This is the party whose endorsed candidate for governor, Tom Emmer, has called SB 1070 — Arizona’s infamous Show Us Your Papers law — “a wonderful first step”. This is also the party that is trying to push copycat legislation (HF 3830) through the Minnesota legislature, legislation emulating SB 1070 to please the powerful bigot element among the Republican base.
Now, sane people, such as the fine folks of Minnesota SEIU Local 26, might wonder about how someone could make his considerable fortune off of Hispanic culture while chairing a political party that writes and endorses race-baiting legislation like SB 1070 and HF 3830. But of course to ask that question causes the “balance”-obsessed pearl-clutchers that were trained at our local corporate legacy media to have attacks of the vapors. Case in point: Doug Grow, who was one of the teeming horde of legacy journos from the sinking StarTribune who sought a new home with MinnPost, the Strib’s de facto rest home for old reporters who still wanted some sort of a paycheck, however tiny, that didn’t involve regularly using the words “Do you want fries with that, sir?”. Grow was seemingly aghast that anyone could ever, ever imply that a Nice Polite Republican like Tony Sutton could be a race-baiting hypocrite, much less a straight-up racist: “As far as I know, Sutton never has made a statement on his personal feelings about immigration reform.”
Um, Dougie? Skip ahead to around the 44-second mark of this video and you can hear Tony Sutton’s views on immigration reform. It’s all on tape, with Sutton talking to a radio audience on a conservative talk show, responding to a caller’s question about whether the proposed Federal immigration “amnesty bill” would contain the alleged “seven-year tax holiday” for illegal immigrants. Not only does Sutton not tell the guy that the tax holiday thing is a blatant and obvious lie, he acts as if it’s for real and “an indication of where the Democrats are going”.
In other SEIU-related immigration news, members of various SEIU locals greeted Arizona’a Republican governor Jan Brewer, who championed SB 1070 and signed it into law, during her visit to the White House last week. As SEIU Executive VP Eliseo Medina says, SB 1070 was “largely designed to energize the Republican Party base during primary season at the expense of immigrants. This political gamesmanship will cost her state and local communities dearly in these difficult economic times, but do nothing to solve the immigration crisis.”
Indeed. Republicans, in Arizona, Minnesota and elsewhere, will soon learn that retooling their beloved Southern Strategy to target Latinos as well as African-Americans is not only amoral, but politically ill-advised as well.



35 Comments












Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Good morning, everyone!
I suggest a Boycott of the Restaurant.
I suggest we call INS on his workers if we see a brown face. Why odds are he is hiring some. Like it or not in wars sacrifices have to be made. This joke makes a living off of my people’s food. This Jerk is a Republican he loves money so their is no way he would not go with the cheapest labor force. There is no way he should use our food and our people to put us in chains.
At the very least he should be publicly asked if he has called the Social Security office about his brown workers social security numbers.
He says he doesn’t have any we show cell phone photos. He says they are all legal we point out the Stats in my link.
http://imagine2050.newcomm.org/2009/02/18/don’t-bash-immigrants-with-your-mouth-full/”
My bold!
Ask this jerk if he buys his meat from no immigrant meatpacking and Poultry processing plants.
Look at his meat suppliers and see if INS has ever raided them.
Conservative hypocrisy knows no bounds, partly because it’s not possible to believe in that philosophy without hypocrisy. It’s based on “the rules are for thee and not for me”.
Where does he get his lettuce, his cheese? Just how can he compete in price with other fast food chains without hiring immigrants at his stores and buying immigrant made food?
Also fast food places are soap operas I wonder if he or any of his family who worked there have ever sampled his brown workers.
That would be a scoop and fast food workers gossip.
Time to catch him on that maybe we ask him to sign a pledge not employ or buy food made with immigrant labor.
Thanks for the information, PW.
As I am viewing pol ads from my Senator Russ Feingold, here at FDL the last couple of days, I am worried because people with whom I converse with in person are far too easily saying to me that their election decisions have already been made. Simply throwing all the incumbents out appears to be the flavor of the day.
The seeming lack of any real desire to explore the issues, has me worried about the fate of people like my Senator.
How many time have his brown workers gone to the emergency room at tax payer expense because they had no healthcare? None show me a restaurant chain with no accidents and I will show you a chain not keeping track of accidents.
Or workers who can’t file workmen’s comp claims. Also some fast food chains to save money challenge paying unemployment and I presume workmen’s comp claims in court.
A large immigrant workforce would of course file none of these claims.
Hi I’m in Kenosha now where are you at:)
Indeed! A very, very good suggestion. If you haven’t watched the documentary, “Food, Inc.”, go rent it. It gives graphic insight into the meat packing/processing industry (and will put you off most animal products for life). That industry is run on illegal immigrants, who are actively recruited from Mexico and Central America by the business owners. INS regularly comes around and deports the workers, but the business owners don’t even get the tiniest taps on the wrist.
