Oh my mama told me
‘Cause she say she learned the hard way
She say she wanna spare the children
She say don’t give or sell your soul away
‘Cause all that you have is your soul
So don’t be tempted by the shiny apple
Don’t you eat of a bitter fruit
Hunger only for a taste of justice
Hunger only for a world of truth
‘Cause all that you have is your soul.
The sentiment above, expressed beautifully by singer-songwriter Tracy Chapman, goes to the heart of Americans’ self-image. In this nation, we tell ourselves, we are free to be true to our souls. I guess it all depends upon what you mean by “true” or “soul.”
Like the narrator’s mother in the song, we seem condemned to learn this truth the hard way, if we learn it at all. If the financial meltdown has not taught us anything else, it should teach us that there’s hell to pay when you sell your soul.
Jean Paul Sartre famously described hell as other people. I think, instead, that our soul is other people. Living within a Ayn Randian/Social Darwinist myth of the isolated individual versus the world, we exploit others for our own advantage. It’s our own souls that pay the price. By the way, Sartre always claimed he was misunderstood. He said:
It simply brings out the capital importance of all other people for each one of us.
I meet people from all walks of life and from all parts of the country who live as if they recognize this simple truth. Our everyday interactions with friends and strangers depend upon it. We give honest change at the bar. We hold doors open for the elderly and the frail (in the South, men still hold them open for women).
Collectively, though, we live by a dim and different light. Others are our competitors in a zero sum game. It’s insane, really. The devilish rich think they can run off with all the money. They shrug off 10 percent unemployment and all the suffering it causes, knowing all the while that it’s caused by their actions. They can’t run away with the money, though, ‘cause there’s nowhere for them to run. That’s Tracy Chapman’s lesson of the bitter fruit. Sartre’s, too.
In his song about a young boy’s friendship with an old oilfield roughneck, Guy Clark sings that they we’re “desperados waiting for a train.” He was on to something there. We live in the Land of the Pinkertons, and it often seems like love and friendship so threaten the Randians among them that those of us looking for a little kindness, love and justice are, of necessity, desperados.
The beautiful thing about Clark’s song is its unpretentious, down-home prairie humanism. The magic of life is in our relationship with others, especially others who never gave up on their souls, fortifying our own. People like the roughneck, who, Clark tells us, was “an old school man of the world” and a “hero of this country.”
The clip above is from an old Letterman broadcast. Singing with Nanci Griffith are Clark, Jimmie Dale Gilmore, Rodney Crowell, Eric Taylor, Jerry Jeff Walker and the inimitable Steve Earle. I’ve been privileged to meet most of this gang. Some of ‘em I know pretty well. We ought to elect them all to Congress.
Hungering only for a taste of justice, only for a world of truth, one day we’re gonna elbow one another and say about the train we’ve been waiting on, “Come on Jack that son-of-a-bitch is coming.”



26 Comments












Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Love this song. First heard Jerry Jeff’s version then discovered Clark’s original.
Though I have to admit a strong fondness for a line from Clark’s “Ramblin’ Jack & Mahan”:
The lineup in that vid is Hall Of Fame of my americana heroes.
The song is a classic, that version an ultimate one.
Thanks.
We’re all a lot more desperate now than we used to be.
I’m not sure the train is coming, though.
Good morning, Glenn. Very nice, as usual. Soul selling in this country has become an industry IMO. Don’t know how people do it but they do.
They shrug off
1018 percent unemployment (give or take a few points) and all the suffering it causes, knowing all the while that it’s caused by their actions.Suggested edit.
Another good one. Thanks, Mr. Smith
It wasn’t anything like it is now before TV. Most pre-TV folks have passed on; all there is are the TV-affected. A nation overrun by narcissists and their envy, all of it bred by TV. The only outlet is greed.
