People are arrested for protesting in front of the White House all the time, but most are charged with misdemeanors. According to Dan Choi’s attorney Yetta Kurland, however, not since Woodrow Wilson had Alice Paul arrested in 1917 has anyone been brought up on federal charges for doing so.
Choi chained himself to the White House fence on November 10, 2010 to protest DADT. He and 12 others activists were arrested and charged with violating a federal regulation prohibiting “interfering with agency functions,” in this case refusing to obey an order from the National Park Service.
The government offered a deal to the protesters, provided they plead guilty to a “failure to move” charge. Choi is the only one who refused to do so.
Assistant U.S. Attorney George faced a skeptical court in March of this year, when U.S. Magistrate Judge John M. Facciola questioned her as to why the government was invoking such harsh and unusual charges in the case. Today George faced an equally skeptical Judge Alan Kay, who had little patience for George’s assertions that she did not know until today that Choi was refusing the government’s deal, and was thus unprepared to proceed. At the the previous hearing, George spent considerable time complaining that Choi was not accepting the government’s deal and removing his name from the settlement documents.
Choi is represented by Kurland and Christopher R. Lynn, who came prepared to argue their case today. Although Judge Kay said repeatedly he thought it would take a half day for the trial, George said she expected it to take two days, as she was prepared to call multiple witnesses. She also told Choi’s attorneys that there was no way he could have failed to hear the order to disperse issued by the park service “unless he’s hard of hearing.”
Ironically, on the same day that Obama’s Justice Department sets the date to put Dan Choi on trial, Sam Stein of the Huffington Post reports that “Obama’s Relationship With Gay Rights Advocates Thaws In Time For 2012.”
Well, some of them anyway.
Update: Yetta Kurland, Dan Choi’s attorney, corrects her earlier statement: “Thanks to the feedback from members of firedoglake community we have learned there have in fact been other incidents of people being arrested and charged federally for chaining themselves to the White House fence since Alice Paul. The point we hope to make at Dan Choi’s trial is that such arrests are unconstitutional and shouldn’t be happening.”



76 Comments





Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Of course he will. Big fucking surprise, from this faux Progressive.
I am sorry to hear this for Lt. Choi’s sake, but I’m guessing the trial will still be in process October 6.
Maybe the progressive left could rally around Choi. My god there most be something to get people off their asses and into the streets. Let the spark lit in Wisconsin turn into a firestorm.
God damn obama’s vindictive.
Furthers my resolution to get to DC on Oct. 6th as my way of saying “fuck you”.
Taylor Marsh published an article earlier today, noting that there’s a grand jury investigation into possible war crimes by low-level CIA employees and contractors, and yet wondering why there’s no investigation of Cheney, Bush, et. al. All part of the same condition, I think, which is that the folks running the government believe justice is something that only punishes other people, particularly the troublesome ones.
Accountability is only for the “little” people not for the MOTU. When the plutocrats finally are held accountable by the people they will wish they had been held accountable earlier.
O is making a federal case of this? I guess that’s what happens when you tangle with a sadistic power freak. (Really, morally, I think this O person is worse than Bush.)
Does he have to TRY SO HARD to dump his voters every day? JFC.
Counter spin for the expected backlash this story would bring out like setting a backfire in front of a forest fire this time though the backfire very well might be worse than the original forest fire.
Jane, Thanks for standing with Lt. Choi. Everyone else seems to have abandoned him over the past 6 months or so.
Another reason to love FDL.
As for the Obama administration, they’re obviously being vindictive and prejudiced here. It’s bullshit. Hopefully Dan’s attorneys will get that point across.
Good point why does Obama’s political team still have jobs? I have not seen such stupid since the Bush Administration.
Perhaps Barry protesteth too much.
Choi was arrested for expressing his First Amendment rights? What’s with this guy? Does he think he lives in a free country or something?
I have seen no difference from the Bushco regime.