Where does this MN racist buy the meat he uses in his phoney “Mexican” (because Mexican is trendy and popular and makes him money) restuarants??? Guaranteed the meat comes from packing plants where undocumented workers are routinely recruited openly in Central America and flown into the USA to work illegally for pittance wages by the business owners who suffer no consquences (and get honking rich off the backs of wage SLAVES).
Stuff like this pisses me off, too. Just so sick and tired of Republican hypocrisy; it knows no bounds.
Boycott the restaurants is another recommendation.
There you go.
By the way, Scarecrow has a lovely Seminal piece up on the massive freakout by Prescott, Arizona residents over an elementary school mural where the central figure — a young Hispanic boy — has skin too dark for the tastes of some of the majority-Anglo populace:
Benjamin Disraeli
I’ll see if the library has Food inc:) President Obama should have INS target immigrant foes who make their money off of immigrants and their food suppliers I support immigrants but I cannot support my people working to make a guy rich who wants to oppress my people.
Who I know will use his money to oppress us even more.
That’s why the folks in the know who like Mexican food try to go to locations like Boca Chica (a real Mexican restaurant that’s been around for ages in St. Paul’s Hispanic community) or, if they visit chains, Chipotle (which uses Niman Ranch meat).
I’ve never read Benjamin Disraeli but I certainly agree with that statement. It must be. Without the hypocrisy, the system is counter productive even to it’s adherents.
I don’t think we have Boca Chica in Ca. but I really like the tacos at Chipotle. In fact I like Hispanic food almost any where, any time.
Will all of you pot-banging drama queens that have jumped on the populist bandwagon of “illegal brown is beautiful” and “open borders to everyone” because it’s “so now, so hip and so cool” just stick a sock in it! You’re starting to sound as out of touch that you might just as well be saying “Where’s the beef” or “Here come da judge”.
This country is a sovereign nation with borders and laws that have to be respected – even as others scoff at both them – or we are not the country we claim to be.
Don’t like the federal immigration laws then beat up the laws, not those citizens that respect our country’s sovereignty and abide by it’s laws.
I’m what some might call a “flaming liberal” because I feel for the prediciment of those illegals who have made a life in the US, started families and work hard. But the fact reamins that they ignored our borders and our laws and now we are left to figure out a way of giving them a path to citizenship that does not mock or disrespect the millions upon millions of immigrants who sacrificed and chose to enter our country legally.
And even though you may chose not to accept these facts, AZ’s immigration law is a near mirror image of federal immigration laws. So, mock our country not AZ or the other states that are prepared to act because our own government won’t.
Remember, protect the legal not the scoff laws, that’s the American thing to do…
BOYCOTT!??! In case you haven’t noticed what you peddling is financial extortion and coersion plain and simple.
Where did you learn your politics for change – the Mexican mafia?
That’s right Einstein, boycott AZ or any other state that goes along and put even more people – both legal American AND illegal scofflaws – out of work, that’ll really show ‘em how we feel about enforcing our immigration laws and protecting our sovereign national borders…
We are not the country we claim to be as PW points out the same rich guys who hire immigrants at low wages are also anti immigrant why divide and conquer.
Immigrants who could work legal could leave crappy fast food jobs and get employed elsewhere at hirer wages
the Wage Slave Owners do not want that.
So they manipulate the uneducated mob ( thats you ) into fighting against giving immigrants rights.
Any Free Market Person should see if Immigrants could leave crap jobs that would put upward pressure on wages.
Any Free Market person would also point out that if Immigrants leave then any job they did that can be Outsourced to Mexico would be outsourced to Mexico.
Tyranny needs uneducated and angry, fearful or jealous voters. Democracy needs voters educated on the issues.
We are all descendants of immigrants . Some who came here legally ,some who came illegally and some who came long before there were immigration laws.
I am truly amazed that some people would ignore the fact that their people were immigrants .
My family came here looking for an opportunity to make a better life for themselves , they were no different than the people coming over our southern borders .
This Arizona law is an example of institutional bigotry , meant to single out a specific group of people.
I hope that this law is found to be unconstitutional .
Mesa Mick,
I find your reasoning a little thin, given the existing reality.
I am from Arizona, and have found two things that are interesting to me.
The majority of Hispanic Democrats are opposed to SB 1070.
The majority of white Democrats favor SB 1070.
Now, why is that?
Equally important is the “propaganda pollution”. Take, for example, pro-immigration advocates demonstrate with a five-long parade and consisting of an approximate 20,000 participants. The anti-immigration advocates demonstrate with a gather in a local stadium with an approximate 1,500 participants in attendance.
Consequent, as an pro-immigration advocate, I favor, first and foremost, voter registration. In the meantime and in Arizona, Republicans outnumber the Independents. And the Independents outnumber the Democrats. Thus, as sad state of affairs for Democrats, and Arizona’s Independents do know how to ‘suck up’ to the Republicans, and yet, get nothing in return, other than higher unemployment rates and the assorted behaviors leading cavalier dismissal and abject neglect.
Jaango
Good points, Jaango.
