Via Lindsay Beyerstein, the Guardian reports today:
Vital warning systems on the Deepwater Horizon oil rig were switched off at the time of the explosion in order to spare workers being woken by false alarms, a federal investigation has heard.
The revelation that alarm systems on the rig at the centre of the disaster were disabled – and that key safety mechanisms had also consciously been switched off – came in testimony by a chief technician working for Transocean, the drilling company that owned the rig.
. . . Sensors monitoring conditions on the rig and in the Macondo oil well beneath it were still working, but the computer had been instructed not to trigger any alarms in case of adverse readings.
. . . [the Transocean technician] said he discovered that the physical alarm system had been disabled a full year before the disaster. When he asked why, he said he was told that the view from even the most senior Transocean official on the rig had been that “they did not want people woken up at three o’clock in the morning due to false alarms“.
As Lindsay notes, “BP/Transocean’s concern for rig workers is touching”… and I’m sure the workers who died in the Deepwater Horizon explosion would be quick to express their gratitude if they weren’t, well, otherwise engaged at the moment.
If this reminds you of the corruption of debt ratings prior to the financial-industry meltdown two years ago, “Bin Laden Determined to Strike in U.S.,” the “stovepiping” of intelligence prior to the invasion of Iraq, and… well, almost everything else that has gone wrong during the last decade or so, there’s probably a reason. Not wanting to hear bad news turns into refusing to hear bad news, which… inevitably, turns into bad news.





124 Comments





Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
I hate alarm clocks too but I am not living on a floating oil rig.
And Hi Swopa!
swopa!
Swopa!
In hindsight, that three AM false alarm doesn’t seem so bad, does it?
How are you this fine Friday evening?
am doing well — how about you?
I think the way it works is Swopa writes something and then some gnome posts it here at the designated moment when no one is looking.
A rig that’s burping and belching, kicking and screaming GET OUT! seems alarming enough for me. “Too bad we can’t stay baby!”
A lot of people deserve to go to prison for this for the rest of their lives. Will it happen? Of course not.
Will anyone get knighted for saving BP? If it gets saved, yes.
BP is a fly by night outfit. You look at the problems in Alaska, in its refinery in Texas, at the Gulf blowout. It is a persistent and repeated pattern of ignoring safety issues. And why not? BP gets away with it everytime. The Gulf blowout should have it up on felony counts, what should be a death sentence for a corporation. Instead their profit margins will be reduced a little, that’s all.
This is why I never worked offshore. It’s like being in jail, with the chance of drowning.
The thing about this version of events is that Transocean is implicated. In another account I saw today, it was BP’s decision to cut off the alarm system in question (which I’m not sure what it is exactly they cut off a year ago).
Sadly, the Deepwater Horizon disaster adds to the list of Bush administration “no one could have predicted” events: 9/11, Iraq insurgency, Katrina, financial meltdown…
The Obama administration gets a share of this one, because President Obama ostentatiously leaped onto the GOP’s “drill baby drill” bandwagon two weeks before it blew up.
each rig is its very own devils island
That was very strange hearing that from Obama, at all. It was a WTF moment. Did the bard of Wasilla have his ear?
Too Big To Fail’s equally destructive twin, Too Big To Punish.
Fine this evening!
It wasn’t surprising, in reality Obama might just be the most conservative president we’ve ever had, even more so than the previous administration. Anything else is a fabrication. He is certainly more conservative than Nixon or Reagan and ALL his Dem predecessors… none of whom were particularly liberal but did fight occasionally on behalf of working (and WISH they were working) Americans
In my opinion.
‘evening, all-
Too Big To Fail, Too Big To Punish….Too Big To Govern…How long before corporations, as citizens, point out that they are subject to taxation without representation, and demand representation in the Congress?
They already own the House and Senate lock, stock, and barrel. They also own the Executive Branch and while they might not own the Judicial Branch TECHNICALLY, it rules in their favor more often than not.
We’re the ones without representation.
Lobbying being what it is, aren’t corporations more subject to representation without taxation?
Even land based. I can’t tell you how many “Oh Shit” moments I have encountered, causing all to run for the hills. This particular hole, of deep Water Horizons and BP is an absolute case study of botched, wormy assed shit putting a great headwind against the total depth and pot of gold at the end of the bent pipe. The pressures dealt with in the oilfield are other-worldly, both pounds per square inch and on personnel. In the production zone, multiple shortcuts were taken, forced by BP. Safety pays, unless it gets in the way of profits.
But….that just doesn’t make sense based upon everything Glenn Beck says…
Bartender, whiskeys neat for my two friends..
Ratfood, someone, here, months ago said, “Too ——- big to fail, too ——- big to nail, and too ——- big to go to jail.”
