pw and ALL DAWGS!!
PW you know I love ya but we really have to stop falling into their trap and calling the redistribution plot “tax cuts”
middle class, lower class and of course upper class are all very happy with “tax cuts” because they don’t know they aren’t cuts at all they are add ons
we need to start calling these supposed “cuts” ” middle class asset redistribution to the wealthy”
hopefully someone can come up with a more compact term but they are NOT “tax cuts”
NOT in Washington – MY teacher’s union the WEA is strongly for thinking about actively meeting and considering discussing appropriate responses to being really really careful,
otherwise
all the legislators and elected Democrats who sold us out will NOT invite our union “Leadership” to the occasional seat at the rubber chicken buffet!
/ end snark … kind of.
Why are community employees taking the blame and taking the financial hit for the collapse of AAA rated ponzi schemes and pyramid schemes? NOT as much as we think from the deliberate actions of thieving lying aristocrats who are just doing what lying stealing elites do –
WHERE is Democratic “leadership” ?? I saw that the EX-$ell-0ut in chief clinton had a piece in Newsweek justifying his billshit to wall street turned into 0bummershit to wall street!
THE PROBLEM is NOT lying stealing aristocrats doing their job, THE PROBLEM is the fucking political incompetents and fucking sell outs sucking up “leadership” paychecks in the Democratic party.
Give the aristocrats credit – the game plan is to rip off the bottom 99% so that the bottom 99% have the opportunity to be a doormat, or an ass kisser, or a back scratcher, or a cannon fodder, or a serf, or some combination of all of the above – and to achieve that game plan they ONLY hire liars who are good at lying! DUH??
How come out “leadership” can NOT hire people to effectively market the truth?
rmm
rmm.
The thing to keep in mind is that the glue that has held the Reagan coalition together for 30 years is deficit spending and the Social Security surplus (stealth deficit spending). We’ve built up a huge debt that is able to be serviced only because interest rates are near zero. The SS surplus is getting smaller (as expected). So the free money drug that the Republicans have used to buy off their constituents for 30 years is just about gone. When it goes, so does the Reagan coalition.
So ask yourself a question? How much economic value did America waste today as a society driving to work, travelling on vacation and/or transporting goods and products? It has been said that the Erie Canal system reduced the cost of transportation by 90% and fueled America’s westward movement. Today the cost of basic transportation guts America to the tune of at least a billions of dollars a day, and people wonder where all the money when to? The biggest tax on life is the cost and inefficient use of energy. Instead we protect the very interests which, in spite of the perceived liberties they provide, enslave USA! So just continue to waste all that money out the tailpipe and screw America while the Koch brothers get to spend the money extracted from the American people, to by politicians and law, at our expense. I recall how BIG Tobacco instilled the notion of “freedom,” when marketing their deadly product. The Marlboro Men all died of lung cancer. Real Freedom, Real Liberty! This is what big oil sells America, an illusion. A lie. Just like Big tobacco and those who think tax cuts for the rich, will stimulate the economy, its the same big lie! These bastards lie right through their pearly white teeth! What they need is a symbolic cross-check, in the “chicklettes” cracking some of those pearly white teeth. Hockey is a great sport. Where retribution is permitted, to level the playing field when there are bullies taking head shots at team mates.
We could have rail roads. But the Oil Companies wont allow it. Shucks!
I have a temporary job for a federal agency in a rural county. Federal and state government workers bring in most of the income here. But they are passive, passive, passive. I never hear a peep about any activity, but only a bunch of tea party bilge in the lunchroom. They should own their Congressman, but he is a leading tea bagger, leading the attack in a very personal way on federal workers. Most of my co-workers probly vote for him.
Hell, even Republicans like former Minnesota governor and state treasurer Arne Carlson were warning in the ’90s not to do the tax cuts. But they went ahead and did them, which is one reason why Carlson left — or was kicked out of — the party a few years ago.
Good morning, everyone! How are your gardens growing?
Strawberries are coming in in Oregon, but I am not home to enjoy them.
Great post, PW.
