“All men are created equal.” Ostensibly, this is the American creed. But most of the conservative agenda flows from an essential belief in human inequality. Oh, conservatives pay a lot of empty lip service to the Declaration of Independence and to the notion of individual freedom. What they really want is to codify a political great chain of being with them at the top and the less worthy stuck in and pacified in their places.
Could Scott Walker’s assault on unions and the middle class make this any more obvious? Or the conservative war on women made obvious by the cynical, deceitful, destructive attacks on Planned Parenthood? Or conservative efforts to deny voting rights to everyone outside of their gated communities? Or their economic policies that advance, justify and guarantee a gross economic inequality that makes yesterday’s Banana Republic seem like paradise?
It is, I think, my greatest political frustration that so many in the media and elsewhere consider these anti-democratic policies legitimate in a working democracy. They are not. They are, at their core, authoritarian, hierarchical and disenfranchising. They have much more in common with the philosophy of King George than the philosophy of Thomas Jefferson. They are anti-democratic and intended to hand power and wealth to a tiny minority while relegating everyone else to second-, third-, and fourth-class status. And they want the law to guarantee this political chain of being.
It remains an ugly wonder that so many in the punished classes buy the argument that egalitarian efforts to reign in the rich are assaults on their already shrunken freedoms. One day, historians will have a field day with their sad ignorance.
There was a popular song from the Revolutionary Era, “Come Here, Fellow Servant.” It was taken from an 18th Century English satire of the upper class, High Life Below the Stairs. Imagine for a moment a Boston tavern scene of 1770. The raucous drinkers are lifting pints to revolution and freedom. Someone begins singing, and all sing along:
Nature made all alike, no distinction she craves,
So we laugh at the great world its fools and its knaves;
For we are all Servants, but they are all slaves.
Where is that spirit in America today? Where is the commitment to egalitarian freedom, to an ethic that recognizes human equality? To a recognition that Power seeks only its own future at the sacrifice of the powerless?
Where is it? On the Streets of Madison. Here’s a song to sing along:
Come here, fellow Servant, and listen to me,
I’ll show you how those of superior degree
Are only dependents, no better than we.
Both high and low in this do agree,Chorus
‘Tis here, fellow servant, and there fellow servant,
And all in a livery.
‘Tis here, fellow servant, and there fellow Servant,
And all in a livery.
See yonder fine spark, in embroidery dress’d
Who bows to the great, and, if they smile, is blest;
Who is he? i’faith, but a servant at best,Chorus
‘Tis here, fellow servant, and there fellow servant,
And all in a livery.
‘Tis here, fellow servant, and there fellow Servant,
And all in a livery.
Nature made all alike, no distinction she craves,
So we laugh at the great world its fools and its knaves;
For we are all Servants, but they are all slaves.Chorus
‘Tis here, fellow servant, and there fellow servant,
And all in a livery.
‘Tis here, fellow servant, and there fellow Servant,
And all in a livery.
The fat shining glutton looks up to his shelf,
The wrinkled lean miser bows down to his pelf,
And the curl-pated beau is a slave to himselfChorus
‘Tis here, fellow servant, and there fellow servant,
And all in a livery.
‘Tis here, fellow servant, and there fellow Servant,
And all in a livery.
The gay sparkling belle who the whole town alarms,
And with eyes, lips and neck, sets the smarts all in arms,
Is a vassal herself, a meer drudge to her charmsChorus
‘Tis here, fellow servant, and there fellow servant,
And all in a livery.
‘Tis here, fellow servant, and there fellow Servant,
And all in a livery.
Then we’ll drink like our betters, and laugh, sing and love,
And when sick of one place, to another we’ll move,
For with little and great, the best joy is to rove,Chorus
‘Tis here, fellow servant, and there fellow servant,
And all in a livery.
‘Tis here, fellow servant, and there fellow Servant,
And all in a livery.



79 Comments












Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
What you are talking about has absolutely nothing to do with conservatism, and everything to do with elitism, a distorted and destructive outlook shared by both ‘major’ parties.