And SCOTUS has, recently, reiterated its “belief” that “corporations are people, too”.
The disconnect is “big” enough to swallow the world …
DW
Can anything make sense based on what Glenn Bleccch says?
Well…there’s that. heh
Sense and Beck in the same sentence, talk about yer cognitive dissonance… :)
until there is accountability, they will continue to cut safety corners to maintain maximum profit.
Well, BP knows how to squeeze blood out of turnips so to speak, they have been using prison labor in their clean-up. No worries if these guys get sick.
Yeah…I actually threw up in my mouth just a little bit.
I’ve concluded that all we need to do to correct the imbalance is for each and every American to head a multi-billion dollar corporation.
See, there was a simple solution right in front of us the entire time…
The taxpayers will pick up the tab for that too. It’s enough to make a CEO believe in the Almighty (dollar).
Adding to your great list, Swopa: not bothering Michael Brown while he was choosing a place for dinner, and not interrupting John McCain’s birthday cake party while he and George Bush were celebrating (2005).
Seems to me that the quickest way to make that happen is to follow Douglas Adams’ lead in Restaurant at the End of the Universe and adopt the leaf as legal tender. There will be some initial inflation problems, of course.
All the really good investigative reporting seems to come out of Europe. The U.S. corporate media types are nothing more than wannabe courtesans.
Will the leaf’s value correspond to its size?
Not to mention the rapid deforestation. Would kinda suck for the desert dwellers. Maybe we should use dirt, everybody has that.
Can you speak plainly? What do you mean by “until there is accountability,” exactly?
Gad, I hope not. I always come out on the losing end of these types of evaluations.
University of South Florida researchers have linked the BP spill to the giant underwater plumes through chemical analysis. Researchers confirm subsea Gulf oil plumes are from BP well
There is a lot of good investigative reporting in the U.S., you just won’t often see it on TV or in print. Much of it has emerged right here, thanks to people like Jane and Marcy and a great many others.
But you could pay people you don’t like with stinging nettles or something like that.
Which is the best argument against tort reform. I went into a little detail over at my place on this subject. At the risk of blogwhoring, click my moniker and you can find it. Second from the top.
Will there ever be a trial where this could be evidence? Btw, how many lawsuits are now pending against BP, Transocean, and Halliburton?
Wowie zowie, a true “ownership” society, and, as you say, the solution has been here, all the time, right before our eyes.
But now, we may see it … plain as day.
(Erm … I do wonder what else we’ve been missing …?)
;~DW
I’m pretty certain those plumes are naturally occurring. If you bore a big hole into an underwater oil reserve, it spews out… naturally.
Time for me to head out. Thanks to the absent Swopa for the LN post. Splendid evening to all.
BP? Fly by night? Hardly.
BP, under a previous name, helped Jimmy Roosevelt overthrow the duly elected leader of Iran and install the Shah.
I wonder if Obama is for tort reform. It would prove the credentials he’s been given here (which I don’t dispute). I just don’t know where he really stands.
I was thinking the damage on this spill would reach a bit past $1 trillion. The sub-sea plume stuff amplifies the “they’ve killed the Gulf” meme quite a bit beyond a trillion bucks. We won’t know for ten years how bad the beginnings of this are, if we’re even allowed to find out. Watch for a big fire overtaking the University of South Florida science building real soon.
Amoco, I hardly knew ya!
NOAA: “What are these plumes you speak of?”
Ah, Toxicodendron radicans to Congress, then?
(Especially appropriate for graduates of the ivy leagues.)
DW
Simple answer to the health care crisis… (a) don’t get sick, (b) don’t get injured, (c) don’t get pregnant.
A and B are a work in progress but I’m doing a really stellar job on C.
Hey, me too! Hiya dude.
Great! I would really hate blaming those plumes on an multi-national mega corporation!
Also (d) don’t get old.
Shoot, not doing so well on that.
I wouldn’t be having any beach bonfires along the Gulf Coast anytime soon.
Well if “(a)” and or “(b)” befalls you, then you must quietly go to your reward, thanking your lucky stars that you had the good fortune to live in a country with the most compassionate, exceptional, and bestest health care in the world.
On edit: EDP @ 55 reminds us … “(d)” (follow same prescription as “(a)” and “(b)” …
Say … what?
DW
On my way out the door but turns to wave, “Hi, Christine!”
I imagine you’re enjoying the same weather we have, heat index over 100 today. Scores of people in the area hospitalized for heat related causes. I hope your family is coping well.
Off now to slumber land… :)
Swopa has left the building. Must be at the Kosfest. What a lovely setting they chose. Gag!
Nite, dearie,
Stay well, we are off on a road trip tomorrow, just to stay cool. See you tomorrow.
