Pollock's "The Deep"
I caught sight of my reflection
I caught it in the window
I saw the darkness in my heart
I saw the signs of my undoing
They had been there from the start
So many American bodies are sprayed with blood, their own, their lover’s, their mother’s and father’s, their brother’s and sister’s. Oh we are so certain of our innocence, but we are a nation tattooed in crimson, eyes to belly, with Jackson Pollock’s The Deep.
We called it a New World then carved a Trail of Tears for those who knew it to be ancient: the Choctaw, the Cherokee, the Seminole. And now we walk that Trail ourselves, lost and tormented, crying for Gabrielle Giffords, U.S. Judge John Roll and the other victims of the Tucson shootings.
The “Rawhide Orator,” Choctaw Chief George Washington Harkins, in 1831 wrote to the American people before leaving for the Trail of Tears:
I could cheerfully hope, that those of another age and generation may not feel the effects of those oppressive measures that have been so illiberally dealt out to us; and that peace and happiness may be their reward.
A cheerful hope, and one unfulfilled, as the ghosts of dead immigrants whisper to us from the Arizona desert.
Within a few short hours of Saturday’s shootings, pundits and politicians were decrying the violent political rhetoric and symbolism that feeds the fires of hell. The conversations could have – and should have – taken place long before Saturday. They all knew what was coming.
And the darkness still has work to do
The knotted chord’s untying
The heated and the holy
Oh they’re sitting there on high
So secure with everything they’re buying
Just Friday I did an interview with Thorne Dreyer of Texas’ The Rag Blog and Austin’s KOOP-FM in which I warned again of our escalating political violence and compared our era to the years preceding the Civil War. Gods, I should have prayed hard to be wrong.
Gabrielle, you are named for the angel who foretold the coming of eternal peace. In your remarkable March, 2010 MSNBC interview following the vandalism of your office, you saw a different future:
They really do need to realize that their rhetoric and firing people up and even things for example where on Sarah Palin’s targeted list…the way she has it depicted, it has the crosshairs of a gun sight over our district. When people do that they have to realize there are consequences to that action.
What haunts us is not a momentary collapse of good manners. We have spoken often here about the loss of sociality in the public sphere. It is a fact that many in power have very consciously promoted hatred and violence. I suppose they meant it poetically. They will all plead innocence now and wear modest garlands of grace about them. It’s a thin disguise.
My grip is surely slipping
I think I’ve lost my hold
Yes I think I’ve lost my hold
I cannot get insurance any more
They don’t take credit, only gold
Is that a dagger or a crucifix I see
You hold so tightly in your hand
And all the while the distance grows between you and me
I do not understand
We are a polarized people, and violence races like a water snake through the river of our history. We are attracted to those who kill for their prejudices or beliefs. But as John Wayne’s Ethan Edwards discovered in The Searchers, such is the path to the death of the soul.
And it does not need to be this way. Our greatness lies less in violent victories than in moments of democratic transcendence, from the Bill of Rights to women’s suffrage. We are linked to one another, like it or not. When one falls to the bloody ground, so will the other.
This is not a game. It is a great struggle for human freedom and peace, and we can no longer tolerate the cowardly murderers who stir the beasts in us for a few gold coins. Pilate’s hands, they may be reminded, have not yet been washed.
At my request you take me in
In that tenderness I am floating away
No certainty, nothing to rely on
Holding still for a moment
What a moment this is
Oh for a moment of forgetting
A moment of bliss
Oh….
As it happens, as the shots were fired in Tucson we were safe and unaware in our home, holding still in a moment of forgetting and bliss, as the song says. And I’m reminded that we must make of love not a refuge from the world but the world itself, and that will be the end of forgetting.
I can hear the distant thunder
Of a million unheard souls
Of a million unheard souls
Watch each one reach for creature comfort
For the filling of their holes
One another to hold — that is all we are given in this life, and I mean that with a fierceness that ought to set the violent to wondering. And we’ll hold them tenderly, too, because if we’re to love we must acknowledge and extinguish the fear that can twist the hearts of those who very briefly share this place with us.
In the blood of Eden we have done everything we can
In the blood of Eden, so we end as we began
With the man in the woman and the woman in the man
It was all for the union, oh the union of the woman, the woman and the man




71 Comments












Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
I wonder if AZ will pay if any of today’s shooting victim’s need an organ transplant?
I want to be able to get basic cable without having to pay for Hate TV like Glen Beck. I don’t want any of my cash to go supporting a guy who jokes on tv about poisoning Nancy Pelosi.
I don’t want to buy anything advertised on Sarah’s tv show when her website had a bullseye on Gabby’s face.
If you support Free Markets then I want the Freedom to chose who I give my money to people who incite Murder should have their FCC broadcast license pulled.