Most of the U.S. public believes in a “me” society and not a “we” society consequently taxes are just a burden to the individual. It’s finally catching up to the selfish, myopic ugly American.
But but but FREEDOM!!!! (English translation: I moved to the exurbs so I wouldn’t have to see black people and now you want to make me sit on a bus with them?!?)
Hey, good morning P Dub
Generally, things are going slowly. Now that summer has finally arrived, I’m seeing some activity. I’ve got some plums ripening on the tree, but not a lot. It’s a smallish tree. Tomatoes are finally getting larger and a few are getting yellow…a step towards red. The zuchs are starting…they’re so cute when they are small. The grapes are turning pin and should be harvestable in a week or so. I put a pumpkin plant and a watermelon plant in the ground and they are starting to get multiple leaves. Of course, it’s early for them. That’s about it.
Thanks for asking.
Oh yes, I’ve got a couple nice healthy looking bell peppers that I’ve been tempted to pluck, but I’m waiting patiently. Will take them camping with me this next week. Should make for some good breakfast potatoes.
How’s your home grown?
There obviously was a REASON to put the screws to America in these tax cuts and the reason, IMO, was to get US exactly where we are now.
Once they rob us of everything, watch those tax cuts vanish.
It seems to be a state by state “final solution” with both parties participating.
Oh, fine. Now I have coffee on my laptop screen.
…….”they’re too busy telling us we must give up our retirements so that rich people don’t have to pay taxes.”
That’s it in a nut shell PW.
That’s a tragedy! Fresh strawberries are here too.
Impressive. Bell peppers, tomatoes: you’ve got a good climate.
Picked the 1st tomato just yesterday. Everything’s doing pretty well except the cucumbers. That one’s got me stumped. It’s alive, but growing in ultra slow-mo. Maybe I should sprinkle a couple pounds of amphetamines on the soil. Hell, I might even make it into “Crack Gardener of the Month” magazine…
Off for a ride with local cyclists. One or two are not even right wingers.
It’s been coolish here — aside from a small heat wave two week ago when it hit 103F for the first time in ages — but also very wet, so stuff on my balcony’s coming along. Snap peas are the first out of the gate, though I could be harvesting celery if I wanted. The tomato plants are all flowering and one has a tiny green tomato the size of a pea — I’ve staked up my four tomato plants in preparation for a pretty big growth spurt.
Try a 1-to-1 mix of coffee grounds and egg shells.
In the foothills, high desertish, in Southern California.
Have fun!
Lemme guess: Most of your co-workers are white.
Does that work on other plants that are growing “slowish”?
Sounds wonderful. I had a garden in Santa Clara. Good hot summers with a little maritime influence. Now the Willamette Valley in Oregon has quite a different weather regime.
I’ll give it a whirl. Hard to get all the lab equipment and supplies to make that other, um, soil conditioner, anyway… heh
I would have a hard time working in a group that was mostly white. Having grown up in LA, I’m used to diversity. There were times when we vacationed through Northern California, and driving through some of the towns, I would get the kind-of willies.
The other day at work (my volunteer gig), a gal was telling a story about her travails with some cops in Simi Valley. She said, well, ’cause you are, you know white, you wouldn’t know. I didn’t tell her about the burden of the white man, I just said lo siento.
Oh, shoto. You’re making me smile. And, not to mention the dangers involved. The cops and the potential kaboom.
I think I’d have a hard time in a place where it rained all the time. I’m used to the dry and the heat. As an older dog, I can learn a few new tricks, but I’m limited.
Would you still want some of our rain? We’ve got a bit too much right now…
Good point.
Yeah. I know about the older business. Something called cardoon is growing like crazy in my garden. I got a very baleful look from Mrs. C when I mentioned that the stalks are reputedly edible. f
For the work I put in the garden hasn’t given up a whole lot. Maybe when I get back home (soon) I can do some good with collards and a few other things. Corn, cukes, beans and stuff are OK, too. Tomatoes not so much. Plums were mentioned earlier. A neighbor has let us have as many plums as we want on an abandoned tree in his lot. Wow! the best I ever had. They come in in September. Gonna be developed and tree will be a goner soon, I’m afraid.