Soon the newspapers will be screaming — North Korea Sinks USF research ship in the Gulf of Mexico!!
BP Killing Off Horses On Public Land To Get Oil Leases
http://blog.alexanderhiggins.com/2010/07/13/bp-killing-… /
Above Top Secret is reporting that their investigative piece into the killing of Mustangs on public lands to allow BP to receive drilling leases and oil pipeline permits on public lands is being picked up by CNN.
The ATS report investigates the relationship of corruption between BP and the Federal Government, which includes a corrupt culture of sex, drugs and bribes, to side step Federal laws that would otherwise prevent BP from attaining the leases on public lands.
The La Times reports on the issue:
Interior Secretary Ken Salazar’s take on controversial wild horse roundup
The federal Bureau of Land Management’s controversial roundup of approximately 2,500 wild horses in Nevada has been met with protest from outraged animal advocates who argue that the measure is cruel and unnecessary. Secretary of the Interior Ken Salazar explains his position on the mustang dilemma in The Times’ Opinion section…
In the Times’ opinion piece published by Salazar begins by pointing out that wild horses have been under threat from loss of habitat for decades.
Since Spanish conquistadors brought horses to the American continent four centuries ago, the majestic animals that once roamed wild on our nation’s great prairies have endured dramatic changes in the American landscape. The grasslands of the Midwest gave way to farms. Barbed-wire fences closed the ranges of Texas. Western cities grew and suburbs sprawled.
‘Nite, ratfood, sleep well.
DW
*waving g’nite to the leaving sleepy pups*
Well, that’s an abrupt change of pace. Thanks. These circle jerks are a bit repetitive. Nice to hear from you Sadly.
This issue of the alarms turned off is superceded by the issue of the matters involving the BOP, it’s building, it’s construction, the failures of the BOP and of BP to preserve well integrity as they pumped in cement and failed to do THAT properly, the insanity of pulling off mud monitors early before the cement had set, and SO much more.
There’s also the issue of another well closer to shore that BP drilled that failed miserably, and might be still leaking.
And THAT’S got NOTHING to do with the idioicy and lechery of Matt Simmons and HIS whackaloon theory about other leaks.
What am I sayiing?
This issue of the alarm system failure is FAR from the shit that matters.
Had it been enabled, it would not have saved a single one of them 11 dead, or anyone else, or the rig itself.
Pure crap, then, is where this info about the alarm system is buried,
Pure crap, and completely fucking irrelevant to the real story and the science.
Pure crap. And a disgrace to be spinning it for ANY reason, at FDL or Seminal.
IMHO.
Harumph.
Not all clocks and alarms are good. I remember when my company installed a time clock. They expected us to clock in and out. This is not done in the oilfield, so i took a sledgehammer and beat the son-of-a-bitch completely flat. I carried it into the office and laid it on the terminal managers desk. I told him I had no idea what happened, but it looked like something fell on it about 7 or 8 times.
No more time clocks.
Did you say “There is a lot of good investigative reporting in the U.S., you just won’t often see it on TV or in print. Much of it has emerged right here, thanks to people like Jane and Marcy and a great many others”?
It bears repeating.
If Barack OBama is not the sickest little twerp to come along since “W”, then I am at a severe loss to imagine who it might be, even Rahmbo works for Obama.
Disgusting and outrageous, sadly.
Bee Pee needs to be rendered down to its essence and burned in the nearest internal combustion device … mileages may vary …
DW
See, THIS dude gets it and tells it.
Thanks Rat . . . I’m with you on this comment.
All the phookin way.
And I’ll pour as long as I can drink
Hear, hear!
THAT is a wonderful story, err, fact. Thanks, man.
Your response was timely and most appropriate, Oilfieldguy.
I’ve no doubt that it was most satisfying, as well.
;~DW
So you “punched” the clock?
Flat. Out.
He did.
DW
Are they even letting people smoke there?
sorry
http://blog.alexanderhiggins.com/2010/07/13/bp-killing-horses-public-land-oil-leases/
Here’s a quote from Straight from the Horse’s Heart late last June (very apt here):
Flip your cigarette on the beach sand and die!
I had sergeant in the Army that was almost that mean about butts, but….
The chief culprits may seem to be in BP, but I say he is in the White House. Pres. Barack Obama chose Ken Salazar, Sec’y of Interior, to whom the Chief of the Mining and Minerals agency reported. That agency approved the licensing of BP to drill and was responsible for inspecting its operation.
Obama declared, weeks before the explosion, that the deep-water drilling technology was now safe. Obama and his Attorney General should be prosecuting executives at BP for negligently causing the murder of the eleven workers who died on the rig. Others should be prosecuted as well, for example Salazar and his M&M agency Chief.
