Will the moon actually turn blue? While the moon’s appeared blue in the past, it’s unrelated to its appearance twice monthly:
There have been times when the moon actually turned blue. When an Indonesian volcano erupted in 1883, its dust turned sunsets green and the moon blue all around the world for almost two years. In 1927, the Indian monsoons were late arriving and the extra-long dry season blew up enough dust for a blue moon. And, moons in northeastern North America turned blue in 1950 from forest fires in Sweden and Canada threw smoke particles causing the moon to appear blue.
The twice-per-month definition of a Blue Moon stems from an error made in a popular science magazine shortly after World War II:
Laurence J. Lafleur (1907-66) of Antioch College, Ohio, discussed Blue Moons in a question-and-answer column in Sky & Telescope, July 1943, page 17, citing the 1937 Maine Farmers’ Almanac as his source. It is clear that Lafleur had a copy of the almanac at his side as he wrote, since he quoted word for word the commentary on the August 1937 calendar page. This commentary notes that the Moon occasionally “comes full thirteen times in a year,” but Lafleur did not judge whether this referred to a tropical year or a calendar year. More important, he did not mention the specific dates of any Blue Moons and never said anything about two full Moons in one calendar month.
Some three years later, in March 1946, an article entitled “Once in a Blue Moon” appeared in Sky & Telescope (page 3). Its author, James Hugh Pruett (1886-1955), was an amateur astronomer living in Eugene, Oregon, and a frequent contributor to S&T. Pruett wrote on a variety of topics, especially fireball meteors. In his article on Blue Moons, he mentioned the 1937 Maine almanac and repeated some of Lafleur’s earlier comments. Then, unfortunately, he went on to say, “Seven times in 19 years there were — and still are — 13 full moons in a year. This gives 11 months with one full moon each and one with two. This second in a month, so I interpret it, was called Blue Moon.”
This is where the fault began, it appears: previously, the Blue Moon was when a fourth full moon appeared in any season, and it wasn’t necessarily the second full moon in any month. As American culture became more mechanized and urbanized, our definition of Blue Moon shifted from a seasonal one — the “extra moon” mixed amongst a season’s normal three full moons — to a strictly monthly-calendar-based definition. Picked up in 1980 by the radio program StarDate, the 1946 re-definition of a Blue Moon was quickly adopted in America by a population much less attached to the meaning of moons and seasons:
With two decades of popular usage behind it, the second-full-Moon-in-a-month (mis)interpretation is like a genie that can’t be forced back into its bottle. But that’s not necessarily a bad thing. Rather than argue over whether to celebrate the dawn of the new millennium on January 1st in 2000 or 2001, those with the sunniest outlooks will celebrate twice.
But a less agricultural, less moon-centered culture appears to have dropped the fourth-full-moon-in-a-season definition completely, having adopted the easier-to-track twice-monthly occurrence as our only one. A children’s almanac and Trivial Pursuit further cemented America’s adoption of the new definition:
Later, this definition of Blue Moon was also popularized by a children’s book (Margot McLoon-Basta and Alice Sigel, “Kids’ World Almanac of Records and Facts,” published in New York by World Almanac Publications, in 1985), and the board game Trivial Pursuit.
One way to enjoy two successive Blue Moons very quickly, of course, would be to travel to Asia or Australia or New Zealand, as they have two full moons in January 2010, not December 2009:
If you’re in Australia, New Zealand or Asia, your clocks and calendars will show that same moon falling on January 1, 2010. So your blue moon will come at the end of January, 2010.
Folklorist Philip Hiscock explains in his definitive article on the International Planetarium Society website that the twice-in-a-month-full-moon definition of a Blue Moon is probably here to stay:
“Old folklore” it is not, but real folklore it is.
So — have you any once-in-a-Blue-Moon activities planned for this New Year’s Eve?



130 Comments












Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Happy Blue Moon to you, Teddy.
teddy!
Teddy!
