Fox News.com contributor Richard Benedetto thinks Dana Milbank’s February moratorium on Sarah Palin betrays the noble ideals of journalism.
Let me repeat that. FOX NEWS.COM CONTRIBUTOR Richard Benedetto thinks Dana Milbank’s February moratorium on Sarah Palin betrays the noble ideals of journalism.
Yeah:
Holding back information is the antithesis of what journalism is all about. Declaring a blanket moratorium on mentioning a certain newsmaker falls under the definition of censorship.
In Dean Clark parlance, let the ideas — all ideas — compete freely and openly. The best ones will eventually win. But singling out someone for non-coverage because we don’t like them or don’t agree with their views violates that basic tenet, whether it is conservative Palin or some outspoken figures on the liberal left such as Michael Moore or Al Sharpton.
Culled entirely from links surrounding his op-ed, here are some things currently winning the glorious competition of ideas Benedetto thinks we have going on right now:
Gays Escalate Assault on Chick-Fil-A
A Nice, Wholesome Hooters Girl for the Kids
A scantily clad waitress role model, gays besieging fast food, and Dana Perino refusing to believe that the president’s just not that into her. Those don’t constitute the antithesis of what journalism is all about. Those are fine. What will cause the entire structure of the world to cave in on itself is Dana Milbank deciding not to breathlessly quote whatever ill-spelt nonsense Sarah Palin regurgitates into the chirping mouths of her Twitter followers. THAT is a bridge too far.
Benedetto seems to believe that he and his fellow Fox-bots have jobs because their ideas won a free and fair competition for people’s attention. Because if journalism is a meritocracy, in which only the best ideas get a hearing, and he’s getting a hearing, well, then his ideas must be the best! And Dana Milbank must not be allowed to question the formula lest it flatten the whole house of cards.
For what it’s worth, I actually appreciate Milbank’s acknowledgment, entirely too rare in journalism, that the choices journalists make about which stories to cover are just that: choices. That those choices set an agenda and direct the public conversation and those who have a large microphone do, in fact, have influence and can make decisions about how to use it.
However, Milbank’s moratorium comes across overall as just a blatant, link-whoring attempt to get anybody alive right now to give a tinker’s curse what Dana Milbank thinks. American journalism would be much better served by other types of self-policing, like a ban on round-the-clock weather coverage every time there’s an inch of snow in Chicago.
What would YOU like to see a news moratorium on?
A.
[Ed. Note: Please welcome Allison to the FDL family. You may know her as Athenae. Watertiger will be taking a break from her weekly Late Night slot, but assures us that she will be back and has helped us to convince Allison to pick up the Monday Late Night slot.]




210 Comments












Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
So Sarah, Plain and Silly (a/k/a Bible Spice, Caribou Barbie) is now a newsmaker? How the mighty have fallen!
Hi everybody. *waves* I brought some scotch. And some patchouli oil. I hear you hippies are into that.
A.
Oh, and I think a news moratorium on the whole ReGooplican Party would be a Good Thing.
Milbank…
Fox…
Palin…
Hey, Allison!
Hold the patchouli, but I might be convinced to have a scotch…
ATHENAE!
where are the ferrets?
Athenae!
Welcome to Late night! I want a ban on all Fox News reporting. It causes brain damage.
Can’t have a news moratorium on Faux News (Real Noise), because that would be meta-news moratorium. That’s like asking the Genie in the lamp for 3 more wishes as your first wish. Or last, for that matter.
Seconded.
Or at least John McCain.
If I never heard the name Michelle Bachmann again I’d be a happy, happy woman…
And Elliott is right — we need MOAR FERRETS!
Welcome, Athenae! So great to see you here!
I would rather drink the patchouli. A little Irish on the other hand….
Ferrets? If Athenae has ferrets, she needs to be reading Get Fuzzy. There’s a big conflict between Bucky T. Katt and Fungo Rodriguez-the-Ferret.