I have always depended on the kindness of ingrates. And I’ve learned that my only useful purpose is to provide sufficient Schadenfreude for my associates.
word.
thanks, Glenn. Having watched the disintegration of a family member afflicted with mental illness, who went from strong moral values to rightwing values – wherein ‘do-gooder’ is invective – in my experience the result of inability to deal with reality is part of the rejection of personal need for character. But cannot say that is true for everyone.
The biggest barrier, as I see it, is that people do not know how to enact this progressive vision, at least not outside their personal interactions. There is a fatalism that things cannot be another way, not necessarily because of innate human frailty, but because the game is fixed. Of course, the game is fixed – we just have to play a different game. The question is: what would that game look like?
I have no doubt that collective zero-sum-game mindset can be changed, but not until people find another way. Rather than seeing the mindset as a barrier, we might use it to offer an alternative that people are already looking for, even if they are not sure what shape it will take.
oh dear God, I truly hope I one day can shake your hand and buy you a cold one. that is some poetry, Cowboy
It doesn’t matter if anyone ‘believes’ we have ‘souls’. But it’s hard to deny the awareness of what we call consciousness, and particularly self-consciousness. Awareness and self-awareness probably depend on illusions and delusions; it’s just too rare to find anyone with a good sense of awareness. Anyway, if you think the torture and terrifying suffering of billions of creatures we raise for slaughter and to eat does not leach out and hover like strange karma, I would disagree. Wrong is wrong and bad is bad even if there are no absolutes. I would need a damn good argument for why we think we should be entitled to anything better than we have now.
Thanks Glenn, very much. Great observations, and the video and song are
‘all heart and soul’!
The basis for the comment is Dr. Albert Schweitzer’s famous philosophy of ethics.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Albert_Schweitzer
(Dr. Schweitzer’s grand-niece was Jean-Paul Sartre’s mother.)
My comment is a bit off topic but troubles me deeply. My local paper has carried recent stories of horrific animal abuse. Afghan hounnds being intentionally starved to death, 2 emaciated dogs being thrown from car windows, and 2 days ago, a dog beaten with baseball bats and on the verge of being buried alive.
Ghandi said the greatnest of a nation can be judged by the way it treats it’s animals. These stories of abuse speak volumes about the decline of our society. The poor are demonized for being poor, immigrants are demonized because they are immigrants, the sick demonized for being sick, the unemployed demonized for being unemployed, and so on. The lack of compassion for other living things bodes ill for our society.
So much soul selling the market is saturated. Like the housing bubble!!
It’d be my honor to shake your hand, cb12. Thanks so much.
“Collectively, though, we live by a dim and different light. Others are our competitors in a zero sum game. It’s insane, really. “; finally someone says what is the reality, that it IS INSANE.
I’d also add that theologian/philospher Mark Johnston (in his book, “Surviving Death,” makes a good case that “soul is other people” might literally be true, and might be how our souls literally survive death. Check it out…
“Knowing myself yet being someone other” Forgot where i first read that…Anyone?
T. S. Eliot
The Four Quartets
Little Gidding, II
http://www.ubriaco.com/fq.html
Thanks Vanderpost kept sticking in my head. But i knew that was not where i first read it.
Heh. Love is outlawed when hatred is law. Wonderful post, and I didn’t think I’d like it when I started.
What is this collective madness that has spread over our nation? How are we so easily swayed to yearn for the snake-oil salesmen? It’s got to be more than TV, X-box, American Idolatry, missing blondes, beaten dogs/women/children. The stench of dispair can be overcome by community, but grows in solitude.
My Mom keeps saying that these times remind her of the depression, and Weimar Germany. For a gal with dementia, her brief periods of lucidity – and prescient comments, she speaks an authentic truth.
Never underestimate the power of the Golden Rule for it’s as old as we are and we’re literally all the same.
Follow the path with heart, practice the Golden Rule, and you will never lose your soul or be alone.
Thanks, Glen.
You have a poet’s way of getting to the heart of the matter without preaching.
I deeply appreciate what you have to say.
Mason, thanks so much. I think “the poet’s way” has more to do with the listeners that the reciters. And I credit FDL for that….
A writer can’t help for more than that. Thanks!