What a great find! There are few things more empowering than a sing-along : ) Makes me want to head to the nearest pub for a pint and to foment rebellion…
I don’t disagree that neo-liberal, elitist elements exist in both major parties. However, the American conservative movement has a worldview at its core, and that worldview is autocratic, hierarchical and authoritarian.
Me too. The song is catchy. It’s amazing how the drive for equality and freedom was so pronounced among the folk in Colonial times.
All true. And while you are right about the spirit animating the protestors, the danger is that existing leaders will only oppose this particular assault, instead of tying them a together and offering some positive alternative. I am reminded of all the people that fail to see that while the Republicans attack the right to vote, Democrats fail to try to protect it, by for example, expanding it to all citizens over 18, no exceptions.
What is more, it is fine to take our inspiration from WI, but there are things to be done both to protect rights to organize and to push back against the predators more generally everywhere.
Democratic capitulation on issues like voting rights is a terrible scandal. We could diminish that scandal by framing today’s conservative movement for what it is — taking Lakoff’s advice finally. We’d make it much harder for Democrats to capitulate if they were seen clearly as enabling an authoritarian future devoid of economic possibility and freedom.
But, as I noted, the anti-democratic movement is seen as legitimate. And it’s not.
Agree with your assessment and answer in the post and to @1 Glenn.
Thanks for a super post.
The more your assessment of the class war being played out in authoritarian policy plays gets written, the more it will be heard.
Your insights will never be weakened by having them repeated here at FDL.
Good Morning, Glenn S.
Thanks for your post. It’s such a warm feeling for me to know that like minded folks are out there. U B 1.
Thanks, demi. As klynn said @7, repetition of this framing is critical. The more we do, the more warm bodies there will be who share the views.
What is democratic about:
* forcing employees to join a union and pay dues
* allowing state employees to contribute less to insurance and pensions than others
* allowing union members to gain wage increases denied others
The founding fathers ( notice no mothers here) were anything but egalitarians. The Constitution was designed specifically to do just the opposite. The founders feared “the power of the mob” as they called “the people.” It wasn’t till Andrew Jackson’s time that universal white male suffrage came about. The reactionaries of today who call themselves Conservatives are in fact trying to return us to a time when ONLY the landed gentry had all the power and everyone else was either a peasant, slave or women , with no vote or for some no rights at all. They have a plan to get us there ASAP and were seeing it put on fast forward now. The attempts at Union busting are to destroy whats left of the Progressive wing of the Dem. wing of the $$ party. Both parties then will be pushed even further to the right. All the elements are now assembled for a one party authoritarian regime and it will only take another so called nat’l emerg. to get the rest of the way. The suspension of the Constitution and the emerg. implementation of dictatorial powers is close. Won’t it be an irony when it’s Mr. hope and change himself that imposes this new State of being on us?
Shops hold democratic elections to become unionized. Benefits are negotiated by elected union representatives and elected public officials. Scapegoating unions is a power play intended to eliminate conservatives’ political opposition. A one-party nation is their goal, and that is anti-democratic.
Today I’m writing more about the public will for equality and freedom than I am about the resulting Constitution. There’s no question that the Framers’ 1) failure to abolish slavery; 2) favoring the propertied was less than egalitarian.
Poor Don, unable to argue against the reality of unions or the arguments for them. Of course, stronger unions means better pay and working conditions for everyone – as employers try to stave of organizing in their shop. And the WI public sector unions contribute 100% of their pension (the issue is the size of the contribution, not who pays it).
But the final problem is the most powerful one – union members can vote to change their union. That is why its democratic.
It remains an ugly wonder that so many in the punished classes buy the argument that egalitarian efforts to reign in the rich are assaults on their already shrunken freedoms. One day, historians will have a field day with their sad ignorance. —
That is the crux of the problem in a nutshell. The woefully and willfully ignorant people who have bought the Bullshit spewed out by The Masters lock, stock and barrel. It’s like some collective Village Idiot who gleefully loads the rifles of the fire squad for his own execution.
Unions help to raise the pay of people who are not even in a union. And if you object to someone making more than you, it is likely that you both will end up with nothing. Union people work very hard and if they make more money, it’s fine with me.
