Remember when I talked last Saturday about Minnesota Republican gubernatorial candidate Tom Emmer’s War on the Waitstaff? Remember how his claim that the waiters and waitresses at a particular St. Paul eatery made $100,000 a year was debunked by one of the joint’s owners?
Well, guess what — Emmer’s still repeating that debunked claim, this time to a friendly audience, the Republican Jewish Coalition (skip ahead to the 4:30 mark):
Tom Emmer speaks to fundraiser
Uploaded by cptned.
If any of the Democrats in the race — Margaret Kelliher, Mark Dayton, or Matt Entenza — said something as blatantly wrong (not to mention nutty) as this, it would be described as such on the front page of both local papers and be a big story in local newscasts for weeks, and none of the Dems would have dared repeat it, even in front of a friendly group. Dayton in particular is someone who has been tarred as a nutcase even as Republicans like Emmer, Dick Day and Michele Bachmann get comparatively gentle media treatment. (Kinda like how Eliot Spitzer is “disgraced”, but Newt Gingrich and David Vitter aren’t as far as the Corporate GOP/Media Complex is concerned. But I digress.)
Speaking of Diaper Dave Vitter, Emmer’s story seems to get changed about as often as a newborn’s nappies; after Emmer released his alleged “fact-check” claiming that he really doesn’t think servers make $100,000 and that he doesn’t back cutting their wages, Alliance for a Better Minnesota released its own, accurate fact-check (here’s the PDF version that’s designed to be printed out and handed out to waitstaff), that absolutely detonated Emmer’s claims. But so far, the media entities most likely to notice this, much less highlight this (the Strib’s Jon Tevlin aside), are the bloggers:
MN Publius’s Zack Stephenson was the first to notice that Emmer was still reciting the $100,000 myth to select audiences even after he’d kinda-sorta recanted it to the general public. (It’s rather odd to me that the video, which was posted by conservative blogger “Captain” Ed Morrisey of Captain’s Quarters, hasn’t been pulled or apparently even edited yet; as Sally Jo Sorensen of Bluestem Prairie notes, Emmer’s associates are known for being awfully quick to scrub online media they control.) Stephenson’s colleague Jeff Rosenberg has noted both that Emmer’s been trying to finesse his statements about servers, and that servers are, far from being filthy rich, in the lowest-paid occupation in the state of Minnesota. (Oh, and Rosenberg points out that waitstaff aren’t the only working-class people on whom Emmer’s making war: As governor, Tom Emmer would sign a bill that would cut the minimum wage.)
Flash of the Centristy blog was one of the persons attending Emmer’s attempt to make nice with waitstaff for the cameras at Cafe de Ol’ Mexico last Wednesday. As the event wore on and the servers refused for the most part to play his game, one Emmer supporter was heard by Flash muttering “What is he doing….this is a catastrophe”.
Spotty of The Cucking Stool notes that not only did Emmer get an earful from angry servers, he also got a “tip” — in the form of two thousand pennies — from Robert Erickson, who we’ve met before as the gent who poses as an anti-European-immigration activist to tweak the GOP in general (and Tom Emmer in particular). Erickson, who is the working persona of Nick Espinosa, was, ahem, escorted out of Ol’ Mexico before he could say to Emmer: “Your attacks on the minimum wage for working people make about as much sense as your crusade against the hard working immigrants who are a vibrant part of our community.” Erickson knows, as do the folks at SEIU Local 26, that the issues of living wages and immigration are tied together, as sweatshop lords — be they restaurateurs or factory owners — count on having a steady supply of workers whose precarious legal status makes them readily exploitable; giving these workers full legal rights means making it harder for crooked employers to screw them. Erickson’s offered to meet face-to-face with Emmer to talk about this and other issues, but — after agreeing to do so — Emmer did another of his 180s, much to Erickson’s disgust:
After urging me to “have a little courage” to talk to you face to face, it seems you have again changed your mind. By now, Minnesota and the nation have a clear view of your two-faced ways.
You say I ran out the back door, when really I was shoved out by your security. You say you want to talk, but refused the invitation to a community meeting with those affected by your policies.
[...]
Wages for wait staff isn’t the only place you waver. You have waffled about your position on the Arizona’s controversial immigration law SB1070. First you praised it on MPR as a “wonderful first step”, then, in a recent interview you backpedaled and failed to answer whether or not you would support bringing similar measures to Minnesota.
Before the Ol’ Mexico meltdown on Wednesday, Emmer had tried another another stunt, this one involving waiting on tables, at the same restaurant on Monday. As Joe Bodell of the Minnesota Progressive Project says, critiquing a WCCO-TV story on the subject:
What the WCCO report doesn’t tell you is that Ol’ Mexico, the restaurant where Emmer shadowed a waiter, is owned by one Elizabeth Pavlick. Ms. Pavlick donated $250 to Tom Emmer’s gubernatorial campaign on December 31st, 2009. You can find her name on page 19 of Emmer’s year-end 2009 CFB report.
