Good morning and Happy New Year, everyone!
Remember last week when we learned how to make stock? Today, in honor of the bowl games, we’ll be having a bowl of our own. We’re going to take the stock and make soup with it — creamy mushroom soup, in fact. For you Julia Child fans, the recipe will be quite familiar, as it’s essentially the one in Mastering the Art of French Cooking with a few variations thrown in at whim. This recipe is designed to serve six, so bear that in mind when creating it for smaller or larger audiences. You can start this during the pregame show, check on it during commercial breaks, and serve it up at halftime.
You will need:
Ingredients: Six cups of stock, at least four ounces (one stick or eight tablespoons) of butter, a pound of mushrooms, 1/4 cup of diced onion, three to five tablespoons of flour, a few sprigs of parsley, part of a bay leaf, a pinch or two of thyme, a teaspoon of lemon juice, salt to taste, one pint of heavy cream, and the yolks from two eggs. It will help you a lot to have this all measured and set out before you start cooking.
Tools: Two three-quart or larger kettles or pots, a soup strainer, a small saucepan or frying pan, a knife and cutting board, a soup ladle.
At the start of the pregame show, take the stock (about three ice cube tray’s worth) and set it to boiling. While you wait for it to boil, take the mushrooms and separate the stems from the caps; next, mince the stems almost to a pulp, but merely slice the caps into thin cross-sections. When you’re done with that, chop up the parsley and set it aside; then melt three to five tablespoons of butter in a saucepan and then add in the diced onion. Sauté for about ten minutes or until the onions are translucent but not yet brown, then toss in about three to five tablespoons of flour. Stir while cooking until the flour is well incorporated into the mix, then cook for about three minutes more after that (this is done to eliminate the “floury” taste from what is going to be a thickening agent as well as a flavoring).
By the time you’ve finished cooking what many of you have already recognized as a sort of oniony roux, the stock should be boiling. Turn down the heat, put the roux into the stock and stir until well incorporated. Add in the parsley, thyme, bay leaf, pinch of salt (though if you’re using regular American butter you can omit the salt) and whatever other seasonings you think you’d like in there, and toss in the mushroom stems. Stir well, partially cover and leave it alone on a low heat to simmer for at least twenty minutes (longer if you can manage it — mushroom stems are tough buggers and need a bit of time to be persuaded to surrender their flavors to the soup). This should take you to the end of the first quarter.
During the first-quarter break (or the commercial break immediately after that, if it’s a fast-moving game), strain out the mushroom stems, onions, bay leaf and other solids by pouring the liquid from the one pot to the other; press the collected mushroom and onion bits to retrieve every last drop of juice from them, toss the juice back into the soup, and toss the drained solids into the compost pile. (In the pictured example above, I’ve decided to skip this step and leave in the solids, just for grins.)
Now, per Julia, you should be doing the following step immediately after the last one; but, since we’re timing this to be done at halftime, we can delay it a little bit until about midway to three-quarters of the way through the second quarter. Take the sliced mushroom caps, sauté with two tablespoons butter and the lemon juice for about five minutes, then pour mushrooms, butter and all into the waiting soup and let simmer together for ten minutes. At the last commercial break before halftime, mix the two egg yolks in with the cream, then add hot soup in, a spoonful at a time well stirred, until you have a cup of soupy, eggy, creamy liquid; then turn down the heat so that the soup is almost but not quite simmering, add in the cream-egg mix, and cook for two minutes, being careful not to let the soup simmer.
Turn off the heat, dish up and enjoy the Soup Bowl as a halftime highlight! Bon appetit!




121 Comments





Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Nice, PW.
And here I forgot about those bowl games…too many balls? A bowl of soup..or gruel…. will hit the ol’
spot, however!
Happy New Year, everyone! Coffee’s still hot and we’ve got cream in the fridge.
Hey Kass! How goes it?
H N Y, P Woman
I first misread the title of this thread. Thought it said Looking for Guys. Ha! I was a little perplexed. I thought, Well that’s a new one for the lake.
HI PW….did you notice that PUAC had become a foodie thread at the end? Makes a nice segue!
