The award winning documentary Favela Rising shows the power of music as a force for social change and how one man’s vision can save a community.
Rio de Janeiro is known for beaches, for Carnaval, for the giant statue of Jesus…but behind and beneath are the favelas, the shantytown slums of Rio. The 600 favelas operate as their own communities, but as one resident points out, the residents’ opportunities for advancement are limited because of their zip code.
Extreme poverty rules the favelas, along with drug lords who rule through torture, murder and money. In 1993, when four policemen were killed in Vigário Geral, one of the poorest favelas, police retaliated by killing 21 innocent people. And out of this was born Grupo Cultural AfroReggae, a music and cultural movement, created counteract the violent drug industry and police oppression.
After starting a newspaper featuring hip hop and local music, the group started a cultural center, and using traditional drumming, martial arts and dance, as well as recycling projects, recruited children and teens off the streets taught them tools for social change through self improvement and pride. At one concert a drug lord thanked Anderson Sa, GCAR’s front man, for keeping his little brother out of crime.
Music empowered the favela, and Banda AfroReggae was signed to Universal Music Group, vowing to put the money they made back into community projects and expand into other favelas, taking into account what those communities needed rather than imposing an action plan. They kept these promises, and continued to improve lives in Before GCAR began, there were 125 drug lords in the Vigário Geral community; by 2001 that number had dwindled to 25.
But when a truce between a neighboring favela Lucas and Vigário Geral errupts into violence, Anderson and his fellow community leaders are put at risk as a lynch mob descends on them, spurred by rumors of Anderson rapping a girl and taking hostages. Anderson stays waits for the mob, because he says that to run would be to be admitting guilt.
Anderson and a drug lord from Lucas who part of the mob begin talking and the situation resolves, as Anderson explains that they are not for one drug cartel or another, but a voice in the community, a loud voice…
And then Anderson’s voice is nearly extinguished as he suffers a freak accident and is left paralyzed from the neck down. His neurosurgeon, familiar with AfroReggae, does the surgery for free, part of his doctor’s politics, that those who can pay, do and those who can’t shouldn’t.
Miracles do occur, and as Anderson says the favela’s spine has always been broken. Prayers are answered and Anderson walk again, and within months is performing on stage with AfroReggae.
Favela Rising was shot in part by a group called Nos do Cinema using the crew’s DV equipment. Our guest Matt Mochary and co-director Jeff Zimbalist would sometimes leave cameras with the children when they returned to New York. The utter violent realism of the footage is in sharp contrast to the music and movement of hope crated by AfroReggae.



56 Comments












Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Before we start, just a couple quick notes: Please refresh your browser ever minute or so to see new comments, questions and answers. To reply to specific comment, hit the reply button underneath it and then type away. Always after a comment or question hit “send comment.”
Please stay on topic–in this case Favela Rising, the favelas of Rio, music as a force for social change, community-based programs for social change….
If you want to jump in about health care or anything else not about please find a post elsewhere on FDL to do so. Thank you.
Please–and I can’t believe I still have to say this, but–no ad hominen remarks. And please be respectful of our guests and of each other. And yeah, I tpye badly…
Hi Matt and welcome!
Thanks, Lisa.
And thanks joining us from Brazil where it’s 11pm.. HOw did you first learn about Anderson Sa and Afro Reggae?
On think I forgot to mention in my post, and it’s hugely important is that the city of Rio asked GCAR to expand their program into other favelas
Before we get started here, I want to thank Lisa and Firedoglake for singling out Favela Rising and creating this event tonight. If you want to find out more about the film or buy the DVD from us, please visit our website at http://www.favelarising.com. Or email me directly at matt@mochary.com with any questions comments.
This was a film that Jeff and I made from our hearts. And, as such, we respond to anyone who reachs out to us. At least, we have so far …
Could you also tell a bit about hte history of the favelas? Many peopel aren;t that aware of that side of Rio (though there are tour companies that offer guided visits to a few safer ones)
I first learned of AfroReggae when I was invited to Rio by the Hewlett Foundation. Basically, the Hewlett Foundation invited a few Americans to Brazil who they knew were interested in giving back to the community down to Brazil. The gist from Hewlett was: You Matt have good intentions, but you really don’t know what you’re doing. So let us show you what a real group looks like.
They introduced me to AfroReggae, and immediately I was glad that I had accepted the invitation.
As soon as I met Anderson, I knew his story had to be told to the world. I called up my friend, and former film teacher, Jeff and made him a very bad offer: Quit your job and, for no money, come make a film with a former student of yours.
To my utter shock, Jeff agreed. And 5 days later he was in Brazil with me and we were making a film together.
