Well, now it seems that Texas Gov. Rick Perry has been attacked by one coyote and three “anarchists.” Quite the inspiring credentials for a presidential run, I’d say.
The Texas Department of Public Safety on Thursday linked the June, 2008 burning of the Texas Governor’s Mansion to an Austin “anarchist group” whose members included two young men convicted of making Molotov cocktails during the National Republican Convention in Minneapolis later that same year.
Maybe not-so-coincidentally, the DPS’s revelation comes a little less than a month before the March 12, South by Southwest Film Festival premiere of Better This World, a powerful new documentary about the two troubled Austin activists and the FBI informant who entrapped them.
Before going on, I want to make it clear that I condemn political violence of any sort, whether or not it has been encouraged by a government’s entrapping agents provocateurs. I am as repelled by ideologues on the left as I am by those on the right. You encounter them often in politics. They are not even fun to sit next to, much less work with. Closed minds make bad decisions and often discredit heroic efforts by the open-minded who happen to share some policy goals.
Discrediting, of course, is just what governments have done to anti-authoritarian movements throughout history, especially over the last 100-150 years or so. As Alex Butterworth details in his book, The World That Never Was: A True Story of Dreamers, Schemers, Anarchists, and Secret Agents, much of the violence pinned on “anarchists” was actually staged by government infiltrators.
As I noted here last week in “One Moment in the World’s Salvation,” I also regret the intentional deformation of the term anarchism, which was used by Russian Prince Peter Kropotkin, Leo Tolstoy, American philosopher William James and others to refer to a non-violent philosophy that placed the individual and community above hierarchy and authoritarian control. Today, anarchist means a violent enemy of the state. So it goes.
When I wrote the piece last week, however, I had no idea that Texas state troopers would just a few days later put anarchism back in the news. I hope they catch and convict the criminals who burned the Texas Governor’s Mansion. And I really hope an FBI informant or domestic spy didn’t put the arsonist or arsonists up to it.
When the mansion burned, it was being renovated. Gov. Perry and his family had already moved out of it and into a West Austin swankienda. It was near that home that Perry gunned down a coyote that crossed his jogging path. These days, coyotes get a rap almost as bad as anarchists. Bagging both species would make of Perry something like a domestic, great white hunter, I suppose, and embellish his presidential resume. Sarah Palin’s killing of a caribou seems pathetically wimpy by comparison.
A few points about the DPS statement. They don’t seem to be accusing either of the two men convicted of assembling firebombs in Minneapolis. The statement very carefully talks about “one of the men arrested in Minnesota.” Notice it does not say “one of the men convicted.” The Austin American-Statesman’s online headline, “Minnesota bomb plotters linked to mansion fire,” doesn’t fit the reporting.
In a follow-up story, the DPS is, once again, careful with its words, pointing to “an Austin-based anarchist group whose members were prosecuted…”
More telling, there was an FBI informer – Brandon Darby – in the midst of those the DPS connects to the Mansion fire. That’s pretty embarrassing. Darby is the informer who mentored and then fingered David McKay and Bradley Crowder, the two men convicted of making firebombs in Minnesota.
If what the DPS says is true, the FBI informer missed the burning of the Governor’s Mansion but helped entrap and bust the perps on fires that never happened. Crime prevention deserves praise, of course, but I’m just saying…
I also find it hard to believe that any members of this alleged “anarchist group” have been able to keep their secret about burning down the governor’s mansion. Clearly, the FBI has many individuals in mind for their virtual “anarchist group.” It appears that three of those fellows — McKay, Crowder and informant Darby — know nothing about it. Are we to believe that with two doing federal prison time, one actually working for the FBI and others under intense scrutiny, that none have yet spilled the beans?
What’s the point of all this? As Butterworth details in his book, the symbiotic relationship among secret police informers and their targets leads, in the end, to a great amount of stupidity on all sides. I suppose the cat-and-mouse game will be with us always.
I hope activists here and around the world will learn the lesson of Egypt. The Egyptians’ non-violent revolution is a model. People of great courage, discipline and commitment toppled a brutal regime, never taking the bait when assaulted by government police and overcoming the agents provocateurs in their midst.
Activist violence is morally deplorable and dependably ineffective. When the assembly of a me-against-the-world self-image triumphs over altruistic efforts at justice and freedom, the cause is lost. In the end, the authorities love that type because they are so easily undone.
Meanwhile, it won’t be long before Gov. Perry is on FoxNews telling viewers how he narrowly escaped an anarchist plot. The show goes on forever and the party never ends.