Welcome to the Lake, Allison, and thanks for the scotch.
Could we please have a news moratorium on the Bush family? Yet another generation crawling out from under a rock today…
The ferrets are presently freaking out at the snow here. According to the newscasts, we are all going to die. I have stocked up on booze and flour, so if anyone needs to barter for those items, take a number.
A.
McCain’s not enough. I can’t stand to hear Tracks o’ My Tears Boehner for at least the next six months.
And speaking of news being embargoed by others, Egypt is sure turning into a s*** sandwich. Hosni has apparently lost his diplomatese-to-Arabic dictionary.
A. Since a moratorium on Palin has already been taken, I think I’d like to see a moratorium on the sports world gushing over Michael Vick. The man is loathsome and for a bunch of people who claim to want wholesome heroes for kids to look up to, they sure seem to be giving this dog torturing, unrepentant jerk a free pass because he apparently has some measure of athletic talent.
Ewwww. Just when you thought it was safe to go rock-hounding…
That’s two of the basic food groups. Do you have caffeine, artificial sweeteners and preservatives and chocolate covered too?
the grown-ups left the newsroom long ago.
If I could find some single-malt Irish whiskeys I might get converted. Blends are mehhh.
Amen. I was so relieved when the Pack knocked them off. And not just because I hate the Eagles.
I’m partial to Canadian Rye…! ;-)
Aloha, Athenae…! A delight to see you here…! *g*
I wouldn’t object to a moratorium on all sports news. True, it would force network affiliates to find other content for about half of their nightly news broadcast, but tough cheese.
Hi Athenea!
After watching our MSM for the past week and comparing it to Al Jazera coverage, I think we need a moratorium on American Broadcast Nooze services.
They are a piece of SheeeIt!
Ain’t that covered by a general moratorium on ReGooplicans? Which new Bush crawled out from under a rock?
Canadian Rye is good as well. Not as good as Irish, however.
I could live with that. Quite happily.
Barbara Jr. pulled a Meghan McCain and spoke out in favor of marriage equality.
What BC said.
And make mine a double — double welcome and double scotch.
Then if you could be so kind as to remove RC scold/apologist/fearmonger Bill Donohue from the news, I would be eternally grateful.
You know, I just wish the Vick coverage (and sports coverage in general) would acknowledge that plenty of people who are good at their jobs are total fucking assholes. I wish our sportotainment media complex could give people credit for understanding that because I think most of America could make that leap. We’ve all worked with at least one person in our lives who we wouldn’t throw a rope to if he was drowning but can find a professional use for.
A.
Ditto.
That’s covered under the blind pig principle. Accidents happen, blind pigs find acorns now and again…
The way Ed Schultz and so many others in regular cable news fell all over themselves justifying having a man crush on Vick by saying “he’s done his time” was disgusting. And Sorry, my opinion of Whoopi Goldberg suffered mightily when she leaped to his defense. I’ll never see her in the same light again.
One of the twins is reportedly breaking from Dear ol’ Daddy W and will appear in a video supporting same sex marriage. While that could be admirable, coming from that family it’s just far too little and too late given the damage they have done to the LBGT community.
Seconded, happily.
Can we put him into an isolation chamber with Bill Bennett? And as long as were consolidating scolds, I suppose Beckerhead ought to go in there too.
Hear! Hear! The just don’t seem able to separate talent from general assholiness. Because somebody’s talented at playing a game, they must be a wonderful person thereby. Classic conservative thought. No nuance. No room for disagreement.
Not to mention the rest of the country. Nothing any of them ever do from now on to eternity will make up for that.
Yeah, I’m not really sure what it is about Vick’s story that I’m supposed to be inspired by. He’s a lucky, lucky bastard who would be nowhere if he couldn’t play football.
No kidding.
Ed’s a former NFL jock, and he’s got a man-crush on anybody who’s played in the NFL. Ed starts talking football, I start looking for something to help me ignore him. If you listen to Ed, it’s going to happen occasionally.
