If ever a town earned the right to perpetual panic, New Orleans is it. The people of New Orleans face the economic and environmental consequences of the BP oil spill before they’ve fully recovered from Katrina. I’ve been spending a good amount of time in New Orleans lately, and panic is the last thing on the minds of New Orleanians.
On Frenchmen Street, a two-block circus of music and bars not far from the Quarter, a young street poet bangs away at his spontaneous verse on an old Royal typewriter and recites them for tips. He came to New Orleans from D.C. to work as an ambulance driver. A city hiring freeze left him a lot of time to write. But he’s not panicked. He was, I promise, happy, if in a bluesy kind of way.
I don’t meet many happy people in politics these days. I’m not sure I meet any. In the political arena, panic is everywhere. On the Right, there’s panic about zombie communism. Maybe we should shorten the name of this ultimate straw-bogeyman to zommunism. Anyway, On the Left, there’s panic about undead fascism. Those not panicked about being sold out are panicked about being accused of being sellouts.
One of Austin’s greater slacker rituals used to be the annual North Austin/South Austin tug-o-war called the “Tug of Honor.” A big rope was strung across the Colorado River, and hundreds of beer-drinking partisans lined up on their side of the river, grabbed the rope and tugged. At some point, one side or the other tumbled into the river. Now, we are much too panicked for that sort of revelry. But there’s another point here.
If you’ve ever been on the losing side in a tug-o-war, you know that moment of panic when your team is overpowered, its mutual footing lost. There’s a kind of oh-my-god panic. Somehow, in our current political circumstance, all sides seem to be having such a moment at the same time. The laws of physics hint that that shouldn’t be possible.
I’m not talking about earnest engagement and advocacy, about the moral courage to advance the causes one believes in. Not all political disagreement falls into the panic mode. Still, and don’t panic at this, I think political ideology is usually, if not always, thin and two-dimensional. Our ideological wars beat with dry if frenzied hearts. The point is, some of our humanity is lost when it’s Certainty versus Certainty on the political playing field. We all loose the resources we use to cope with hope and heartache in our everyday lives.
I can almost never remember today the thing that made me panic day before yesterday. That’s not exactly right. It’s better to say I can almost never work myself into a panic today over the thing that panicked me day before yesterday.
Some symptoms of panic: a fear that all is lost when something is lost; an absolute, religious faith in one’s own judgment; the taking of political setbacks personally; repeated lashing out at those who disagree with us; the certainty that the world (or democracy, or America, or something) will not survive if one’s view does not prevail immediately.
Now, I believe democracy is at risk these days. I think America is fast becoming a kind of purple plutocracy. Corporations are persons, legal entities with no accountability. Corporations are the new humans, above the people and beyond the checks and balances. In this there is great danger. (By the way, if corporations are persons, isn’t it fair to describe Big Insurance as psychopathic? Wikipedia says, “Psychopathy is a personality disorder characterized by an abnormal lack of empathy combined with strongly amoral conduct, masked by an ability to appear outwardly normal.” I rest my case.)
But reason to panic doesn’t mean we should panic. Cable news lives to keep us on the edge of panic. What was once NightLine is now Once-A-Minute Line. Everything is urgent, from the Hollywood fall-from-grace (nothing is less urgent than Mel Gibson), to a traffic pileup. America was panicked into war over Saddam’s weapons of mass destruction. I rest another case.
I’m with the street poets of New Orleans, and there’s no such thing as a poem written in panic. Or a good law, either.



85 Comments












Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
GLENN!!
“Laws’ and “physics” are words I’ve never applied to politicians. I went to watch the tug-o-war once though when a boyfriend was competing. I’m glad I made him bring a change of clothes so he didn’t get my car seat all wet! :)
Sometimes what we is doing is fighting over resources in contests that decide whether we will have food, clothing & shelter, work or enforced idleness, life or death. In that light, our contests are not exactly all about fine points of ideology. Somnetimes they are about survival.
But if the larger point is that we should make a habit of civility and never for get to celebrate, then yeah, I am down with that.
Oh, thank you Glenn. We can be aware of the evils of this world, but it’s just not healthy to allow panic to rule our lives. We weren’t built to endure it.
Your story of the poet reminds me of this song Why should I be discouraged?
Maybe because I have anxiety attacks, I’m inclined to think that the left has not taken seriously enough the kind of danger poised by the radical right. These are people who routinely tell lies, and those lies are repeated by too many other careless non-thinkers. When some one here seriously comments that Barney Frank is guilty of ‘social engineering’, I know we’re not talking to rational people. But they do vote. I’ll hold onto the worry beads.
