Nobody’s gonna remember how long it took. They’re only gonna look and see that it was done.
- New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg, on the use of eminent domain to build a basketball arena in Brooklyn.
And if it were not for tonight’s film, Battle for Brooklyn, how many would remember how long it took to build the Nets’ arena at the corner of Flatbush and Atlantic, and the human cost as well?
In 2003, developer Bruce Ratner announced he would be building Atlantic Yards, a a grandiose arena/retail/residential/mixed use facility–22 acres, with 16 high rises–in Prospect Heights in the heart of Brooklyn, which he claimed would provide thousands of jobs in the neighborhood. Graphic designer Daniel Goldstein, who had just bought an apartment in the center of the proposed Atlantic Yards development–his new home would be center court, is stunned and he joins forces with others who oppose what is seen as a land grab.
Using eminent domain, The city of New York seizes property, displacing hundreds of residents and numerous businesses. Goldstein, living with his fiancee in an apartment he had spent five years searching for, refuses to sell and remains the lone holdout in his own building, joining with others, including city council member Letitia James, to fight the development . The struggle lasts for seven years and through 35 court battles. Ratner’s company finally encourages the city to declare the neighborhood blighted–despite thriving businesses like the local bar and an auto repair shop that has been operating for over four decades.
Ratner’s PR people start to spin the race and class cards: Grassroots supporters of the Atlantic Yards project chant
Jobs, jobs, jobs
only to be revealed as an Astroturf group whose tax filings show them to be funded by Ratner’s company to the tune of $5 million.
While Ratner starts to feel financial pressure as the stock market drops–shares of his company tumble from almost $65 down to $5 and he is forced to downscale the project, loosing architect Frank Gehry’s design–reluctant activist Goldstein faces personal difficulties: His mother dies and he and his fiancee break up. But as Goldstein soldiers on, his skills as a community organizer and spokesperson grow, and he falls in love with, then marries, a fellow organizer and they begin to raise their children as they battle for the soul of their community.



113 Comments












Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Before we start, just a couple quick notes:
Please refresh your browser every minute or so to see new comments, questions and answers.
To reply to specific comment, hit the reply button underneath it and then type away. Always after a comment or question hit “send comment.”
Please stay on topic/s–in this case tonight’s film Battle for Brooklyn, eminent domain, the destruction of neighborhoods, astroturfing…
If you want to jump in about other subjects, please find a post elsewhere on FDL to do so. Thank you.
Please be respectful of our guests and of each other. And yeah, I tpye badly…
Hello Suki, Daniel, Michael and David. Welcome to Firedoglake Movie Night. Thank you for being here tonight!
Hello, good evening
and thanks for having us.
Hi Daniel! HOw are you? Thank you for being here and for allowing cameras into your life for years to show us the often ugly truth about eminent domain.
Hi Mr. Goldstein.
I sure admire the work you’ve done. Even though I don’t live in Brooklyn, or NYC, thank you.
Big opening this Friday — will it be seen all over NYC?
Hello. Thanks for having us.
How did you meet the filmmakers David, Michael and Suki?
Well, I thought it was important early on this seven year fight to allow filmmakers capture what was happening to me personally and to our community. and I couldn’t be more pleased that this incredible film will serve as an historical document for so many communities and individuals having to deal with government abuses such as eminent domain abuse and top down, non-democratic city planning.
It is opening at Cinema Village on June 17th, thats 22 East 12th street, 1,3,5,7, 9:15 screenings.
Funnnily enough, I knew Mike since 1987. a good college friend of mine and MIke were high school friends. since we were somewhat aquainted, I felt comfortable with him shooting such intimate stuff in a way i wouldn’t have with other filmmakers.
Last week on Movie Night with Save the Farm we saw how eminent domain was used to help Los Angeles, when the city bought the land for the South Central Farm from a developer who found a clause in the contract (the land must be developed, basically) and claimed that a farm was not the correct use. Eventually the courts sided with him and the land was sold back to him, the 14 acre farm torn up–the development and “jobs jobs jobs” promised by it never materialized…
Thank you for making this.
