Via TPM yesterday, George Packer aims his virtual pen at the hollow center of George Bush’s quasi-autobiography in the New Yorker:
Every memoir is a tissue of omission and evasion; memoirs by public figures are especially unreliable. What’s remarkable about “Decision Points” is how frequently and casually it leaves out facts, large and small, whose absence draws more attention than their inclusion would have. In his account of the 2000 election, Bush neglects to mention that he lost the popular vote. He refers to the firing, in 2002, of his top economic adviser, Lawrence Lindsey, but not to the fact that it came immediately after Lindsey violated the Administration’s optimistic line by saying that the Iraq war could cost as much as two hundred billion dollars. In a brief recounting of one of the central scandals of his Presidency, the Administration’s outing of the intelligence officer Valerie Plame, Bush doesn’t acknowledge that two senior White House aides, Karl Rove and Lewis (Scooter) Libby, alerted half a dozen reporters to her identity.
In fact, Dubya and his ghostwriters’ version of the Plame-CIA outing is even more curiously incurious than Packer suggests. Condensing the lengthy investigation and Libby’s trial to roughly a paragraph, Bush faithfully cites the GOP talking point that Richard Armitage was Robert Novak’s source in exposing Plame, so special prosecutor Patrick Fitzgerald shouldn’t have bothered investigating anything or anyone else… and then blithely notes that he refused to pardon the convicted Libby because his lawyers unanimously agreed the verdicts were justified.
A chief executive whose mental gears were engaged might have thought to himself, “Hmm, wait a second. Why would Scooter lie, to the point of obstructing justice, if he wasn’t involved in the leak to Novak?” He might have been even more suspicious when his vice president compared Libby to “a soldier on the battlefield” — implying that Libby’s crimes were committed on behalf of the administration.
Unless, of course, Bush already knew all that. What was it that note said about “the guy that was asked to stick his neck in the meat grinder” – you know, the one with the crossed-out reference to “the Pres” suggesting that Bush himself had told Libby to take a fall to protect Karl Rove other administration officials? In which case it’s not a matter of incuriosity at all, but consciously evading questions Bush & Co. desperately don’t want asked, much less answered.
It brings to mind the line from Joe Orton’s play, Loot, where a corrupt Scotland Yard detective describes an unspoken police rule: “Never search your own backyard; you might find what you’re looking for.”




156 Comments





Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Worst. Preznit. Ever.
:::blood pressure rising:::
going to get beer…
Swopa!
And on top of everything else, we can thank Bush for presiding over such an erosion of civil liberties and the rule of law that Obama had something to work from. What a fuckwad.
swopa!
I’m #1 Yah
Why is that remarkable? After eight years of the chimp, I find it perfectly predictable.
Fixed it for ya.
Hey Swopa.
Had Decision Points been the least bit honest or insightful it would have been surprising.
Well, you know how badly the Shrub must have wanted to set the record crooked.
Thanks Margaret – wasn’t sure how to qualify that one.
Hurts to think about our current preznit too – but the beer helps. :)
One day we need to investigate who buys these Winger books in bulk Bush’s book is a best seller but unlike other best sellers will anyone not in the media talk about reading the book?
Will anyone normal ever quote the book in an argument?
You mean crookeder maybe?
Unequivocal proof that people who still separate Republicans and Democrats are implying disparity where none exists.
Not in an honest argument.
a picture is worth a thousand words
http://wonkette.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/08/drunk-bush-olympics-2.jpg
Who buys these books? My brother-in-law, for one. He’s reasonably well-educated, but he’s an insurance adjuster and spends way too much time in the car listening to the likes of Limp-paw and Becker-head.
If I was listening to those knuckleheads and Hannity daily, I might be drinking the FlavorAide too.
the review was good,a little too kind
Swopa…! Suz…! ;-)
oy…where was he educated Georgia Tech, TCU?
Southern Illinois U.
It seems Bush just does not care enough to give his backers a convincing lie for his mistakes. Bush is no Nixon.
Bush can’t seem to say what he needs to excite his base…he’s squeamish about openly using hate to blame scapegoats for America’s problems. Bush is no Hitler, Rush Limbaugh, or Sarah Palin.
Bush is not giving convincing excuses or alibis for his many crimes instead he admits to some ignores many by admitting to some crimes and some facts but not other crimes and facts he actually manages to weaken his already dubya ious reputation.
What purpose was this book suppose to serve?
looks like an enhanced pat-down to me
Salukis, eh…? ;-)
“No one ever went broke underestimating the intelligence of the American public.” –
— Henry Mencken
hahahaha
Pickles has a heckuva smirk herself, doesn’t she?