I encourage everyone to see “Food, Inc.” because it not only highlights the hypocrisy surrounding undocumented workers being very forthrightly and openly recruited by US businesses in Central America, but also shows how the onus is ONLY on the illegal workers when INS comes around. Sure, those people probably know that what they’re doing is risky at best, illegal worst. Fine.
But my question to Mesa Mick and others is: WHY is it completely and totally “OK” for US businesses to travel into Mexico and other Central American countries, OPENLY recruit citizens of those nations to work illegally in their companies, PAY to fly those undocumented workers into the USA, and hire them as workers KNOWING that those people are illegal and do not have acceptable working status? And yet, those business owners suffer NO consequence whatsover. None: not even the slightest fine.
WHY is that ok??
AZ businesses also engaged in such practices. Esp the restaurant and hospitality businesses, construction and BigAG. Those companies either recruited and/or knowingly hired undocumented workers when the boom was on. WHY? For the same exact reason that the meat packing industries in the south do. The business owners get RICH by paying illegal workers paltry slave wages, often forcing illegal workers to work under very unsafe conditions. But the Republican business owners get RICH from that knowing that THEY will suffer no consequences for engaging in an illegal activity.
Then when the economy goes into a bust cycle, suddenly all these self-same Republicans get all holier than thou and want pass racist draconian laws that – surprise surprise – ONLY have a negative consequence for the undocumented workers.
Hey: if undocumented workers get caught, then fine. They know the penalty, and so it goes.
But where is there is parity and justice under the law in this case? There simply isn’t.
I’ve said over and over: IF people – whether conservative or liberal – are so allsofired *concerned* about undocumented workers, then go after the businesses that KNOWINGLY recruit and hire these types of workers. There are plenty of laws on the books to go after these businesses, but you will rarely see those laws put into action.
Unless or until I see uniform application of the laws against BOTH the business owners AND the undocumented workers, don’t tell me how *great* the AZ law is. It’s not. It stinks. Plus the AZ law, as it now stands, will only server to DISTRACT the safety officers from doing their job. The problems that currently exist along the border these days have little to do with illegals coming into the USA to find work. Rather the problems these days are with the drug cartels waging war with each other, plus drug and gun running.
Indeed. I only go to Mexican restaurants owned and operated by Mexican Americans. That’s just me, but in general the food is better and more authentic anyway.
But I agree re Chipoltle – pleasantly surpised by the quality of the food. Not that authentic, but healthy. Recommended.
Defintely look for that documentary. It’s very well done, plus there’s a lot in it about how Monsanto is ruining family-run agriculture. A French documentary called “The World According to Monsanto” is also recommended. Eye opening stuff and very instructive.
I’ve known a lot about the perfidy of Monsanto for years, but my very aware leftie friends who saw “Food Inc” with me were amazed by what they learned about Monsanto and what it’s doing to our nation’s food supply (and not happy with what they learned).
Highly recommended.
Just a slight correction, if I may: “Mexican” and “Hispanic” are not the same thing with regards to food and culture.
Great post (as always), PW! Here’s my link to it…
(and get a load of the El Banco de MNGOP 10-peso note!)
http://tildology.com/2010/06/05/el-banco-de-mngop/
Yeah, your certitude on the issue of scofflaws are OK has won me over TCU. I’m a true beliver just like you now.
So, fuck US laws and borders. Give immigrants – even the illegal ones – full citizenship and voting rights. That’ll really show “the man”. Now he will be able to pay slave wages to immigrants and natural born Americans without fear of breaking any laws.
Briliant TCU, your arguments are just funkin’ brilliant.
Where you from anyway, that brown supremist group La Raza? Or are you from LA – Rumor has it that illegal brown is A-OK with their city council because over 50% of LA country is rumored to be populated with card-carrying members of the Rio Grande Swim Club and there is a bill pending that will make Spanish-Only signs mandatory. But that’s OK, according to you TCU obeying the law is an option…
Stop drinking the illegal brown is beautiful koolaid and work to make America a better place for LEGAL immigrants, not just illegal ones. Here’s a concept for you – Reform laws don’t break them just because “you feel the pain” of those that do…
Phoenix Woman et al, one of my sources in Central AZ mentioned the distortion of AZ politics by Mormon Church money and a very organized program not any different than with California’s Prop 8. Please check this out.
Nope next step Immigrants and Natural born Americans get organized and join Unions. :)
The best you got is name calling my remarks about your intelligence were based on the intelligence of your comments. Anyway I do stick up for people who are being oppressed Brown, Black, Gay, Women even White Men.
White Men need to stop looking at poor immigrants as the competition and realize the guys with all the money are keeping us all divided.
Think Hitler blaming the Jews for Germany losing the war and the Great Depression.
Immigrants are a scapegoat and your being played for a sucker.
I am working to change the law which is totally within my rights as a citizen. Obeying laws that oppress people just because its the law is wrong.
Your arguments about lower wages disappear being caused by immigrants disappear when we make them legal so you retreat to the law never mind the reason for the law disappeared too.
Belief in what you want to believe not logic guides you.
Where were you and all the other anti immigrant rule of law people when Bush and Cheney were waterboarding people?