It is also at IndieScreen in Williamsburg, Brooklyn from June 17-25
current screening schedule is here:
http://battleforbrooklyn.com/screenings
Cinema Village showtimes and tickets are here:
http://www.readyticket.net/webticket/htmlshowtimes/27/ShowTimes40711.html
It was very intimate, and human ot see both your development as a community organizer and spokesperson and how your live changed and evolved through (despite and because of) the battle for brooklyn.
Where did you end up moving to?
And what steps can communities take to prevent eminent domain and/or “blighted” status?
I’ve moved actually only about 3 blocks away from the arena site to North Park Slope. Just jumped over Flatbush avenue, so I have the misfortune of having to witness the steel going up for arena structure.
Also, Daniel did the artwork for a previous film of ours – the narrative feature “Radiation” made in 1999.
This is Suki, one of the filmmakers.
What were some of the challenges you faced as filmmakers? You certainly got threatened a lot by security…
you asked what steps can communities take to prevent eminent domain and/or “blighted” status?
that is a tough question. eminent domain has it proper uses, as in a public use, but it has come to mean almost anything in most states, even, simply, increased tax revenue. But if communities start developing community development organizations, even if they are very ad hoc, they can start looking around through documents and research and just everyday observation to see what areas might be ripe for developer driven eminent domain and bogus blight. From my point of view blight in NYC these days is a bogus term, it just doesn’t exist in the way the legal precedents really intended it. so now its come to mean neighborhoods that are actually very desirable but may be “edgy,” as in no so pretty to certain powerbrokers.
communities can start now, if they think bogus blight might be foisted on them, documenting how unblighted their neighborhoods are…
But if eminent domain IS declared and a community determined to be blighted, it is time for that community to organize and fundraise to go to court and to do some political lobbying. To my mind fighting abusive use of eminent domain is a political winner for most politicians, yet most don’t seem to realize it.
Polling after Kelo showed that something like 90% of Americans opposed the decision that stood for the proposition that if a property can be put to a greater economic use then the government has the right to take it. Well that is an extremely slippery slope as ANY property can be put to greater economic use.
awesome. thank you. tell us a bit about B.U.I.L.D, the group that was pro-Ratner’s development. And about all those “jobs, jobs, jobs” Ratner promised. How’d that work out?
The biggest challenge was really the time frame – having this last for 7.5 years. There was definitely some question around 2005 if we should keep shooting “Where is this going?” “Will the ending be satisfying?” I’ll let Michael speak to challenges during the shooting itself…security, etc.
{Suki}
Well, the latest reporting shows that there are roughly 400 jobs on site (there were 10,000 or 15,000 promised) and SEVEN have gone to local workers.
the biggest challenge like suki said was just having the resources and wherewthall to stick with it.
The security wasn’t as much forceful as an annoyance. They wouldn’t let us into press conferences- or events because we weren’t accredited press.
and i think BUILD members and some of its leadership was well-intentioned and sincerely thought that this project would bring many good employee opportunities to a community, predominately African American, that is suffering from major unemployment. but the Atlantic Yards opponents felt from early on that this was a sham and exploitation of a bad situation by the developer Forest City Ratner. And Ratner’s job creation track record in Brooklyn is, well, a failure.
How much footage did you have at the end of 7.5 yrs?! Did you start piecing together as you shot?
do you think that BUILD volunteers for the most part were unaware that they were funded by Ratner?
the Garden is a great film- and we were working concurrently on our projects- at one point when we were stalled I suggested to Scott that we combine them and have back and forth narrative.
That would be an awesome double bill!
Probably many were unaware, but the leadership was definitely aware. To this day though the leaders deny Ratner gave them funding, but they can’t seem to explain why the told the IRS Ratner gave them $5 million.
