While trawling the web for Wisconsin news, I ran across this bizarre piece by David Zurawik. Mr. Zurawik, in addition to being a notorious tone troll who thinks lefties with facts are worse than righties with lies, is also a union-hating guy who thinks that the truth is icky and partisan and just wishes that those with the truth and the facts, like Rachel Maddow and Ed Schultz, would just pipe down and let their wealthier and better-bred betters do all the talking:
On the plus side, MSNBC was the first of the cable news channels to commit to intense coverage of this story earlier in the week — following up with Ed Schultz broadcasting live from Madison Thursday night.
On the minus side, its coverage has been partisan and rabble-rousing to the point where it seems as if cable show hosts like Schultz are exploiting the anger of the situation, rather than reporting the story and trying to bring context, clarity and understanding to a troubled situation.
He then goes on to mock the comparisons between the Wisconsin and Egyptian protests, and then say that it’s not union-busting because Politifact says it isn’t. Well, okay then. NOT.
Hello, ink-stained wretch! Union-busting is exactly what it is. It’s not about the “budget deficit”. The “budget deficit” is one of Walker’s own making, resulting from tax breaks to his buddies — as you would know if you didn’t depend on Politifact and network TV to tell you everything you know.
In fact, as our own David Dayen demonstrates here and here, the ALEC-designed bill takes dead aim at collective bargaining.
What’s ALEC? The Koch-brothers funded far-right-wing American Legislative Exchange Council, which is dedicated to taking over state legislatures to destroy workers’ rights and environmental safeguards (the Koches being heavily into coal and oil). As Bluestem Prairie’s Sally Jo Sorensen notes, they helped write SB 1070, the infamous “Show Us Your Papers” bill that turned the State of Arizona into a police state predicated on harassment of brown-skinned Spanish-speakers. They are the forces behind the cookie-cutter union-busting bills in various state legislatures, not just Wisconsin’s:
Wisconsin has become the critical start point for a much broader assault on worker’s rights and unions. Ohio has seen similar protests over a very similar bill. And states like Arizona, Florida, Indiana, Iowa, New Hampshire, New Jersey and New Mexico are considering additional limits on public employee rights, though not to the extent of Ohio and Wisconsin.
The origins, as I wrote about Monday, come from ALEC, the American Legislative Exchange Council, a key driver in the conservative movement. One reason why you see similar bills from Republicans pop up in multiple states is ALEC, which pushes an agenda for state legislators to pick up and run with. We know that ALEC brought together Walker and southern state Governors after the elections to discuss so-called “right-to-work” legislation. We know that ALEC commended Walker for his first successful piece of legislation, the bill slashing business taxes that created the budget deficit which he is now exploiting to take away public employee rights. They are basically behind all of this.
In short, if your state is doing something that is good, the ALEC mokes are unalterably opposed to it.
——
As a side note: What is it with the union-hatred among self-important media pundits like you, Mr. Zurawik? Was your grandpa a union member who spanked you when you got into his fishing lures? Was he a rich industrialist who taught you to feel that nobody who worked with their hands for a living deserved to have a living wage, much less be able to put kids through college? Did a guy whose dad was a longshoreman key your car when you were in high school? Really, what is the deal with you?
Why such a hate-on for the one force that more than any other propelled most of our great-grandparents and their offspring into America’s middle class? Are you, being safely ensconced in the world of the well-off, trying to pull up what remains of the upward-mobility ladder that unions created and guarded until people like you worked to destroy them? Or do you just worship Ayn Rand? Really, what is the deal here?
Oh, and by the way — remember how you mocked the comparisons of the Wisconsin and Egypt protests? Well, guess what — many Egyptians, particularly noted journalist Mona Eltahawy, are among those folks making these comparisons. Neener neener neener.



66 Comments










Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
wasnt david zurawik a food columnist for the baltimore sun, or wrote movie reviews or something?
Grrrr…people like this are just making me crazy…is somebody breeding them?
I dont bother to read most of the “fear the people” pieces being written about Wisconsin, they are legion. and anyway if youve seen one youve seen them all.
If this is the same guy, you can send him an email with your opinion.