Good Morning Glenn great post!!… As always. And Do KEEP the conservation going describing how this IS CLASS WARFARE being waged by the Right and the RICH… We need to continue to call it what it is Warfare and we have been loosing badly… Wisconsin is but a spark of the beginning of the long battle back to a fair and equitable Nation where workers have a basic right to organize and bargain for their work place wages and conditions… The Right would just love to Crush all Unions with no exception and return to the days of sweat shop working conditions. Where you have zero voice and can be fired for no reason.
Thanks again for keep the conversations going. The MSM sure isn’t reporting these events but fleetingly..
Some years ago I read Alexander Herzen’s “My Past and Thoughts.” Herzen was a 19th Century Russian Democrat(Tom Stoppard wrote a trilogy in which he figures prominently — “The Coast of Utopia”). Anyway, his disappointment at the Russian people’s passivity and ignorance haunted him throughout his life. This is just to say that demoralization and the production of public passivity is now and always has been the favored tactic of authoritarians.
Thanks, nahant. As you say, we must keep the framing and the conversation going if we hope to awaken greater numbers.
What many union haters ignore is that public sector unions accept lower wages for a guaranteed pension benefit. Cheney currently collects millions of dollars from Halliburton as “deferred compensation.” Union pensions are also deferred compensation.
Because they bargained in good faith for all they earn… Like a contract ya think?? Stop being jealous of them and negotiate for yourself!! You are just spewing the Right wing Talking points who want to bust all Unions…
I love the song, it’s so singable. I wonder if the tune in the video is the one used by the Colonials.
I went to the rally in Nashville on Saturday, and heard several recent songs written in to be easily sung and thus remembered.
Well, I think yesterday’s protests were a failure. Why? Let’s start with the numbers. 70-100,000 in Wisconsin, while commendable, is what percentage of union members. What do I mean? If 7-10 percent of the workforce is a member of a private sector union, and estimates of over 30% of the public workforce is a member of a public sector union, where the hell were these people yesterday? Besides Wisconsin, most places saw very few protesters. There should be millions of union members. Where were they? It was a Saturday, were they all working? And that is not even mentioning how many protesting yesterday did not belong to a union at all. If this were Europe, and a union called for a protest, MILLIONS would have showed up. Union busting Republicans will take yesterday as a victory for them.
As far as I know, the melody is the same. I was unable to confirm this with multiple google searches, however. Whatever the case, it sure is singable.
Actually, donbacon has no leverage trying to negotiate by himself. He is at the mercy of his paymasters.
Another most excellent post, Mr. Smith. I also continue to be mystified by the “punished classes’” willingness to not only agree with these assaults, but to actually defend them. I had an experience about a week ago with a work associate of mine where I casually, and in a matter-of-fact way asserted that Glenn Beck is quite literally mental, and that we’re actually bearing witness to a man who’s losing his mind a little bit more each day. The long and short of it is that my utterance caused a major rift between this individual and myself. As I said, I just don’t get it. Seriously, when the likes of Joe Scarborough states that Beck is nuts, we must assume that Beck has long since gone around the bend, and that he’s ready for the proverbial straight-jacket and Thorazine drip…
Isn’t that kind of a “glass half empty” argument? I say this because if we want the movement to grow, we must build morale and optimism. Realistically assess where we are, of course.
This isn’t Europe. It must be easy to sit in Canada and throw stones at us.
For those who want everyone to work for the banksters for free, don’t listen to this audio report from Beirut.
Read it again SD. I wasn’t throwing stones at “us”. I was asking the same questions, everybody will. Where were the millions of union members that want non-union people to support them?
Not really Glenn. If you don’t even have the support of fellow unions, which should number alot more than 70-100,000, then you are in deep trouble.
CB, even union leaders acknowledge the movement is much diminished. Deterioration of the core industries that sustained it is one cause, sustained attacks from the Right helped, distractions of social issues over the last 30 years also cost it. The fact that tens of thousands are gathering over many days is a hopeful sign. To say there should be more is not going to help bring more out tomorrow.