I also think that in part BUILD is genuine astroturf, and in part genuine grassroots. its pretty complicated and has a lot to do with VERY local politics.
We shot about 400 hours of footage over all. We knew that we couldn’t really cut right away but we started logging and keeping track of stuff- which also gave us perspective on what kind of story we were capturing. At some point we started to work with it a little if only to be able to cut a fund raising trailer.
It was only once it became clear what the end game was that we began to really start to pull together the story. Our first cut was probably 3 and a half hours. While we worked on the film for nearly 8 years- the first two were very intensive and the last two were as well. The first two for me mostly – and the last two for suki- and David.
It was really in the last 8 months that the editing began to really come together.
Daniel, I’m so sorry to hear about this. While I haven’t lived in Brooklyn since 1969, I went to high school at Bishop McDonnell’s on Eastern Parkway on the eastern end of the Botanic Gardens. (It’s now a school for the deaf)
Can you tell me if taxpayer dollars are being used to give another sport’s team a brand new stadium?
My sister, who lives north of the City, told me about the new Mets stadium and how ticket prices are so expensive only corporations can still afford to purchase them.
Los Angeles had eminent domain invoked during the 1984 Olympics, and of course Dodger Stadium and Bunker Hill. Now with the idea of a pro football team in downtown, it’s looming again.
James Caldwell, the president of Build came to a screening on Saturday and I was a bit nervous- but he loved the film and he did most of the q and a. I think that he is sincere about wanting to get people jobs, but I do think that if he looked harder at what was going on he could see that the developer was working to divide the community for their own advantage.
Hey Lisa. Hey Pups. Orlando Sentinel told the City Beautiful today that Sarah Palin’s movie is commin’. It is decidely unimpressed. To put it mildly.
Yes, this arena is being publicly subsidized. The NYC Independent Budget Office analyzed it and showed about $760 million in public benefit to the developer—in subsidies, gov’t backed financing, tax breaks, below market land and opportunity costs. And that is just the arena part of the project (the other part is proposed to be 16 residential towers).
yeah, how about those Nets? Ratner sold them to a Russian business man, didn’t he?
time to start raising money and interviewing lawyers
I’m a native Brooklynite, and to show you how long I’ve been away (and how little attention I pay to basketball), I hadn’t heard about this new arena.
Is it just going up now? How big of an area did this thing wind up gobbling up? What would you say to people like my cousin who say that Bloomberg’s been a good mayor?
Ooh, thanks for the warning. That’s where I settled.
Yes, but for Mikhail Prokhorov swooping in and bailing out Bruce Ratner’s money-bleeding operation we would have killed the arena.
not just a Russian businessman, but an ethically questionable oligarch who is either the richest or second richest in Russia
It’s happening everywhere- and everytime it’s a loss to the community. Just over the river in NJ, a small community was pressured to build a minor leauge soccer stadium and none of the benefits arrived. At Yankee stadium the local businesses are suffering because the Yankess built the stadium to capture all the dollars. They also built a huge subsidized parking deck on top of several parks and its going to go bankrupt…
I think that’s one of the reasons this film is so important- it can give people a tool to fight back – to show that it’s not just a few naysayers trying to stop progress- but instead and army of Casandras.
yes, it is under construction, the whole project an anrena w/ 16 towers of 6,430 residential units would take up 22 acres in the heart of Brooklyn. 22 acres in NYC is enormous. the World Trade Center site is 16 acres
Thanks Beefheart. Try to catch a screening of it and let us know your thoughts at MyFDL!! La Figa covered it and Nick Broomfield’s Sarah doc last night
Tonight we are all about the Brooklyn International Film Festival award winner (which opens this week in NYC) BATTLE FOR BROOKLYN. Juicy stuff!
Yes, it’s going up now. Well on it’s way. I’m from NJ, originally, and the NJ Nets are moving there. They play in a new (2-3 yrs old. 4 tops) arena in newark now. not new enough i guess. owners of sports teams are scumbuckets.
its an army of folks who are willing not just to see through the BS but act on what they’ve seen.
