Yet another state circling Bathtub America’s drain:
To close a deficit that he asserted was approaching a staggering $11 billion, [New Jersey Governor Chris] Christie called for the layoffs of 1,300 state workers, closings of state psychiatric institutions, an $820 million cut in aid to public schools, and nearly half a billion dollars less in aid to towns and cities. He also suspended until May 2011 a popular property-tax rebate program, breaking one of his own campaign promises.
Democrats were quick to characterize Mr. Christie’s proposal as falling disproportionately on the backs of the middle class, poor, elderly, schoolchildren, college students and inner-city residents, while leaving largely unscathed the wealthy and most businesses.
(…)
“Today, we are fulfilling the promise of a smaller government that lives within its means,” [Christie] said at a joint legislative session here. “The defenders of the status quo have already begun to yell and scream. They will try to demonize me. They will seek to divide us rather than unite us. But even they know in their hearts, if not yet in their minds — it is time for a change.”
I was going to list all the ways this lean, efficient budget will cut services and increase expenses for the poor and middle class, but I keep coming back to this:
The battle to ensue is likely to shape up around the so-called millionaire’s tax, a one-year income-tax surcharge on people making more than $400,000 that Mr. Christie vowed not to renew. (Democrats allowed it to lapse in December.) If that surcharge were renewed, it would bring in close to $1 billion.
In his speech, Mr. Christie reaffirmed his stance on the issue, saying New Jersey’s tax burden was already the nation’s costliest. “Mark my words today: If a tax increase is sent to my desk, I will veto it,” he said.
That’s the essence of Bathtub America right there: Cutting the education budget so you can eliminate a tax on millionaires. Christie even has the nerve to say that “the watchwords of this budget are shared sacrifice and fairness,” when most of that sacrifice will be borne by ordinary people so that the rich can be spared.
The NYT story points out that this is happening in several states with Republican governors, which makes perfect sense. The “starve-the-beast” strategy isn’t so effective with a federal government that can borrow almost indefinitely, but it works like gangbusters on state governments that have to balance their budgets each year. State-level Republicans simply insist that any tax increases on corporations or wealth would start a job-destroying death spiral, thus making draconian cuts the only option, as deeply regrettable as it might be.
Sure, the government kinda stops working, but everyone knows that the private sector does a much better job anyway. If you can afford it.




52 Comments












Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Eli!
Seems like you’ll have lotsa uses for that exciting new tag, Eli. Sadly.
It’s on it’s way in Georgia.
Egr!
Too true.
Soon, it will be playing everywhere…
Sort of begs the question where they’ll find the other 10 billion. Not that they shouldn’t tax the rich, too, of course.
This is what happens when you don’t go vote. As flawed and bought as the Democratic Party is, the GOP is still far, far worse. Not voting doesn’t get the Democratic Party to listen to progressives, it gets policies like we’re starting to see in Virginia and New Jersey. I don’t have the answers to getting congressional Democrats to be better and more responsive but staying home on election day isn’t it, that I’m sure of.
I was biting my tongue to not start the post off with “This is what happens when you elect a Republican governor…”
Playing in CA:
“The layoff notices are considered preliminary and were part of the more than 23,000 notices sent out statewide by Monday. Final notices will be sent May 15, though not everyone who received a March notice will be laid off. Last year, 60 percent of the 26,000 teachers who received pink slips ended up losing their jobs.
Well whose surprised at this? The voters in NJ had to know that Mr. Christie is a GOPer elitist didn’t they? I didn’t vote for this guy. Figure it out though he’s still wildly popular anyway. Taxes will go up especially property taxes under this guy anyway. Doesn’t matter the Sheeple love him, why? Because, he’s picked his poster child the schools / teacher Unions etc. as the scapegoats and the public loves it. The rich will be victims before this guy is done, mark my words. The poor Rich guys will be canonized by this guy as the creators of all jobs ( even if there in China) no matter its another Reagan redux and its going to work like a charm. NJites like Christie cause he’s a bully and not a wimpy College prof. looking rich guy like Corzine. Corzine was a PR disaster the poor guy just didn’t understand the NJ psyche at all.