Fortunately we get to enjoy Teddy more than once in a blue moon.
Hey Teddy!
Happy last Sunday of this most peculiar year!
Blue moon. Being a tidal flats community that means clamming with a bonfire. Major low tide.
I’m starting to feel like an old dog..”why did I think that was fun”..
Here’s to Old Dog’s with fight left in em. Just no love for the Clamming anymore.!.
Good evening, ratty. How are you tonight?
Hi Suzanne….
Aw, you are sweet.
Late Sunday Late Night of Aught-Nine!
Sounds like fun. Reminds me of summers on Cape Cod.
Isn’t it funny, the idea of folklore that’s not too old? I was really struck by that: it’s real folklore, just not old folklore.
Never better and yourself?
Got to use the snow blower for the first time this season. Let the good times roll!
Shhhhh. Don’t tell my students. They all think I am an ogre.
Did you get buried where you are or did you miss the worst of it?
The boys up the street from my mom got her snowblower out last week — it’s forty years old, and my dad and I hadn’t used it in years. They drained the gastank, refilled it, and the old beast started right up. I made LOTSA money with that thing through high school; they could have as well, but were only interested in helping the old lady get her own drive cleared (one lane) and then back inside for them!
The whole urban legend phenomenon is proof of the ongoing significance and vitality of folklore in our lives. Of course, it does not provide a sound basis for public policy, contrary the Republican Party’s positions. See death panels, Mary Matalin, etc.
Only had about 4 inches. I just didn’t want to let it get packed down and do the thaw and freeze cycle that makes it a real nuisance. Or get another snow on top of it. Also a good opportunity to make certain the blower is in good working order before the heavy stuff arrives.
that was so nice of them teddy.
Nice kids. Almost gives you hope for the continued existence of civilization.
Isn’t that amazing? I doubt if there is anything manufactured today that will still operate 40 years from now.
And kudos to your mom’s neighbors.
Good plan. I hate having to walk on packed snow, especially after it has partially thawed and refrozen. Freaking lumpy ice.
Yep, I have a low center of gravity but when I do fall my bumper ain’t what it used to be.
Do you cultivate that image? /s
‘Instant traditions’ are a fine tradition.
Magic actually. Magic with bitter cold ,digging through rock/sand chasing the evasive little fucking clam necks that dart back into the shore. But very surreal fun. We lived 13 years on the tide flats while the kids were growing up. Incredible, the lessons that Nature has to give, full spectrum.
Been there, done that!!*g*
Everything hurts more and take longer to heal when you get older.
No, but I do have a reputation for being tough, which I suppose is partially true. I do actually expect them to pay attention and learn some of the material I present to them.
I thought it was so interesting that just as Americans moved away from our agricultural traditions, we gave up a definition of the ‘extra moon’ that had to do with planting, harvest, and nature — and accepted a new definition, based on an error, that had to do with the arbitrary calendar. Cool stuff.
Yes, she’s very lucky to have great neighbors who look out for her. This is especially welcome now, with her phone out of order for the sixth week in a row. Verizon seems completely unconcerned that an eighty year old woman who lives alone has spotty telephone availability at best. Oh well.
Wonder if you’re the first teacher they’ve met up with who requires this of them.
At the beginning of the twentieth century, 40% of America’s population directly worked in agriculture. Today it is less than 1%. A couple of years ago we passed a major milestone in world history and, for the first time in 4.5 million years of human history, most people now live in cities. We have become an urban planet.
We’re getting high winds here now, supposed to snow tomorrow.
Hi Teddy! Hi firepups. Merry seasonings.
If they were accepted by an accredited university one hopes they haven’t skated their entire life… Just most of it. :-)
Hi SnarK. Wassup?
From what I can tell, they certainly never encountered it in high school. I teach a lot of freshmen and they are the ones who seem most intimidated (and do the worst in my classes). I am actually pretty popular among upper division and graduate students. Of course the downside of that is that my 300-level classes, which normally enroll 15-20 students, run to 40-60 students.
