I was looking to see if there was a break, a cut, some obvious demarcation, because even then, with no real understanding of video tape, I knew that they couldn’t just be turning a camera on a fire and walking away. Besides, why does the fire never seem to burn out?
Well, I never found it. That break. I don’t remember how long I looked, but it felt like an eternity.
You know where I am going with this, right?
That’s right, I am going straight into a metaphor!
As we wind down a year filled, at first, with some eyes-half-shut hope, and, at its last, perhaps, with some eyes-half-open disappointment, I think about that ever-burning and oft-returning Yule log. All that passion trying desperately to turn that powerful, hardened stump into a heap of ash, yet, never quite doing so.
Perhaps some—many even—thought that all the work was done last year. After eight years of misery and misrule, we had finally ramped up and rallied enough passion and power to get Democrats into all the leadership positions of our federal government—surely that was sufficient to relegate the GOP and their ideals to the ash-heap of history.
But, as we have learned, be it through the health care fight, or the escalation of the war in Afghanistan, the continued coddling of the banksters, the failure to rollback the unitary executive powers usurped by Bush, or any of a dozen other important matters, the tree of tyranny does not burn quickly.
Nor should it, I suppose. It didn’t get there by accident, and it doesn’t go away without incident. It isn’t enough, and never was, to just cast a vote and say: Now it’s someone else’s problem—I did my bit. That sucks, I know, but there are no saviors in a collective struggle (I hope that isn’t too sacrilegious a thought for Christmas). Change requires so much more than one charismatic leader, one or two votes, and a $25 donation. Especially when you want to replace the ideas of those that can donate a million times more.
If you didn’t think this going into the Obama years, then it is easy to see how you could turn cynical, disheartened, or think that you already had your road to Damascus moment, so being blind to the reality of this year is really just as good as faith that things will work out—haters be damned.
However, if you had spent your youth watching an endless loop of a burning log on a little TV—or saw just how long and hard the struggle for civil rights, equality, an end to poverty, and a more transparent government have been—then you might believe something different. The struggle is never really over, no more than it is ever really anyone else’s struggle more than it is yours. For everything you did last year was great and amazing, but every year following, you, we, need to be just as amazing. The fight is never won, the enemy is never vanquished, the log is never turned completely to dust.
And I am not sure that is the end you want, exactly, either. I would rather the battle is won and the other side won-over—rather than just see them bruised, bloodied, or buried—so that next time, you have that many more on your side for the fight.
It is exhausting, I know, and not everyone has the same time and energy to give, but if we ever want to see the Obama administration and our whole government become more than just a burning bush, that is what we, together, must do.
Merry Christmas to all, and, to all, a good, bright, shiny hope-filled day.



89 Comments












Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Thanks Gregg!
Thank you Gregg.
Merry Merry.
Evening. Well said and very true. I think many of us knew going into this that we still had much work ahead of us, though I doubt most of us knew just how much. I think the past year has revealed just how dysfunctional both of our political parties and many of our political institutions. We already knew that the corporate press was hopeless and they seem to be getting worse.
Oh, to have a President we admire because he/she thunders at lunacy.
Next time, perhaps.
I have been waiting all my life for that.
I’d gladly settle for a president who isn’t a pathological liar.
Is this one particularly galling because of our own projections upon the individual, or because we feel like we are making headway as a movement and are still unable to move the dial?
And competent.
As long as we’re making a wish list, one who puts service to average Americans ahead of moneyed interests.
I think a bit of both, depending on the individuals. I never really had any illusions about Obama being very liberal and always assumed that we would have to work to push him and Congress to the left, but may others did project their hopes onto him. It is also the case that we have been building a fairly successful grassroots movement which has had an impact on the electoral process, but our interests and agendas are still being ignored or dismissed by those in power.
I have been waiting all my life for that one as well.
Even more important. We can’t afford to despair and begin to live as though we believe the lies. There is something to be said for the influence of a sane constituency within the culture.