Solarso, this is how Zurawik describes himself:
I have been the Baltimore Sun’s TV critic since 1989. Before that I was TV critic/columnist at the Dallas Times Herald. I earned a Ph.D. in American Studies (pop culture-media studies) from the University of Maryland, College Park in 2000. I have an M.A. from the University of Wisconsin in specialized reporting (pop culture). I am the author of “The Jews of Prime Time,” a look at 50 years of Jewish idenitity in front of behind the cameras of network TV (Brandeis University Press/University Press of New England, 2003).
PW, I don’t think it’s right to say that Politifact says that this is not union busting. What the linked article says (or said, before the link suddenly broke) is that Ed Schultz’s claim that people might lose 20% of their income overnight is an exaggeration. Now, looking at Politifact’s rating of truth/falsity, it’s pretty clear that their scales aren’t particularly well-balanced.
The only democracy we will see in the US will be seen in the streets .
The mechanisms that make the democratic process work have collapsed entirely .
Egyptian and the protesters in the Northern Africa and the rest o the mid east all somehow know what we should also remember .
The power has always been with the people and by merely not cooperating en masse the entire edifice of lies , greed and corruption would disappear overnight .
PW, great piece you have here. I like that you brought us more about the ALEC association and how they are spreading it to all the states that picked up Repug or Teaparty Governors.
The Crotch Bros. are something else. I have a boycott out against their eggs, especially for the month of April. THE ENTIRE MONTH, should be locally farm raised eggs only, not store bought.
I have no idea how to stop or slow them down, but the more light we put on these usurpers the better. They have been shadowed and kept behind the curtain for far too long!
KUDOS to you!
I’d also like to say that those reports of Ed are blatantly false! He is with the people, he talks to them and also has special interviews with others. Okay, yeah they are all supporters of the protest, but so far nobody from Walker’s office has been out with Ed to discuss their view. I wouldn’t count on it. Anyway, Ed said last night that the crowd knows that Dick Armey and the Crotch Bros. are sending in the Tea Party. They are expecting it and are ready to go fact by fact with them.
yeah, i want to ask him if politifact picks his ties for him, and if they jibe with his “lucky astrology mood watch”
How do you know which eggs are Koch?
Glad to see this topic so I could grumble on something I saw/heard first thing this morning on the teevee and it would at least be somewhat on topic. It was a local SF Bay Area station reporting on the House spending cut bill. They way they put it was that the bill would “protect California companies and farmers from environmental and other regulations” …not that it would cut funds for enforcement of environmental and health regulations to protect Americans.
Brilliant, just fucking brilliant.
i would suggest that eveyone go to the “z” peice and speak the truth to “z’s” brand of wingtip licking class defamation, but that would only promote his standing in search engines and he only allows 1 “against” comment per 100 fawning atrocites.baltimore (small b intended) has a size hangup and “z” is one of the closest thing they have to a
celebrityguy who wrote a book that HBO made a semi popular tv show about.The Koch brothers and others of their ilk are tempting fate . They may begin by winning victories against the rest of the human species but based on the numbers , ( no I don’t mean the printed ones on their bank receipts )theirs is a fools errand .
The end result will be their either being taxed to death, having their fortunes confiscated by a irate population that conclude that facts demonstrate that democracy can not exist simultaneously with such disparity of wealth, or far worse for the lot of us .
I’m sorry all that money can not fill the hole in their unhappiness but the rest of us are not to blame. We are in the same boat .
Better stop short than fill to the brim.
Over sharpen the blade, and the edge will soon blunt. Amass a store
of gold and jade, and no one can protect it. Claim wealth and
titles, and disaster will follow.
Tao te ching
What a pity the State Employees do not have an actual friend in the White House–as in FDR’s time.
With friends like Obama–they won’t need any enemies.
Wall Street’s Obama–for the moment–vaguely, rhetorically backs the employees–while urging deep austerity–and all-out assault on ‘entitlements’ for non-Wall Streeters–just like the Establishment GOP that spawned Gov. Walker.
Neither Obama nor his GOP austerity-lovers were so penny-pinching when Wall Street demanded a few trillion more $ than these unionists.