People who take a position against what these unions are trying to accomplish are failing to understand (among other things) one salient point: If the oligarchs succeed in busting the unions (which is obviously the objective), what makes those people think they’re not next on the hit list? The unions are one of the last barriers against the implementation of a full-blown corporate state. I hope the Wisconsin model goes national. I consider it to be equivalent to the civil rights movement of the 60′s. Seeing these citizens mobilize against the oligarchs and kleptocrats gives me a measure of hope, however slight.
The unions fall, and you’re next. Bank on it…
Very True… But his jealousy comes through loud and clear… But the truth is that wages for the average have actually gone down from $30400 to $30000 since 1970 while the top has been exploding at hundreds of percent since then.. We are Loosing the economic war that started as soon as the new Deal was made law… The rich really resent the fact that workers might just have a shot at a decent life..
But what’s the tactical point of the negativity? That’s what I’m trying to say. We should praise those who are showing up and make others realize they will be heroes when they show up as well.
Yo SD. What’s up? Do you have a Caturday going today?
The Wisconsin Lie Exposed – Taxpayers Actually Contribute Nothing To Public Employee Pensions
The Rights lying talking points!!
Very important point! Thanks for the link.
What’s democratic about paying people less than a living wage, making them work overtime without pay, and denying them pensions, paid sick leave, and paid vacations?
Without unions, you’d be working sixty hours a week, in bad conditions, and with minimal pay and no benefits. Dues are a small price for better working conditions.
No, those questions will be asked by reichwing pundits to show that there’s no support for the unions. We have a difficult time getting Americans out of their houses to stand up for many things. The anti-war protests are a great example. With approval of the wars at around 35% we couldn’t muster up a decent anti-war protest. We’re having to start over and it’s not going to happen overnight.
You betch’um, Red Ryder.
All over the country.
A lot of them were probably working, too, to pay their bills.
Or, because the rallies were far apart, at home – when the @#$%^&*() rally finder is set for 200 miles, they’re assuming that you have the time to drive two or three hours to go to one.
Under the new WI bill there would still be democratic elections annually but there would be no closed shop, workers could opt out of unions and the government would no longer collect union dues.
If unions are such a good idea then what is the problem? If a majority of the workforce opts out then the people have spoken. If a significant minority opts out then the only negative effect is that some people will pay dues and some won’t — and that is the heart of the dilemma for the Dems. Dues money to be used for political campaigns, while enriching and empowering the union bosses.
How is it “busting the union” to give people a democratic choice on whether to join or not?
I did see that. Had there been one close to me I would have gone taken part and taken pictures of the crowd. But with the price of gas over $3.50 a gallon it is hard to spend the money when you are on SS and have many other bills to pay…
Workers can still bargain for wages up to the rate of inflation under the new bill, but not for benefits.
Whether or not a person should join the union voluntarily is a moot and/or academic point in the current economic context. If the unions are crushed, the rest of the work force is next on the hit list. Make no mistake about that. The oligarchs want it all, and they’ll run over whomever they have to in order to get it.
Just how democratic is that.. Wages up to inflation when the CPI doesn’t cover food, fuel and many “Other” necessities that are skyrocketing?? How Democratic is that huh?? And NO benefits WTF Bacon you just want to render the workers so they will be nice little people and STFU about any RIGHTS What is democratic about that??
So Canada is sitting on a significant real estate bubble, folks are losing their pensions to multinational banksters all while American drones prowl Canadian skies. How’s that tar sands exploitation by Exxon and BP working out for you, Canada?
No wonder that young Canadians write some of the best songs of social and political satire:
The Burning Hell infomercial
P.S. Canadian maple syrup RULES but it has no future if you let King Corn continue it’s wayward government subsidized ways of turning all food to fakes (High Fructose Corn Syrup).
really like this Mr Smith ;)
great discussion too folks!
and nahant that Johnston article referred to in the FORBES article is a must read for countering much of the misinformation propagated : cuz taxpayers actually contribute nothing to the public worker pensions
Thanks, ksp.
I prefer maple syrup from Vermont. Just had some on French toast.
yeah, I’m fwding this to friends and relatives!!!
In other words, they can try to maintain their standard of living.
Glenn, Wisconsin is doing nothing that hasn’t already been done. Indiana did it, what, 6 years ago? And the governor was re-elected, the teachers are still teaching and getting paid, and the world hasn’t ended. Just don’t think there is the support out there for public servants.