True, true. But what the Obama Admin didn’t see coming was the Prop 8 decision today. Apparently even though Judge Walker was Teh Gay, he still made a sound legal decision. Fancy that.
Who were the alleged Anonymous hackers they just arrested overseas? Good thing, otherwise the DoJ might have tried Anonymous in absentia.
You’ve all seen the A99 videos?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XySGw-g2tyk
(snicker, snicker)
Completely OT, but why is there an ad for James MacDougald’s new book about Galtian uber-bullshit on my FDL page right now?
Is Obama still out on a tour trying to brag about his record of job creation if so can we get someone to ask him about Dan Choi being tried on federal charges instead of just a misdemeanor?
Also on what basis/reasoning did Obama decide that federal charges not misdemeanor charges were warranted?
The buck stops with you O the Gay community I’m sure is asking the same questions.
The dogs have been making him feel right at home. Lucy got to wear his hat this morning (video), and I did my usual chauffeur duties. Seems like old times, driving to the Prettyman courthouse. Just no Scooter.
This level of stupid is above and beyond the regular stupid this is right up there with the Best of Bush stupid.
1) they’re network ads that come from Google etc, we don’t approve them, they just show up.
2) You may be seeing something that others don’t see if you live in a particular part of the country and it’s a geotargeted ad, or they are using keywords to deliver it to you based on something that you Googled.
Bottom line: it’s not us. It’s the Toobz.
So when everyone was already talking about Gay news this happens. Obama likes trying to put out fires with gas I take it.
On the personal side of this issue I’m happy and touched that Lt. Choi has someone in his life to stick with him through this. The Army threw him under the bus, a lot of the advocacy groups have turned their backs, and now the Federal government is persecuting him. It’s wonderful that you’re there for him.
This is in the same boat, IMHO, as the treatment of Bradley Manning and the harassment of David House. Fascism alive and well in America.
It’s also right up there with the Best of Bush mean and evil.
I knew you wouldn’t hang me out to dry with Randian reading suggestions.
I just wasn’t sure what code or process they could be using that would make their computer system think anyone on FDL would be interested in reading that trash. It was laughable.
Bush III is working out great. Can’t wait for Bush IV
Google needs to work on targeting their ads better.
It’s hard to imagine the DoJ, which has frequently stuck its thumbs in the eyes of the federal judiciary, and the Obama administration, which has often done the same, receiving credit or extra consideration for lapses of information or preparedness or for a claimed inability adequately to communicate internally. Try your case or get out.
The administration seems to hate critics of all kind, whistleblowers or not, except for critics among the Republican Party. This is not an administration that can expect any but a small portion of its base to vote for its re-election. Its best hope is that the Goopers self-destruct before Nov. 2012, because it’s alienating people faster than a vegan at a barbecue.
Is this a sign the WH is cracking down on everyone from now on or just the Gay community?
Unfortunate timing for the Obama Administration. News of California heading another step closer to legalized gay marriage. News of Obama’s justice department persecuting a gay man.
Gotta love it.
Jefferson Memorial Flash Mob brutalized by US Parks Police For Dancing, Protesting Court Ruling (VIDEO)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=2PDhjNF9eUQ
Looks like Obama and the powers that be decided they do not want to be bothered by protesters in DC anymore
Sure if you are not on Obama’s PR team heck even the Lefty hating Obamabots must be thinking sure we hate Gays and Lefties but the timing on this makes us look incompetent more Col Clink than Gestapo .
Making a federal case about open unconventional criticism when it has a ready, frequently used option of a simple misdemeanor plea with no practical consequence? This administration clearly hates its base more than its nominal lifelong opponents.
Amazing isn’t 0 thinks going throw out a few bones and get their vote.
Thanks Jane
Google might be sending us Rand ads because we mention Rand so much they just don’t realize we mock Rand.
If I’m right on this their tech is primitive.
Mahalo, Jane for your tireless efforts…! *g*
Next stop Boston, then on to Minneapolis…! *whew*
If we click on these ads will FDL get any $
I think you mean “disperse” here.
