Dictators often come wrapped in lofty literary pretensions, it seems. And you thought the novel was dead.
Suzanne Murkelson has a terrific piece in Foreign Policy about the literary lives of dictators. She was disciplined enough to avoid the term tortured prose. But I’m not.
Murkelson notes that it was the late Turkmen autocrat Saparmurat Niyazov who blurbed his own work:
A person that reads Ruhnama becomes smart … and after it, he will go to heaven…
What writer wouldn’t love such an Amazon review? The gift of intelligence in this life, the promise of eternal happiness in the afterlife? I wonder what you get if you reread it?
Muammar al-Qaddafi wrote a children’s story called “The Astronaut’s Suicide” about an American space explorer who ends it all after he returns to Earth and discovers he’s lost his job due to budget cuts. Goodnight, Moon. One hopes he at least read Niyazov.
New York Times columnist Gail Collins has made the supreme sacrifice and actually read some of the recent work of contemporary American politicians. Her conclusion?
We may be embarking on a new era in politics, in which candidates and officials are just as likely to be brought down by bad writing as adultery.
Maybe there are politician/authors telling their spouses they are out hiking the Appalachian Trail when they are actually off composing their magnum opuses in dark coffee houses. If there are, I bet they don’t confess it in their books.
Wouldn’t it be great if all the dictators belonged to a special intellectual group, like Bloomsbury or the Beats? Maybe they could be called the Beaters.
I don’t know what to think about Saddam Hussein’s novel, Zabiba and the King, which includes a passage about having sex with a bear. I’m equally baffled by the official propaganda claim that Kim Jong Il has written 1,500 books.
Joseph Stalin is easier to come to literary grips with. He wrote pastoral odes. Here’s a passage from his poem, “Morning”:
The pinkish bud has opened,
Rushing to the pale-blue violet
And, stirred by a light breeze,
The lily of the valley has bent over the grass.
As Collins has shown us in her columns on the books of American politicians, our local literary men-who-would-be-kings focus less on bent lilies or copulation with bears and more on the subject that obsesses them all: themselves.
Political autobiographies and memoirs have become just another item on the campaign must-do list, like direct mail, kissing babies and rubber chicken dinners with suckers-who-would-be-donors. The lives they depict are, of course, highly redacted. So even if there was something about a bear in the past it’s unlikely to make it into an American politician’s book.
According to Ken Layne over at Wonkette, Rolling Stone Keith Richards is the author of America’s greatest political book, putting Mitt Romney, Newt Gingrich, Mike Huckabee and other politician/authors to shame. Richards earns the title by including several scathing anecdotes involving the Stones and American politicians. For instance, while governor of Arkansas, Huckabee pardoned Richards for a 30-year-old offense he was never charged with. “I got pardoned anyway,” Richards wrote.
Barack Obama received generally positive reviews for two of his books, Dreams from my Father and The Audacity of Hope. They were candid and well-written, qualities that helped raise suspicions that Obama was not an American at all.
But it is Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini who wins the award for candor, I think. He wrote a poem, published by The New Republic after his death, which gives us a Khomeini we had no idea of:
Open the door of the tavern and let us go there day and night,
For I am sick and tired of the mosque and seminary.
I have torn off the garb of asceticism and hypocrisy,
Putting on the cloak of the tavern-hunting shaykh and becoming aware.
The city preacher has so tormented me with his advice
That I have sought aid from the breath of the wine-drenched profligate.
Leave me alone to remember the idol-temple,
I who have been awakened by the hand of the tavern’s idol.
I feel about politician/authors the way Khomeini felt about the city preacher. They have so tormented me with their advice that I prefer the tavern, day and night.




30 Comments





Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Good Morning Glenn.. Now to finish reading the post☺ ☺
Good morning, nahant. Hope you enjoy.
I thought Khomeini was the preacher!
Sliding a Beer down the Bar for Glenn after all that he NEEDS one! St Pauli Girl OK?
You bet! And here’s me lifting the chilled mug to you and everyone here at FDL!
Just proving, I guess, how literature lets us step outside ourselves! Way outside himself, in this case.
“Snowflake” memos by Rumsfeld written during his 2001-2006 tenure as Sec of Defense. May 21. Subject: To Discuss with P. Known knowns, unknowns, and unknown unknowns. The absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. The three charts showing what we knew and when we knew it, and the importance of recalling this when reading intel.
And we wonder why our ‘adventures’ in Iraq and Afghanistan were (and still are) humongous mis-adventures? Dictators/would-be dictators become enraptured by their profundity and probably the last things on their minds at night before they fall asleep is the profundity, “Either it will rain tomorrow or it won’t.”
Glenn, Trump anticipated this post. When not tirelessly investigating Obama’s birth records, Trump has been reviewing the literary quality of Obama’s books and researching their authorship.
It seems Dreams From My Father is “Ernest Hemingway-plus.”
And, was written by Barry Soetero’s best friend and a super-genius,
the infamous Bill Ayers.
Who knew?
http://tpmdc.talkingpointsmemo.com/2011/04/trump-bill-ayers-wrote-obamas-book-video.php
Trump is a poster child for contemporary media insanity. He is nothing but an addled clown, a celebrity-for-celebrity’s sake, a bad-haired ass of a man. Yet the media gives him a platform, treats him as if he is someone deserving of a listen. Back to the tavern.