Any good Maple syrup from any of the New England states is great.. One of the things I do miss since leaving was the local Maple syrup makers, just the smell of boiling Maple sap is mouth watering never mind all the great sweets made from it mmmmmmm…
Making Maple Syrup
This isn’t about Canada, although it has serious problems on the horizon. I will say one thing about Canada (at least Ontario). If the teacher’s and their unions tried this in Ontario, they would get very very little public support. Their unions are stronger than any gov’t party, and as rich if not richer than many corporations. The Teacher’s Union in Ontario, owns malls, properties, sports franchises, etc, etc. They’ve made huge coin for their members. Maybe the public sector unions in the US should give their Canadian members a phone call and ask them how they did it?? Do a google on what the Ontario Teacher’s Federation owns, or even has for cash. One of the richest unions by far.
Vermont gold! French toast rawks but so does sunnyside up egg on an English muffin but I will accept chicken on a raft.
Chicken on a Raft – The Young Tradition
Gelnn, I think you have outdone yourself in this wonderful presentation. Just what we need to endure and grow. The fact is the people who know and seek justice are growing in numbers in spite of all arrayed against us.
As an aside, I can’t stand to watch much of the Sunday pundits but did catch Lawrence O’Donnel injecting the observation that what is ignored in the obsession with the “deficits” is where the money is to repair them, the superwealthy. At least there is one voice.
Glenn, thanks for another great post. Don’t know how things got so twisted in this country but I hope we find a solution soon. The PTB can’t hold the line forever.
True – except when folks like myself are called by the State to estimate the cost of new pension benefits we are screamed at and the hearing canceled by representatives saying, and I quote from Massachusetts in 1974, it is an insult to question (cost out) the value of the pension demanded and the police captains do not object to the union contract and the police captains note that we have never before demanded cost estimates of these contracts.
At that point I gave up – folks like me, and me, got the state to START pre-funding the liability at least. But the multiple pensions – join the military and military service counts toward the 20 years for full pension, change towns and get multiple pensions, pension pay based on last year, or last “day”, with overtime, with Billy Bulgur’s pension ruled to include as final pay the value of the car and home as part of his job.
It is a lot of state workers getting 10% less in wages and 10% less in pensions as police/fire/prison/sanitation get ridiculous pensions – and then police endorse the GOP who want to destroy other public unions and know the police excess is both protected (no one wants to take away anything from the police) and will be used as examples of excessive public union pensions – the public being unable to separate police from other public unions.
Keep the good fight going here and everywhere, Glenn.
I frankly think the demonstrations going on across the country will get stronger. The Academy Awards will be another good platform tonight.
“Where is that spirit in America today? Where is the commitment to egalitarian freedom, to an ethic that recognizes human equality? To a recognition that Power seeks only its own future at the sacrifice of the powerless?”
well, part of the problem is that the American revolution turned out to be a masters revolution, and not really a servants revolution after all, despite the high spirits at the time.Genuine Revolutionary, Thomas Paine, would eventully leave the country in disgust, and go to Australia to attempt to make a revolution there. The idea didnt catch on.
GREAT read Mr. Smith thanks for your work, rcc’d.
N don’t forget Pups, Scroll The Troll . . . they ain’t worth your time.
Time is running out to untwist them,Twain!
‘Anonymous’ targets the brothers Koch, claiming attempts ‘to usurp American Democracy’
Looks like the Koch brothers have “Awoken the “Sleeper”! And Unions have gained another ally!! We need all we can get to defeat the right!! And Defeat them we must!!
It’s true that there were a lot of earlier and more populist revolutions against state authorities. But the Framers did leave us a living constitution that doesn’t prohibit broad-based, progressive, egalitarian reforms. We have built upon it. Just much more to be done.
Koch a Doodle Dandy!
Remember “No taxation without representation”? It has always struck me that we allow states to remove the vote from felons, but continue to tax them. Once the state removes their vote, they magically lose the right to vote for federal representatives as well, even though there is no federal restriction on felons’ voting rights.
ROFLMAO!!!
Grab by their scrawny necks and wring the #$$%$ out of them…
Koch a Doodle Dandy indeed!!