I’m seriously worried that our hard fought for President doesn’t have the courage of nor confidence in his rhetoric or (principles?). FDR, whose wealthy family went back to a time when New York was New Amsterdam and had been Governor of New York, didn’t give a rat’s ass what the fat cats said about him. He wanted to do something for the country, convinced of its rightness, surrounded by hand picked, like minded people, He did it.
Obama seems swamped by the sheer awesomeness of his job, a perfect example of the dog chasing a car and catching it; now WTF. He has picked a crowd of awful people as advisers, Geitner, Summers, Emanuel, etc.. He is allowing the military to bully him into wretched, illogical decisions. No one since Alexander The Great has been able to accomplish anything in Afghanistan; Generals Petraeus & McChrystal are going to pacify it. In a pigs eye.
Does he really think that the Republicans were lying when they promised him his very own “Waterloo”? That they were kidding when they promised “No votes” on anything related to heath care reform?
He has pursued the myth of bipartisanship. Courting the hatchet faced senator from Maine as if one Republican vote would make it all “Bipartisan”. Does he have such a low opinion of the intelligence of the American people? Bah, Humbug! He and cronies have another, secret agenda. Corporate support, maybe?
He is providing NO leadership on Health Care reform, abdicating his responsibility to a corrupt congress. “Just pass something” seems to be his objective. If the jackasses in congress pass a bill mandating that everyone buy health insurance without providing a REAL public option that people can afford, we may get the “French Revolution” this country so desperately needs. And from the looks of the state of play at the moment, that looks like just what they are gonna do. By the way I plan to be among the first on the barricades with a brick.
The fight has only just begun the Democrats are just as corrupt as the Republicans.
Obama is an improvement over that other guy , though right now I’m not sure how much.
OT, but I was talking to my son tonight and he says that the 14 inches of snow they got in OKC yesterday set a record for snow – for the whole year! Up where he lives, they only got 8 inches, but apparently it was blowing pretty good as well. The whole state had white out blizzard conditions.
We could be disgusted but it was impossible to be disappointed by Bush because our expectations were so low.
I took Obama’s campaign promises with a large dose of salt, believing even the most well intentioned individual would have great difficulty changing the culture of Washington. As it turned out, the fact that it was so quickly revealed he lacked even good intentions was very disheartening.
Do any of you, think we will ever elect a President, that is farther to the left ,than Obama?
My sister told me it isn’t even supposed to rise much higher than freezing until Tuesday, so it won’t be going anywhere. I wouldn’t be surprised if they’re bringing snow removal equipment in from Colorado or elsewhere, since they probably keep very little at hand.
True to a degree, though I think the Republicans are still more corrupt on the whole. The HCR battle did reveal, however, just how corrupt and dysfunctional our political institutions have become. We really have to eliminate the influence of big money, both from individuals and from corporations, if we expect to make any meaningful changes. That fight is going to make health care look like a Sunday school picnic.
THE WAR ON POVERTY WAS NEVER WON. Corporatist don’t want that… criminalize poverty and keep the prison doors revolving. Politicize religion and rule the eddective way by fear. As long as competitive sport Saturday’s Hero is the prime concern on folks mind and politics is shunned a democracy will not solve the problems that make our people suffer.
How long will the disenfranchised settle for a bad deal. I guess more people need to be shut out. It is disturbing that republicas and other conservatives get what they want by breaking the bubble.
Yeah. Pete said they expect it to hang around for the next week, but that they expect to have the interstates clear and drivable tomorrow. Not sure where they found the equipment (maybe they just aren’t clearing anything else).
My fear is that progressives will do to the D’s ,what the teabaggers have done to the R’s.
Not soon. By the time a person rises to that level in politics they’ve already mortgaged their soul to every special interest under the sun.
At first read your comment bears a strong resemblance to statements made by the dkos trolls in the past few days but I am confident you must be making some different point.
Please elaborate.
The difference is that there are many more of us than there are teabaggers and we are much closer to the mainstream in America than they are. I think we do need to shake up the Democratic Party and perhaps chase out some of the Blue Dogs and ConservaDems.