Seasons greetings to you as well! How are things going? Have you picked the colleges you are applying to yet?
Quibble: my memory is that only 25% of U.S. pop was in ag at turn of century, but too lazy to get the book out of my attic to look it up.
Hi Snarky One!
High winds worry me more than snow. Lots of trees in the area and it’s been several years since we’ve had a a major ice-storm to cull the the weak limbs.
I’m checking into having an electrician wire a transfer switch so I can plug a portable generator into an outside outlet and power all the important stuff. Furnace, sump pump, refrigerator, and a couple lights anyway. Bob insists.
Kassie! How are you?
Applying to? I am already accepted in the entire U Texas system and already know that Yale doesn’t want me (but I rejected them first so :P!), and I am hoping hoping hoping to go to Princeton or Vassar.
Well, this is the University of Montana and we are a third tier school. We also used to have a policy of admitting every student who graduated in the top half of their high school class from a Montana high school (another brilliant idea dreamed up by our largely Republican legislators). That is not necessarily a high bar when they are from Two Dot or Nye. We have tightened admissions somewhat in the past couple of years.
Actually, it was 43%. See here.
40 percent is consistent with what I remember. In the 19th and early 20 century most people thought of working for wages as being comparable to slavery. Self-sufficiency was preferable, not to mention more practical outside the large population centers.
Here it’s the top 10%.
UT is a very good school a(first tier), but you can give most of the rest a pass. Absolutely go with the best school that accepts you and offers what you are interested in. Be sure to check on the quality of the program(s) you are interested in, as high ranked schools often have a few very weak departments.
Good. Smart bird. I’d be fine without trees around, they give me the creeps. (One fell on my house about 10 years ago.)
Give me a pinon and a juniper, and a view of some cottonwood and aspen far off and I’m fine.
Howdy howdy howdy SK.
OK. I confess to Altzheimers.
The Texas system, unlike Montana, has standards. Many of our legislators, good old boy ranchers and farmers, really do not understand the value of a college education to begin with and many of the Republicans are inclined to view higher education as an unnecessary frill. That might explain our lowest in the nation per student state funding.
Having the house shaded in the Summer really helps with utilities. I have huge 50 year old soft maples on the South side and they are prone to break. Had a straight-line wind remove the top half of one in the mid-90s. Only struck a glancing blow to the house, so could have been much worse. Makes me a tad nervous though.
Hey, you don’t have to teach this shit every semester. I probably would not know off the top of my head otherwise (it is for the lecture on modernization).
They can also help with heating costs by providing a wind break in winter.
Given that both my parents grew up in farm country if not actually on farms, and all of my grandparents as well, it’s a surprise to me that there even is a definition of ‘blue moon’ other than its appearance.
This is where my parents retired to – they had the house built for them. Pan the camera around and you can see the neighborhood. (There’s a vineyard next door.) This is, literally, miles from anywhere.
Confession is good for the… what was I talking about?
Cassie and DrDick!
Oh, this is good news Cassie! We are thinking of you. Listen to DrDick — he really knows what he is saying.
That’s about as much as most generators can handle. (Been there, done that.)
I forgot.
Well, I guess people had to have a way to account for that “extra” full moon that appeared almost every three years; without accounting for its appearance in growing, or planting, or harvesting season, the “named” 12 full moons would get seriously off track. So the ‘extra’ moon would be called the Blue Moon, but not for where it appeared in a named month, but for when it appeared as the Fourth Moon in a season.
I’ve been pricing some that handle over 4,000 watts sustained, 5,500 peak. I’m sure you’re correct. Don’t want to overload it. My breaker box does not have a master switch, so between installing that and a transfer switch I suspect the electrician is going to cost as much as the generator.
I’d really like to have one of those permanent outdoor backup generators that runs on natural gas. Pretty big investment, though.
evening Pups just a drive by as we are about to get Lost!! 5th season on BlueRay… woot..
i had always thought it was the 2nd moon in a calendar month — didn’t know about the seasonal naming until i read it in your post teddy.