But did he read the book I argue with wingers and I quote books they do to mostly history or economics they don’t quote Rush, Sarah and I bet they won’t quote Bush. They will repeat what the news tells them about the book but actually read the book?
I would check for cobwebs:)
The purpose?
To make GWB a brazillion bux.
Because he needs it…
brazilian wax? ouch.
to lay the groundwork for the revisionist history of the boosh administration… and to make money — the wingnut welfare way
Must disagree Sadlyyes Newsweek sold for $1 recently Tucker went from Cable tv to third rate blogs, a few talking heads jumped to the huffpost the MSM is losing money bigtime.
The chicken of the MSM pushing GOP economic policies has come home to roost. The NY Times needs to repay a bailout loan to Carlos Slim soon I think.
Thanks for that mental image…
Who knows? I avoided the topic of politics like the plague, out of respect for Mrs. Dr. CT.
like the freakin joker
http://1.bp.blogspot.com/__kLZHfshpZA/TC3jXyO6ibI/AAAAAAAADjM/VJjGDFvwtvU/s1600/joker_final12801.jpg
Isn’t there an easier way than putting Bush’s lack of intelligence up for public show, the lies, the omitted facts and arguments? Even Sarah will be able to find stuff to mock Jeb with in the GOP Primary debates if he runs.
Copperhead country. Southern Illinois is really southern, I hear.
good point!
Bush could have better kept his dignity doing porn it seems Bush can’t even hire a competent Ghost Writer.
Put him in a dress and give him a wig and they would be indistinguishable.
you got it
he who controls the past,controls the present etc
So much the better.
Jeb is the more dangerous of the two: he apparently can occasionally string a few coherent thoughts together.
Pickles Oblong? (second from left if you’re unfamiliar with the series)
Y’know, I did a Google image search for that pic and as is typically the case when searching for cartoon characters discovered there are people who dedicate themselves to manufacturing porn based on the series. I passed on those but did find this pic of a terrific Milo Oblong tattoo.
Lauras a piece of work/of shit…either or etc so forth
Ack! Brain bleach, stat!
I have not had one GOPer quote from any GOP book or mention reading a GOP book since P. J. O’Rourke last wrote a popular book.
did ya go to TS today?
Agreed Jeb seems the smartest GOPer likely to run. Huckabee could best connect with moderate voters they worry we for their ability to win the election.
Sarah wins as scariest if she somehow gets into office.
Maybe Jeb will name Chang as his running-mate.
The ones I’ve talked with mostly like to quote Buckley and Locke and the like… or just make s*** up.
If he’s gonna do that he should name Chang and Eng and get the whole set.
Its an ugly soul that messes it up for you I can’t think Sarah is hot I mean sure last call if I did not know the hurtful things she says, the lies yes I’d take her home.
But I do know what she says and that kills it for me. An ugly soul can trump physical looks.
I saw some of the George Bush porn. The production values were good but I found the excessive body hair a tad distracting.
hahahahahahah
i forgot about that
More often than not.
Modern Conservative thought died with Buckley. Conservative thought that works in the real world did that ever exist?
707!!!
I don’t let myself forget it. Ridiculing Jeb’s imaginary friend may be one of our best weapons against a Bush III imperial presidency.
I’m glad someone got it… or acknowledged getting it.
Nope, I decided to skip black Friday but they’re holding it for me. I’ll probably get out there tomorrow. I need to get Kuroneko’s shots updated while I still have the money to do it anyway.
They should get Chang, Eng and Archie, then all of the Bunkers will be covered.
In that case, we’d need some Bunker busters, wouldn’t we?
I’m not getting the point of this blog. Is there some reason why anyone should care what Bush has to say ever?
that would make a HYSTERICAL Sat Nite Live sketch
Hmmm. Does SNL buy outside material?
can the humane society give you a voucher?
i bet they do
can you see him going to them for advice…it writes itself
its getting to that time…..goodnite dear peeps
Imagine all of the bandwidth out there and yet you think that your opinion of this blog is relevant. News flash: You don’t have to stay. I though Republicans were all about free choice and market driven services?
g’nite sadly
Dunno but it’s only thirty bucks or so.
Nighters!
At the least I can write a Diary entry of the script. I was thinking more about Jebbie deciding he wanted Chang, and going to find Chang and learning that he can’t have Chang without Eng…
If they did, they might not suck so much.
Good Evening Folks
Looks like you are all having a good time.
I just finished a rather sad, poignant book and thought I’d swing by for a few yucks. Also watching a Rolling Stones movie. The one Marty Scorsese directed.
Somebody, anybody, make me laugh.
Any review about Bush’s “fact-based” memoir should be entitled, “Derision Points about Decision Points.” Because this is all that Bush deserves, derision, derision, derision.