If the government won’t do it then let us do it.
AZ needs to get its act together housing values in AZ will keep going down if they don’t. They already scared off the illegals, anybody who might need an organ donation older people fit that category they won’t be looking to buy homes there either.
Now parents with kids who like going to the mall won’t want to buy especially if the police can’t catch the Murderer’s friend.
Its time for America to realize that hate speech and lies affect them because as the Tea Bagger shoot immigrants and Democrats their kids will get caught in the crossfire.
By helping others by defending other’s rights you help yourself. You defend your own rights.
True isn’t it. By helping others you help yourself.
Nope no way Jan says so… ya know the Gov who thinks she is God!!
Great Post Glenn as always.
We Must have the “Fairness Doctrine ” Brought back to Our air waves and get the Hate Messengers OFF the Air!! After all the People do own the airways and the hate purveyors just lease them from us. Just another area where St Ronnie opened the door to this spewing of hate and the slow decline of our nation..
As long as they’re not on Medicaid and have great health insurance.
I love Peter Gabriel. But I’m not going to sit like a lamb if the civil war starts. The liberals have been way too passive.
where’s the old SDS fervor or even the civil rights fervor?.
I don’t WANT to be afraid of people who hold different views, but some really ARE fearful creatures. And to pretend they are not dangerously deluded is to ignore the gods-given instincts I was born with.
Our supposed “government” isn’t going to do an thing because US divided is exactly what they want.
The only “sin” is to not defend yourself or the innocent” – Dean Knootz
Repeal of the Fairness Doctrine has been a catastrophe. Restoration of something like it is essential. But more essential is to transform the character of those who would breach such a barrier to preach hate.
I call the passivity docilism, and it is as dangerous as the violence itself. The hate language is intended to demoralize and pacify, and the first step in defeating it is to refuse its goals. Doesn’t mean we escalate the violence. Martin Luther King Jr. showed us a way to confront violence peacefully, morally, effectively.
Dean Koontz….sorry
That to Glenn. But they will fight you tooth and nail as Hate Speech is their Golden Goose! And of course they will scream 1st amendment 1st amendment. But hey if the people own the airways then we surely can regulate them to remove that kind od speech or maybe hold them accountable for such speech, make it expensive to do it..
Yes, but it was the Black Panthers that really got them nervous enough to pay attention to King.
I look around and see no one with the guts of the 60′s and 70′s movements today.
Too many are ready to follow the pied pipers over a cliff today
Then we’d better start with the Speaker of the House. Via Brad DeLong:
Timshel, indeed.
Good morning, Glenn. The heart cries and the mind cries out for justice. Maybe, just maybe, the murder of a nine year old girl will reach some of the spewers of hate and cause them to tone down what they call “free speech.” They think that they have the right to free speech but that we don’t. I imagine they are about to learn that we all have it. I say that we should go straight at them and condemn them in every way possible….every day.
People only transform their characters after intensive self searching. And that can only begin when a problem is recognized in the first place.
Our government made a Faustian bargain a long time ago. Now it’s a question of whether America will survive at all, in any form, except as the military arm of The New World Order
One part of the narrative that needs changing: the false assertion that both left and right have engaged in equal levels of violence. Virtually all political violence in this country has emerged from the right. There are exceptions, but they prove the rule. The Weather Underground was ridiculous. The Panthers used the threat of violence to guard their neighborhoods. And, certainly, many grew impatient with King’s non-violence. But he persisted and prevailed.
To take the blind (and safe) approach, as so many pundits do, by condemning all parties they let the truly violent off the hook. Except McKinley (killed by a fringe anarchist who helped destroy the peaceful, social democratic nature of that brief movement) all of our assassins have come from the right. It’s amazing that the country can still shudder at the cultural upheaval of the sixties without noticing that all those assassinated were of the Left.
Sadly, I don’t see the death of Christina Green affecting these people 1 iota. They’ll rationalize the shootings until the sun falls from the sky.
Yes. There is no choice but to “go straight at them” as you say. There’s no room for timidity here. Change is made. We can’t expect even a tragic event to be transformative on its own.
And, already the pundit narrative is shifting to somewhat absolve those responsible for the rising hate.
You know, when the haters use their violent language, they do it hoping for consequences. Then, when the consequences are clearly immoral and tragic, they rush to distance themselves from any consequences whatsoever.
And they will blame us somehow.
However, I keep coming back to King. He was steadfast in holding a moral mirror up the country, and it worked. Minds were changed. We erred by not persisting after his murder. We dropped the moral mirror, and we are now seeing the consequences of resurgent bigotry and hate. But King can still give us hope.
I would add Gandhi’s name to that mix. Rev Dr King was much inspired by Gandhi.