No prob Eli. I don’t mind saying it for you. As bad as the Democrats are, being batshit crazy is not the rule for them as it is for the teabagging GOP.
Hadn’t you noticed that they only listen to progressives to find out what not to do?
Of course! It’s hard to miss when people like LIEberman come out and say so. I did point out that I didn’t know how to make Democrats listen to progressive voices. I had thought that the assumption would be that I’m acknowledging that they don’t. Sorry for being unclear.
It looks to me as though Democrats are in charge of both chambers of the New Jersey legislature. If Democrats were willing to stand on principle, they could fight this. My guess is they won’t.
I won’t “stay home” (we have mail-in ballot here), but I’m perfectly willing to vote out lousy Democrats. Doing so might remind the rest of them where their loyalties should lie.
Same thing is happening here in Florida — the legislature is working on the most draconian anti-teacher legislation the nation has ever seen, dreamed up and co-sponsored by the Republicans who control the legislature and the governor has already indicated his support in signing the bill.
They are basically going to cut teacher pay by 50% and base the rest on “bonuses” based on student test scores. A nifty twofer — bust the teachers’ union (which is largely powerless in this right-to-work state anyway), cut the budget by billions, and scapegoat teachers. I’m sure the conservative public will be thrilled.
America is dying a slow ugly death and the worst part of this whole scenario is that the Republicans used Obama and Duncan’s “Race To The Top” grant as the blueprint for this heinous law. I’ve been thrown under the bus as a gay person, a union member, a pro-choicer, a liberal progressive, and now, as a teacher. I have never felt so betrayed in my whole life.
Doing so might remind the rest of them where their loyalties should lie.
It won’t. That’s what voters in Texas thought fifteen years or so ago.
Another gem from the NYT story:
Very encouraging…
I wonder why no one points out to these clowns that we had way higher taxes in the 50s and 60s and way lower unemployment.
And Clinton’s tax increases didn’t exactly kill the economy either.
Aloha, Eli…!
Hawaii’s well underway the ‘belt-tightening’ measures… Furlough Fridays have already been implemented for not only our teachers, but, all state and county funded social services… Our two biggest unions HGEA and UPW have already caved into the economic realities and have reworked their contracts for both; the individual Counties and with the State…!
At least Aunty Linda isn’t issuing IOU’s yet…! 8-(
Aloha, CTut!
evening, firegods
WOW! Washington state teachers are getting railroaded by the Gates & Broad foundations pushing the phake reform, quite effectively. We’re the cause of all the dysfunction, NOT the people in charge of creating the dysfunction.
our “democratic” legislature can’t discuss community investment without using right wing framing, so, guess who is wining even when the thugs are a minority party!
I went to a legislative district caucus on sunday just to tell people to NOT vote for 1 incumbent.
ALWAYS vote. NEVER vote fascist. STOP voting sell out.
(be bold – piss your vote away by voting for yourself !)
rmm.
Virginia has gone the way of NJ. As extra bonuses, Ken & Bobbie put on “let’s discriminate against gays in state government” and “we all need more guns” sideshows. We also have numerous “Don’t tread on me” bills to pre-empt any federal health care mandates (!); learned from the distinguished Bob Marshall that kids with disabilities are God’s punishment for their Mothers’ abortions and spent lots of time discussing the terrors of being implanted with tracking devices. I wonder what TJ would think of the Old Dominion now.
Add Nevada to that list as well.
Education and other social infrastructure cuts keep bleeding, long after the act is done. Best & Brightest is a dream, Dumbest & Meanest is the onrushing reality.
I’ve never missed a vote in my nearly 50 years of life (since I turned 18 anyway). But let me tell you it’s getting pretty damned hard to swallow the bile and vote knowing that even if I vote for the democrats (Obama, Senator Nelson) who can get elected here in FL, I’ll just be getting another version of the republican hate only with empty promises attached. The good, progressive democrats always go under here since this is a “conservative” area.