Gone finally.
Sure, a little bit. At least when we get a bit of the wet, I don’t have to water the yard as much. I can be a lazy person sometimes. :)
FWIW the robbing of the middle class has been going on for a hundred years probably more. They are trying to accelerate the process and to go for the kill. Until the electorate of this country divests itself from the R vs D paradigm this will continue. Corporate America has always ruled this country. IMHO. I have been reading The Nazi Hydra in America and it is an eye opening historical account of this country since the 1900′s. An account that never will be taught in schools. Frightening.
Arrgh. I must be going senile — I thought for sure that I’d deliberately put up the whole NYT URL and bolded the word “pension” in it to show who’s going to be wrongly blamed for the state budget crises:
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/06/24/business/economy/24pension.html
I know what you mean about the energy output vs. the reward of harvast. Especially when you can buy stuff for so cheap. Huge boxes of strawberries for $2.99. But, of course, they don’t taste anything like the ones you grow yourself. Especially true for tomatoes too.
Ah, thanks, Editor person! *smooches*
It’s also stress relief, plus it gives you something over which you have a fair amount of influence and control, which is always good for the soul.
Well, that too, PW, that too.
What the hell else do I have any control over? Ha ha. Me. I can control how I react to stuff.
PS….I just finished pulling out some weeds. Very cathartic. And, yes, weeds…I am the boss of you.
Thanks again.
I’m glad you brought up that asshole Pawlenty from my home state. All the GOP does here is yap endlessly about Minnesota having the highest taxes in the country. If that was true, why was Minnesota the home for decades to 3M, Sperry-Univac, General Mills, a Ford truck plant, IBM, Honeywell, Pillsbury, Control Data Corporation, Deluxe Check, Midland Co-op, Land ‘o Lakes, Cargill, ADM? The list goes on and on. These companies were at their height when taxes, corporate and personal, were at their highest. State governments are completely screwed up, not because of profligate spending, but because they’ve been starved for revenue. We had the 35W bridge collapse on Pawlenty’s watch. The infrastructure here is rotting from neglect. And it’s not because public employees are getting paid too much in wages and benefits.
Slaves wanted liberty and protection of law. The slave owners would not permit it. The Antebellum Senate and House Divided protected the institution of slavery. In fact the slave owners took America to civil war to protect their way of doing business. 650,000+ dead Americans, Shucks……
Today Americans want a standard of living and economic opportunity to attain that standard of living. To bad Congress protects oil corporations the way Congress once protected the institution of slavery? Ironically what both the oil corporations and slave owners sought to protect was “energy profits.” Exploitation of a slave for his uncompensated labor and exploitation of Americans as we continue to waste .80 cents of every dollar spent on gasoline.
Ah shucks is putting is mildly! It should be more like WTF!
Exactly. The budget hole, which he created before he became governor, is even bigger now that he’s out of office.
And bear in mind that — up until he squeaked out a win in 2006 (too bad we couldn’t have taped Mike Hatch’s mouth shut from October 2006 on, or else things would be quite different now), Pawlenty still had to take the concerns of regular Minnesotans into account, so there was some restraint on him. But ever since November of 2006, his whole being has been dedicated to winning over the neo-confederate Bircher/White Citizens Council types that make up the GOP’s primary voter base. (It’s a sign of how pathetic he is at this that Michele Bachmann is wiping the floor with him without even breaking a sweat — and she hadn’t really even dreamed of running for president in 2012 until about six months ago.)
“Until the electorate of this country divests itself from the R vs D paradigm this will continue. Corporate America has always ruled this country. IMHO. I have been reading The Nazi Hydra in America and it is an eye opening historical account of this country since the 1900′s. An account that never will be taught in schools. Frightening.”