I never met a mushroom I didn’t like, and I’d love to make this soup, but I live alone and I’m guessing it wouldn’t freeze well??
On edit: I am definitely making this (and bookmarking for later).
Hiya PW.
A friend recently brought me some of her mushroom soup. She used some coconut milk instead of so much stock & butter. Really good.
Well, I could put out an APB for some guys to show up. Look, over there! Heidi Klum!
That’ll get them here right quick.
Actually, you can readily scale it back. I’ve made half-size batches with ease. And you can stop right at the point before adding the cream and freeze all but the part you intend to eat right away.
If you’re “cooking for guys” they’ll show up!
Happy New Year, everyone!
Oooh! It would likely taste very nearly the same, too. Curry with heavy cream tastes a lot like coconut curry.
I’m wondering: How well would it freeze?
Grab a bowl, Dick!
Oh thanks, good idea! I wasn’t sure the mushrooms would freeze very well either, but maybe…
I’ve successfully frozen mushroom soup, so it should work.
Getting to know more about mushrooms is on my list of things to do. I’ve mostly used the white buttons ones, but the supermarket selection has gotten more varied, so raw materials are readily available.
I’ve even made this with morels, in which case I recommend using a very white stock and simmering for at least an hour.
As I said in 14, I’ve frozen soups with cream. Also chicken a la king, which I fancy up by adding some cream.
The only time I’ve used coconut milk is in a recipe for a mild flavored Indian recipe for leftover turkey, which was in the NYT after Tgiving 2009. Yummy.
The soup tasted really buttery, and my friend told me that coconut milk is healthy. If you don’t add Indian or Thai spices, you don’t get that twist on the flavor. I bought some in cans & am going to look for different ways to use it. Apparently you can put it in a whole bunch of different kinds of foods as a substitute for other liquids.
PW, I did not get a chance to tell you how much I enjoyed and learned from your earlier diary. As a non-cook, your conversational style and your play-by-play made the whole enterprise much clearer and inviting. I haven’t read a lot of cooking writing (obviously) but your style really pulled me in to the adventure and enjoyment, which I never anticipate. So thanks for putting all this down.
Why so long to simmer? Aren’t all kinds of mushrooms cooked fairly quickly?
H N Y everyone,
Instructions for men about how to cook was my initial thought.
I’ve never made mushroom soup, but this sounds very good. I’ll be making this sometime soon. Thanks for the recipe. Using some coconut milk might be a good idea for me.
I’m going to try making soup. Have a gift cert. for BB&B – any recommendations on what kind of pot I need (size, material)? Thanks.
PW, Happy New Year!
Thanks for the recipe. I also like to take mushroom soup and slow cook pork in it. Yummm!
I’m sure others will have very good suggestions, but I would suggest an enameled cast-iron pot. They are very heavy, hold heat, clean very easily, and also go in the oven. However, they tend to be expensive and you may catch one on mark down.
Instructions for men?
;)
I love Scanpan cookware. It’s expensive & I think they don’t carry it at BBB. But after buying an initial set online, I wouldn’t go with anything else. It’s nonstick and has a thick bottom, so it’s hard to burn anything. But it also isn’t that heavy, so you don’t have to work out on the the weight machine to cart it around the kitchen. I use one of the large stock pots for soups (don’t know what size without going downstairs to measure & I’m too lazy to do that right now).
My daughter in law, who is a gourmet cook, has several big pots. The one often recommended is pricey — the enamel over cast iron. (LeCrueset, I think.) Just be sure it is big. I tried to make bean soup in my 5-qt crock pot yesterday and had to dump it into my big aluminum pot because it wouldn’t fit in the crock pot.
Morels are so mild, yet their stems and bodies can be so tough, that in my experience they need a bit of extra coaxing to yield up enough flavor sufficient to avoid being overwhelmed even by onions.
See my 25. I find the ones you describe as just being too heavy to be convenient.
Aha, stems are tough. Could you cut them off & “sweat” them before adding to the soup so you don’t end up overcooking everything else?
Ooops, on edit, I see that you say the bodies can also be tough, so forget my comment.
Ugh! Turns out that too much chocolate the night before can leave you just as queasy as too much alcohol the next morning.