Hmmm…
We’re millions , why is it we care about one man in a building built by slave labor ?
We need to be our own best friends and create a new life outside the one offered through the corporations .
Like exodus without relocating geographically .
Great message at Egyptian rally via twitpic:
“”Egypt Supports Wisconsin
“One World
“One Pain”
It’s all about protecting noble companies from the evil of regulation.
Sorry for the delay. I went to give a heads up to EW.
Anyway, you don’t know the difference at the store. That’s why I say buy local farm raised.
“ALEC.” Almost 70 IQ, drooling-level clever. Don’t these gangster shitheads ever get tired?
That is a classic pic.
That’s really cool.
Thanks.
I can think of several places to post that link . Great picture !
Siun’s upstairs with a Bahrain post.
Thanks PW.
I hope Labor considers framing this as a fight against U.S. tax dollars being spent on goods tainted by child labor.
Apple admits child labor growing problem at its China factories
That would encourage a more general boycott by U.S. consumers.
We desperately need some organization and coordination. It can’t (and shouldn’t) all come from unions, it won’t come from the democratic party or politicians, Acorn is gone, Move-on is milqtoast.
Where do we go to begin organizing? How do we bring this about? Random protests, of any size, won’t change anything. Nor will incessant blogging. Though both are necessary components of a larger strategy.
Ideas?
Someone please explain to me WHY union voters support Republicans and vote for them?
I agree. The electoral process has been completely gamed; the media have been completely purchased. All that is left for the time being is witnessing. It`s like the pre-civil-rights South but now on a national scale.
Per everyone else, thanks.
A progressive Wisconsin blog with which I’m familiar, Milwaukee County First, used the photo in a post. I’m sure other Wisconsin blogs are too. It would be great if the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel would use it, but I won’t hold my breath.
I had hoped FDL would put together a forum to discus all viable means of non violent non cooperation and that that would be a good place to start.
Getting a new blog site is easy but making it popular enough to begin attracking attention would be difficult without the star power .
The best that could happeni is that an established community such as FDL would provide the meeting place online and we can begin actually strategizing .
I send $20/month to FDL.
It starts with information you can trust.
Jane and Marcy have proven time and time again that they can be trusted.
NPR had a Democratic senatorial `refugee` from Wisconsin on this morning. The guy was hopeless. Instead of pounding on the fact that the so-called `deficit`was generated by Walker`s tax gift, he got lost in details about various features of funding pensions. What is it that these guys can`t see the forest for the trees? Not doubting his good will, but he was no nerdy, no one would go on the street for what he was saying. These guys just don`t get it.
Exactly but hey… I’m an optimist .
This is likely to be the best thing that ever happened to democracy in America .
Have you asked them personally and sent the link ?
They have a lot to boycott! (I didn’t even know about the eggs)
This website has a list of Koch products.
But I have a feeling this is a very limited list. For instance, how many generic/house brands of paper towels and napkins are made by them?
Today, the front line in the battle against feudalism is in Madison, Wisconsin. AFAIK, the teaparty rally is scheduled for 3:00 today.
I think all states have local progressive blogs. I think local action is critical, because the primaries are coming up. A lot of states have critical races for the U.S. Senate.
Throughout its history, Jane has exhibited terrific brand discipline. She understands resource allocation and prioritization. She and Marcy are also under enormous pressure from vichy-Dems. They will do anything to make FDL look bad or unreliable.
I find the reflexive “It’s not Egypt.” mantra very curious. By economical standards it isn’t (yet, though the Republicans are very hard at work to make it that way), and nobody made a claim to that effect. But when protesters in Madison are holding up signs that read “Walk like an Egyptian!” that means they are indeed inspired by what they have seen in the Middle East, that they recognized what happened there, and that they feel empowered by it. Maybe that’s the point we should be making because it could reveal that mockery as the whistling in the dark that it is.
when you think of current, widespread anti-government union republican political tactics,
be sure to think of don siegelman.
don siegelman?
yes the former very poular and competent governor of alabama whom karl rove and u.s. attorney leura canary schemed to indict and successfully prosecute in a blately political prosecution.
result: severe damage to the democratic party in ala.
connection?
government employee unions have been strong backers over time of democratic causes and candidates. they provide money, campaign workers, and voters.
damaging these unions and freightening their leaders into political neutrality is, i suspect, the over-atching reason so many republican governors are yelling, in unison, “union, union” like “fire, fire”.
one should always assume, until it’s proven otherwise, that any major republican political tactic has as an ulterior motive bringing the republican party closer and closer to complete political dominance in american politics.