Hi. I would tell your cousin that Bloomberg has had his priorities backwards. He’s been a great mayor when it comes to fighting smoking and trans fats but terrible when it comes to education and the other big issues.
The project is 22 acres- but only a few are the arena block- but it will be 18 acres of parking lots for the forseeable future.
I think that bloomberg started out doing some good things- but in general he leads with a top down business mentality that leaves communities out of the process. It’s very disturbing.
the sensible and cost effective thing to do, for Ratner, Brookylyn, and New Jersey would have been to move the Nets permanently to the new Newark arena. they are there temporarily for 2 years.
but it was never about basketball- it was about using the nets as a trojan horse to get control of the most valuable real estate in Brooklyn
terrible, incredibly terrible when it comes to community involvement and development. his legacy will be failed big projects that bypassed communities.
in the film there is a scene where Bloomberg is next to Ratner at a press conference for the signing of a bogus Community Benefits Agreement (CBA) and Ratner is asked to say what happens if he doesn’t meet his commitments. Ratner says that there would probably be litigation against him. Bloomberg jumps in and says, “Let me just say here that Bruce Ratner’s word is all that we need.”
Yup, one billionaire businessmen telling us to blindly trust another. Definitely not the way Blooomberg would run his corporation.
100% true.
How much was allocated for affordable housing (which in L.A. is a boon to cevelopers since “affordable” means smaller rooms, less green space and fewer parking spaces per unit (a one bedroom apt in normal housing gets 1.6 assigned parking spaces–.6 of a car?! whatever) while affordable housing gets 1 space per (smaller) bedroom.
I think that our next film will be about how schools in NYC are affected by this same attitude. I believe in the idea that business should be run with an efficient mentality at times- but schools and communities are not businesses. When we try to deal with them in un-democratic- top down ways it always backfires
yeah. that soccer stadium is in the towm next to where i grew up. soccer-crazy area. easy sell. it’s a shame. i love sports but these owners have cities fawning all over them. then they sell the team, make millions and move on. these stadiums/areans used to be 40-50 years old. sometimes more. but they didn’t have “luxury boxes” which sell for $$$$$$. so they just MUST have new arenas.
It is sad to see people stay in their neighborhood, which gradually gentrifies as people move in who care about the area and businesses (like Freddy’s the bar) and sniffing an opportunity, even before Starbucks can land–whooosh–developers snatch it up and concrete it over.
In Battle for Brooklyn we see a family business, a car repair shop owned by two brothers for almost 50 yrs get getted and turned into a dirt lot.
Will this movie be playing outside of the NYC area either in theaters or on the cable networks -Premium movie station or the Documentary channel on Direct TV? I would love to see it.
all of the federal housing subsidies allocated to New York on an annual basis would be eaten up by the Ratner plan. and same here, the so-called affordable housing, which is not affordable to most Brooklynites, is a boon to the developer because of the subsidies and other breaks that come with it. It is really the only way Ratner can afford to build any housing, on our dime.
One estimate showed about 1.4 billion in housing subsidy for this project, but none has been granted yet.
and yes, the affordable units are smaller. an “affordable” 2 bedroom in the project would be smaller than a market rate 2 bedroom.
Thanks SBR, you rea dmy mind! What are the plans for a roll out? Glad you are playing long enough to get Oscar consideration, btw!
We were on a panel the other night about the state of documentary in the age of instant communication. The question was kind of – are docs still relevant in a culture where revolutions are fought with information.. and twitter and photos. I think that in this case – they are incredibly relevant. If we hadn’t patiently followed- and documented the promises vs. the reality- then they would have owned the narrative. It appears that they have won the battle- but I think that they are losing control of the narrative. They can try to argue that we are maligning them- but even project proponents like Errol Louis and James Caldwell have declared the film fair- yet it completely destroys the narrative they have spent so much money to create.