Holy Shirt…! Joke Line experienced an epiphany today…
Israel First, Yet Again
Read a Carl Hiaasen novel, Demi.
So, these two guys walk into a bar. Pretty stupid, you’re thinking, ’cause after the first guy walked into the bar the second one should have been looking where he was going…
You know what they say about blind pigs, CT.
Although I suppose it isn’t true in Hawai’i. I’m assuming that goats and pigs are still major pests on the Big Island?
Shackles on his wrists, while he awaits sentencing in the docket of The Hague…! ;-)
That can only mean one thing: He didn’t get a speaking gig at AIPAC this year.
What do you call a man who survives having his left arm and left leg cut off?
Allright.
I’m telling ya AIPAC is going down…! Mark my words…! With Rosen v. AIPAC and an IRS investigation looming… Happy joy joy…! ;-)
Hiya Demi – Howsitgoineh?
sounds like some heavy reading…
didja hear that willie nelson got popped for possession? CT was on the story so fast, i thought he might have been on the tourbus…
What rolls down stairs
Alone or in pairs?
Runs over the neighbors dog?
I still think the Mongoose had the biggest impact on Hawai’i…! 8-(
I’d never heard of him. Just googled. Looks good. Maybe I can get someone to buy me one for xmas.
I’m not going to hold my breath. Even if it does go down, there will quickly be another apparatus in place to dictate our foreign policy to us from Israel.
Eh, it’s going well. We found a car for me. Picking it up tomorrow. Girl’s got wheels, almost.
Thanks, Peg. :)
It’s log, it’s log
It’s big, it’s heavy, it’s wood
It’s log, it’s log
It’s better than bad, it’s good
No prob. :)
It’s some of the funniest stuff I’ve read in a long time. I can strongly recommend both Sick Puppy and Skinny Dip.
I’ll warn you that every Hiaasen novel I’ve read has some Fargo-esque elements. But them that gets that sort of treatment deserve it.
Thank you Margaret.
It’s happy, happy, joy, joy for me when I find other fans of the Chihuahua from Picasso-ville.
Everyone wants a log
Hiya Pups! Just logging on after a full work day and a silly night of dinner and movie! How is everyone?
hopefully somebody *pimped* your ride with some phat 18′s and a cranking sound system. that, or a strictly A-to-B type ride is cool too.
log
How can one not be? Like denying yourself oxygen.
The former Mrs CounterTenor thought R&S were infantile.
I’m okay. How are you?
I sent you something on FB, hope it makes you laugh.
Well we KNOW what happens to brains deprived of oxygen. This is just evidence of the horrific effects of Ren and Stimpy depravation
*sigh* I know…! Can’t one dream about it…? ;-)
Mark LeVine offers an interesting new approach…
Obama: getting ‘poned’ Bibi style
I don’t know what phat 18′s are but the guy we’re buying it from used to race it. Acura Integra. He took the high performance engine out and put a standard, but rebuilt one and a newly rebuilt transmission (almost typed tranny, but didn’t want to get yelled at.) It’s still got a stiff suspension and my husband’s got a stereo in the garage he said he’d put in. Zippy me.
Evening all.
Read Bush’s book then think about how much that book will help Jeb in the GOP Primary:)
When referring to automobiles tranny is a perfectly acceptable term.
Oilfieldguy! Que pinches pasa?
Tranny use is okay for transmissions, just not people. (speaking as something of an authority on the matter)
I thought the term was pwned?
Your up on Israel now that the American election is over any signs Israel and or America will attack Iran? Was that fleet no tied up dealing with North Korea meant to relieve American ships near the Persian Gulf?
If so would an extended stay near North Korea delay any possible American strike on Iran?
Just got back into town. Nobody saved me no turkey.
wow – i’m impressed. that’s a good car
(btw, 18″ rims are considered cool, but only on rappers escalades.)
I drive a 10 year old soobie outback that looks like all the other mom-wagons out here in Denver…but it’s great in the snow.
:::uploading some turkee for OFG:::
we had leftovers…
I’m just great Margaret, and I’m so happy to be here. Really!
What! Is that true?
That blows. Should I try to stuff a sammich through the intertubez?
LeVine talks about it…! ;-)
I worked up a new Villanelle. It’s my third one, but this is for my sister who is getting married. I’d sorta like some feedback before I send it to her. Are the firepups game for some poetic criticism?
That is too funny. I especially like the illustrations. Saving the site to favorites. Many Fanks.
I don’t foresee anything until the new House is seated…! After that all bets are off…! ;-)
I just wanted to make you smile. Did it work? Thought I’d return the favor.
Good night, ‘pups.
g’nite bct
Oh gosh, I read that wrong. I didn’t realize you were speaking of your ex wife. Didn’t mean to seem insensitive. I still think Ren and Stimpy are like air though.