Oh, goodie another cooking thread. As the rest of the world starves we all sit around on this 1st day of 2011, telling each other how to best stuff our fat, stupid faces. Peace
Yup!
Kieran, here’s the Le Creuset stock pot selection from BBB.
I do a bit of that as well.
What, I’m gonna be the token dude? But…but I’se already noes how ta cook. I’se southern, single and can’t stand processed food.
Indeed. Have some coffee!
Hey, that means you get all the wimmins to yerself!
You want some cheese with that whine?
Seriously. Get your own blog and you can run it the way you see fit. Peace.
Ooh! I so rarely drink coffee I didn’t think about that. I’ll bet that will settle me right down. Thanks. :)
Good Morning and Happy New Year Phoenix Woman and Firedogs -
wow – this must be a typo ! Le Creuset, 8 qt stockpot for $71
the 6 qt is only $40
No one is twisting your arm to show up on a cooking thread.
And it’s a long-standing human tradition, under all kinds of external circumstances, to look for interesting ways to meet nutritional & social needs.
So if you don’t like it, find a diary that meets your online needs, or a good book to read. Or, get outside & do something about the world starvation that you seem to be so concerned about.
How about some paté? Gives a little body to that cheap ass whine.
Thanks! I always worry that I chat too much, so it’s nice to hear feedback that reinforces my instincts.
Bless you. :-)
By the way, you may soon have incoming from a friend of mine.
I assume you are describing yourself. I like getting tips on cooking those expensive beans and rice and garlic and onions and things that many of us work to produce in our very own gardens. I do hope the rest of your new year is more uplifting than you are sounding this morning.
Not a bad night. I got to see my friend Mark from Nihon but when I started up my car to leave, I noticed I had a headlight out. Made it home without any tickets though. I got out of there before the bars closed and still the first driver I encountered on Bandera was polluted.
As long as it’s the kind that comes out of a can and is labeled “K ration 1943 creamed corn”.
OMG! Yes, it must be a typo! They are usually followed by another zero!
Speaking of good books, I have a new one to start on the new year: Sin Patron.
Fools with handguns in the neighborhood kept me wary all evening. Kept waiting for a stray round to come through one of the windows.
Soup is a very economical and healthy way to feed a family. I see no reason why we can’t share recipes that help out in this low money, no job time. It’s better than eating dirt!
You haven’t finished that yet? Damn, girl, you’ve had 2 whole days. *g*
Oh man I hate that. We had a tiny bit of that last night but the cops were so thick it was much less than last year. I was actually astonished at the lack of fireworks this year. Maybe a quarter what it was last year.
Haven’t started it yet. My friend came over from a whole other continent. The least I could do is put off my reading for a couple of days. :)
apparently not :D, look at the prices on the BBB link PW posted
we only ‘shop’ when it involves one of our kids and man oh man, this is waaaay better than the outlet mall prices
Same boat only in northern waters, well on northern ice at the moment. Absolutely nothing token about your contributions here that I’ve ever seen.
I like my cast iron, but I have wondered if it’ll some day be too much! Until then …
More gunfire than fireworks. Idiots.
Surely you didn’t stop at that outlet in San Marcos? That place is way high.
Yeah, I see that the first one is enameled steel. That is not as good a cook IMO. That heavy cast iron one with the enamel is like the ones that I have. Yes, they are heavy, but OMG can they do an amazing job.
I’ve kind of OD’d on the kinds of books I’ve already bought but haven’t yet read. I’m thinking I might do more fiction this year, but my thoughts haven’t gelled yet.
So far, I find tastes in fiction differ greatly (or at least mine seem to differ from others’), so I’m reluctant to take recommendations.
Typically, if I just collect ideas for awhile, a good one pops up.
I was with drunken pyromaniacs –
Hold Ma Beer, Watch This ! is the Texas state motto afterall :D
Hey I was glad we got some rain and the wind had died down. If that hadn’t happened I wouldn’t have dared left my place last night.
Try His Dark Materials by Pullman. I can’t recommend it highly enough. Especially if you’re familiar with Milton and Paradise Lost.
Ooh! Shouldn’t we ask Ymhotep if it’s okay to talk about books now?
