Monday’s New York Times has an article by Ethan Bronner which pleads the anti-democracy case in terms anyone here fighting the Big Bank MOTU’s will find chilling. Titled “Crackdown Was Only Option, Bahrain Sunnis Say,” Bronner tells us:
But in the past week or two, the nature of the protest shifted — and so did any hope that demands for change would cross sectarian lines and unite Bahrainis in a cohesive democracy movement. The mainly Shiite demonstrators moved beyond Pearl Square, taking over areas leading to the financial and diplomatic districts of the capital. They closed off streets with makeshift roadblocks and shouted slogans calling for the death of the royal family.
“Twenty-five percent of Bahrain’s G.D.P. comes from banks,” Mr. Abdulmalik said as he sat in the soft Persian Gulf sunshine. “I sympathize with many of the demands of the demonstrators. But no country would allow the takeover of its financial district. The economic future of the country was at stake. What happened this week, as sad as it is, is good.”
Adulmalik is a Bahraini banker and, of course, is very liberal and urbane.
Bronner goes on to write:
To many around the world, the events of the past week … seem like the brutal work of a desperate autocracy.
He works in excuses for the siege of Salmaniya hospital and never once mentions the dead and wounded – and then continues with the following – notice that the 70% Shia are now just 2/3:
But for Sunnis, who make up about a third of the country’s citizenry but hold the main levers of power, it was the only choice of a country facing a rising tide of chaos that imperiled its livelihood and future.
Bronner, after considerable Iran and Lebanon scare talk, goes on to describe a private tour of a historic district being restored with Adulmalik’s company’s support and where Adulmalik’s “guests” just happen to run into the Bahrain culture minister – a woman whose Western attire is specifically noted – who:
told the demonstrators, ‘This country is developing, and you will stifle it.’ Something had to be done, and it was.”
Perhaps Mr. Bronner would like to consider these things that just “had to be done”. . .
The International Federation for Human Rights (FIDH) is extremely worried at the security condition of its deputy Secretary General, Nabeel Rajab, President of the Bahrain Center for Human Rights.
On Sunday, March 20th 2011, after they visited his father’s house, around 20 plain clothes policemen, armed with guns and wearing masks, entered Nabeel Rajab’s house at 2:00 am and started to search the house, as Nabeel, his wife and their young children were standing in the bedroom. After a search of 45 minutes, the police confiscated the computers and took some bags, books and CDs. Nabeel Rajab was then tightly handcuffed in front of his family and taken into the back of a 4×4 car, where he was blindfolded.
For more than one hour, the police kept him in the car and started to insult him and to force him to praise the Bahraini highest authorities, by saying « Long live the Prime Minister, I love the Prime Minister ». As he refused to obey the orders, Rajab was insulted once more and kicked in the face by one of the policemen, while another one was threatening to rape him.
After more than one hour of physical and psychological abuse, Nabeel Rajab was transferred to another car, taken to some premises belonging to the Ministry of Interior for interrogation.
There, he was told by an officer that the police were following what he was saying on Twitter and troublemakers like him should leave the country.
He was finally sent back home at 4 am.
Or perhaps this:
Ali AbdulEmam, know by some by his nickname “the blog-father” for setting up the first free uncensored online forum in Bahrain for political and social debate, is today missing from his home and his family are unable to establish contact with him…
At around quarter past one in the morning of the 18th of March the housing complex in Aali were Ali rented a flat from one of his cousins who awoke to hear the metal gate outside being riddled with bullets.
Around 50 masked and heavily armed security personnel then proceeded to break down the wooden door of the house. Ali’s cousin, his wife and his daughter were asleep in the ground floor flat. They burst in on them before the wife or the daughter had a chance to cover up and demanded to know where Ali was while pointing a gun at their faces.
They replied that Ali and his wife had not been home for three days and they had no idea where he was. Incensed that their repeated questions were not yielding any results, they trashed the house and then moved up a floor where there were two more flats and kicked the doors in…
After tearing the flats apart and breaking everything they could, they filled a large suitcase with every kind of camera, hard drive, video recorder or DVD that they could find.
They then returned to the terrified occupants of the ground floor and repeated their demands, this time threatening to take the daughter instead. The Father and Mother said they would take their daughter only over their dead bodies, after a short stand off the police backed off, possibly realizing that the family really had no idea where Ali or his wife and children were.
Ali, who had heard security was looking for him, had left the house 3 days earlier and now no one is sure if he has been arrested or is in hiding.
Maybe Mr. Bronner would like to ask his new friend in the Ministry of Culture, where Ali is?
A note on the photo: Taken by AngryArabiya, the photo is of a painting done by an unknown demonstrator near the Pearl Roundabout. It was been removed at the same time Pearl was destroyed by the government. Thanks to AngryArabiya for permission to use at FDL.




31 Comments












Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Anyone surprised?
Sadly, very little surprises me these days. I almost wish there were something that could, but then, I have to be careful what I ask for.
Well, color me astonished. This is the most surprising thing that’s happened since I discovered that super glue sticks things together.
I figure it will start happening here any time now.
Bahrain king speaks of ‘foiled foreign plot’
King Hamad thanks troops from GCC countries for help in ending unrest after weeks of protests. ( from Al Jaz)
And the NYT is going to start charging online readers for this junk?
Well, they’re going to TRY.
Boxturtle (That’s another shovelfull of dirt on the Grey Lady’s coffin)
On Civilian Casualties; Craig Murray; 3/21/11
http://craigmurray.org.uk/archives/2011/03/on-civilian-casualties/
“But no country would allow the takeover of its financial district.”