Senate Bill 6 is being called the “Teacher Abuse” bill here. It guts due process, professional contracts, seniority, collective bargaining, and a host of other hard-fought crumbs we’ve been able to hang onto here. All with the blessings of Arne Duncan, Obama, and the Business Roundtable. Obama is seen as an extension of Bush when it comes to education, even by the conservatives who hate him.
I’m alternating between rage, nausea, fear, and helplessness right now. We are already among the lowest paid teachers in the country. With this new law we will be reduced to fast-food worker levels and any hope I had of an even close to middle class life is now dashed. Teaching jobs are scarce around the country so it’s either stay here and swallow it or be unemployed. At 50. With crappy, mandated healthcare to boot. And bankrupting debt, including unaffordable student loans.
I’ll vote. Maybe for Jane Hamsher or Christy. But I feel so disillusioned that it seems an exercise in masochism.
This is the bitterest essence of our frustration: That after all this time thinking we just need to get rid of Dubya and the Republican Congress, we finally get a Democratic Congress and President and discover… they’re really not much better than what we got rid of.
So what the fuck do we do now?
Maybe a Progressive Party is the answer. Clearly the Republicans are worse than the Democrats but that is an extremely low bar.
Well, at this point we certainly have nothing to lose by starting the Progressive Party.
Coffee anyone…? Third party or Indy, babee…! ;-)
well if the democrats really care, they should actually do things to earn our vote then
I’m 50 – teaching is my 3rd career, this is my 3rd year – I was a cook during the 80′s & into the 90′s. I’m used to shit pay, shit benefits, zilch “security” on anything.
I can NOT skip voting, but… the pathetics in WA to vote for ?? I’m done.
Just told my wife (we’re from massachusetts & I’ve been in seattle for 20 years) the stories from this diary – the dolts I work with aren’t gonna have squat, and, right now most of them are busier with their salmon fishing, drooling in front of american idol, or other hobbies, than they are with having a clue about what is waiting for them.
I’m appalled that I learn about what is happening around the country to fellow teachers from a f$#$#%ing blog, instead of the Washington Education Association and its $50 million plus in dues a year.
I’m on the speaker’s list tomorrow for the school board … why stick my neck out for my co-worker dolts???
rmm.
Most of them don’t.
Maybe you can get a few of them to wake up.
Sorry, the blame in NJ lies strictly with the Corpocrats not the voters. Gov. Goldman Sachs was brutal. His campaign was on autopilot. It was campaign via commercial for six months.
He visited South Jersey twice in the last month of the campaign. He paid lip service to the unions and, as a person, he was just a miserable, spoiled bully. And a terrible public speaker to boot.
BTW, the budget Christie released today is even worse than the report indicates. A third of the speech was nothing but a full-frontal assault on the 240,000 teachers and school administrators in the state. Overpaid, pampered teachers. Essentially, he is proposing that all public employees (i.e wage earners) pay a minimum of 1.5-percent of their salaries toward their health insurance, effectively invalidating the negotiated collective bargaining process.
Just maybe it would be more effective strategy if we talked more about the way Oregon has raised taxes and on the rich too. Lets find out how that campaign got started and spend time thinking about how to adopt, adapt, improve such laws in many more states.
The case is there to be made. All the wealth has gone upward with fewer and lower taxes for the rich who are already scamming the tax system in ways the average Jill can’t afford. There are great charts of this and they could be made better and clearer. We have a massive reeducation job to do. The elites effectively neutered the left by keeping it from ever getting airtime. Here we have a forum and we spend so much of it (I am not exempting myself) giving space and time to the arguments we need to refute. Lets do the refuting and the recruiting and the reeducating. Blog space for ideas and accomplishments that are going in the right direction.
Maybe the most important thing to learn form the teabaggers is how much they’ve influenced the debate by being outrageous and out there. I know they’ve got Dick Army and Fox bankrolling and publicizing them and the rest of the msm playing back up band and that if environmentalists brought a gun to a presidential rally they’d be arrested as terrorists but we are not powerless. We are the majority in a center left country, a fact that Repubs, Faux news and most of the msm are trying to pretend is not so by throwing up a shit storm. In my experience people throwing up shit storms are trying to conceal something.