No snow here so I’m good. When I was younger and cuter and could get away with being a princess, I drove a Datsun Z, a Stealth, a small pick up. I never ever ever wanted to drive a momobile, but considering our teensy budget for this vehicle, I was willing to go with the most reliable engine we could find. I think this will fit the bill.
Good night.
What if those ships are delayed for a few months or longer by North Korea who backs up and or relieves and stocks the ships we already have there with the weapons they need to attack Iran?
like air with lots of bodily function jokes thrown in…
It’s okay Margaret. There’re an infinite number of reasons she’s my ex. Finding no humor in Ren and Stimpy is somewhere on the list.
Okay, here goes, my sisters name is Amber and her fiance’s name is Chad. That way the title makes sense. Tell me what you guys think of this:
de To Chamber
My sister tells me she shall soon be wed
A new Brother-In-Law our family will gain
Two people bound to a single path tread
Amber is not foolish and uses her head
To the masher and rake she is bane;
My sister tells me she shall soon be wed
Chad knows work and how profits are bled
Slackers and layabouts who suffer no pain
Two people bound to a single path tread
Council given, they heard what was said
From friends and relations, it fell like rain
My sister tells me she shall soon be wed
Set hopes on sail wind blown fears fled
False dread washes greedily for the drain
Two people bound to a single path tread
May the years bear fruit for love be fed
And desire and helpmate be their bread
My sister tells me she shall soon be wed
Two people bound to a single path tread
I’ll bet but it wasn’t my place to pass judgment and being tired is my only excuse. Goodnight. :)
oooooh i like that dood
Not bad. :)
No one has mentioned that Bush probably doesn’t remember half the stuff he left out. Strikes me as someone who can’t retain things well.
Hey, Suz, Julianna Banana is making quite a bump of herself. :)
I like it too and think they’ll appreciate your work.
You know, for an older guy, Mick Jagger is still hot. He’s singing Some Girls. I always liked that song.
yep, I smiled. :)
It’s time for me to go to bed too folks. Oya!
she is twain — yesterday was jen’s halfway day, exactly 20 weeks.
g’nite margaret
Sweet dreams for a sweet gal. smooch.
glad you liked it!
Lovely. Hope she feels well – hope granny does, too.
Thanks for the flowers. I’ll go ahead and post it. Some online guest registry thing. Lots of congrats and stuff. I’m supposed to give the toast at the reception, so I figured I’d kick it up to a Whole Nuvva Level.
Wow. It took that long into the deal to determine the gender? It’s many so long, I forgot the details.
(white light to Jen and Julianna)
I used to give people songs when they exasperated or annoyed me to the point that I was unable to trust myself to express my feelings without losing it. I once gave my mother “You Can’t Always Get What You Want” and it just infuriated her. Much later though, after she died, I found among her records of Barbara Streisand, Perry Como, The Nutcracker and etc, that 45 of the Rolling Stones. It must have touched her as much as it pissed her off. I cried about that a bit.
thanks twain — i’m still smiling from our holiday. she’s still having occasional bouts of nausea but has finally gotten past the constant morning sickness phase.
Like it very much, OFG.
they scheduled her anatomical scan for week 18 so we found out on the 18th.
Nobody mentioned Bush borrowed stuff from other GOPer books and invented details of having seen the President of Afghanistan get sworn in.
So he lied or is doing a Reagan with old age that fact raises questions of Jeb’s fitness for office.
So we ask a trap question we ask Jeb if allegations in his brothers book are false. Jeb says of course then we or Sarah Palin in the GOP debates reads the Bush seeing the Afghan President swearing in passage then we or Sarah says Dementia is it hereditary.
Jeb zinged by Sarah on a book question would make the news for days. Jeb being a Bush and into revenge seeing his Presidential hopes dashed would take out Sarah.
Divide and Conquer!
Yes, it must have if she kept it.
very cool, OFG. (i had to look up villanelle.)
I’m gonna take off. Thanks for the smiles, gang. Cool crew.
“What purpose was this book suppose to serve?”
He needs something to put in his liberry.
1. Bush didn’t write that memoir; there’re too many sentences.
2. He was contemplating ditching the Dick after his first term, but then Cheney reminded him, “Who the hell do you think is gonna run the country?”
3. He was mad as hell “they” wouldn’t let him return to Washington on 9/11. Yeah, there he goes again, diving headlong into battle.
4. He ordered the shooting down of the pentagon plane-as-missile. But he decided to save telling anyone for nine years. It’d make such a dramatic draw for his memoirs, you know.
Come to think of it, why couldn’t some jets like the ones pacing Air Force 1 that day, just swing up from that same base and save the day in Washington.
5. Ahhh, so much to contemplate. And all sparked from the mind of an imbecile.