And I can’t figure out who this “Allen” is.
Sorry for the edits, probably someone backstage can fix them. And the very idea that the administration will charge Dan Choi with a Federal crime is disgusting beyond belief!!!
Ask Jane I am not part of the high command:)
OMG Federal crime! means Federal Prison! rules are different there than regular prison plus its under direct Federal control. O can keep him quiet if he wants too.
I guess we are having political prisons in this country but just for Lefties.
And in a related note, HuffPo links to a Politico story about a fundraiser O did just the other day where the most notable thing was the missing crowd. Seems that the entire balcony of the building was empty, as were many seats on the left and right sides of the main seating area downstairs. And it wasn’t a big bucks event; tickets started at $44.
I just hope it gets even worse.
I’d assume they’d send him to the Communication Management Unit at Terre Haute…! 8-(
Great catch nobody wants empty seats when trying to sell the idea your popular Obama over booked his Political team is really inept.
Not getting that joke.
It is often that primitive.
nope, not a dime
Wasn’t/isn’t a joke… 8-(
They might… just like they’ve sent some environmental activitists to CMUs… to shut them up and put them basically where the sun don’t shine.
See this recent book salon for more info re CMUs and environmental activists:
http://fdlbooksalon.com/2011/06/11/green-is-the-new-red/
Ok
No, no it’s not, and it’s not out of the question for Lt Dan Choi. Let’s all take a moment to consider what Obama did to Pfc Bradley Manning.
Have to confess that I *never* thought I’d see a worse CiC than W, but Obama has outdone Bush by a lot of miles. unconscionable.
Interesting there seems room for improvement or replacement of google.
Me, too, and I frickin’ hope that progressives/leftists/Union members and other fellow travelers start waking up to the “nooz” about how incredibly awful Obama truly IS; venal, vindictive, power-mad, more than sold out. The more time goes by, the more I’m not just disgusted by O… I’m frankly moving into the *horrified* category. And that is, sadly, NOT snark.
Thanks, Jane, for updating us about Lt Dan Choi. I’m truly sorry, but not surprised, to hear this news. Figures.
And yet another WASTE of my tax dollars, amongst many other sorry factors. My sympathies to Choi, who like Pfc Bradley Manning, is a TRUE American hero.
http://www.yassinaref.com/prison.htm
Pitchforks/Torches:2012
Jane, what is the Min/max for the charge that Lt.Choi faces…?
I have often said that Obama is a liar, a murderer, a torturer and a traitor. It seems trivial to say he is also a prick. But he is also a prick.
6 months I think, same as Alice Paul got.
Mahalo, Jane…! He’d also be considered an excon and lose his voting rights/etc…! 8-(
And here I was thinking that nobody could top Anthony Wiener in making politically fatal decisions. Maybe this is a calculated punch-the-queers and bash-the-hippies move, though. Digby and Joan Walsh will huff and puff and then tell everybody to vote for the President, so the President knows he can skim off conservative independents and still collect the liberal vote. As the hamster wheel turns . . .
How much uglier can it get? Looks like one can be picked up for almost anything…..So sad….
That is how it works… you click on it and FDL get some tiny bit of credit but clicks add up and can mean decent revenue for the site.. Why else let someone to put stuff on your web site?? And it is all automated..
When it comes to banking fraud and war criminals, O doesn’t want to look backwards at those heinous deeds. When it comes to an individual fighting for equal rights, he wants to punish and be a vindictive SOB. When it comes to union workers fighting for the right to collective bargaining, O loses his balls. Even President Reagan acknowledged that collective bargaining was a right inherent in the US Constitution.
Thanks Jane, for keeping us up to date on important issues. And you are so gorgeous!!!
More dancing out of turn:
The performance was part of a Martin Luther King tribute. The dance celebrates the opera’s main theme of education as the path to uplift from the superstition and enforced ignorance of slavery times.