They have damaged every community across the WORLD! Are they still talking putting Jeb up for Preznit III?
Ooooooo! Tag team Thunderdome Death Match among the religious fanatics!
Yep. NotJenna was well known around UT as the smarter, more compassionate of the sisters while they were attending college there. It’s important to note that is an extremely low hurdle though.
How about a media blackout of Breitbart and all his evil little minions?
Who would be still in JAIL if he couldn’t play football!
Why we give these sports/famous people a break in the law is just ridiculous.
Conservatives don’t do nuance.
I tried to explain Manichaeanism to one, and they just insisted that the Universe was black v. white, good v. evil, etc.
And it re-enforces the lesson for kids that if you are good at sports, you can pretty much do any fucking thing you want and people will forgive you and worship you.
Oh Gawd…! Well, at least some of the vermin spawn ain’t as addled with the Kool Aid as their forbears…!
Come to think of it, maybe if all of them (down to the 13th cousins 15 times removed) volunteer for the first (one way) manned mission to Pluto.
And they hate Ren and Stimpy!
Ha! Sounds like politicians.
I’m baffled by the people who seem so convinced that he’s a legitimate candidate for 2012 or 2016. I think a Nixon would have a better chance of getting elected than a Bush after the way Dubya fucked this country up.
Three Persons enter! One God leaves!
Welcome Allison: that post is loaded with people who need to be ignored.
For my part, I intend to totally ignore the American Enterprise Institute’s pretend scholar Peter Wallison for the rest of my life, starting with tomorrow’s book salon.
Actually, Kelly, I suspect that if he had not been a wealthy NFLer he might not have done any time at all. Dog fighting is way more expensive than cock fighting, and cock fighting is not an inexpensive past time.
LMAO!
True. It only means that you are marginally sentient and not a total sociopath.
I stopped listening to Ed about the time he decided Vick was an okay guy after all.
Oh no way in HELL do the Bushes get to go into space. What if they’re the first humans the Cylons or Klingons or Minbari encounter? We’ll be so SCREWED. Think of our interstellar reputations!
I say we just shoot a couple dozen copies of Jimmy Carter’s books into space with a note that says, “We tried, honest.”
A.
What rolls down stairs,
Alone or in pairs,
Runs over the neighbor’s dog?
Impunity, I hates it. It’s the opposite of accountability and rule of law, and it’s a huge part of what’s wrong with this country right now.
My very first posts here at FDL were about the importance of accountability and how its mechanisms (media, elections, judiciary) had completely broken down.
Yeah, but Beck, Rush, etc have had two full years to change that history. Now sheeples think it was O that did all fuckups.
Welcome to firedoglake, Allison. We do indeed like pachouli…
I would like to see jounalistic moratoriums on:
I think the world could do with a whole lot less Pat Robertson…!
Like being less crazy than Jeffrey Dahmer…
What’s great for a snack
and fits on your back
it’s log, log, log
We have a whole lot less of Rev. Falwell now. Whaddaya want?
LOL!
Oh, definitely. Nothing the man says should qualify as news–we’ve heard it all before.
Less Pat Buchanan too.
Mine too!
There can’t be little enough Pat Buchanan.
Seconded.
Ooooo! That innovation minded, great inventor Bill Gates is on Charlie Rose tonight.
We should all watch as he talks about privatization of schools and why Americans have all become dumb as dirt!
You know who else I wouldn’t mind seeing a moratorium on? George…Fucking…Will.
I feel bad now. I think my first diary here ever was about people injecting their personal opinions into science and thinking they were relevant in that context. Though I guess that could have sorta been considered accountability.
Peg, Ed had Col. Wilkerson on tonite and Larry delivered a blistering critique of our ME policy…! It was breathtakingly frank with no holds barred whatsoever…! ;-)
The only thing Bill Gates is good for is taking a Belgian pie in the face.
If journalism is a meritocracy, why is alJazeera not on every cheap cable package, why do their reporters get killed and imprisoned at higher rates than any other network?