Heh. We will, in the fullness of time, burn Wall Street to the ground. Or, if cooler heads prevail, turn it into a museum. Like the holocaust museum.
Replace Shite with African American and see if the WH gets why we are mad?
Foreign plot wasn’t it Commies inciting the Negro in the day and the anti Nuclear weapons, Nuclear power movement?
Conflicting reports at AJ about the happenings in Yemen. One report shows top army officials defecting, but another reports the Defence Minister the army will defend President Saleh against any “coup against democracy.”
On edit: NYT has zero credibility.
But for Southern Plantation owners the Civil War and owning Slaves was the only choice of a country facing a rising tide of chaos that imperiled its livelihood and future.
Its sad but many still consider the Times a Liberal Paper. I don’t think we have a true Liberal Major Newspaper in the country anymore. By ending the Fairness Doctrine the only Papers we have are Fair to Advertisers/Corporations.
Have to throw in this link to an article on huffpo, by Doug Bandow, on how stupid is the ‘war’ in Libya:
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/doug-bandow/war-in-libya-barack-obama_b_838049.html
Admiral Mullen displays the correct way to split hairs.
Shorter Mullen:
All little brown people are created equal, but some are more equal than others.
Obama is really trying hard to beat Bush for worse President ever I didn’t think it would be possible to beat Bush but Obama is making me believe…in a third party Presidential candidate.
Jim White has a fresh cross-post already in progress: Japanese Nuclear Plant Operator Missed Key Equipment Inspections, CEO Ducks Spotlight
The utter immorality of it isn’t what’s surprising, though I don’t know Bronner or his work, but that any press is taking any note of Bahrain whatsoever.
The US seriously has no, or *wants no*, leverage over the Saudis, ‘our partners in peace’, and we all get why. Mark Levine writes that we are becoming quickly irrelevant, but I’m afraid that we are still relevant enough in all the BAD ways.
http://english.aljazeera.net/indepth/opinion/2011/03/20113179218339808.html
And while the Saudis are quashing the protests with tanks and troops, the US will be selling $60 of weapons and systems and fighter jets to them, and training the pilots and crews — in Idaho.
http://my.firedoglake.com/wendydavis/2011/03/20/saudi-pilots-to-train-in-idaho-saudis-help-crush-protests-in-bahrain/
Bad is bad Libya is bad so is Bahrain and Yemen by supporting the bad we make ourselves the target of any Arab protester CIA front companies and American oil companies lives just got much harder, American diplomacy just got harder.
We have identified our selves with the rich when the Arab World is in the mood for Robin Hood.
Great article. Good eye.
It’s a curious thing to be watching the networks reporting of an attacking in Libya ,but not of an attacking in Bahrain and Yemen? In Bahrain one man owns 95% of the wealth, and video of people being shot a point-blank range are going viral on the YouTube. In Yemen, friendly protesters are being shot dead by roof-top snipers, and all in the midst of this story of Libya.
After what happen in Tunisia, and in Egypt it has become apparently clear that there is a greater story happening in the region -some compare it to the spring revolutions of mid 1800′s, and I would to.
The story I imagine is that people have had enough of clerical, imperial, and dictatorial oppression cast upon them for so long in that region, and that they now collectively carry a wish for a better way of living in the breast of their heart, becoming fearless against snake-bite opposition, money and weapons; attempting to fulfill and honorable outcome.
The entire region implicitly, if not explicitly, understands this, but does Paris, London, and Washington -or- even the giant purse strings that govern them?
In every article he has penned about the Mavi Marmara murders, Ethan Bronner has either failed to mention American citizen Furkan Doğan, one of those murdered, or has described Doğan as “a Turk.” I complained to the NYT about this. They have not bothered to reply.
Link please? A diary would be great to bring out this point.
I can’t remember who reported this yesterday – either BBC or Al Jazeera, but I also heard that the Saudis turned back a convoy of medical supplies from Kuwait bound for Bahrain. Just awful.
The revolting Wolfowitz was on TV yesterday spouting the same “Bahrain is different” tripe.
I would have thought that Judy Miller would have destroyed the New York Times’ legitimacy as an independent source of news.
The consequences of this misinformation will be even poorer decision-making with respect to Bahrain.
The fact is that the Khalifas, having rejected a path of constitutional monarchy, are going to lose before the movement in the Middle East abates. The question is only how long it will take and how much killing will occur.
Your headline about MOTUs is on target. We are not witnessing the actions of a US elite anymore. We are witnessing a global elite, who have very close personal relationships and their own infrastructure.
Googling all I found was that the convoy was ‘temorarily detained’, but is now en route. The odd thing is that Kuwait is part of the Gulf Coast Council, isn’t sending troops to Bahrain, though UAE and Qatar, et.al. are now. So are the medical supplies and doctors for rebels? Or government forces?
http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20110319/ap_on_re_mi_ea/ml_bahrain_protests
Asshats are playing right into sectarian divisions, and I understood that more than just Shiia in Bahrain were protesting. Powderkeg, I’d say.
” We are not witnessing the actions of a US elite anymore. We are witnessing a global elite, who have very close personal relationships and their own infrastructure.”
Turning ‘the world is not flat’ crap on its head; sovereign boundaries don’t count any longer.
“Sovereign boundaries are for the little people.” Dontcha know.
The US media has been busily depicting the Bahrainian rebels as thugs with Molotov cocktails for at least the past three weeks that I can remember. Though now that CBS reporters have been shot at by riot police, this might soon change.
I have yet to read or see a coherent explanation of the difference in U.S. attitudes between the Libyan rebels and the rebels in Bahrain.
You betcha! I know MY place; do you? ;o)