If coffee doesn’t work you might try the old “hair of the dog” remedy.
Every year some innocent person dies from gunfire and every year it remains a misdemeanor in most states to fire a weapon up into the air. It’s negligent homicide. No less.
I used to use that to cure a hangover. It’s like lighting a back fire. Put a buzz on and the hangover fades.
Thanks for all of your kind suggestions. Now go back to the gluttony that you seemingly worship with the endless ways that you promote to eat and eat and eat. Peace
LMAO. It’s the word of truth.
I just went to two shopping channel sites. The Paula Dean or Rachal Ray stock pots look good too. Both are coated on the inside and will do well for a long, slow cook.
Waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaah!
goodness no. oldnslow swerved back on to I-35 when it dawned on us we were pulling off for gas at that exit – lol
How do ya know a redneck is about to commit suicide?
Hey, y’all, watch ‘is!
The adults are talking. Here’s a graham cracker, now go outside and play.
You really woke up on the wrong side of life today. What is your problem with sharing good food for those on a limited budget?
Right? That place is a friggin’ NIGHTMARE!
HAHAHAHAHA!
LOL! You got that one! I hear that all the time just before they do something so stupit you wet your pants.
Nah, s/he’s like this on every thread s/he makes an appearance. Failed attention seeker. Registered on 27 Nov and has been a pain since the first comment.
Damn. That’s exactly what Clayton said when he tried to race a train to a crossing. Glad I jumped out of the back of that truck just as his foot hit the gas pedal. He killed three others along with himself.
lol. am too lazy to go in and upload just yet, but I have photos of mr let’s hold the lighted roman candle . . . also have a really good one of a beaming oldnslow holding a box of mortars X~o
Got a cute story for caturday but I’ll have guests so it might just be a hit and run tomorrow. :)
(It oughta really piss off Ymhotep with it’s frivolous nature)
Dutch oven, with or without feet? Part of me wants without feet to work better on the stove, but part of me says with feet so you can actually set it down on the counter while the contents are warm. Although I’ve had no luck finding one without feet.
LMAO! I can picture that in my mind very clearly.
That’s fucking frightening.
on edit – should have clarified that oldnslow was not the idiot holding the candle, he was supervising his fellow pyro’s
And the passive-aggressive or whatever, sign off with, “peace,” after throwing an insult gets a bit annoying, but it’s only words, I guess.
Let me ask you Mr. Dragon, what’s your definition of a “pain?” And don’t say “Ymhotep” because that would be a stupid remark even for you. Peace
Yeah. Three of us jumped out. They got dragged so far that the South Houston FD and PD responded.
Get a sturdy trivet.
Ah! I was actually picturing him with the mortars though.
Heh!
See my 74.
~~modnote: please, let’s not make this personal.~~
Yes, then you have the best of both worlds!
Please give me one example—just one—of any insult that I have ever directed toward any individual on this blog. Peace
You got nothing. Peace
I found a cast iron one, big, with feet and a rim around the lid where one can heap hot embers from the fire to use it like an oven for outdoor baking, or what ever.
Narcissist. As simple as that. Gotta be the center of everything. Every conversation has to revolve around him/her and be about what s/he finds important. Honestly surprised that s/he has found defenders here.
~~modnote: please, let’s not make this personal.~~
I’ve noticed the same with a JP12 or something along that line.
That’s a load of crap and you know it. Peace
Very well then. I cede the thread to Ymhotep. See you guys later. I hope you have a good day.
A-yep.
Later, Margaret!
By the way, folks: I know I’m as bad at it as anyone, but try not to feed the energy creatures.
PW, thanks so much for the food thread.
I’m afraid in WI, with our new emperor-elect Walker demanding all legislative rules committee recommendations pass over his desk before they go on to the rest of the legislature, that is going to make politics a bit sticky here and cooking might get shoved to the back burner.
This is the my next kitchen purchase.
Ouch! Glad you got out of that one OK. I stopped partying with my college roomies because they hung around with guys like that. The time I nearly got electrocuted from a live power line wire was enough for me.
A bowl of mushroom soup is now gluttony? Are we supposed to be self flagellating, too?
Whoops.
No worries! Like I said, I’m one of the worst offenders in this regard.