Funny how that works.



14 Comments












Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
G’morning, everyone! I actually remembered to make coffee last night, so I’ve got some brewing. Sugar and Splenda are on the counter and cream and fake cream are in the fridge.
Good Morning, PW, Firepups.
So the wait staff in St. Paul are only getting $100 G’s / year? I was thinking it was a cool million. I must have screwed up a decimal. Time for new glasses.
I wasn’t really familiar with this dirtbag Emmer until now. Put a bag on his head and he could pass for my congressman, who I hope is summarily ejected in November, gerrymandered district to the contrary notwithstanding.
Mornin’, PW, pups
I’m waiting for Rick Scott to pull the same kinda stunt here in FL. He tried to have the courts find the “Millionaire’s Amendment” unconstitutional so that his opponent, McCollum, wouldn’t receive any public funds to offset the $20M+ Scott has spent trying to buy the FL governorship.
Hi PW,
Thanks for the link to the Alliance fact check sheet. I mentioned this story to the waitstaff at a local restaurant here in Ohio. I felt it was important for people in all states to talk about this story because if it is a story that gets feet in the Midwest, it will become a national concern in the future.
The staff at the restaurant were shocked that a candidate would base their pitch for lowering minimum wage on a few wait staff salaries.
I recommend that people print off the Alliance fact sheet and pass it off to any waitstaff you know. The waitstaff of the nation need to track this story because it will become the bigger story of lowering the national minimum wage eventually.
Bless you! Yes, please pass this on! This info is useful across the nation, as Wars on the Waitstaff aren’t confined to Minnesota.
This really irritates me. Who cares if a server makes $100,000 a year? Should only CEOs and politicians make a lot of money? I thought the American ideal was to work hard and earn a good living. If you do it serving people, how is that any less valid than being a doctor or lawyer?
Emmer’s talking point is really about class warfare. He seems to be campaigning against working class people. Maybe, because of all of the offshoring of manufacturing jobs, bashing unions and blue-collar workers doesn’t have the cachet it once did. I guess now the focus needs to be tearing apart service workers since the service industry is about all that’s left of our economy.
There’s also more than a hint of Southern Strategy about it, as a lot of these jobs are held by nonwhites, many of them undocumented workers. As with advocating lower taxes and lower spending on social programs, bashing low-wage workers is a way to bash nonwhites for political gain and get away it.
I keep thinking, “there’s no way these wingnuts can get any worse,” and then they whip out something else to prove me wrong. Just incredible.
Sorry for the semi-OT post but I lost my internet access at home last night and can’t log on at my leisure to wait for an open thread.
Mrs. JP got laid off last night and, with my UI benefits expiring and the Senate not doing shit last week re: an extension, we are truly, truly fucked and facing eviction. Anything anyone could do would be greatly appreciated. There aren’t even any homeless shelters here.
Hell, if waitstaff makes $100,000 a year (based on $2.63 an hour), tell me where those jobs are!
,
Don’t think this is correct,
I think you would find that forgotten class of workers, musicians, are by far the lowest paid workers, in Minnesota, or anywhere else in North America.
It is not possible to even have a place to live on musician’s pay these days.
I listen to KFAN sports out of the twin cities; two of their hosts (Barrero and ” common man Dan Cole” have covered this story extensively, and were firmly on the side of the waiters. as were the majority of their callers.
yes. workers should know their place. they have no right to more than …….. dollars.
some People are also upset with the pay that star athletes get. they calculate the amount baseball players get per swing of the bat.
the fact that these athletes are doing things few can……. doesn’t matter.
brainwashed. divided and conquered.
I’m tell ya, these dems are just like Yassar Arafat…He never passed up an opportunity to pass up an opportunity and neither do the liberals.
I’m to the point now that I’m kinda hopin’ that the dems get their butts kicked by the rethuglicants in Nov. and maybe, just maybe, they will learn how to play hardball with the batshit crazy conservatives. But if history is any guide, they will probably just ask the rethugs if they want a reach around while they are tossin’ those rethuglicant crackers salad…
But musicians aren’t exactly critical to the economy….
Emmer looks like your standard Republican white male: jowls and puffy red face. It’s like a uniform or something. Radio jock Lars Larson is, to me, the quintessential Republican pot-bellied white man. He’s the standard for all the rest. You also have to be a hunter, and eat lots of red meat to prove you are a real man. Lots of Dems are like this, as well, but Repubs have cornered the market on this look and act.
Do they go to school for it, or something?