And hopefully, that destruction will wake people up – and get them to pay a lot more critical attention to what they read and hear
So true. Training students is very different than Teaching students.
Battle for Brooklyn
Screenings – http://battleforbrooklyn.com/screenings
exactly. i was hoping that would happen. i’m a nest fans. it’s a new arena…. like you say, makes too much sense. that Prudential Aena is really nice, I hear. so this will be the nets 3rd arena in about 4 years. btw, madison sq. garden opened in 1968 or 69 and is still busy as hell. all they had to do to build that was knock down Penn Station—a landmark building.
btw, as of now there is not even a design for a single residential building. yet ratner benefitted from eminent domain, governor and mayor support, and other subsidies because of the promise of “affordable housing”
It’s a scam, like some hideous real life version of Sim City meets Empire Builder. What exactly is ratner’s benefit–long or short term? Is it a grift?
The film opens in NYC on Friday and we have a few other dates set up-
LA – at the Laemmle Music Hall starting Aug 19th. Those are our Oscar qualifying runs. We have to release it first in NY to build interest outside NY. In the film world- all the other theaters wait to see how it does in NY first before they decide whether or not to book it.
Since we arranged to have the film be the opening night selection at Brooklyn Film Fest we realized we just had to get it out right after that- and I think that has worked out real well. We got a lot of press interest since it’s such a NY story – from the festival screenings- and then this week we’ll get a ton of reviews- if it does well- we will show it all over.
Right, so please tell all your New York friends that they gotta go see Battle for Brooklyn this weekend (June 17, 18,19) at Cinema Village. This really is an American (and universal, really) story that is important for wider audiences to see.
I answered this in response to 58- but yes we will get it out there. The amazing thing about the film so far is that everyone from liberals to conservatives to libertarians have all loved the film because everyone hates kleptocracy…. seriously- we have had such an incredible response to the film so far- it’s been a long tough road to get the film to this point and it is intensely gratifying to have it work so well.
the biggest benefit long and short term is he has control of 22 acres of some of the most valuable real estate in NYC and he got it for a song. he can even sell a lot of it off down the road if he wants to.
but how did he get the scam over on those in power, he sloganized “Jobs, Housing and Hoops” and they stopped thinking after that.
This reminds me of the same preferential treatment given to bankstas and their investors so they could destroy The Farm (hat tip Michael Kuehnert and Lisa Derrick, June 6, 2011).
Its one of the few movies (and issues) that can bring the full political spectrum together, perhaps not the elected officials, but the people for certain.
we spent a year -after we had a good rough cut- crafting the film to flow like a river- I think one reason we are having such a good response is that people come in expecting a “doc” he said she said taking head kind of thing – but it plays like a hollywood film and all of a sudden it’s over and they realize that they have been emotinally involved and it’s kind of overwhelming…
it is not different either from all the no-bid contracts that plague us. this was a no-bid contract. and in the end it is the same as what went on with the banksters, nobody in government stopped to say—this doesn’t seem right.
Jesus wept a bucket of tears! Are our politicians that damn gullible? Ratner could have used the money he paid to develop small local businesses that would employ people, service businesses, retail etc….Created and developed a NEIGHBORHOOD.
“everyone hates kleptocracy” LOVE THAT!
we are adding more dates all the time to Battleforbrooklyn.com – and you can always check in on facebook for updates on where the film will play.
btw- I didn’t get a chance to thank you Lisa and Bev for having us on- its a real honor- as we follow your emails and appreciate all that you do towards raising the level of discussion and debate.