“really have to eliminate the influence of big money,”
Hah , nope just another pipe dream , like healthcare reform and the public option !
The issue profile that describes Progressives is, when polled anonymously across the country, the majority of the country – anti-war, pro significant health care reform, restoration of DOJ, etc.
You can’t say that about the TeabaggerRight.
The Overton Window has skewed wildly.
Edit: YMMV
I was referring to the election in Ny 23th district . I don’t want see our party fragmented, To win elections we should not be fighting among ourselves
Since substantive campaign finance reform would require action by Congress, who are the main benefactors of the current corrupt system I fear you are correct.
Yeah about 60-70% of the country depending on the issue comes down as progressive and has consistently done so for 30 years. The people are far to the left of our leaders.
If solidarity gives us morally bankrupt candidates like Obama, Reid, and the rest of the Senate majority, what do we gain by sticking together?
Electing more Ben Nelsons and Blanche Lincolns honestly does not benefit us in the least. If we are going to move the party to the left, where the American people are, then we are going to have to push out the conservative Democrats in favor of more progressive candidates.
we are much closer to the mainstream , but our MSM likes to call our country center right and the public buys it.
I still wonder if that IS the challenge. Maybe so, but the best buttstroke we have is to… electorally disassemble Obama. So we have many more backward steps before we can stride forward.
But it still isn’t true. We are in fact a center left country, but our political and media elites are center right.
I’ve seen some of those polls, the people are farther left, than they themselves believe
I won’t argue with you there. Let’s not shoot ourselves in the foot in the process , is all I’m saying
I think Jane has hit on a good tactic in looking for common cause with folks on the right. The Obama Administration has brushed off criticism from progressives by labeling it “grumbling from the radical left.” When the pressure is applied simultaneously from both the left and right they will hopefully find it more difficult to dismiss.
In many ways, while a huge disappointment, Obama is far less a problem than Congress, in particular the Senate. We simply cannot allow Democratic Senators to refuse to vote for cloture on key Democratic initiatives. I could live with them voting against the bill itself, but never with not allowing it to come to a simple majority vote.
Hey there billybugs, and to all of you.
A couple weeks ago I was being all snide and snarky etc., saying “you’re all gay now.”
What I really mean by that is, look, you’re in the same long term boat that I’ve been sailing in for EVAH!
It won’t change tomorrow, next week, or next year. It’s going to take a LONG GODDAMN TIME, longer than any of us like, with more turns, and setbacks than we like.
But real change will come. Not through some campaign. Not through politicians actually.
But through us. By our steadfast commitment to what we believe, not by personalities who charm or pretend.
Through what we actually believe, by doing what we do.
And what we do is challenge the status quo. Every day.
Living what we believe, believing what we live, and having no daylight in between the two.
That is what has gotten me as far as I have come, which is so much further than the bromides and myths I was told 30 years ago.
So in truth, we’re not all gay now. We are in the struggle for justice, peace, and equality for real, not in some fake PR DNC way. And we’ll get there.
By being shrewd, and real, and loud, and proud and by frikking SEIZING our ideals and our rights and blazing forward with them.
That’s the firepup way, if you ask me.
/endrant
I am afraid I must respectfully disagree.
You were, of course, right.
Merry Christmas dude.
Troll! “g”
Just kidding, on what grounds?
Wish you’d told me you were speaking metaphorically before I did all that shopping.
Many, which I do not really want to get into here, but principally I do not trust any of them and think it is all too easy for it to backfire on us.
I’ve known all along that I was in this thing for the long haul .
The people griping and complaining, that change isn’t happening quickly enough, really get on my nerves.
This is a slow, sometimes painfully slow, process.
Be patient and keep your nose to the grindstone!
Change will happen !
Been working on it all my adult life. Progress really has been rather retrograde since the mid-70s.
I think of it more as a small scale experiment. Rahm SHOULD be investigated, if this helps accomplish that, or if it merely increases scrutiny of the administration that is progress. If not, we’re simply where we were at the outset.