LOL! How about 6 to 9 monther Friedman?
Unfortunately he’s very serious and therefore must have his propaganda catapulted.
It’s log, it’s log,
It’s big, it’s heavy, it’s wood!
It’s log, it’s log,
It’s better than bad,
It’s GOOD!!
The fact that people continue to invite John McCain on their shows like he’s the Shadow President blows my mind. Anybody remember when John Kerry was treated like that? Anybody?
*crickets*
A.
How about a 6 to 9 month moratorium for him?
I’ve replaced my MSNBC bookmark with Al Jazeera. I had forgotten what journalism looked like.
Yes, we definitely have to add McStinky to the list.
If McCain hadn’t convinced me of his unsuitability for the Oval Office before the 2008 election, he’s certainly done so since then. What an asshole.
Great Idea! In the cell next to Manning will do!
I remember when Joe Lieberman was!
George Will didn’t get tenure at Michigan State. They were way ahead of the curve…
Everyone wants a log
you’re gonna love a log
Come on and get your log
Everyone needs a log
Log! From BLAM-O!
Speaking of useless billionaires, I would be quite delighted if Pete Peterson and Michael Bloomfield were disappeared.
And the Kochs. Although excessive media coverage is not exactly the problem there.
Rapture up the Koch Brothers!
I was kinda hoping that he and Will and Judith Miller and every other fucking “journalist” who shilled for war would be forced to live out their lives in exile in Dubai. It would give me a great deal of pleasure to contemplate the irony of those people living under Sharia.
I can’t remember any Democrat treated like that and I was born in the Truman administration.
And give me their shit. Heck, I take 1/100th and be ecstatic.
God, how I’d love to never gaze upon Lieberdweeb’s smug, whiny countenance again.
Lieberman, and any other Democrat willing to throw progressives under the bus.
Pinky, are you pondering what I’m pondering?
Me too, but Dubai is too westernized. They look the other way at all the foreigners coming in. Pick another homebase for them.
They should have to work in the orphanages in Irak until the last kid gets through college.
And sleep with the goats.
Yep. Doesn’t happen. Allison is spot on though. Every week, there’s McCain second guessing every decision, every piece of legislation and telling us how he would have done it differently, if only…..
Lieberman is NOT a Democrat, even if the idiots let him hang out with them.
That’s pretty greedy… I’d take 1% of this year’s net.
David Broder
Maureen Dowd
Thomas Friedman
William Kristol
why?
Hey! I wanna be Brain!
Democrats do tend to pretend like their losing presidential candidates no longer exist. Republicans, they just wait a few years and then run them again like nothing ever happened.
A.
Somalia.
Whew! Margaret, Kelly has got the place!
Yes, but where will we find a boomerang and a trampoline at this hour?
I really like Kelly’s idea @106. Either that or Afghanistan.
we’d been collectively stupid enough to elect him.
Any speculation on what the hypothetical Preznit McCain would do with the s*** sandwich that used be called Egypt?
As if the man had even two functioning brain cells.
It’s always 5 PM someplace, Pinky…
Pfft! His answer for everything is to invade and impose our (exceptional) will upon those ungrateful people.
On edit: Though two years in he might be running low on troops, being at war with everybody from Afghanistan to Zimbabwe.
They don’t even seem to wait anymore. Most of the 2008 primary slate have just run continuously. (See Also: Mitt Romney, Mike Huckabee…)
That or bomb, bomb, bomb it back into the stone age.
In other words, he can always take a bad situation and make it worse.
Drill, baby, Drill!
Hey, Dr. D. How much snow are you all ‘specting out of this mess?
Well, you have to admit that with the brain trust the Goopers have now the field of at least marginally presentable candidates is pretty damned small.
Oops. Dr. Dick has that one at 122.
That takes talent and motivation. Look at his success on the Forrestal…
Democrats want to fall in love. Republicans want to fall in line.
Excluding, of course, Israel.
He is the anti-Mary Tyler Moore:
“Who can take a nothing day,
and suddenly make it all seem worthwhile?”