Hey nahant! I used to watch Mad Men at this hour, and miss them.
You got Lost?
Hi and bye, nahant.
Splendid evening to y’all.
Hey Christine! How’s life in the great Midwest? cold here in the northern Rockies, but I have another week off before I go back to teaching (a Wintersession short course) and I plan to enjoy it.
Dearest DrDick!
Tonight we are getting a nice layer of snow, just a wee bit of 6 inches as of now. MrCE is just off his book tour and hopes to see the second printing in 2010. Home just tonight from Philadelphia, seeing kids from New York.
And all from a mistake a guy made in a magazine, that got picked up on a radio program, and then included in Trivial Pursuit!
Hi and bye again ye charming peeps!
My houseful of people depart tomorrow; I shall return forthwith!
Hope you all enjoyed yourselves over the holiday.
xo –
Kelly
amazing
Yeah, the transfer switch is going to cost you.
We had it originally on the pole outside, but it got moved into the garage next to the breaker box, so as to make it easier. Or at least more pleasant. The switchbox is fair-sized in itself, so make sure there’s room for it. (The generator was also in the garage, with the exhaust pipe going through the outside wall, between the doors.)
Hey, Suz…! Is there any reason my diary at the Seminal isn’t showing up in the latest diaries…?
that’s not a good link ct.. let me look
Not much snow here. We had a light dusting just before Christmas, so we had a kind of ratty, dingy white Christmas. More predicted later this week, so maybe a white New Years. This, this, and this are what it looked like around here last year.
Love and kisses! Happy holidays!
here’s the link and tech is looking into it ct
supposed to be soggy new years here — raining off and on all week
Much Mahalo, M’dear…! Ya’ll are the bestest…! ;-)
Beautiful! And, that’s what it looks like here tonight –such a surprise as we expected rain and mud. It looks wonderful tonight!
They are predicting snow possible starting Tuesday night and on through the weekend. Since I do not have to go anywhere or do anything, I could enjoy that. Gets real pretty around here with a good snowfall (just a pain in the ass to get around).
I think it needs a great deal more study, since it may be one of the first popular-culturally twisted folklores. It’s like the rumor about Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds being about LSD, kind of.
It is like I keep telling my students in intro. Culture (including folklore) is constantly changing and evolving.
What a great performance. Jazz. You can hear her voice and the piano as separately as they are wholely intertwined together.
How long would she last on American Idol, two weeks?
Sometimes my Seminal diaries take a while, too, CT. You came to the right place to get it fixed, though. I can see Suzanne’s arc-welder sending sparks all the way down here in SF!
There were lots and lots of YouTube choices for “Blue Moon” but Diane simply captivated me. I’m glad you like it too.
Suzanne is the power tool queen of mods.
refresh seminal and look at all the new diaries
*shutting down arc-welder*
hey ct — didja notice your diary was in the rec’d box?
Heh… Cool…! *g*
Snow in Philly:
http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_lXVn6jfMvR4/SzbZXhi5j1I/AAAAAAAAA0w/GAKUlXFRKnc/s1600-h/4211176649_a6aaf5d80a_b.jpg
that doesn’t look like philly — but it sure is pretty
It’s SO dark here down the coast now!
Suz didya know there was reports of the masses whupping the riot police’s arses in some areas…? ;-)
Have to agree with Suze.
Hey Suzanne,
Just 35 minutes outside of downtown, at the Grands place. They have 32 acres.
Certainly a lovely place to spend Xmas.
tis gorgeous — i was thinking i was gonna see a cityscape… nice to see there is that much open space just 35 mins outside of downtown. i tend to think everything east of the mississippi is wall to wall urban
It was beautiful.
gonna be a nasty pushback on that one i fear….. historically they have had a heavy hand in their responses to dissent
Beautiful. I always enjoy your pictures. Thanks
Suz is my fave…! It’s amazing how little play there is in the MSM about what’s happening in Iran…!