Good morning, Glenn. When did Americans become people who panic? I keep trying to remember because there was no panic at all during WW2. My mind keeps going back to the assassination of JFK. Something died along with him that day, something safe and good about the country. We haven’t coped well since then and it gets worse every day.
Watching the Republicans block and water down legislation and watching the Democrats allow them to do so time after time with barely a whimper has put me pretty firmly in the throw the bastards out caucus until very recently. Last week, I didn’t really have the heart to read and keep up with the news, much less comment on it, it’s been so bad for so long.
Lately though, I’m more of the opinion that I’m marginally less inclined to reward the Republicans for their insane, destructive behavior just because I want to punish Democrats for their crappy, weak kneed behavior. Because in our system, punishing one always equals rewarding the other. It sucks ass and I hate it but hating it doesn’t change it. The only thing more galling than proving Rahm Emanuel right is allowing the same people who drove us into this ditch to be put back in charge to dig us in deeper. Feeble though it is, at least some attempt is being made to get us out of it now.
Democrats aren’t going to grow a spine or become less corrupt without some kind of major, fundamental change in our system. The same can be said about the inevitable result that punishing one party will always lead to gains by the other. The Republicans aren’t going to stop obstructing or behaving irrationally until there are some kind of consequences that are bad for them. Rewarding them by giving them power back will only encourage them to further enrich their patrons and allies by stripping the little remaining wealth from the middle class and they will be in more of a position to do so.
That’s my opinion and I’m certain there are people who will argue with it. I’m not happy with it myself. Like I said, our system sucks ass but the best we can do is attempt to make it work for us. Four steps backward is never worth one step forward. Punishing the Democrats won’t make them take the right lesson about the way they treat Progressives, we know that. I’m not ready to jump on the partisan bandwagon and I probably never will be but I think putting the Republicans back in charge either proactively or through apathy isn’t the answer. I don’t know what that answer is but I think I have a pretty good handle on what it isn’t.
Ruth I share your concern and frustration with what appears to the lack of serious attention to the power of the primitive pull of the conservatives. I really don’t know how seriously the Democratic leadership of all wings take the threat. I know the MSM has been and continues to be so destructive in painting even the craziest of their talk and candidates as equivalent to serious discourse.
I think my greatest sense of panic comes from the fear that I will be transformed by fear and rage to take up their style. I echo arcadesproject at #3
I want to defeat them with my tools.
Well said.
I concur about the loss of JFK and loss of trust, optimism, trust. Almost as if the national depression never completely lifted. Thank you for the reminder.
It’s the larger point. We can and should approach even life or death or liberty or death moments with more equanimity (not acceptance or passivity, but calm determination) and less panic.
sounds like fun. i wish i would have gotten out more in the 90′s.
AS FOR the “politics of panic”…im way beyond that personally, i’ve moved on to the politics of despair. The politics of panic are for those who still have enough hope to panic. I dont think the next stage for moi will be the politics of acceptance however, im planning for the politics of revenge.
It is too hot in New Orleans to panic. I was there a week ago. I didn’t panic once. But when I got home….
Jessie Coulter!!! Perfect song for these thoughts….
Difficult choice, isn’t it? I feel the same as you and I go back and forth in my mind constantly. I will vote for Boxer because she has done some things that I like and Carly just scares me. I also will vote for my rep Jackie Speier because she’s really good. Brown most definitely – eMeg is a mess. My problem is going to occur in 2012. Guess I’ll have to wait and see what happens.
Exactly so.
What about the role of poltical blogs in this?
I do believe we can avoid having to become transformed into them and yet be stronger in our confrontation of just what their words and actions represent. The best, virtually only, example of that was Rachel Maddow’s Ron Paul dissection.
Most of us (me included) don’t have her skill but I think we can do better than just say “that is a difference in opinion” Instead perhaps, “You may believe that sincerely but the fact of applying that belief without reason is ….thus.” IOW confront, confront, confront!
That isn’t to say we should stop pressing any of them to do the right thing. I’ll keep supporting more progressive candidates over establishment Democrats because shaming the latter obviously doesn’t do any good.
Ruth, just the fact that you reflect upon your reaction says there’s no panic there. Worry beads are handy! And, just to repeat (often) the point, the alternative to panic is not blindness or passive acceptance. Gandhi and King never panicked. Neither has the Dalai Lama. Good role models.
Fortunately we can kick decisions on the Presidency down the road. I hope somebody seriously challenges him from the left!
You know it was really the loss of all of the great liberal leaders in such a short time.. I asked someone the other day “where are the great liberal leaders?” His answer was “they killed them.”