Obama does not prosecute torturers and murderers. He cannot because Obama is permitting the torture of others, by renditions. Obama is murdering others, by unnecessary warfare that kills civilians more than combatants.
Barack Obama is the enemy of justice at home and abroad. He should be the target of our contempt.
Great to see you in the threads. For those of us who had the pleasure of meeting you before this dang NN10 thing became all the rage.
Here’s something from the last century.
Thanks, sadly.
I gonna add Salazar to the most-disgusting twerp list as his slime has oozed far enough “upwards” of late, on a number of deceits, to warrant this elevation from minor minion scum status to the “BIG” time ..
Odd, that Bee Pee is always involved.
Must be coinkidinks.
DW
Thanks. I wondered what the real story was with those horses. Heckuva job Ken Salazar rides again!! Neigh!!
Pinal County Sheriff: Obama near ‘borderline’ of treason
Read more: http://www.azcentral.com/12news/news/articles/2010/07/23/20100723pinal-county-babeu-president-treason.html#ixzz0uZWDDS5k
Remember the Mobil Oil logo of Pegasus, the Flying Horse?
Time don’t fly after all…
Hey OFG!
Sure!! And bho is the main target of my contempt, but My contempt for this entire admin knows no bounds. So I have enough contempt left over for Salazar.
isn’t that the same sheriff that mccain did that walk along the border fence ad with?
The flying red horse?
Of course.
Was it Sinclair that had the green dinosaur?
DW
These “people” are really out there, aren’t they?? I can’t stand bho either, but these types are really sick mofos.
brontosaurus, I think.
Yeah a Dino… How subtle.
I am not sure. He is the Pinal County Sheriff which just south of Maricopa County, Phoenix’s county.
Not sure if it was him or Joe Arpaio – another “fine” AZ sheriff.
He is a crazy.
its the same guy
Ohgawd, come to think of it, that’s really sick. You know, Paul Simon thought of his song Mother and Child Reunion when he was eating a Chinese dish of chicken and eggs.
The Pima County (Tucson) sheriff is against SB 1070.
I found the item on Yahoo news from July 6, about two weeks ago. There have been no developments since then. The only thing it says about BP is:
It just says he’s got the goods on BP and some unidentified relationship with the El Paso entity. But that’s it. Nothing to hang one’s hat on, I’m afraid.
That’s what sticks in me mind, Christine.
My, how times have changed (‘though not so much recently, say the last decade or so, we seem to be stuck in a mindless “place”).
DW
There all gross. Btw I recently got to hear in person AZ state rep John Kavanaugh “defend” SB 1070. What a smug pos liar he is but sort of smooth in a sleazy way. Really thinks very highly of himself & the bs he was peddling.
And “we” don’t “do” subtlety any longer (it’s all much shorter, now).
;~DW
No, it is just what I saw at the 1962 New York World Fair. The Sinclair pavilion. Big. Green. Bronto.
Folks in Tucson are closer to the border & are much cleare about the facts. And they are dealing much more directly with the MX drug cartel war. SB 1070 will only waste $$$$ needed for the real problems being faced at the border…. And it ain’t illegal nannies making cheap wages.
Tee hee… Still fwiw the Dino was kinda amusing in a sick kind of way.
And all I ever saw were a few signs … and then Sinclair got et, or sumthin.
And then, Esso became Exxon …
And then … we learned about Big. As in oil “spills” …
Fortunately, everything is now oil right.
DW
Yep.
hey larue — how’s sac tonight?
I keep trying to post “There Will Be Blood & 9/10ths” but it won’t post.
Doin Well Sistah!
Really well!
Pickin, grinnin, cookin, and headed into A Grand Saturday!
*G*
hmm…
hey aitchd — how ya doing tonight?
OFG is a hoss, good to see you step up and acknowledge.
*bows*
Hey Sweetie! I’m feeling wonderful! Was doing just all right until you asked. You doing okay?
Stop! Just STOP! I mean STOP this insanity!
STOP IT!
Yer killin me.
*G*
i am — most folks have moved upstairs to late late nite and letting our hair down a wee bit — come on upstairs and join in
You often amaze hoss . . .
*G*
Whenever I lurk at your fine place, I don’t get any of the refs because I never watch any TV.
Here I come anyway…
Who are you calling a gnome? ;-)
No, I passed up NN this year… actually have for the past couple of years now, but I considered attending this year since it’s a short flight away.
I went to the first one in Vegas, and my main memory is waking up to a blazingly bright sun unexpectedly shining into my room at 4:30 or thereabouts in the morning.
BP just wanted the over stressed workers to get a good nights sleep?
Cousin “ID” running wild……