NOTE: While David McKay’s first trial ended in a mistrial because jurors were convinced he had been entrapped, McKay subsequently recanted the entrapment defense and pleaded guilty. Since Brandon Darby was McKay’s mentor and a government infiltrator in question, this means a court judgment found no entrapment by Darby.





57 Comments





Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Morning Glenn… Now to finish reading.. But first Violence nor the threat of violence has a place in Politics period!!
*modnote: amen*
Seconded.
I’ve spent my entire life believing violence is not the answer. Considering the opposition has no such qualms, I’m seriously rethinking that.
I’m not going to expound on my theory about who burned up the governor’s mansion but I am going to call bullshit on the DPS’ theory. The Texas Department of Public Safety in overseen by the Texas Public Safety Commission, which is a group of five people who are appointed by the Governor, (one of the few real powers he has are appointments), and confirmed by the Senate for staggered, six year terms. As Perry has been governor for eleven years now and as the Texas Senate has had a majority of Republicans for much longer, there can be no doubt that they are all Perry cronies whose “findings” will be precisely that which Perry told them to “find”. Couple the cronies on the commission with the unabashed ideological zealotry of attorney general Greg Abbott, (sworn in on December 2, 2002), and you have all of the machinery under control and in place to make any “investigation” highly suspect. I don’t believe this “result” anymore than I would believe a drug company’s “study” of the efficacy of a drug around which their entire future success is bound.
The Feebs trap the folks who haven’t done anything but can’t stop the ones who are intent on doing something? Or is that won’t stop the ones intent on doing something?
And if you really want to be scared Glenn, Florida Governor VoldeScott wants to use Perry and Texas as his ‘model’ for governing.
Glenn, thanks for this excellent post – you made my Sunday!
O/T, but this is so cool: Lambert at Correntewire points to a poster (Valhalla) who is telling about this pizza place (Ian’s Pizza) that said they would accept contributions online for pizza delivery to the protestors in WI. Valhalla points out:
http://correntewire.com/
VoldeScott! Someone might tell him that Perry’s about to cut public school funding by 25 percent, not that he’d care, but the parents in all the neighborhood schools that have to close will care.
Morning stranger..
It’s almost like Wisconsin. Where two brothers are Assembly Speaker and Senate President and their father heads up the state troopers. All in the family.
Again, I’m not going to expound on my theory but I’ve got one word: Reichstag. I don’t know that it was initially burned for political reasons but that’s how it will be used by Perry. This whole episode stinks.
I second that howdy to KJM MD…though I’ve always found “morning strangers” a little unsettling.:)
Yes it does.
Good morning, Glenn. Your usual good post is appreciated. Can you tell us what the Democrats in Texas are doing? Are they active in trying to stop some of this nonsense with Gov. Hair?
Incestuous bunch Republicans, aren’t they?
Good morning Glenn and Nahant – wishing you both a sunny warm day in the freezing winter. Thanks to you both for keeping the light amidst the darkness.
Oh, I’d imagine Scott has already heard about Perry’s cuts.
He’s happily doing quite similar, cutting jobs, cutting taxes but “creating jobs” while he does so. Honest, he has said this.
Hey it stopped raining and the Sun is out!!! Will be better than the 42 and down pours of the last few days… Snow on all the hills around here.. but melting quickly as we break 50 today ☺ ☺
Sine when does the right create jobs at any time… They just want to cut cut cut and leave the rest out in the cold. While they give away the common assets of the people for pennies on the dollar..
I can’t imagine what they think the world will look like after they scorch it, though I do think the GOP grew envious of all those bully-boy banana republics where we installed the tyrants who kept all the money and the people pacified with violence.
Convenient coinkydink – the movie and the DPS statement, isn’t it. Should boost viewers at the movie (unintended consequences and all that).
So exactly how did the DPS determine that the fire was not a matter of carelessness and negligence?
Two things strike me about this:
The DPS wants the case to be closed quickly.
The DPS does not want to finger any “real” Texans.
There is what appears to be a very clear video of someone throwing a firebomb onto the porch, and they referred to that video at the time of the fire. I believe some idiot caused the fire, it’s just their parsing of their words — and tossing around the fearsome “anarchist” thing, that raises my eyebrows.
Bought ‘em 2 pizzas last night. Ain’t cheap @ $22 each.