Word. When I meet with people who don’t want to vote for the Dems, I ask them to try donating to http://www.publicampaign.org if voting makes them queasy, as for most of them (aside from the Ralph-the-Leninist types who really do want the GOP to win on the idea that they’ll wreck things faster than the Dems will, thus causing Americans steeped in over a century of focus-group-tested demonizing of Marxism to suddenly become fervent Commies) their problem isn’t with the system but the money that corrupts it.
Provocative question, oldgold.
There’s no general answer. Raw assertiveness without regard for context and the long view can be a symptom of panic, and it can breed more panic. Certainly, there are some in the blogosphere who suffer from that.
I’ve noticed many times that traffic and comments can be increased by it, too, so the temptation is always there.
But investigative reporting and keen analysis, along with tough opinion journalism, can be signs of healthy determination AND concern for a reasoned and passionate approach.
To me, it remains an open question whether the immediacy and minute-by-minute news cycling is inhibiting a certain thoughtfulness. I do think that’s a danger.
Shorter Glenn, for those who think he’s just telling us to ignore bad things:
Although I don’t normally think this way, those deaths in such a short period of time make me start looking for my tinfoil hat.
Hey Girlfriend! I like the direction you’re taking with your new perspective. It’s a much healthier purview, imho.
Heading out to enjoy the day. All y’all take care of yourselves and each other.
And, thanks again, Glenn, for your words and time.
I have serious problems with both the system and the money that corrupts it of course but once again, putting the Republicans back in the driver’s seat strikes me as throwing gasoline on your house when it’s on fire because you’re pissed off at the fire department for taking so long to start fighting it.
The one who had a real chance at transforming our nation was Robert Kennedy.
Enjoy your day Deb. :)
In the run-up to WWII, American conservatives re-learned the power of fear and panic in propaganda. Post-war, the technical tools available to do that were also greatly enhanced. Though it took time, Americans were able to overcome the Right’s propaganda effort re: Vietnam protests and civil unrest and move decisively against an unjust war. Decades later, though, we’ve lost some of that ability, I fear. The responsibility for a restoration of a kind of calm independence among the people falls by default to the Left, because the Right wins by creating panic.
My theory is that once we defined “America” as only the geographic entity made by the 50 states, and decided that what it was all about was pursuit of the Benjamins, a corporate dystopia was inevitable. Not that making a buck wasn’t always a healthy part of our experience- but once that’s all that matters, Democracy doesn’t stand a chance. However, my constant panic is muted somewhat by the observation that the new generation is starting to understand that run-away consumerism and the winner-take-all mentality of our generation is a dead-end.
Beautiful. It’s going on my wall. Thanks, Phoenix Woman.
Well the heat is definitely rising in the south. Perhaps whole BP event has been a tipping point. The young people are even writing hip-hop songs about the corporate control of life in the United States. This one is just an example: Sorry Aint Enough No More (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZCTn9tqU-mE )
Wow! A Frank Herbert fan? Or just “Dune”?
That’s a great song!
Me too. And also the fact that in practice it worked.
That is great news! Get it into the music.
Those deaths, plus Kent State. There’s not enough tin foil…
Good to know that I’m not alone. The consequences have been massive.
THAT’S where I remember that from! Thank you, I was scratching a hole in my scalp. It’s been so long. I’m a bigger Frank Herbert in general fan than I am a strictly Dune fan though.
Our political classes are having a tug of war with reality. Reality is starting to win, not that they will ever admit it.
I’m getting a bit sick of perpetually losing, not so good for the psyche. With that i bid concern adieu.
“Look at my king all dressed in red.-
I-KO, I-KO, un-day, I bet-cha five dollars he’ll
kill you dead. —Jock-a-mo fee na-ne.-
I am not panicked, but I am annoyed. Demanding legislation be slightly more progressive than the most conservative precincts of some Blue Dog Corporate Democrat somehow makes me an immature and unserious lefty blogger who simply does not understand the incrementalist approach to policy.
I agree.
“Few men are willing to brave the disapproval of their fellows, the censure of their colleagues, the wrath of their society. Moral courage is a rarer commodity than bravery in battle or great intelligence. Yet it is the one essential, vital quality of those who seek to change a world which yields most painfully to change.”
Robert F. Kennedy
If he were here today he would be really disappointed with our callous treatment of the dispossessed that he tried so hard to reach and include in our society. And undoubtedly, he would also be disappointed in the degradation of the mission of our political system. The Kennedys believed public service was a noble act that was the responsibility of every citizen. Today, it is a sordid circus serving selfish interest and powerful corporate elites.