I find the rigged, no-bid contracts circumstance unconscionable.
i don’t think it is so much that they are that gullible, but that they are not effective enough to initiate really job development or to understand ….oh, okay, yes, they are gullible too. and they like being greased by Ratner types. I mean Forest City Enterprises, the parent company in Cleveland, is one of the biggest, if not the biggest, publicly traded development firms in the US and so they hold an incredible amount of political power and sway in NY
it’s true though. So far audiences have loved the film- We have had some difficulty getting gatekeepers to program it/ select it- and I think that has to do with the fact that it deals with such murky complex subjects like eminent domain and media… in a not directly judgemental way…
Consider contacting the Santa Barbara Film Festival. The festival is at the end of January each year and has an amazing array of documentaries each year. Because of our proximity to LA, we also attract a lot of the PTB in Hollywood- that’s not necessarily a good thing for the locals but it would be for a film maker.
Thanks so much. As a native of two cities that have seen their share of insane development efforts that destroyed much of the good and historic parts of town, I want to thank you.
i joined mike and suki and david in Toronto at Hot Docs Film Festival and the 2 sold out audiences there loved the film. it has broad appeal beyond NYC and Brooklyn. its relatable, and funny and enraging.
We are thrilled to have you and honored. Land use and water use–since there is only so much left and populations are expanding–are of vital importance.
We have another land use film coming up June 27 The Last Mountain, about coal mining corporation and a tiny community vying for the last great mountain in Appalachia in a battle for the future of energy that affects us all.
Good luck and thanks for being here…Reads like a morality tale, which it is. Who will defeat the creeps? You did a great job.
these problems and the push back against them are happening all over. we, Develop Don’t Destroy Brooklyn, get contacted all the time from all over the country by people telling us about the development abuses they are dealing with.
Evidentally Bruce Ratner never read this book about Robert Moses:
http://www.amazon.com/Power-Broker-Robert-Moses-Fall/dp/0394720245
I am hoping that you are the Nelson Rockefeller of our time.
Rev Billy – who has written about the Last Mountain- gave a rousing intro to the film the other night- and he has some great moments in it as well.
One of the things that we want the film to do is to get people to challenge their own notions of left right divide. Eminent Domain is seen as a Conservative issue- so much so that liberal groups sided with the developer- Acorn backed the project. We applied for a ton of grants – but liberal groups wouldn’t fund it. The developer understands this and did everything they could to posit the project as a do-gooder project- jobs, housing, hoops- a socialist paradise… when it was none of the above…except hoops.
How about getting the film to libraries? I often send links of FDL Movie Nights to teachers and a library board member all who really appreciate the tips that they use to construct lesson plans or consider for expanding their collections. Teachers, home schooling parents and other library patrons either request or check out the materials. Portland, OR and Multnomah County have the largest circulation of books and such materials in the US.
Portlandia: Did You Read?
He totally read the Power Broker- it was his playbook.
I hope he read the ending too.
was going to say that.
Norman Oder in his extensive, must-read review of the film in Dissent wrote:
In terms of distribution. We will do a theatrical/ outreach release- in order to build awareness of the film. Then we will do an educational release- we want to go to colleges with a full day seminar about the issues-
Then it will hopefully run on Cable- and eventually Sept 2012 (when the arena opens) go to DVD- so we can do a big press push to challenge the narrative they are going to try to create once again
Speaking of that narrative- I watched an NBA finals game the other night and there was a 30 second spot about the arena- that 30 second spot probably cost 10 times as much as our film….
By the way, there are a number of very thoughtful reviews and features on the film, they’re at:
http://www.battleforbrooklyn.com/press
What is next for all of you aside from spreading the word about Battle for Brooklyn? What projects?
This is a great conversation- and we love discussing the film- when this party ends I hope that people will consider continuing the convo on the battle for brooklyn facebook page- it won’t be so robust – but we’ll keep it going.
Michael, thank you for letting me know that as it caused another light bulb to go off over my head. I’m happy do what I can to “even the odds” for a great film. :-)
Battle for Brooklyn FB https://www.facebook.com/battleforbrooklyn
as for me, I’m working on a book, a very personal one, about the 7 years leading the fight against Ratner’s project. And i’m still actively involved with Develop Don’t Destroy Brooklyn which, like all the community groups in the area, is still trying to contend with what will be a disastrous construction or dormant 22 acre site for the next 20-30 years.
but i think you meant the filmmakers….so….