Canada is not the country it used to be in only 12 years. Ask yourself what are the counter forces against the systematic corruption of Ottawa, Toronto and Mississauga by the neo-cons/neo-liberals (the two fickle faces of the same multinational kleptocracy)? The fact of and the way Harper avoided the no vote of confidence certainly sent a message.
The attack on Planned Parenthood’s provision of infant and maternal healthcare services is especially enlightening about the rightists’ objectives. Most of those services go to the poor and working class, the young and those without or with little health care insurance, where every dollar spent on health care means food or lighting or heat or bus fares that won’t be purchased or paid for.
What do the Republicans and their cooperative Democrats propose to replace the health care services that their defunding would deny? Nuttin’. Absolutely nothing. The poor and working class, the young and those without or with little health care will have to do without.
We’ve all gotta share the pain say the millionaires in Congress, whose fully paid, exemplary health care services – including a US Navy-staffed ward in the basement of the Capitol – remain untouched. Like the careers and futures of the banksters that crashed the world economy, their pay and perks, their careers and reputations are sacrosanct.
Good news about Anon. The Kockroaches can run, but they can’t hide.
Koch a doodle doo! And Woo Hoo. Also.
Great post, Glenn. Thank you!
As for the tune: Probably easiest just to contact Ms Taraz, the performer, at her website and ask for her documentation!
Since she appears to be a dedicated Living History practitioner, I’d say she’s probably researched the heck out of all her tunes.
Her YouTube channel and website are great fun.
Not to mention that, in WI at least, it’s the middle of an Upper Midwest WINTER.
Getting as many people mobilized as a big Packers game? Over almost 2 weeks? Over politics?
Thermos looks half full to me.
After the first raise received by union members and NOT received by nonunion workers in that workplace, the whining will reach the heavens.
Didn’t you know that fair share workers receive the same improvements that union members receive? Dues are a small price to pay when you’re the only workers in America who still have, or maybe have had, pensions and health benefits on the job.
And I must say that union members have agreed in the past to reduce their own wages in order to protect and contribute to their pensions funds. They’ve made their payments every paycheck. It isn’t the workers’ fault if local or state gov’t has not paid in what it legally agreed to pay. And it is not local or state gov’ts’ fault if the banks’ criminal acts or Wall St’s gambling addiction have corrupted these accounts.
Try living in a “right to work” state if you believe unions are not democratic! In a state like Wyoming, you can carry a gun without a permit, but you can’t earn a decent living and they pay you what they think you are worth…lots of minimum wage jobs here, but not much of a future. Give me union working conditions anytime! If you choose Walmart as an employer, let me know just how democratic that is, okay?
I’d say that Wyoming looks pretty good.
CHEYENNE, March 28, 2008 – A booming energy industry has helped Wyoming’s average income double over the past decade. In 1996, the average Wyomingite earned $21,875 a year and the state ranked 33rd for average income. Last year, Wyoming’s average income was $43,226 and the state ranked sixth, according to U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis figures released this week.
http://trib.com/news/state-and-regional/article_9e4f34f1-4205-5717-9221-cd663685a2e3.html
6/20/2010
DETROIT — Newly hired members of the United Auto Workers at GM, Ford and Chrysler earn about $14 per hour, half what veterans make under their current contract. [That's $28,000 annual]
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/37789668/ns/business-autos/
February 26, 2011
. . .in Wisconsin, where Gov. Scott Walker’s face-off with unions has thrust public sector compensation into the national spotlight, the state pays janitors a median wage of nearly $27,000, about the same as they would make in the private sector.
http://www.theledger.com/article/20110226/ZNYT02/102263012/1001/BUSINESS?Title=In-Battle-Over-State-Payrolls-Data-Show-a-Mixed-Picture
I am not a Jefferson scholar, but I believe that at some level he purposely planted that commitment to equality in America’s founding document knowing that we were far from living up to it. The presence of that commitment has forced long struggle between the ideal of equality the value of all people and the existing structures of society and economy that have been denying and resisting it at every step.
Strong forces want to deny it, to subvert it, to wiggle out of it, but it remains as a goal for those who believe in it.