We have learned that the powerful are willing to sacrifice America and its citizens in ways unimaginable. Unfettered capitalism has bound us with the rope of our own human nature and we are fully trapped. You would think there was a grand plan. But adept psychopaths can suck the energy out of every opportunity presented. They move from one open wound to another. It cannot last. Either the golden goose will be dead or the tipping point will be reached. The BP tragedy may be it. Or it could be the “trimming” of Social Security by the Melamine Cat Food Commission.
Re-imagine the world today, if RFK had won in 1968.
Oh, exactly. And “heightening the contradictions” didn’t work in 1930s Germany, with a population that was far less indoctrinated against Marxism than ours. (It didn’t work in 2000 America, either.)
I hate to go there but I just realized Glenn pulled away some of my own defense to panic. As most of you all know I live in a gun culture of largely information diminished evangelical Christians. The county votes 90% GOP. At primary voting when I asked for a Democratic ballot I was told by the poll worker that I didn’t want that and handed a GOP ballot.
I have slowly given into fear of them. I have stopped provocative bumper stickers (after several were pulled off) and even at the old folks luncheons and dinners I speak only of lake levels.
I recall when W was elected the second time almost feeling relief that he won because I was afraid of the guns.
In summary perhaps we must accept that in certain parts of the country we really are living under oppression through fear?
Yup. All Glenn’s saying is to let your annoynance motivate you, not paralyze you.
Even with all that fear and propaganda, Republicans still fell short by about twenty points. You took a huge jump and leapt clean over the “southern strategy” where actively recruiting racists into the republican party, coupled with joining with the “Talibangelicals” on social issues closed the gap. Both of these two groups gain sustenance from fear of “the other.” If they believe we have a Kenyan Usurper using Black Panthers and illegal immigrants to staff ACORN to build a machine out of torn up American flags held together by aborted fetuses and fueled by a faggy Chardonnay to elect Democrats, then well, it could mean trouble.
No problem there. I kicked in $500 to fdl’s beat Blanche campaign, only to be told by an unnamed *cough* Rahm *cough* administration official that I had flushed my money down the toilet. So I put fdl on my permanent payroll with a monthly stipend.
Mostly just Dune, as I feel that the Law of Diminishing Returns kicked in pretty hard thereafter; also, it got a bit harder to take the basis of his imagined universe (namely, the Butlerian Jihad) seriously, as Moore’s Law in the real world showed that a) Herbert’s fears about AI were pretty much groundless, and b) Herbert’s 1960s-era belief that humans could be made via biological means to exceed any computer in terms of computational power didn’t take into account the lightning-fast speed of AI’s evolution.
AND THE KILLIN’ GOEZ ON AND ON AND…
Citizen Glenn W. Smith and the Firepup Freedom Fighters:
“I think political ideology is, usually if not always, thin and two dimensional.”
I’m not certain where you meant to go with this today, Brother Glenn, but let me just say that the fear and terror experienced today comes from an absense of ideology, a response to politics that has been conditioned by hammering over and over again the lie that all politics, politicians and ideologies are the same and are bad. The absense of a set of ideas that helps to frame and understand what you experience is basic to a rational life and certainly necessary if human beings are going to ultimately survive on this planet.
Last week, Mrs. Norske and I met with our broker that handles the small family trust we have and this beautiful, 30ish snotty nosed go-getter tried to give us a lesson in the physiology of the economy and wrote on the smart-board that all economies are driven by fear and greed. Nowhere did she mention the activities that create products or services needed to sustain life in the social group. What she was really describing was the political ideology of corporate fascism. When seen in 2 dimensions, her description of the physiology of capitalist economy is very understandable until you introduce the rest of the anatomy.
No, Brother Smith, we are all citizens of New Orleans and we are all desperately tryin’ to make sense of our experience in order to pull each other away from the void that looms in front of us. Ideology is NOT bad, and it is certainly not two dimensional if it succeeds in being a real ideology that makes sense of collective experience through an internal consistentcy.
Thanks for the testimony today Citizen, and remember we are all in this together if you remind yourself that we are all destined for the same place anyway.
KEEP THE FAITH AND PASS THE AMMUNITION, THIS WAR WILL GO ON WITHOUT YOU SO YOU MIGHT AS WELL FIGHT!!
Can we still say the Dreams still lives? I guess we must.
Didn’t mean to diminish the Right’s exploitation of racism. They did it then, they are doing it now. In fact, I have great frustration with mainstream pundits who underplay the role of racism, crediting the Tea Party with “legitimate policy concerns” when in their hearts they know there would be no Tea Party if Obama was white.
At least the truth sill lives.