We meant you too Daniel! Thanks for the update. a BOOK! yay! You know we do a book salon too…
Like i mentioned above- we have a school’s doc in the works- working on Battle has really taught us a lot about community and community building and we have become over involved with our children’s local public school- a lot of the top down management also discussed above have created a lot of community division and we want to examine this process in a film… Just tonight we were at an extremely emotional meeting about how to deal with issues of race and class when people don’t want to deal with them but instead run from them…
I’ve written about some of these issues on the NY Times local blog
we are also working on a film about the nature of family – nature/nurture
rumur.com/donor67 for a trailer
whoops, that was meant as a reply to Lisa’s “What is next for all of you aside from spreading the word about Battle for Brooklyn? What projects?”
its a big challenge to write about such an epic struggle, but I think it is really important that my story is told, for various reasons, in more detail than any film possibly could.
Hey Lisa, Bev and the whole FDL team, thanks so much for inviting us on and sharing this amazing film with your members and readers.
well when we get to cut the miniseries from our 400 hours of footagee..
Thank you all a great movie night–David, Michael Suki and Daniel! Inspirational and informative!
And pups, thanks for being here! See you next week for Question One
Lisa, is there a way to include “Movie Night” as a tag on all the FDL Movie Night posts? This way one can go to one HTML page to see all the transcripts like one can do for the Book Salons.
Thank you Bev, Lisa, Michael and everybody for another great Movie Night!
What was the “battle?” Sounds one-sided and no battle at all.
Yes
thank you for having us- it’s a bit of a fractured way to commmunicate- but I think we finally got the hang of it. More than anything we want this film to act as a tool to help unite communities- even when there are forces trying to divide them. It pleases me greatly that so far the film seems to be working in that manner even in this community.
community building is messy and rough- and it’s easy to see why people just slip away and want others to just take control- but in the end that messiness creates beauty- it hasn’t been easy to work through some of the issues in our local school- and there are a lot that are still there- but the process has been so powerful and we’ve grown so much as people- that it’s all worth it- just like it was for Dan to fight his fight.
it was a battle over ideas- it was a bit onesided in terms of resources- but one sided in reverse in terms of real passion- and resources and passion seem to cancel each other out….
oh it’ll happen
time for dinner…. see you all next time
couldn’t let this one go. we held off Ratner for 7 years, and if the richest man in russia hadn’t swooped in to financially bail out Ratner, we would have stopped the project. and the battle was through 4 major lawsuits on the federal and state levels, and in the end very few people were left standing, not even Ratner whose reputation is forever sullied and whose project is synonymous with eminent domain abuse, corruption and bad planning.
It was a battle for sure.
Wow, I can’t wait to see this documentary! In 2002, my wife and I nearly bought a condominium at 636 Pacific — the Atlantic Arts Building. At that time, no one said anything about an impending megadevelopment that would attempt in a couple of years to seize and demolish the building.
Daniel, I can’t quite tell from the trailer and promo materials, but was that your building? And thank you for your work on Develop, Not Destroy. The way this project was rammed down people’s throats and how different communities were manipulated to prevent organized opposition always sickened me.
Also, does the film ever mention that developer Bruce Ratner is the brother of attorney Michael Ratner, who’s headed the Center for Constitutional Rights? Talk about your polar opposites. (I was told this some years back by a lawyer who knew the good Ratner.)
that’s the one, 636 Pacific, now gone: http://rumur.com/bfbstills/636_pacific_street.jpg
the film does not talk about Michael Ratner, too tangential to the story. BUT yes, Michael Ratner of CCR is Bruce’s brother, but it doesn’t end there. Michael is an investor in the project who will make a financial gain from it. talk about hypocrite.
here are some articles on the Bruce and Michael nexus