When ever they are confronted with their deeds they always cry foul and say it wasn’t “Their words”!! Ha words do have consequences they always do whether good or bad…
We really need to push back on the pundit bullshit.
Most of the European death camps were constructed and used by right wingers. And don’t let some right winger try to tell you that Stalin was a Leftist man of the people. He was not. He was as right wing as was Mao, Pol Pot or Amin. Peace
AND THE KILLIN’ GOEZ ON AND ON AND…
Citizen Glenn W. Smith:
The saddness in my heart today has extinguished my anger. I have three beautiful children, three amazing grandchildren (so far) and the gift of love and hope from a lifetime soulmate. But the wound I suffer from the experience of war, the smell of blood and fear, these I will carry now to my death.
I have been crying out in the FDL wilderness now for years that the blood born of violence, hatred, fear and ignorance stains our collective history as Americans and has contaminated the planet. I have used the term “fascism” from the beginning to characterize the common boundries of our politics and I have fed from the righteous anger generated by the purposeful murder of the dream that was once America. But after yesterday, I no longer have the strength to fight.
A long time ago, when my son was a year old, I promised him that he and his children would never have to suffer war in the name of American virtue again and that he and his would be free to carry forward the truth and hope of our history. I failed, I could not secure that promise. And now my children and my brothers and sisters on this planet will endure the horror of a darkness that may have no end.
The beast of capitalism and it’s attending furies of terror, fear, suffering and death is upon us and the “terrible swift sword” of righteous vengence that was promised to kill the beast is a myth that is fading with the light of hope.
Now everyone will experience the terrible truth that veterans of war have carried thoughout our history.
You know, if you erase the hate from the Republican message of the last several months, there is no message at all. I mean that seriously and literally. Their entire message is based in hatred, bigotry, and violence.
One way to honor and remember the victims of the violence is to aggressively campaign against the hate message. Without it, the right has nothing.
Very difficult to respond to your honest and hearfelt comment. I can’t disagree, but I can offer hope, if only to suggest that hope is the very thing the other side wants to extinguish. So I choose hope as an act of resistance.
Citizen Glenn W. Smith:
“Republican” is nuthin’ but a terrorist state of mind.
Thanks Glenn. Glad to have you hear reminding us that we have more than condemnation to offer – we have a positive vision of an alternative.
They have always been that way but have grown bolder over the years in their vitriol. And yes they have only the message of “NO” no no and more no.
What has the Republicans ever done to help the working masses in this country except to make their lives more miserable through union busting, lowering the safety nets for those in need and always always helping those in power gain more riches and power…
Hope is great. But non-violent action is better. Peace
Yes we do. And I hope we can open the conversation to more about the character of America and, while aggressively condemning today’s violence and hatred, get people to see the long historical trajectory of those twin evils.
The oligarchy owns the Republican Party lock, stock and barrel. Peace
I’d like to think the postponing of their stupid health care repeal was done to honor the fallen in Arizona. But that’s not it. They do not know how to even debate the issue without the hatred and violence, and they’re smart enough not to do that this week.
That’s my point. Eliminate the violence and they are left with no message at all.
Glenn, you had it right the first time. They do not mean it poetically. To speak the truth about what they are doing, and not let them claim innocence, is one piece of going straight after them.
Exactly right, oregondave.
What say we end the violence in Afghanistan? That might set a good example for all Americans to follow. Peace
That’s exactly the reason they postponed. Cowards that they are.
Norske people like you are the heart of FDL not the fringe:)
Agreed. It is hard to make sense of this sort of thing without remembering the history of private violence used to enforce second class personhood, targeting both those who stand up for their own rights and those elites perceived as standing with them. Reconstruction is an obvious part of this history, but the West in particular has its own parallel history, targeting different Others to similar effects.
Citizen Glenn W. Smith:
The corporate wars have now come home and the response of the government and it’s “security” apparatus will be to smother free speech and assault the victims of this violence as somehow deserving of the fate they have planned for all of us all along . There is a book titled “Friendly Fascism The New Face of Power in America” by Bertram Gross published in 1980 in anticipation of Reagan’s election. Read it and weep for the truth of the end of the American experiment.
From C&L this am: Keith Olberman:
Special Comment: Violence and threats have no place in democracy
But there’s an important clue here, not just to their cowardice. Stripped of the hate, their arguments disappear. It may seem callous to fall so quickly into practical political tactics, but we cannot wait. We have to press now and forcefully.
Which is why I argue for the end of forgetting.
Thanks for this link, nahant.
Right fuckin’ on. Not next week, not tomorrow. Now!
Now! And thanks to FDL for leading the way.
Yeah, now all we have to do is get through to these brain-dead assholes.
Please, no violence as we move forward. Peace
ML King may not have gotten through to them, but he marginalized them and captured the hearts and minds of the nation. Some, I think, are simply lost and overwhelmed by fear. And we can reach them.