I have reservations about both of those points and do not think we can limit damage just to Obama and not to the Democrats and progressives generally (because you know Grover and the Conservatives are going to use anything they find to hammer us unmercifully).
For a while it seemed like we had some momentum , but lately seems like we’re going backwards again
The Democratic Party has been moving to the right for 30 years. Clinton’s policies were largely indistinguishable for those of Ford or , for the most part, Nixon.
It’s already fragmented. The liberal/progressives have been told to shut up and swallow the lies.
Grover and others on the right would turn on us in a heartbeat
They already have the daggers and poison needles at the ready.
Nixon was more progressive than Obama/s
But it’s just this reality (yes, I agree with this statement) that has kept Dems/Liberals/Progressives back on our heels for decades. And getting hammered unmercifully has never required cause.
True to a large extent. I said during the primaries that there was very little difference between Hillary and Obama and that Hillary was to the right of Bill.
You really believe the conservatives can inflict greater damage on the Dem party than Dems have done to themselves? Just the HCR debacle is cause enough to send them back into exile. I despise the GOP but Obama is philosophically a Republican. The Senate Dems might utilize a different vehicle to enable corporate looting, disguising it as a social program but the end result is the same.
On a brighter note, I still have a kitchen to clean. Wishing festive holiday remnants to all.
I’m pooped !
The holidays wear me out .
Merry Christmas to all and to all a……. good night !
We have to hammer back and hold them accountable. What has gotten us into this mess is that we are willing to overlook their shortcomings and failing, hold our noses, and give them our money and vote for them just because they have a “D” after their name. That has to stop. We do not vote for ConservaDems or donate to them. Period. We work our asses off to primary everyone of these fuckers. We must hold them accountable on our terms, and that does not include sleazeball conservatives like Grover Nordquist.
nite ratfood (i still have a kitchen to clean,but am content to do it at 3am)
nite billy
Yes and that we can undermine our own credibility by aligning ourselves with them.
Nighters. Have fun with the kitchen. Say hi to Bob for me.
Night, billie.
Nordquist aside, I think a broader approach will dilute what strength we have. Yes, we oppose every one of them, but we have to concentrate.
Harry would be a good place to start, but he is so vulnerable that just a nudge may do him in.
Blanche Lincoln – now that is a get.
We do win some small victories. The CEO of Whole Foods is stepping down. It’s not earth-shaking but it’s something. And as Scarlett said “tomorrow is another day.”
I do not necessarily disagree about targeting, though I am not sure having a Republican would be worse than having Harry. At least we wouldn’t get blamed for his screw ups. Lincoln is a good target, as is Landrieu or my own worthless senior senator, Max Baucus. Of course in Max’s case we may not have to do anything. There are rumors that he may quit after this term.
We have slowly, but steadily been making headway and having an impact in a variety of ways. We have been very successful at fund raising and it is starting to pay off. there is still a lot to do.
Oh, Landreau would be sweet, Baucus too. But I know nothing about their numbers back home.
Sadly, yes — since I left high school in the 1970′s, nothing has really moved forward. There has been virtually no progress, save for science, and even that has been mightily restrained.
The two most important factors, if I were to pick just two, were the fall of unions and the rise of movement conservatism. These two things aren’t mutually exclusive, either. Conservatives finally organized across their entire spectrum through a meeting of the minds of key families; they set about undoing everything a healthy middle class bought as public services. Unions were also partially a victim of their own success. They were powerful enough to change the direction of corporations but without adequate incentives to change at the same pace as corporations. They could also afford to indulge in voting for God-guns-gays instead of union-friendly candidates, thereby cutting their own throats while assuring the rise of movement conservatives.
The only way we are going to put a break on our current situation is to have a countervailing rise of movement progressivism. We must find a common ground behind which all progressives can unite, and then push in the same direction, organizing resources to achieve our ends. I think the 2003-2004 Dean campaign and the concurrent rise of progressive blogging was the front edge of this movement, but it needs more conscious effort if we are ever to recover gains lost and make new progress.