PW, I became interested in ALEC a few years ago when Michele Bachmann was still in the State Senate and she attended an ALEC get-together to debate the gay marriage issue. That was her hobbyhorse at the time. Some other Minnesota legislators went I learned and they submitted travel vouchers. So it was paid by the taxpayers. Bachmann did not which led me to believe some right wing lobbying group, like ALEC itself, paid for the trip. (Bachmann is a great user of all expense paid trips to Israel, paid for by pro-Israel lobbying groups).
ALEC meets all the requirements of a “lobbying organization” under Minnesota law but somehow they had been able to wriggle out of this. The State Campaign Finance Board made some determination in 1996 which at that time allowed them to get away with it. I think I know what my new project is going to be if ALEC is still running around pretending it is not a lobbying organization.
the vichy dems are terrified of whats going to happen in 2012. they blame FDL for a lot of those problems. jeez! if we would just stop reading and thinking about stuff!
It actually goes beyond union-busting. And that is the inconvenient truth that Rachel Maddow and Ed Schultz have been pointing out. And it goes beyond the campaign funding of Democratic candidates that has only three big contributors left – AFSCME, SEIU, and NEA. The Kochs are part of a interlocking network of rich conservatives (their Americans for Progress executive is Art Pope of Raleigh NC, whose network includes Civitas, the John Locke foundation, and a bunch of kept McClatchy political pundits. This network swamped the 2010 midterms with post-Citizens United funding, not all of it apparent in the list of largest donors. There were hydra-heads of front groups passing on money from the same people.
The target is clear. Complete control over federal, state, county, and municipal governments of any size and the prevention of alternative voices having an effect on politics. It’s the old “permanent Republican majority” strategy now writ very large. To see the effect on county governments, look at how the infusion of Koch and Pope money that inflated the campaign expenditures of a school board race resulted in the reversal of the desegregation of Wake County NC’s schools. The strategy was to take a low turnout election, swamp it with money, take power and make radical changes that the majority of people had not supported. It is this last item that has made the response in Wisconsin so dramatic; folks who didn’t vote woke up to find out what Walker was doing to their lives.
And the purpose of ALEC is to network these renegade legislatures in a coordinated fashion so that it splits the resources and forces opposing the takeover. So Wisconsin, Michigan, Indiana, and Ohio are coordinated. Similar efforts are going on in the South with North Carolina’s first post-Reconstruction Republican legislature trying to make sweeping changes before anyone finds out. Fortunately, North Carolina’s governor is a Democrat, which slows things down just a bit.
Wisconsin, the most labor-friendly state is the battleground. If progressives (forget the Democrats, they will follow not lead) win a victory in Wisconsin, Ohio, Indiana, Michigan for labor, these things will happen. Other states will be more reluctant to try stripping existing public employee collective bargaining rights. The issue of collective bargaining, what it does, and how it helps workers will be debated in a way that a new post-PATCO generation of workers might become educated about what’s really in their interest. There is a foundation for labor to claw back lost members and extend organizing into the “right-to-work” states. The information plantation of contractors and subcontractors and short-term gigs with little security might be organized. And unions might become the new mechanism for addressing a labor “market” that isn’t, a so-called market that fails to connect jobs with workers and clear the market.
And if lightning strikes and protests force the resignation of Walker and Kasich and diminish Daniels, and if legislators who support these plans are recalled, there is a fundamental momentum to a progressive movement that is more widespread, not connected to any political party’s operations and flexible enough begin to dictate the political environment instead of having to react to it.
What is needed now are large numbers of Wisconsinites supporting the folks in Madison and large numbers of Ohioans supporting the folks in Columbus. By large, we are talking hundreds of thousands.
Here is a more comprehensive list from the facebook page Boycott and Defeat Koch Industries.