I agree TCU, Norski is not the fringe in way or manner… I have always enjoyed reading Norski’s comments and thoughts on our country and politics.
And I totally agree with him that I also thought that my kids and 10 grand kids (I know 10 can’t believe it myself) would have a good shot at a decent life… Now I am not sure at all.
Yes, but your children and grandchildren have the great benefit of your commitment, and that is a model that will last generations. We haven’t changed the world as we’d hoped, but we haven’t given up. And that’s as great a gift as a changed world.
Good luck with that SD with their blinders on and ear plugs in place they will never listen, see the light of peace.. or learn, I hope they carry the guilt of what “They” have wrought to their graves.
I tend to agree Glenn I do. I do know I raised my kids right as I see the fruits of my endeavors in their work of raising their own families and I see their dedication to their kids and all six of them make me proud of them. They are all good hard working citizens and oh by the way they are all on the left. We need them to just be more active…
This is one reason I wrote about the personal/private and public as I did, taking the love in the home outside into the world.
Makes me wonder just how much and what kind of love is in some of those houses.
Good and very disturbing question,SD.
It is a sad fact that when this story fades from the news that the pilots sitting in trailers in AZ will rain down their Hellfire on the people half way around the world. It’s a shame that we can not or will not do what is necessary to stop the violence that is unleashed in the name of American Exceptionalism.
When will we realize that this is just more Collateral Damage from the Perpetual War that we all support directly or indirectly? Some of us may proclaim that we oppose War but we re-elect our Representitives who continue to fund them.
Why is it that we become engaged only when our women and children are killed or maimed when not far from this crime women and children are being killed every day?
I suspect that you and many others here haven’t waited to become engaged. But it is eerie how the media will address these urgent issues today, but in addressing them they make them melt away like snow.
Glenn,
You are on fire with this post. Twain suggested yesterday about keeping after any and all vitriol and expressions of such from the Right.
Now the suggestion in a later comment on this same thread suggests that the R’s postponed all action this week because they could not express their feelings without the hatred intermingling is exactly right.
We do need to hold their feet to the fire and everyday. We need to come together in this community to plan on how to do these actions and then, not just in writing about it here, take the ideas into the community forums and work like the devil for the next two years to show the Republicans for what they really are…NOTHING BUT HATE-MONGERS.
You are exactly right, AC2. We must confront them directly, and we have to take our insights and commitments into our communities. Every conversation we have is important. Thanks so much for your call to action.
We must not drop the ball on this. Though it might sound unfeeling, this is an opportunity to keep saying “Hate Speech Kills Children.” I regret the loss of every life and the wounding of others but killing that lovely child just makes me sick. As the parent of 4 and grandmother of 4, I fell such rage. The politicians will mouth all the right words and most of them could care less – unless it effects them. Well, let’s make sure that it does effect them.
Glenn,
The call to action is yours and every commenter here.
I have such high respect for Norske, Twain, cbl2, Margaret, and the list could go on and on. There are great minds here and I am held in awe of the comments sometimes but it is not enough for us to talk, we need to find a way on this forum to help each other strategize the best ways to bring this together to continue from this day forward confronting those who would spew hatred to get their way.
Edward Teller yesterday if I am correct, wanted to organize a silent protest at Sarah’s house, but it appeared people were too afraid to participate. I admire ET’s courage so we need to take those ideas, share them with FDL and how we can get out and make a big difference here.
FDL and writers like you lead the way and I will soldier on with you.
I am so late to this thread today, but I too wish to thank you Glenn for your words again today.
There are two seeds I see in the comments. First, perhaps we can find a way to say we are not going to pay for hate speech in our TV packages any more. I don’t know how to do this, but a national action to call for people who object to having their dollars go to promoters of hate speech would be a great campaign that would likely have an impact, I believe. Like the war tax that was collected in phone bills of the past, that some of us refused to pay. We will say that in good consceince, we will not pay for it any more.
The other is a national call for action to stand for civility in our common discourse. Pick a day, MLK day would be a good time, there are already a lot of people who have MLK marches, organize it this week.
Bgrothus, both are great suggestions and relatively easy to accomplish. The latter — a public commitment to concord (Aristotle’s term) or comity or civility, and MLK day would be perfect as he set such a profound example.
The boycott of campaign hate spending will be harder to accomplish, but it’s not impossible. We need to pursue that and see what kind of suggestions people have.
I am sure I can participate in locally organizing something for MLK day. Seems like an opportune moment to seize.
Thanks for your support, we can’t give up on getting to a better place.
Great piece, Glenn. Even if I can’t catch it in real-time, I like to track back and see what you wrote. Thank you for sharing here with us.
Thanke you, mzchief, and thanks to the open, thoughtful and powerful fdl community that makes our conversation possible.