The elites decided money could trump democracy. At the moment it has but it doesn’t have to be that way. Its time to tax the rich. Its past time for a bold left. But we all have to give up the belief in the almighty dollar. No more bread and circuses.
yeah …
in the midst of 50++ hour a week job, I’ll change the world.
The message should have been on the side of the middle left majority since before prop 13 in ’78, nevermind Raygun I, II, Cheney I, II, III.
The first step in changing the world seems to be interminable meetings of happy happy – in Seattle, “active” in the union means pissing away 4 hours a month going to meetings to find out all the secrets which could just be on a goddam web page, so we could spend our time …
not at stupid meetings …
ugh.
rmm.
I’m with the both of you. I voted for change, not Republican Lite. And I thought Democrats were supposed to be the party of the common man and woman, not corporatist money grabbers.
I don’t know what to do either.
i’m in bellevue
know of any actual progressive gatherings around seattle? or are they all just a waste of time and/or part of the democratic machine now
The truth is that things will get much worse before they get even a little better.
Obama’s election and subsequent hijinx is an important moment for us in that it has now and at last demonstrated without the slightest ambiguity how completely broken our government is.
The fact is that there wont be eyes in any numbers to see this for a good 10 years or more. By which time, it will be even later than it is now, which is to say, too late by a decade or three.
‘I believe in America’.
But I was born human before I was born American, and our deal with our betters frankly stinks more and more. Yet who am I to argue with those who like it, and who line up to bend over for autographed seconds with a smile?
Fortunately, the world is wide, even yet.
Unfortunately, the world is also small…and has ever been so.
Can this end well?
No.
Welcome to trouble as the sparks fly upward.
Republican governors are channeling Kim Jong-il when it comes to economic development, that’s nothing new. But the buck stops in Washington DC, not the governor’s mansion.
In general, state budgets are overwelmed. That means that our federal government needs to step in and help out.
Are Obama, Reid and Pelosi coming to our rescue? If not then I’m going to start refering to Obama as “Dear Leader”.
Great post!
I LOVE THIS.
Why shouldn’t teachers and public employees pay 1.5% of their salary for their CADILLAC plans they have? You need to get off your high horse and see how the rest of the state lives. I’m in NJ too and am currently paying about 45-50% of my income in taxes. All the while state employees wanted an 11% increase in their pay DURING A RECESSION.
Seriously??
Thank GOD for Christie and sanity. The only thing I disagree with is the lack of the “millionaires tax” which actually if people could read is a tax on those making over $400,000. That should remain and i’m sure with the Democratic legislature it will.
Its about time someone took this seriously. All Corzine ever did was SLEEP with the unions (CARLA KATZ) and make ridiculous sweetheart furlough deals with them. Sorry but you’re bankrupting us. Small businesses were dying in NJ before yesterday.
Maybe you’re a teacher and you can’t AFFORD 32 cents per day to pay for your cadillac healthcare plan (I don’t know) but its about time someone started paying for it.
Corruption and pay to play need to END in NJ. “Public service isn’t about enriching yourself and your friends.” Unless you’re for keeping up people like this:
http://www.nj.com/hudson/index.ssf/2010/02/us_attorney_on_beldini_verdict.html
Or are you in favor of keeping all the municipalities and these people:
http://blog.nj.com/njv_editorial_page/2009/12/more_pension_abuses_exposed.html
http://www.nj.com/news/index.ssf/2010/03/new_brunswick_retirements_for/1607/comments-newest.html
http://www.nj.com/news/index.ssf/2010/03/as_state_seeks_to_curb_sick_da.html
http://www.nj.com/news/local/index.ssf/2009/12/parsippany_officers_retiring_w/3686/comments-4.html
Please Eli only speak when you have an idea what you’re speaking about. About this you have no clue. Come to NJ and find out what its really like. These union and government crooks make Tony Soprano look like Betty White.
bayville,
why don’t you share with us what you do? you wouldn’t be a teacher perhaps???
maybe you’re one of THESE teachers:
http://www.americanprogress.org/issues/2010/03/teacher_dismissal.html
In a recent survey of a nationally representative sample of teachers conducted by Public Agenda and Learning Point Associates, 59 percent of teachers reported that there were a few teachers in their building who “fail to do a good job and are simply going through the motions” and 18 percent of teachers reported there were more than a few.