Ah, yes, the Wisconsin version of the crap Gutshot tried to pull in Minnesota, and of Bush’s “unitary executive”. So much for representative democracy!
Ooooh!
When I moved into the place I’m at I found an old rusty cast iron double burner griddle tucked away in the basement. I promptly laid claim to it and fixed it up. It doesn’t have the ribbed side, but I’m still quite pleased with it. Gluttony is so much easier with large cookware!
My gramma had a griddle on her gas stove. She made silver dollar pancakes to die for, crispy around the edges. I can make them in my cast iron skillet but can’t make as many at one time as I can on a griddle. Can make more than 1 grilled cheese sammich on it too. I’m gonna look for an old cast iron one in the thrift shops but will buy a new one if’n I have to.
Creamy Portobello Mushroom and Caramelized Onion Soup
Ingredients:
* Half stick of butter (1/8 of a pound, or 2 ounces)
* One large white onion, chopped
* Several cloves of garlic, minced
* One medium chili pepper, de-seeded and chopped fine
* 3-4 portobello caps, w/out stems, sliced 1/4 inch thin and chopped to about 1/2 inch pieces
* 4 cups vegetable broth
* A few splashes of tamari or soy sauce
* 1 cup dry white wine (Chardonnay is a good choice)
* 1 cup half-and-half (you can go with fat-free if the half stick of butter is freaking you out)
* 4 tablespoons wheat flour (or any other flour if you prefer)
* Two large dollops sour cream (same — regular, low fat, either is fine; I went with regular)
* Sage, dill, chives, parsley
* Salt and pepper to taste
In a large deep sauce pan or dutch oven, heat the butter on medium-high heat. Add the chopped onion first, and saute until it begins to go transparent. Sprinkle generously with the sage, dill, chives, and parsley. Add the garlic and chili pepper. Keep sauteing until the onion just begins to caramelize.
Meanwhile, as you’re cooking the onions, in another pot or microwavable bowl, heat the broth or bullion.
Add the chopped portobellos to the saucepan, and saute for a minute with the onions until the mushrooms begin to brown a little. Add the splashes of tamari or soy, then the white wine, stirring frequently. When it begins to boil again, add the broth mixture. When it’s boiling once more, slowly sprinkle in the flour to begin thickening the soup, and keep stirring. (Note, for a non-creamy mushroom-onion soup, it’s actually pretty tasty right here.)
After maybe five minutes, turn down the heat to medium-low and add the half-and-half and the sour cream, and stir well to make it all even. Grind fresh pepper and add salt to taste, although not much will be needed. Cover and simmer on low-low heat for about a half hour to an hour, stirring occasionally, before serving.
Serves three or four as a meal. Perhaps six if you’re just serving it in a small cup as an appetizer. Goes really well with baked cheesy garlic bread, or even just a nice slice of fresh sourdough.
Sometimes you just have to sacrifice!
What a coincidence! I made soup for dinner last night – “sopa de fuba”, a Brazilian soup of sausage and collard greens in a broth made from chicken stock, cornmeal and eggs. I was concerned that it would turn out to be “sopa de fubar”, but it turned out quite well. Home-made soup can be so soul-satisfying.
Or, if you live in Portland OR, you can go to the “Old Wives Tales” on Burnside and buy the best mushroom soup evah! It’s just not mushroom soup, it’s Hungarian Mushroom Soup, and I simply don’t think of making it.
The best part is you don’t have to wait for the Super Bowl to enjoy it. I get a souper bowl any time I want.
Mmmmmm! Thanks.
Nice! Keeping the eggs from setting before they can be incorporated is the tricky part, I imagine — just like in my dish. I notice that it calls for both the yolks and the whites of two eggs.
The nice thing about a well crafted stock is that one doesn’t have to do anything but refresh the herbs, make noodles and ladle the stock over. A pinch of curry gives it an exotic flavor, and if you haven’t cooked all the goodness out of the ingredients, add them as well. I generally cook the stock until the flavor settles down, about 6 hours min, then the carrots and meat taste like wall paper!
But, in spite of “Old Wives Tales” soups, I’ll have to give these a try.
Thanks for the recipes!