Yes it is frightening. And for those whose eye’s gloss over every time they hear the term Nazi, Popyeye99 is RIGHT ON POINT! It is called corporate fascism 101! As Jefferson feared the aristocrats using the undue influence of “money” and a corporate shell, have taken democracy, via Citizens United, just as the concept of democracy, protection of law, god given inalienable rights, was an illusion for human being enslaved and segregated by a southern aristocracy, via Dred Scott! History repeats. No silent American here as they were silent in Germany!
The way Obama is willing to cut spending, it is clear he has already decided to make the Bush/Obama tax cuts permanent.
I am happy to note that some citizens lately have been writing letters to the editor of the local “nooz” paper pointing out that continuing the tax cuts for the super wealthy (and some say it just like that) should be stopped, that we do NOT have allegedly “gawd-awful” high tax rates (and some quote facts and figures), and that the Bush tax cuts must be repealed.
Some citizens also write in pointing out how horrible our state’s infrastructure has become.
FWIW. I agree with a prior comment that we need to start talking in terms of the middle/working class income re-distribution to the super wealthy, because THAT is what it is. We are paying proportionately *more* in taxes, while our wages stagnate or *go down,* while the super wealthy enjoy all their tax loopholes, lurks & incentives and rake in the really big buck$$ off the backs of the middle/working class workers.
Why a certain segment of middle/working class people wish to go along with this abuse is the big question, albeit that R v D paradigm MYTH is part of it. It’s all MY team v. YOUR team, rather than realizing that the us v. them is really about the lower 99% (of whatever political party affiliation) v. the upper 1%.
Thanks for the kind words. :)
And if Mr. Bernanke would declare a preference to return
to teaching we can, in batches:
recapitalize banks, including the TBTF ones run
by self-important fast money-losers;
Give lenders more incentive to lend.
Give those who made good decisions an opportunity to
earn from their savings, though that ability is
impaired, now, after 4 years of aiding a Ponzi scheme
after the fact.
Do whatever is possible on the fiscal side to compensate
for private deleveraging. pure, plain ole Keynesianism,
not apologetically–as much as we can afford.
Like Richard Koo I believe printing dollars is mainly
pushing on a string; though, the U.S. IS much bigger
than Chile, so some I.V. a la Bernanke will still be
necessary.
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB122265260912184329.html
The benefits of the tax cuts for the super wealthy borrowed from
abroad and financed by the rest of the public has not disappeared
but is in bank accounts including offshore.
Think: windfall profits taxes where appropriate.
Fed-financed corporate welfare? Think: royalties.
Offshore drilling? Don’t give it away.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vkf4VQx2MHE
Absent a vibrant middle class the U.S. will be dead in its tracks,
the super-wealthy will have to keep trying to shove debt down
everyone’s throats.
https://sites.google.com/site/evernewecon
You’re welcome!
One would think that adults would have figured out by now that you don’t get something for nothing, but it seems that most Americans haven’t.
Unfortunately adult Americans have failed to figure out how little they get for the money they spend or are taxed? Meanwhile the money utilized by corporations, extracted from the American people, buys law not in the interests of the governed, but protecting the business interests of the corporations. The process has little to do with merit. It has everything to do with protecting cash cows. Yup you don’t get something for nothing. That is why we have unlimited “campaign contributions,” from corporations using tax exempt conduits like the US Chamber of Commerce, to advance a political agendas by throwing money from undisclosed donors to candidates in various states. Then you get something for something? One good example is: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fugitive_slave_laws.
“Congress made a further attempt to address the concerns of slave owners over runaway slaves in 1787 by passing the Northwest Ordinance of 1787.[6] The law appeared to outlaw slavery, which would have reduced the votes of slave states in Congress, but southern representatives were concerned with economic competition from potential slaveholders in the new territory, and the effects that would have on the prices of staple crops such as tobacco. They correctly predicted that slavery would be permitted south of the Ohio River under the Southwest Ordinance of 1790, and therefore did not view this as a threat to slavery.[7] In terms of the actual law, it did not ban slavery in practice, and it continued almost until the start of the Civil War.[8]”
Now whose interest was being protected here? Push that Fast forward button to see the rest of the story or just witness current events! :(