Similarly, the New Teacher Project conducted a recent study of evaluation practices in 12 districts entitled “The Widget Effect” and found that 81 percent of administrators and 58 percent of teachers reported there was a tenured teacher in their school who delivers poor instruction. Finally, a Public Agenda survey found that while overall, principals and superintendents were very satisfied with their teaching staff, more than 7 in 10 reported that making it easier to fire bad teachers, even those with tenure, would be a very effective method of improving teaching quality.
If you have 58% ADMITTING that there are bad teachers out there that CAN’T be let go then the actual number is likely higher.
The gravy train is ending and I can’t be happier!! Its a shame that a handful of bad apples spoil the bunch.
You’ve got to be kidding. You don’t remember the republican privatized DMV do you or the many-yeared EZ Pass snafu as our earlier Christy ran the State into enormous debt.
What is it that you do? What percentage of folks in private business do you suppose “fail to do a good job and are simply going through the motions”? It is my experience, for what its worth, that the numbers are comparable if not worse. Have you ever tried to get phone service for instance?
I don’t remember saying that i was “FOR” privatizing the DMV etc. I’m just for ending the abuses of state government and unions.
My child’s principal makes $175,000. That should be a crime in itself.
Are you FOR keeping the abuses we have currently that are bankrupting NJ?
I’m in sales and what you don’t get about private business is that IF private business “fails to do a good job or simply goes through the motions” they don’t make any money, they don’t survive.
Government employees and unions don’t currently have that FEAR and they should. They should be accountable as should we all. You shouldn’t have public employees hitting the lottery at retirement. Sorry but those days are OVER.
Keep trying to shill for the abusers of the system. Exactly what is it YOU do?
hvdub,
and phone service? You mean like unionized Verizon jobs? Thanks for proving my point.
Verizon absolutely sucks but hey in my office we have a local small business that handles our office phones. We call them, they come that day and fix whatever issue we have. We’ve been trying to get Verizon to fix our lines for a couple years now (when it rains our lines go out and that’s not good for a small business). Verizon won’t hear any of it until we BUY FIOS from them and switch over our internet in the office. More of those good union folks!!
What troubles me most, is how the lower and middle class get behind these creatures as if they will be welcomed to the ($)split. It continues to boggle my mind how people you would most expect to revile these destructive greed motivated robber barons, the very slime that leaves them broke and destitute, ruins they’re children’s education (no art-music-phys ed) takes away any hope of retiring and passing away with a little dignity, continuously defend this bunch as though they were a member of the family. They will follow the pied piper right to the bread line, only to discover there isnt one anymore. “Three great forces rule the world: stupidity, fear and greed.” –Albert Einstein
“….I think a general Government necessary for us, and there is no form of Government but what may be a blessing to the people if well administered, and believe farther that this is likely to be well administered for a course of years, and can only end in Despotism, as other forms have done before it, when the people shall become so corrupted as to need despotic Government, being incapable of any other.”-
Ben Franklin
Its over, find a hole and get in it.
“If you have 58% ADMITTING that there are bad teachers out there that CAN’T be let go then the actual number is likely higher.
The gravy train is ending and I can’t be happier!! Its a shame that a handful of bad apples spoil the bunch.”
The problem with this is that if you are REALLY concerned with the first issue–getting rid of bad teachers, even if they have “tenure,” then THAT’S what you DO.
The fact that so many people are willing to ATTACK the middle class salary structure of teachers who are going a good job–just BECAUSE they ARE teachers is f*cked up and means something else is going on.
I think there ARE bad teachers and that the PROFESSION should address this issue directly. It’s giving people who want a scapegoat for high taxes (they ARE high!) a particularly convenient one.
This kettle has been boiling for years.
I also don’t think it’s ridiculous to have public employees contribute toward their health insurance plans. If they like that particular little benefit, then they should kiss Christie’s feet for helping them keep it around. If I were Emperor, I would move ALL public employees over to “the public option.”
Just “because.”