When you look at the list you can see that they permeate almost every aspect of our physical lives. It would be damn near impossible to not use their products at all. Which makes me marvel…what more do they need to conquer? And why?
I asked that in the 1980s. Never could get a real good answer, but I believe the “Southern Strategy” went nationwide.
looks like you answered my question @40 while I was writing it. Thanks, TD!
Excellent question, thank you.
I am well known, by my real name and address, as well as a subscriber, to a few reporters and at least one editor. I may copy them on an email of the link to Governor Walker, with whom I have a long history.
The cornerstone of the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel’s news coverage is of Milwaukee County. One of their reporters, Dave Umhoeffer, won a Pulitzer in 2008 for uncovering a pension scandal in which Scott Walker, the county executive of Milwaukee County, was armpit deep. The wingnut state AG blocked further investigation and in keeping with their long-standing support of Walker, the newspaper failed to hold him accountable.
Because the photo was in Milwaukee County First, I’m sure some of the reporters and photographers (all union members) have tried to get their non-union editors publish it.
I’m a long time FDLer, but have been largely absent from the comments for the last few years. I very much appreciate you bringing up this issue.
Because in some cases the Democrats up for election are just as bad or worse.
Case in point, Rahm Emmanuel said ,”F*** the unions” and his boss cut the wages of federal workers(largely union).
ALEC page at old Mediatransparency site.
Grants. Lots of money from Scaife, Coors and the Koch brothers.
Hey, Charles!
I meant to say that Zurawik cites Politifact as if to debunk Ed’s claims. Thanks for the sharp eye!
Yup.
Yup. It’s all workers that are being targeted.
Keep up the good fight Boo .
From a group called Alec Watch: Corporate America’s Trojan Horse in the States
They always have plenty of tax payer $$ for their Corp. cronies. Here in NJ Gov. Christie is also attempting to destroy the Public service Unions with similar tactics. He also just forked over a billion of State tax funds to a JP Morgan owned Casino project here in Atlantic City. Why? because Chris needs Wall st. banks to back him for his 2012 run for the WH.
Thanks for the heads up.
Yup, Koch Brothers in full force. Glad to have been informed of the direct connection through ALEC. The Chicago Tribune has:
Pro-labor protesters at Wisconsin Capitol say they aim to keep peace when tea party arrives which says the anti-protest demonstrators, Tea Party people, have been called into action by “Americans For Prosperity” founded by David Koch and Richard Fink.
http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/local/breaking/sns-ap-us-wisconsin-budget-unions,0,3070407.story
And that supposedly independent and squeaky-clean “research organization” founded and funded and on-the-board-ed by the Koch Brothers, the Cato Institute, has a whole front page cheering the Wisconsin Union Busters, and calling for 1-2-3 More Wisconsins!
http://www.cato.org/
We need a better opposition. There are billions of dollars arrayed against us and all the Lakoff Framing research staff in the country on the other side.
At this point, as a longstanding member, I’m getting a letter ready to the ACLU telling them that their ham-handed individual responses to an injustice here and an overreach there is nothing compared to the massive assault unleashed by the Citizens United proponents that they backed with their amicus curiae.
Walk like an egyptian is the perfect music theme…every movement needs a song.
All the mechanisms of democracy…that insure majority rule, have failed. We really need to continue the pressure…When things like what is happening in Wisconsin occur, they create news…and every time there is news, there is a chance that our message gets out. Yes, it will be spun, but the consistent message, linked with pictures that validate the truth, along with behaving in ways that cannot be judged as “bad” or “dangerous” makes it much harder for them to spin against it.
It’s time for all of us, to “walk like an egyptian”. We really have no more democracy left to lose.
I second that !
Don’t these guys have enough money? They don’t want for anything, ever. What is the point of trying to destroy unions and subsequently millions of lives? How much money do they need?
Don’t know about Zurawik, but I’m convinced most of them are pod people.
Today’s Republican “Union Busting” Party is a direct descendant of another group of Union Busters from 150 years ago, the Confederate slaveowners. And we are seeing the same intensely insane conservative (and traitorous) push today that we saw a century and a half ago, the Busting of the Union of the United States of America.