Arresting gay people for protesting for their rights while at the sametime not touching one Wall St Executive for destroying the county… interesting Choi served his country while Obama did not.. another Chicken Hawk
This is a ****ing joke
The guy that runs Troma Films was right when he said Obama makes Nixon look like a tree hugging hippy
Obama is a a fascist. What more do we need to prove this to ourselves? We thought the idiot gee wiz boy Bush was a fascist, but Obama is the real fascist. He loves drones, he loves secrets, he loves power. And he has zero respect for the powerless. Still waiting for Pelosi to call for Obama’s resignation. He claimed to be a Democrat. I know Weiner is a horndog, but he never claimed to not be a horndog. Wiener, however is an actual Democrat. Done with the pony show. I am done with the voting charade. It does feel good to be free of this bullshit. I am not voting for Democrats anymore! As long as this piece of shit liar Obama gets to call himself one.
6 months would make it a misdemeanor. The only federal misdemeanors of which I know are unauthorized use of the Smokey the Bear and Woodsy Owl characters or names, plus Woodsy’s slogan, “Give a hoot, don’t pollute.” Title 18, U.S. Code, Sections 711 and 711a.
Thanks so much for standing with Lt. Choi, Jane! It would be good to know exactly what his charge(s) is/are.
Once again I need to salute Lt. Choi for his valor, above and beyond the call of Duty…! *g*
Can’t believe GWZero has anything to do with this, or anything substantial, any more than W did. It’s all been outsourced to MICNaziCorp, and the Pres is just a sorry-ass vestigal organ.
Anyone that calls themselves a liberal, progressive or radical that votes for his Trojan Horse suffers from self loathing.
When does Obama call out the troops/police to turn on the fire hoses against people that would dare speak truth to power. MLK would make quick work of this fraud.
LOL!!!
Obama and his political team yet again prove they are idiots.
Putting Dan Choi on trial helps OBAMA? How?
A simple question for Obama will be you are willing to put Dan Choi on trial? Yes!
Obama why are you not putting Wall Street Bankers, Bush war criminal on trial, ie real criminals!
Another question for OBAMA? Obama why did you miss the GOP debate last night, because you are clearly a Republican!
Oh, I don’t know. Bush was also a vindictive piece of shit.
Could we please get some “action” from those invited to, or scheduled to attend, next week’s Obama fund-raiser, the one specifically targeted @ gays, in NYC?
Can SOMEONE buy a table and stand up & sing, like the folks in CA?
Can people put a hold on their checks previously submitted?
Can folks cancel in protest?
As long as nothing’s done, Obama continues to believe there’s no problem with his actions.
Somebody had posted a story about a recent ill-attended Obummer ‘fundraiser’, even at the cut-rate cost of $44 a tix to attend…! Speaks volumes, M’dear…! ;-)
Vindictive is absolutely what it is. Obama DESPISES “liberal” activists. His election winning racket needs for the left side of the crowd of Democratic voters to play along and not make him look un-hip.Nothing is more un-hip in 2011 than being anti-gay rights.Its his MO all the way down the line. He viciously prosecutes whistle blowers for the same reason -blown whistles call attention to the fact that as a leader and a human being, he really sucks and he cant stand that. In Obamas universe, everyone is working to ensure that Barrak Obama has a great day and gets everything he wants. Anyone who fails at that mission is worthy of his most severe disapproval.
I don’t believe Paul was arrested by Wilson, though she was arrested by the DC police Commissioner. Could be wrong. See the movie Iron Jawed Angels with Hillary Swank and Francis O’Connor. Alice was instrumental in getting the 19th Amendment ratified in 1920, giving women the right to vote. You should see the movie.
Lt. Choi is an inigma to me. He seems to want to be in these situations. Not good for an Army Lt. who I am sure will be passed over and drummed out of the service.
I do wish him well and am glad he has some friends that will support him.
Like I said. I think Obama is a closet Republican.