AND THE KILLIN’ GOEZ ON AND ON AND…
Citizen Glen W Smith and the Firepup Freedom Fighters:
Keep the faith, Brother Glenn, but more importantly keep your eyes on the prize…don’t be distracted by the distractions, the misdirections and the terrorist threats. I spent 3 days in Madison this last week and will be goin’ again on Tuesday. My head is spinnin’ and my heart is full and at some point soon, I hope today, I will offer a post on the experience of bein’ a part of history again instead of an observer. But I want to call on all of us to remain committed to the truth that we all share about where the real violence in our society comes from and do not waste any energy fearing the anger of our brothers and sisters in this struggle. We all know where the violence will come from and to publically call the people to remain non-violent only legitimizes the lie that there is danger from the mass of people.
No, Citizen Smith, we must focus on the violence that is already here and that is building as our empire implodes and the fascists retrench by re-deploying corporate mercenaries back into the country to fill the void left by the citizen soldiers who are now hung out to dry in Iraq and Afgahnistan and can’t be mobilized to protect their bothers and sisters in the streets of their own country. No one anywhere in the state of Wisconsin, who has had any real contact with what is goin’ on in Madison fears violence from the people and for the first time in our history, the police and local militia are on the side of the people against the power of the oligarchy…that’s why the Madison protest has succeeded and why the the Egyptians won (so far). All the cops and state troopers that I have spoken to and the local cops from my town expressed confidence that the protesters would be peaceful and that any violence would come from the Tea Party mercenaries. The cops on the street in Madison and the troopers on the freeways of the state understand the physics learned by General Custer…they aren’t gunna turn themselves against a force of 70,000 to protect a couple hundred right wing agent provocateurs.
I have been sayin this for several years now Brother Glenn but indulge me one more time: The war is comin’ home to us…it is here now and no one will fight it for us.
KEEP THE FAITH AND PASS THE AMMUNITION, THE STRUGGLE GOES ON AND ON AND…
Good for you eCHAN! Good for you… We are all Wisconsinites at heart..
but money well spent!
I read about this yesterday — anything to buoy up the people on the front lines.
Thank you for being there. Are the people doing okay in the cold?
Someone take advantage? Yikes.
I agree with Margaret and other posters here about the conclusions of DPS, whom we cannot count on to be objective. More likely, they are just sock puppet lackeys for this cruel and evil Governor who needs a scapegoat so that he can indulge his paranoid fantasies and victim complex.
After all, we are talking about a psychopath that would gladly send someone like Cameron Todd Willingham to his death rather than compromise his image as a macho bully to his thuglike supporters:
http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/death-by-fire/?utm_campaign=homepage&utm_medium=proglist&utm_source=proglist
Nice, diary, Glenn. I wonder if I might offer that there may be different sorts of violence; the sort against people or animals, and the sort against machines or buildings. There may be different terms for each, but I don’t know them.
Or it may be that those who do harm to machines and buildings equivocate and parse terms in an effort to explain that their tactics are okay in some instances. Dunno, but it usually helps to use language as precisely as we can for big subjects like this one.
I do think that eco-terroro=ism was often trumped up, and full of lies and misdirections, and like the American Indian Movement, American Media and the eco-wrongdoers loved to push boogey-men, and the truth is often still way out there.
Citizen wendydavis:
Do not be distracted into rhetorical arguments or scholastic conversations about how many angels can dance on a pin. The violence that is comin is movin’ from where it has always come and for once the people have the support of their own police and militia…people are learning at an incredible rate,Sister Wendy, and there is much learning left to be accomoplished but it will come from experience, including the experience of confronting fear and discovering the courage to face violence.
thanks for that. it is so hard to know what is going on without inside info.
and on personal experience, they have great pizza. while at the protest thur, I indulged.
Citizen madma:
Please don’t waste any time on the violence that has already occured, the moment for “figuring out” who is to blame has long since past as has the burning of the governor’s mansion. The violence we must focus on is that which is comin’ and we know who and where it is comin’ from.
good for you
I was not wasting time on any violence. I just enjoy hearing from people who are in the states and know what is going on. At least from what Margaret said, I am assuming she lives in Tx. If I am wrong, please forgive.
I to had that experience in madison. There was one police office between myself and thousands of protesters standing in front of the assembly Thur and he did look nervous, but after a time state troopers came and everyone was very relaxed. With all the protests I have attended, it is the first time ever, I have not seen riot police. I don’t think it would bode well when we saw them in Egypt and they appeared in Madison. What would Hillary and Obama do then?
Solidarity forever, Citizen Norske!