No doubt.
Allison…would Benedetto feel so strongly about freeedom of expression as far as Assange and Wikileaks? They are all so double speak on MSM.
He was most lucky that his daddy and grand-daddy were both Admirals of the Ocean Sea.
Because if he’d been the son of a retired Chief Petty Officer, his ass would have been grass.
Who said they are looking for a presentable candidate? They just want one you’d like to have a beer with and that’s not going to be Huntsman – he a Mormon.
It already passed through and we got about 6 inches. Bunch of wrecks on the interstate east of here yesterday. Eastern Montana got hit a lot harder. Temps, however are still nose diving. Supposed to get down to -7 tonight and tomorrow night with a high of 10 tomorrow.
Plus 5 on that, Kelly.
Yep. Dunno what he would use for the “I”s. I’m guessing either Islam or Io, (those space volcanoes can be very unruly)
True and Huckster is a preacher on the Baptist side. No beer for him.
Fixed it for ya.
Yep. Sorta leaves Mittens out too.
In this case, “presentable” means not frothing at the mouth crazy or dumber than a rock.
Weeee!
And holy shit, it’s so fricking cold here, and getting colder.
Tomorrow’s HIGH in Denver will be -1. Tonight about -7, wind chill somewhere between -15, -20.
[ditch this wine, make me a toddy!]
We’re supposed to get some snow at the high elevations tonight, moving down to us in the afternoon. I just wish I knew if the number is 1 (inch) or 8. If it’s 1, no big deal. If it’s 8, they may shut southern NM down.
Mrs. Dr. BC has already cancelled tomorrow’s class meeting and told the kids they’d be video conferencing. I’m glad she’s smart enough to stay off a sheet of solid ice.
That clears most of the field then. Let’s bring back Thompson – I want to see how the “twins” are doing. :)
That would be proof positive that all is well with the dharmic scales of justice…! ;-)
Like another ne’er-do-well son I could think of…
Further repairs were in order.
Actually, a fair number of scions of high-ranking NCOs end up in the academies. On the other hand, I don’t know what McSame’s application packet looked like. If it was anything like W’s, yeah, the rewrite is appropriate.
Oh boy. We’re in for another round of morons insisting weather and climate are synonymous. I hate cold snaps.
LMAO! Touche’
I’m not sure about inflicting McCain on the orphans. Don’t you think they’ve had enough pain in their lives?
I knew people who served with him. The only reason they had him flying A-4s is because they are practically impossible to crash, yet McCain, overachiever that he is, managed four times I think.
This is going to be an interesting primary season. The Teabagger/Talibangelicals are feeling their oats and the corporatists are fighting to retain control. The old guard knows that the teabagger candidates are unelectable at the national level, but the base will not go for anybody who can. You are starting to see the same dynamic play out in the House. I could almost feel sorry for Boehner. Almost.
People who can’t tell the difference between point data and a trend should just shut the hell up.
I’d appreciate a media moratorium on Dick Cheney’s creepy daughter.
I have a friend who was a Navy pilot. He loved the A-4 above everything the Navy owned. He said it was a pure joy to fly.
Read today that the baggers are looking for someone to primary Scott Brown. Doesn’t take them long to become cannibals.
Doesn’t bode well for the Rethugs’ electoral future, does it? WHat a pity.
It’s exasperating and infuriating and several other multi-syllable words that they don’t stand a chance of understanding.
Whatever might happen to Tracks o’ My Tears isn’t going to be nearly enough by half.
It’s a very forgiving airframe. I think primarily because of the KISS principle. Pain in the ass to roll an engine though. You have to break the aircraft in half to replace it.
And Tom Friedman, David Brooks and George Will.
A typical Republican, consistently failing upward.
That might mean that the three sane Republicans left in Massachusetts might be able to elect a sane candidate, doesn’t it?
They were born cannibals.