I love Khomeni’s poem. I wonder if he regretted it in his dotage.
I’d like to think he reached enlightenment!
Politicians feel the need to massage their own inflated egos by writing books but I don’t have to read them. I would rather pound my fingers with a hammer. And I really like Gail Collins’ writing – she doesn’t have many sacred cows.
Thanks for a good subject, Glenn.
So did Obama or Bill Ayers write Dreams?
Gail Collins is terrific. Great sense of humor, Molly Ivin’s-like.
It really is funny how so many “leaders” move to Megalomaniaville. It’s one reason mockery can be so effective for resistance movements.
Obama. Please note how the conspiracy theorists don’t suggest it was written by some unknown ghostwriter or known saint. No, it has to be someone they’ve already spent millions demonizing.
And he’s going to win. He is everything most admired by average American voter.
Years ago when Laugh In’s Pat Paulsen ran for president it was funny. Now most of the candidates are kookier than his satirical kookiness.
It is hard to imagine any sentient being seeing any redeeming quality in Trump. But in the Idiocracy, I suppose anything is possible.
I listened to the author of the book who did the analysis a couple of weeks ago. The case he made was beyond my pay grade in literary analysis for the most part. But the points he made that impressed me were that O has never written anything like that before or since. Writing is a craft. You just don’t produce a book with prose like Dreams only once in your life. A niece who teaches English lit commented on how well written it was, and she has more skills to judge.
I’ve loaned out Dreams to someone & won’t buy another copy, but I got out Fugitive Days and started scanning it again.
I came away pretty sure that O didn’t write Dreams. Fugitive Days is the much more colorful language (meaning word pictures) that are in Dreams.
So that doesn’t mean Ayers wrote Dreams, but it sure was some one who knows a lot more about how to write than O does.
Well, a good editor can make a huge difference. I know ’cause I’ve been there. In any case, the point of the conspiracy buffs is not that O might have had a ghostwriter. Many famous people do. There point is connect him to the formerly radical Ayers. Just another poorly disguised “he’s not one of us” attack, I think.
In the Hannity interview Trump made another brilliant point.
Now, who knew that Obama’s mother was so prescient that she named her baby for a man, Lolo Soetero, she was going to meet and marry four years later. Now, how can you trump this for thorough investigation and insightful analysis?
http://tpmdc.talkingpointsmemo.com/2011/04/trump-bill-ayers-wrote-obamas-book-video.php
I read that! I wish that Trump et al would just stop all the euphemistic pretense and just go on and use the N-word. ‘Cause that’s what they mean.
Exactly right. And they would do this to anyone who wasn’t white no matter where he/she was born. It makes me so furious. I’m not happy with Obama but it’s not because of his skin color. We are still a racist country.
As I recall Dreams, it’s more than just a good editor. It’s a flare. So ghostwriter for sure. It just occurred to me, since I no longer have my copy, and can’t remember who I loaned it to, maybe I can look through it online.
Yes, I got the not-so-hidden agenda to attach O to Ayers. And that was the part of the lecture that was above my literary pay grade, all about sentence structure, frequency of uses of certain words, and other detailed items about the craft of writing.
Yes, that is exactly what they mean. And, unfortunately, rather than abating as time passes, it is getting worse.
It certainly is becoming more overt. In other times the hatred was underground – now it’s in your face. Disgusting.
Oh Glenn, in case you’re still around.
I did not notice the writing when I read Dreams. It was my niece pointing it out later, and then the lecture I listened to a couple of weeks ago that highlighted that for me.
But what I did notice when I read Dreams is how little these people and community org projects meant to O. There was no follow through, no afterward to tell the reader what happened to them all, even though the book was written years after the work was done. At the time it struck me as a kind of pathology, a way of using people & passing through phases of life, leaving them behind, without forming any continuity or strand of development, how what you learned or who you knew in an earlier phase of your life contributed to who you became.
But it could also be evidence of a ghost writer, in the sense of that person’s not knowing the people or projects, so not sensitive to putting them into a larger picture.
On edit: No search inside this book available for Dreams on amazon.
Well – I did laugh at the idea of Keith Richards being pardoned for what he was never charge with by our leader Huckabee..
But I am not understanding “not charged with” since the swerving car pull over was followed by a 1975 guilty plea to reckless driving with Keith paying a $162.50 fine. The Keith joke at a concert Huckabee attended about how he “used to know the chief of police” in Fordyce got then-Gov. Huckabee, part-time bass player, to propose a pardon of the reckless driving conviction.
And that is where my memory ends on this -
Was the pardon screwed up so that he was pardoned for some other offense? I do recall that Keith signed a statement on the pardon forms that left blank the questions on the Keith criminal history, personal background, and drug use with only an “X” beside the statement, “My institutional adjustment has been exemplary and the ends of justice have been achieved”.
This indeed is one of the few things – other than losing weight – that Huckabee has done that I found interesting -
And again your set up – albeit confusing – did give me a laugh – Thanks :-)
What did bears ever do to these douchebags Ghaddafi and Scooter Libby, anyway?
Did I read that wrong, or did the Ayatollah just say Long Live the Proles?
I don’t know much more about it that what Keith wrote. Here is a link to an Arkansas site that discusses it:
http://arkansasroadstories.com/history/stones.html
And here is the wonkette link:
http://wonkette.com/431656/keith-richards-autobiography-is-americas-greatest-political-book