“In spite of oppressors, in spite of false leaders, in spite of labor’s own lack of understanding of its needs, the cause of the worker continues onward. Slowly his hours are shortened, giving him leisure to read and to think. Slowly his standard of living rises to include some of the good and beautiful things of the world. Slowly the cause of his children becomes the cause of all. His boy is taken from the breaker, his girl from the mill. Slowly those who create the wealth of the world are permitted to share it. The future is in labor’s strong, rough hands.”
- Mother Jones
Sunday morning with Glenn, always time well spent.
We are having an event in Santa Fe on Tuesday in solidarity with WI.
Maybe our time is coming. Egypt has inspired.
It is interesting how the term violence has been distorted by our worship of property. How can you equate an attack on a symbol like a building and an actual violent act on a human being?
While i don’t generally support these acts a good barn burning does get the message across.
I thought that in this case the “mansion” was actually a double-wide trailer. Living here in West Virginia I can tell you that those things catch on fire all the time, all by themselves. Its a matter of poor safety regulations in trailer manufacturing, and, oftentimes, exploding meth labs.
The Egyptian uprising was by no means peaceful. Those people went to violent war. They didn’t just have a sit-in with quick photo-op of being pliantly escorted off for booking on a minor trespass ticket and then back home to the family for dinner. Which has become the American definition of non-violent protest.
The NDP building didn’t just set itself on fire. Initially, protesters violently resisted being dislodged by physically responding the the police. Then later by physically battling government-sponsored thugs in a two-day skirmish that left both sides bloody. I think it’s more accurate to say that the Egyptian protesters were not aggressively belligerent and applied violence in a retaliatory and proportional fashion from a defensive posture.
If those people had simply been non-violent protesters a-la the American Left, Mubarak would still be in power today.
I am not sure where you get your definition on nonviolence, but it does not seem useful or in any way related to what Glenn said.
Sorry for the mixup. I looked it up and the “mansion” really was some kind of big house that caught on fire while being renovated. but I’m sure that there was a trailer in the story somewhere. My suspicion is that the jack-leg contractor put in some bad wiring and burned the place down accidentally, and his insurance company is trying to get out of paying. This is far, far more likely than anarchist Molotov fire bombers.
for more on this go to http://www.texasobserver.org/oped/who-are-these-austin-anarchists
I was responding to this paragraph. It is a totally inaccurate description of what happened in Egypt. The author is talking about arson as totally over the top violence in an American context – and then pointing to an uprising where they torched the HQ of the regime being opposed as proper nonviolent protests?
The Egyptians didn’t behave as Glenn is saying they did. They beat the living crap out of the police and drove them out of Tahrir … just before torching the HQ. My definition of nonviolence involves not picking up a rock and smashing someone else’s head in with it or burning down buildings. Both of which were actions taken by pro-democracy participants Egypt’s (semi) successful uprising.
Perhaps completely nonviolent protest is the answer for America … but we certainly can’t look to what happened in Egypt to support this theory. All I’m saying is if we are going to emulate how the Egyptians did it – we’re going to be burning some stuff down and bashing some heads in with rocks. Not endorsing the course of action. Simply acknowledging the reality of what happened in Egypt that we all watched with our own eyes.
You reacted to more than one thing. I disputed the other one.
The facts on Egypt have nothing to do with that statement.
More than that, the issue of what we can look to depends on what works, not every act that was done. It was the withdrawal of support from the regime that made the difference. The actions you mentioned could never take down a regime on their own.
Agree, kgb. And a few of us on the thread wanted the term ‘violence’ narrowed or explained. The nonviolence in Egypt is the accepted takeaway, as is that it was all n spontaneous social network phenomenon; so much simpler than the complexities and history and many groups involved.
Now I’m confused about your point. Are you disagreeing with my characterization of the typical “peaceful” protest in America?
I don’t disagree that what we can look to depends on what works – in the situation one faces. In the case of Egypt, the actions I mentioned sparked the imagination of a nation. After a vicious assault by the police – a microcosm for the lives most Egyptians live – The protesters were not only still standing, they had driven the police from the streets and struck a blow at a symbol of the regime’s power. The public responded by filling that space the demonstrators had made safe from government assault with their children and mothers.
Indeed, the actions I mentioned could never take down a regime on their own. However, had the protesters not taken those actions to hold Tahrir – the regime would never have fallen. It’s a simple fact. Nonviolence did not win for the protesters in Egypt – fighting their asses off did.
I’m not sure there is any useful parallel to draw for actions in other places facing other situations. But I am quite sure it is not the best route to misconstrue what happened in order to try.
kgb, can you go to my Posterous, and heed the message I left for Crane-s
Station please? Love to get in touch. Thanks.
http://wendyedavis.posterous.com/
I’m reminded of the Zelaya drama in Honduras when “nonviolent” was loosely redefined to include throwing Molotov cocktails and torching/looting stores and buses.