It’s not really about freedom of expression. It’s about bedrock conviction that if his ideas are getting heard, it’s because they’re the best. So much of what these guys are about is wish fulfillment.
Thanks for all the warm welcomes, guys!
A.
Same thing for the DC-3 (C-47). If I were wealthy and could afford a personal airplane, I’d have a DC-3.
We’ll get ya to at least 200 tonight, Allison.
True. Sow the wind ….
Actually, I think in McCain’s case it was definitely failing downward. And not softly, either.
‘Baggers are so incredibly stupid. Scott Brown isn’t wingnutty enough for them but the only reason he won was because Coakley was the shittiest candidate since Yosemite Sam and that was a squeaker but they think Massachusetts is going to elect somebody more right wing?
I’d love a C-47 myself. :)
They are totally delusional. They really believe that they are the majority in America.
I was ready for a LeBron-ectomy last summer.
They were still being used for passenger runs in South America until a few years ago. They’re still being used for cargo runs… re-engined with turboprops in some cases (boo!)
I don’t know if that’s it or it’s more like they honestly feel that their opinions are more important than everybody else’s and they should therefore be the ones most listened to. Unfortunately the news media tends to fuel that perception.
Yep. It’s all so “Crouching Teabag – Hidden Banker” with them.
Bible Spice keeps telling them they are the majority. She couldn’t say that if it wasn’t true, could she?
M’eh. I wouldn’t boo the much more reliable turboprops. Fewer moving parts than a reciprocating engine. By a lot!
Alright, fair enough… But they still have to sleep with the goats…! ;-)
Based on personal observation, I would venture to say that she could not say it if it actually were true.
Bible Spice thinks that book she continually thumps but doesn’t know the contents of is true. She has no credibility with me but I’m just a dirty fucking hippie.
Love that! I think I’ll steal it.
A gift to you!
LOL
OK. I need to toddle off. Those young minds need corrupting again in the morning and I am the one to do it. Take care all.
Plus the reciprocating engines need very highly refined avgas but you can burn just about anything in the turboprops. Less flammable and much less expensive.
Night DrD!
I know, I know, I know. But they don’t sound like a radial engine, and that will always be (for me) the sound of freedom.
Good night, Dr. D.
Awww! Thank you. Now I won’t feel guilty when I use it. :)
They do in the movie “Airplane!”.
That I can go along with.
ROFL, I had forgotten about that. The first time I saw Airplane!, it took until the third or fourth external flying plane scene before I could figure out what the cognitive dissonance was. Then I started laughing, and my date was, “What?!? What’s so funny!”
It’s getting a bit late for me too. Though I sadly don’t have any young minds to corrupt, perhaps I can scandalize a few people in some small way tomorrow. Oya koinu.
I saw it with the rest of my family in the room and my dad and I looked at each other and busted out laughing. Nobody else got it until we explained it.
Aloha, Athenae…!
Pleasant Dreams, Peg and Dr. D…!
Have you tried the brownie recipe in the credits?
Good night, Margaret. Happy scandalization.
It’s TOKLAS’S! LMAO!
Is it really? I haven’t seen the movie in ages, and just remembered that there is a brownie recipe in the credits…
JournalMalism is what rules the beltway.
I tried to do a bit of journalism with my story “Guns Outlawed At Palin Speaking Engagements”
An actual researched news story proving that Palin only speaks in venues where no guns are allowed, even at a hunting convention. But the media covering the story didn’t bother to mention that part.
They wrote
Fox News:
Palin Knocks ‘em Dead in Speech to Safari Club International
No insensitivity there!
Nor here
Newsweek:
Palin Kills It in Gun Country
Yep, journalism is out journalmalism is in.
‘journalmalism’
Pretty good word.
Well, it’s time for me to crawl between the sheets. Good night folks.
Well, to be fair, as a FOX contributor, he should be experienced and well-qualified in betraying the noble ideals of journalism.
CTuttle is upstairs!
Late, Late Night FDL: Democracy
Excellent!
welcome, Athenae!
I resemble that remark.
Tommy