You got some gnarly footage too..over how long a period were you shooting, and tell us about the kids you got involved in the camera work…
The history of the favelas:
In the 1880s, after Brazil’s civil war ended, and slavery was abolished, the slaves from the farmlands all came to the big cities seeking work. They came to Rio. They found jobs as maids and laborers for the wealthy families who lived on the beautiful beaches. Near these wealthy neighborhoods were steep hills that were empty, because they were utterly unsafe to live on. Each year, rains created mudslides that swept away any building or person on the hill. But with no money and the only other empty land many, many miles away, the newly liberated slaves chose to take their chances and built shanty-towns on those dangerous hills next to the wealthy areas.
Now, over 100 years later, those same shanty-towns exist. They sit right above those same wealthy areas. And ironically, the favelas have the much better views.
The martial arts and dance combination is formally called Capoeira, I believe.
I visited Rio in Sept ’02 with a group of friends. We were hosted by a Carioca (native of Rio) and his wife who were living locally in Portland at the time. Although Rio is arguably the most breathtaking city I’ve visited, I appreciated how much time they spent explaining the culture of the city including the history of the favelas.
Thanks for bringing this film to light.
We shot on and off for 2 years. All the really gnarly footage, that was captured by a favela kid or an AfroReggae member. We worked with a group of 6 favela kids who had hung around the filming of City of God and wanted to learn how to make films. We said, OK. We’ll teach you. We gave them each a small handheld DV camera, and told them to shoot interesting footage in the favelas. We didn’t think it would amount to much. Boy were we wrong!
.There are 600 favelas in Rio, you mention in the film. SOme like Rochina 9whihc I read about in Robert Neuwirth’s Shadow Cities) are not as rough and violent, while others are freaking rough, as you show
Thank you for taking the time be here and be interested in the film. It might be time for all of us to go (or go back) to Rio in 2016 for the Olympics. That will be interesting! Let’s see if the drug gangs decide to cooperate with the government or not. My guess is that they will. The drug gangs just want to make money to eat. They are as proud of Brazil as any Brazilian. They don’t want to leave a bad impression while the world is watching.
You had footage from the 1993 massacre of citizens by police…very intense, and some great interviews with kids in the drug cartels..how do you get htose?
I don’t know about Rocinha not being rough. Its more developed. Its got an ATM machine. A post office. But it is also controlled by one of the drug gangs. Last year, there was a battle for control of Rocinha. I don’t remember the details, but it wasn’t pretty.
The reality of poverty is what is rough. And that exists in every favela. There are no schools in the favelas. So favela kids get no education. With no education, they are unemployable. But they still have to eat. So they do the only two things they can to earn money to eat: steal and deal. That’s plain rough.
That was all AfroReggae. After we finished the first cut of the film, we showed it to Anderson and the band. They all cried. Anderson said that there had been 3 other films made about AfroReggae before that, but none as good as the one we’d made. He said that they’d been filming for 10 years waiting for the right moment. And this was it. He later gave us a tape with all their footage.
Again, we didn’t expect much. When we popped the tape in the VCR machine (yeah, it was a VHS tape), our jaws dropped. It was the footage of the massacre and those gangland interviews. It was crazy …
neuwirth made Rocinha seems pretty cherry… are there any NGOs planning to go in nd help wht education?
At one point didnt a McDonalds come into a favela?
Holy heck re footage
Now what is the difference musically beween baile funk and AfroReggae?
One thing I found fascinating was that, according to my Carioca friend, the favelas somehow tap into the city’s electrical grid ‘off the meter’. It’s such an unusual juxtaposition of social class and geography where separation is defined as starkly by elevation above sea level as it is money. The favelas literally dangle over the city.
Unfortunately, I haven’t heard of any NGOs who plan to open schools in the favelas, or help with education.
Its pretty interesting though. When I went into the favelas for the first time, it was easy to see that there were no schools, and no access to education. After the film was done, I thought to myself: “Thank God I liev in a country where there is universal public education!”
Then when I came back to the US, I got into boxing and decided to make a film on the best amateur heavyweight boxers in the world, who all happen to live in NY, and most of them in the South Bronx. So, I ended up spending alot of time in the South Bronx, which is arguably one of the roughest neighborhoods in New York. I had never been there before. Why would I go?
And when I went, it hit me like a ton of bricks. This is exactly like the Rio favelas. There are schools here. But they’re so dysfunctional, they might as well not exist. These kids aren’t hireable. So, like the favela kids, they do the only thing that they’re able to to make money to eat: steal and deal.
And then I had a scary thought: Is it possible that the worst criminals in this country (the gangbangers who have killed by the time they’re 14 years old), do what they do out of necessity not choice? If they were given the chance at legitimate employment would they take it?