It would be a disservice to those who have worked so hard for many years for us to just throw up our hands and quit. We can’t and I suspect that we couldn’t even if we wanted to. Progressives are stubborn. :)
You help us clarify important points. I think I should have said “absolutist” ideologies, at least, because you are right about a certain post-modern erasure of political meaning. I think there’s a difference between the kind of ideologies I describe as thin — a catalog of -isms” and deep worldviews, which we need like air.
Can you believe CNN’s response to that Mark Miller and his piece of obscenity?
Seems Norske is showing the difference between ideology and tribalism as it relates to human political activity. Some cheer and defend their team with complete disregard of ideology. Those who do that are unmoored from principles and are reduced to slack-jawed fanboy lickspittles.
Were you able to school the snotty nosed go-getter?
I am so tired of hearing the notion that “What do you expect? Corporations are supposed to look at their bottom line and make money no matter what.” WTF? Aren’t corporations made up of humans? Should we demand better? After all, we did give them personhood.
Thanks, Glenn. Excellent post.
Indeed, I have no doubt that we would be far better off. I feel so sorry for the young people today who never had RFK and his kind as role models, the “best” the most of them have ever seen is Bill Clinton and Reagan. Pity.
Thanks, Twain, and, as usual, thank you for your probing, insightful comments.
They haven’t killed me …
yet,
Slackjaw Jezebel
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QGBDsTPq9SQ
Smooth action.
Evidentally this smart ass adviser must have graduated from the Gordon Gekko School of Dysfunctional Economics. Sheesh.
Ditto to what Twain said, Glenn. My comment was not meant as a criticism, I always enjoy your work here. I just never let an opportunity go by to point out the racist history of the Republican party.
Great! Great Song!
Didn’t take it as criticism, Oilfieldguy, just agreeing that as a shaping force of the decline Twain asked about, racism should have been mentioned prominently. Thanks.
“….it’s just not healthy to allow panic to rule our lives ….”
Politics does not so much drive me to panic as fill me with dispair.
Thank you, they wrote it about me.
I am honored and awed to know.
” I don’t know what that answer is …..”
The democratic party can be hijacked by the left just as the republicans were hijacked by the social conservatives 30 years ago. Missing from the agenda is patience. We can not change anything in one election cycle.
The battle worth fighting in 2010 is not Congress. It is the state legislatures. It is the state legislatures that will lord over the re-districting that inevitably follows the 2010 census. And it is re-districting that will determine the electoral map for the next decade.
The social conservatives gained ascendency by taking over the republican party at the precinct level. Notably, an old friend recently was elected “democratic committee person” with two write in votes because few dems cared enough to show up.
I’m not panicking.
Non attachment / Non disinterest
This is how the corporatists operate, same here. I am not the dem party, I have no reason to defend them.
Well, that’s certainly the battle I’m fighting this year.
I think this is the best and likely only long term solution. We could learn much from the right wing take over of the GOP. (I was there as a liberal Republican) I have since been trying with our local Democratic Party but despaired in the past two years.
Can you vote by mail?
Have you reported it to the proper authorities? That sounds like voting fraud to me, a very serious crime.
Fear is a very powerful motivator. It also wears out.
It is a bull shit excuse to cover up very serious crimes.
Wow, thank you. So far I have mostly been met with claims I am delusional for thinking so. Your kind words mean a lot to me.
Yes we can vote by mail but we have early voting at the polls also which is when this happened. On an informal poll of friends it was not exclusive to me and in at least one other county. I did report it to the SOS office and the ACLU. I am dinner friends with the Chairmen of the Board of Elections of both counties. I also complained to them and received the explanation that they were just trying to remind voters that they could only vote for one party candidates.
A part of a leader’s job is to stand on the high ground and see the dangers approaching from afar. He might panic for a moment, but then there’s the job of raising the public to the tasks to prepare and eventually to meet the dangers. Rarely is there cause to panic the public, only to control and use their energy to fight.
America is a great and powerful country and we face dangers continuously, sometimes with glee. The doomsayers may think “it’s over”, but there have always been those and we’re still chugging along the way we always have.
America has gone from a backwater colonial farmland to a great technological scientific political economic leader and we can only fantasize what our future might be. For now we have to work through the difficulties to clear the path for our public, our nation to be great.
I felt that way during Dubya’s reign too. But, to have a poll worker actually tell you how to vote is beyond the pale.
or the Michael Milken Advanced Placement Program. sheesh!
Somehow the pressure for ever increasing rates of return is pushing our corporate economic system and markets to the breaking point. So much so that they try to influence changes in law as never before.
If the pressures on corporate leaders remained constant and they stayed out of lawmaking then we might have a level of comfort we could handle.