Personally, I’m not a strict pacifist so the only issue I have is “what are the appropriate lines”. Oh and the minor hypocrisy. Kind of like GOPpers and sex … call it something else or just don’t get caught … but never, NEVER, acknowledge appreciating it’s fruits.
As a former CORE volunteer said of his expereriences in rural MS: non-violence seems better when the cameras are on; when a carload of cretins are holding shotguns at your front door…not so much.
The strange language against ‘idealogues’ in the diary caught me unaware, too; whazzat? I think I may be one on some issues. But violence against a machine like the walking chain-down monsters? Dunno; I might kill one. (can’t think what they’re called…)
Check posterous?
Gov. Perry took a full contingent of security with him out to guard the lakeside mansion he moved into while the governors mansion was under renovation, leaving a skeleton security crew at the mansion to guard it. Prior to the move, Gov. Perry’s office (and maybe even Perry himself) overruled the mansion’s security office recommendation that a full contingent of security should guard the mansion during renovations.
After the arson attack, it became CYA time for Gov. Perry and Republicans, especially those in the governors office. They’d left the governors mansion relatively unguarded. One security guard was at the mansion’s surveillance monitors, some of which were discovered afterward to be malfunctioning. One other guard was reportedly somewhere on the grounds. Gov. Perry took all other security personnel with him to guard his “temporary” lodgings at the lake, a wealthy-donor mansion costing Texas taxpayers $10,000 a month…now for almost three years.
And it was reported a few months ago, that Gov. Perry’s office took away over $10 million allocated for Texas Gulf Coast residents after Hurricane Ike, redirecting this Gulf Coast disaster recovery money to pay for the additional renovation costs caused by the arson attack in Austin. No wonder Gov. Perry and the Republicans in the governors office have kept mum about how many security personnel they took away from guarding the pre-arson governors mansion to guard his lakeside retreat. (The most glaring omission in the post-arson investigation report was the number of security personnel Gov. Perry took with him out to the lakeside mansion. The undermanned size of the governor’s mansion skeleton security crew was reported, but the size of Gov. Perry’s lakeside mansion security force was absent. This would have provided Texas voters with a base-line comparison, which is probably why Perry’s office has kept this hidden. Perry’s lakeside mansion retreat probably had anywhere from 5 to 10 times more security personnel on-site compared to how many were left to guard the governor mansion).
Gov. Rick Perry (R-TX) and Texas Republicans in general have been a disaster for Texas, and the governors mansion (a 150-year-old Texas historical landmark), to say nothing about what Republicans are doing to the rest of our country, our democracy, the future of our nation’s children. Huge budget shortfalls nationwide caused by giveaways to the wealthy. Rising poverty levels, more children starving. Outsourcing costing American workers jobs. Increased infrastructure failures (remember the rolling Texas blackouts a month ago?). Rampant sex scandals at the Texas Youth Commission leading to huge bonuses recently for Republican TYC commissioners (coverup money? hush money?) even while Texas faces a $25 billion budget shortfall caused by Republicans.
And the destruction being wreaked upon Americans (and Texans) by corporate-owned Republican leaders and politicians cuts across party lines, with many less-well-off lower-income Republicans being hurt along with everyone else. Go figure. Less-well-off lower-income Republicans are literally voting to see the American dream for themselves and their children destroyed. Now, THAT is irony, or tragedy, or something.
The road goes on forever the party never ends.
Go to u tube.Type robert earl keen for the song.
I’ll just say that I don’t wish to diminish the courage it took to defend the geography of the protest. I can’t agree, however that the burning of a police headquarters had much to do with the outcome. I know nothing of the circumstances of that fire, but it wouldn’t surprise me to learn it was set by agents of the regime.
And I don’t much see the point of defending violence.
Your question about the “ideologues” graph deserves a reply. I, too, hold to deep values and the policies that lead from them. So I’m not talking about that. I’m talking about the kind of absolutist ideologies that shutter one’s eyes and close one’s mind. None of us have the ultimate answers before which any sacrifice is justified.
I think we should always remain open and aware without sacrificing our commitments to our values. The difference? I encounter it all the time. Some people listen, think, and agree or refute. Others, the ideologues, don’t listen so well. They seem encased in their own grand Idea and don’t really engage at all except to prove again the superiority of that idea — to themselvesm, not to others.