You’re absolutely right. Most favelas have tapped into the power grid. Its amazing to see thousands of electric wires strung along the rooftops. The favela residents are creative!
And yes, the juxtaposition between rich and poor in Rio is stark. And yes, the favelas do hang right over the wealthy beach areas.
For me the juxtaposition is even more extreme, because I have close friends who live in both places. Before knowing me, they would never have looked at each other. Now they are close friends as well.
Baile Funk is the music that is played at the dances put on by the drug gangs to sell drugs and make the favela residents happy (at least those who don’t want to sleep!). Its hard to describe, but you know it when you hear it. The lyrics are very misogonystic. Like American rap.
AfroReggae’s music is based on earlier US R&B. Positive message, but still an intense sound.
And employed for a living wage.
BTW, I loved the doctor who treated Anderson and his politics of payment…
Why hasn’t McDonald’s come into a favela yet? Two reasons:
1. Favela residents can’t afford it McD’s prices.
2. There is no legal land ownership in the favelas, so McD’s wouldn’t do it.
Yeah, that doctor is great.
And yes, employed for a living wage. Well to answer my question about the gangbangers in the US, I decided to find out. I went to Rikers and asked to mentor one of their hard-core youth gangbangers when he was released at 18. They introduced me to one. As hard as they get. Known killer. Destined to live “street life” for the rest of his days.
I was shocked. He jumped at the chance to learn from me. Did everything I said. In 2 weeks, he had a job. 2 years later he is still employed, hasn’t even thought about going back to street life (which is lingo for dealing and stealing) and has a wife and 2 kids. He makes minimum wage. And it is enough for him to live, in his mind, a decent life.
I have sinced worked with 3 other gangbangers, even having one come live with me family and I for a while. And all of them have become like family members to us. They are all doing great. They all wanted to do right from the start. Its just that noone ever showed them how.
wiht no legal ownership, are living spaces passed down through families? are thier landlords? how does the economy function?
And thank you for including the lovely woman who had a “home cafe’ basically cookingout of her kitchen for dug dealers and one day said “AfroReggae supports me, so I won’t serve you.” To see micro economics at work was great.
I think I misunderstood your question. You said that at one point a McD’s did come into a favela? Wow. I hadn’t heard that. But I guess anything’s possible.
That is so awesome. thnak you for doing that and sharing that with us. What is your background, and what are you doing now in Brazil?
yeah, mid 90s I think, they sold ice cream…then closed
Yeah, no legal ownership makes it tough. The favela keeps its own records. So there is informal ownership, but it isn’t enforced by any Brazilian courts, just the local residents. And of course any disputes are settled by the favela’s drug lord. Which is actually what makes the favelas such safe places to be. The drug lords’ justice is swift and brutal. The penalty for theft is death. So, there is no theft inside the favela. But just outside the favela, theft is rampant ….
As for that woman, she is great. She is now famous because of the film. She has her own cooking show on Brazilian television now. She might be even more famous than the AfroReggae guys now.
My background is business. I built and sold a tech business in the late 90s. I’ve hired alot of people, so I know what employers are looking for. And basically, these gangbangers look like thugs, talk like thugs and never show up on time. I just taught them to dress well, speak well and show up early for every appointment. Once they did that, getting a job was easy.
I’m in Brazil now because my wife is Brazilian and she misses it here. So we spend half the year here. We’ll probably keep doing it until our kids are school age (in a few years), and then we’ll probably be in the US full-time. We’ll see …
Oh wow, what is her show?
But you meant, what kind of community work am I doing now in Brazil? None unfortunately. We are in the way south of Brazil, on a very sparsely populated island. There aren’t any favelas here. Its beautiful. Its safe. But no favelas.
What’s up with AfroReggae and their programs now?
I don’t know the name of her show, but she showed me one of the episodes, and Anderson told me that it is huge (especially among Rio’s 3 million favela residents). Her name is Chupetinha. Which means the little baby sucker (as in the sucker that you put in a baby’s mouth). Because she is often sucking on a baby sucker. She had some kind of thyroid problem, and the sucking made her feel better somehow.
They have become big-time. The film made them known. And they took off from there. They also have a TV show. They opened for the Rolling Stones when they played Copacabana beach in front of 2 million people a few years ago. They are working with thousands and thousands of kids, and continue to expand into more favelas. I don’t have exact numbers, so I won’t quote anything. But its impressive.
That is amazing, how uplifting for favelas!
Aside from the stealing and dealing, and home cooking what are some of the other economies in the favelas…
Yup. But as in anything where you start with nothing, its two steps forward, one step back. There’s always a heartbreaking story and a setback that happens every other week it seems. A favela kid getting killed by a stray bullet, an AfroReggae member getting misidentified by the cops and getting gunned down, etc.