Republican Tenthers on the state level and a Tea Party Republican-fabricated majority in the U.S. House of Representatives. State Republican Tenthers have been talking up secession from the Union while House Republicans are working on destroying the Union financially (revenue-draining tax cuts coupled with severe program cuts), even threatening to shut-down our government, Busting the Union, if they don’t get their Union Busting legislative agenda rubber-stamped.
And American workers are once again the target. A century and a half ago white southern slaveowners wanted to keep their cheap-labor slave culture so they tried to Bust the Union by seceding from the United States of America. They failed…then…but morphed later into the Robber Barons (similar cheap-labor lovers), and still later into those (similar anti-regulatory cheap-labor lovers) who tried to assassinate President Franklin Delano Roosevelt over his New Deal policies, and still later yet into today’s anti-regulatory cheap-labor Republican Party leaders and millionaire-billionaire financial backers, almost all of whom are white, with an odd Clarence Thomas or two thrown in.
The U.S. Chamber of Commerce = outsourcing jobs = Union Busting = anti-regulatory cheap-labor lovers = traitors to our democracy. The billionaire Koch brothers = anti-regulatory cheap-labor lovers = Union Busting = traitors to our democracy. Fox “Big Lie” News = propagandists for the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and billionaire Koch brothers (and Rupert Murdoch) = Union Busting = traitors to our democracy. Republican state governors = calling for secession = Union Busting = traitors to our democracy. Hardcore right-wing religious fundamentalists (the American Taliban) = calling for the enslavement of women’s bodies to their sharia-like religious ideology = Union Busting = traitors to our democracy.
This traitorous conservative pattern is plain to see. The “Civil War” has never ended. Conservative whites with a slaveowner mentality (with financial backing from Union Busting Wall Street corporations and John Bircher billionaires like the Union Busting Koch brothers) want to enslave all the rest of us, turning America into a conservative bastion of intolerance (at least intolerance for anything liberal), transforming America into a white totalitarian-run, white authoritarian-controlled society, similar to what blacks faced 150 years ago in the Confederate South. And there is no defining Mason-Dixon Line to be crossed, because these conservative traitors have spread out and infiltrated all levels of our government and society across America. What is happening in Wisconsin is just one of many skirmishes between the forces of darkness (Gov. Walker and his Union Busting anti-regulatory cheap-labor arch-conservative agenda) and the forces of light (all the American workers, public and private, young and old, men and women, all races, all colors, who don’t want to be treated like blacks in the old Confederate South were treated). Hopefully, all the Wisconsin Senate Democrats stand firm and don’t let the Union Busting conservatives get their way, refusing to let the forces of conservative darkness Bust the Unions in Wisconsin, because this conservative, traitorous, anti-American darkness will spread even further than it already has…and the Southern slaveowners (and their ideological progeny) will have won after all these years of lurking in the shadows, scheming, plotting, frothing at the mouth.
Hey, I understand Egyptians are demonstrating in support of workers in Wisconsin! If those good people get even half a chance, they will be one hell of a great nation.
From Chinatown:
Gittes: How much are you worth?
Cross: I’ve no idea. How much do you want?
Gittes: I just want to know what you’re worth. Over ten million?
Cross: Oh my, yes!
Gittes: Why are you doing it? How much better can you eat? What can you
buy that you can’t already afford?
Cross: The future, Mr. Gits – the future!
Thanks for the image.
I hear you. At Talking Points Memo, the 5th column Dems refer to anyone not taking their “we’ll settle for whatever’s on offer” line as “Firebaggers” and Jane takes on the role of their Emmanuel Goldstein. I guess once one has decided to settle, it becomes de rigeur to resent those who haven’t.
Remember Kos (on Countdown w/O’Donnell sitting in) calling for Kucinich to be primaried for not initially buckling on HC?
cwindog@64
josh marshall, in my view, was paid off in april 2008 with the promise of a whitehouse press pass.
if i recall correctly, TPM later received that whitehouse press pass.
now, their faustian bargain requires them to work the streets of journalism to keep that pass.
there’s a word for businessmen-journalists like josh marshall.**
**hint: it is not “journalist”.