Unlike 30 years ago, this is now the last large privately owned property in the county. Surrounded now by McMansions. When we married, it was all dairy farms. Hmmmm
It is easy to take beautiful pictures around here. Mostly you just point and shoot.
Look out on Monday as I’d updated it in the comments…
there is a halo around the moon up here teddy
Same thing is happening down south of here in the Bitterroot Valley. Lots of rich folks buying summer homes and retirees from the coast cashing in and living large. Some of the best farm land in Montana (actually has water!).
*heh* I can relate with that…! ;-)
is what i do — point and click with a decent digital camera.
True dat!
Me too mostly.
MrCE tried to talk to his Dad about how horrible it is that valuable land, once the great breadbasket/dairyland of the east is now a playland. The big mister said that it increased the value of his property. Hey friends!
In many ways that is just the tragedy of the commons played out in a different venue.
And then seven days of mourning, with a climax to that one week later. People forget it was the overlapping, intersecting mourning periods that created the crescendo of activism that took down the Shah in 1979.
that only 1% of land being farmed figure cited upthread worries me. just where is the food supposed to come from that they wanna eat in their mcmansions.
At any rate, to the blue moon, we few four walked every night around the property there in Skippack Township, where my in-laws live. We walked the runway at night, in stars and in clouds. We walked in crispy snow, and in a bitter sleet. We know that we have to say goodbye soon.
That was me and it refers to the percentage of the labor force engaged in farming, not the amount of arable land under cultivation. The latter has been declining as well in many areas, mostly in the best farming lands. to some extent this has been made up by putting more marginal lands under cultivation. The latter, however, is not really sustainable as it relies heavily on intensive irrigation which is draining the aquifers and rivers.
Heh, the Grey Lady also mentioned that even the Shah didn’t have the audacity to quell the masses on Ashura…! *tick* *tock*
Hold on to what you have, while you have it. Those precious memories will sustain you in your loss.
You know, we wept a bit…
What a great photo!
thanks for clarifying for me dr dick — would love to sit in on one of your classes one day
Hey Margot!
We had such fun in the snow — I’m surprised Patty didn’t put up the picture of me pretending to drive the snow plow.
When people go on and on about the awfulness that is no longer but that was Saddam *secret prisons, death squads, torture, disappearances* it always reminds me of The Shah, who was, after all, our guy for decades in Iran.
You do when you can see the inevitable before you. I was perhaps lucky that I lost may parents before I got to that point. I was near there with my father, however, ad knew I did not have that much longer with him.
ES has LLN upstairs…
Sadam was “our guy” in Iraq. We installed him and generally supported him right up until after he invaded Kuwait (note that I said *after* he invaded – we initially green lighted the invasion).
Arnold was on 60 Minutes talking about CA’s water crisis (it was very clear he doesn’t understand it, speaking in only the most general soundbites) and I would have like to see him interviewed by someone other than the very moonstruck Leslie Stahl. She didn’t ask (or they didn’t show) a single decent followup question, and when he made little sense (always) she managed to put words in his mouth to make him seem sort of intelligent.
It has been very frustrating watching the national media enable him on this (and all) issues, since he clearly doesn’t get it and is simply acting in the interests of his wealthy patrons.
You’re absolutely right…! Another of our failed attempts at propping up tin-pot despots…!
I saw that and the situation in California is a classic exmple of what I am talking about. Of course it is all grossly exacerbated by LA’s insane thirst for water which is draining the entire Southwest of its water supply.
Nice video. New Year has come so close to everyone. New Year event encloses every person’s heart with great amount of happiness, joyness. Every corner of the world celebrate mesmerizing event like Sparkling fireworks, good greetings, non-stop partying, electrifying music etc. Here are top ten spots of the world such as New York City, Sydney, London, Paris, Ko Phanagn Thailand, Kiribati, Tokyo, Las Vegas, Boston. How they celebrate new year to see refer http://www.travelworth.com/ring-new-year-in-best-spots-of-the-world.html