Good question. Those were the only businesses that I ever saw. AfroReggae is trying to change that. They have turned music and entertainment into a business that favela kids can learn and perform. And those kids are making real money. CAGR employs over 250 favela kids. And of those, about 200 are the top earners in their household, even though some of those kids are only 16 or so.
that is astounding–ad great for the kids!
what other projects are you working on…
Has the police force improved any?
Outside of the favelas lifting themselves up, has anyone else ever done anything? Has there never been a regional- or national government attempt to assimmilate these communities? What do you think should be done, as a matter of policy?
Thanks for the incredibly inspiring story, Matt, and Lisa for bringing it to us.
Right now, nothing. Making a film is alot of work. I probably have one left in me. And its probably about the convicts that I’ve been working with. The solution is easy. Its all about fixing public education. And the answer is already out there. Its called “choice”. Charter schools. They’re having tremendous success. But the teacher’s union officials are scared to death of charter schools, so they’re doing everything in the considerable power to make sure state legislatures don’t authorize anymore.
But the tide seems to be changing. While Obama is getting beaten back on health care, he is quietly having success in education. He is using federal money to bribe the states into doing the right thing. And there is a new documentary about fixing public education coming out called “Waiting for Superman”. It just premiered to rave reviews at Sundance, and will be in theaters this year. I am hoping that it (like An Inconvenient Truth did with global warming) will instantly educate the country on the problem (and the answer) of public education.
If it does, then I won’t even have to make my film. The work will have been done for me. Let’s hope that’s what happens.
I am therefore cheering on Obama and “Waiting for Superman”.
Great question Ron. Its sad, but the government doesn’t get it. Favelas in Brazil only get positive attention from the government about 90 days before each election. Then the government goes in and does a quick little public works project (like pave a sidewalk) hoping to “buy” the favela residents’ vote with the cheap stunt. Unfortunately, it usually works since something is better than nothing for the favela.
But no. The government doesn’t seem to be interested in a systematic solution.
As for what I think should be done as a matter of policy. There is one thing, and one thing only, that I would focus on. Creating effective schools in the slums. That’s it. With that, within one generation there will be legitimate employment at a liveable wage. And then the favelas will slowly educate themselves out of poverty. Education is the only thing that lifts up an individual. And I think its the only thing that lifts up a communtiy.
When you think about it, that’s all that AfroReggae is doing. They are giving favela kids a practical education. They are teaching them useable skills. CAGR is education.
FYI, Matt runs a foundation too The Mochary Foundation, a charitable organization that promotes public education,
Lisa, thank you for arranging this. My hands are a little sore right now from all the typing. But other than that, this has been an absolute pleasure.
Cheers!
Matt and readers, thank you for joining us. Matt, thank you for the work you do and for this film. And thank Jeff for us too!
Thanks Matt, thanks Lisa.
The greatest gift given is a child, save another one.
After that music, dance,humor,drama,and art enrich and inspire everyone.
“Music blows off the dust of the day.” — T Jefferson.
Music heals, I have no doubt.
We know of Mozart, Bob Dylan, and on and on and on. The Beatles and Sting. My favorite for feel good:Louis “Satchmo” Armstrong.
Commence to jitter and dance for joy. Depression will not dance with you.
Humor delivers truth in a delicious, complex, savory sauce.
Norman Cousins wrote a book on the subject and others know the power. It heals as well as powerful pharmaceuticals.
Drama it’s everything you think, imagine, do, and do not do.
Am I like that, I didn’t know, what a hero, what a jerk.
The poor of the world seem to be somewhat closer to their creator than those that have managed to insulate themselves from it and refuse to gaze at the result of their greed.
The greatest gift given to mankind is a child, save another one.
After that, music, dance,
humor,drama,and art
enrich and inspire everyone.
“Music blows off the dust of the day.” — T Jefferson.
Music heals, I have no doubt.
We know of Mozart, Bob Dylan, and on and on and on. The Beatles and L L Cool J. My favorite for feel good :Louis “Satchmo” Armstrong.
Commence to jitter and dance for joy. Depression will not dance with you.
Humor delivers truth in a delicious, complex, savory, sauce. It heals.
Norman Cousins wrote a book on the subject and others know the power. It heals as well as powerful pharmaceuticals. HA HA HA
Drama, it’s everything you think, imagine, do, and do not do.
Am I like that, I didn’t know, what a hero, what a jerk.
The poor of the world seem to be somewhat closer to their creator than those that have managed to insulate themselves from it and refuse to gaze at the result of their greed.
Sorry,a message told me to re post