Max has pissed a lot of people off back here over the public option. Several of the important Democratic county committees issued a statement over the summer that they would recruit a challenger if there was not one. As I say, however, there are indications that he may retire after this term. The down side of that is that our current governor will likely run if he does and Schweitzer has turned out to be as bad or worse than Baucus or Obama.
Schweitzer was a likable enough fellow during Jon Testor’s campaign. We know how that turned out.
Students are angry about higher fees. Teachers are angry about heavier workloads. Construction workers are angry there is no work. Sick people are angry about costs and poor treatment. Businesses are angry about no loans. Consumers are angry about usury on credit cards. Either partycan use theses and other problems to blame the other. I still find Hugh’s list a basis for disent. Unless Obsma gets good coucil Republicans will take back political as well the virtual contrl they have had for 3 decades. Investors want the casino open. The banksters are looking for another bubble to draw in capital. Obama sided with his senate and corporate mates. 30,000 more troops in answer to bring them home. Is there one issue he has not sided with the republicans. Reaching across the aisle is just another word for selling out the voter base. Meanwhile Busco, Rve and the perps walked scott free. While R’s put D’s in jail.
Time for me to toddle off. Take care all and Merry Christmas.
nite doctor
Merry Christmas Dr. Dick, night.
Hola Margot!
You having a nice holiday?
Your point, Gregg, can’t be driven home too forcefully. They may have more dollars, but we have more voices and, as I’m fond of saying, a million voices speak louder than a million bucks.
I’m past the point of believing in any leader, charismatic or otherwise. The salient fact is that those whom we elect must be told, constantly and relentlessly, what we expect, because we otherwise cede our voice to corporate interests and lobbyists, who are, themselves, constant and relentless. An email every couple of months or a phone call or two a year won’t do it. Give the lobbyists credit for one thing: they work a lot harder to control our legislators than most voters do – with obvious results.
All the campaign dollars in the world are useless to a rep hearing from constituents whose number is greater than their last margin of victory, “Support this or you’ve lost my vote.” Ultimately, our reps are more afraid of us than their corporate masters…when they hear from enough of us. We put ‘em there; they know we can take ‘em out. But when we don’t do the talking, they listen to the only voices they hear.
Yes, thanks Newton. Dog loved seeing the peeps in the nursing home, they liked seeing her. How’s it with you?
What a nice thing to do…
It’s fine with me, thank you. Staving off the tryptophan coma as we speak.
Oh we were seeing family, and the dog was requested specially. Also makes it easier to ease on out of there when it gets time to leave. The dog gets too hot and we gotta go.
My rep only listens to the conservatives in our district. I feel like a leper, and I voted his ass in, he’s a Blue Dog but I didn’t know that then. I am going to vote him out, or try to.
I saw this title and remembered how much I liked “Westworld.” :-)
The solution to the problem of the tree of tyranny not burning quickly is clear from the metaphor. It’s not to work together to get the log to burn faster. It’s to turn off the television.
Life (and politics) isn’t to be watched, it’s to be celebrated loving the people around us.
Watching a yule log burn is the same as watching our Government in action.
Everything is going up in flames.
Reading at 6am. Splendid discussion. Thanks all.
It has become clear, in my mind, that Barack Obama is a hustler. Just as he went from being totally indifferent to religious belief to acquiring the proper religious mien essential for success in American politics, so to has he mastered sizing up a “room”, and out-Zeligging Leonard Zelig.
It is no secret to anyone that America is run by the rich and powerful, not by the voters. So Obama, much like Bill Clinton, acquired the skill to straddle the great divide between the haves and the have-nots. But there was never any question, I believe, in his mind, that it would be foolhardy to lead a charge for the working man against the ruling, financial elite. He is smart enough to know that attempting to do so would result in his being politically crushed.
So America went from a sadistic frat boy with a Dr. Strangeglove partner presidency, to a Chicago Hustler president, who is so brazen and self-assured that he would deliver a dump-truck of economic and social manure on the remaining middle class lawns across America, and call himself their Redeemer in doing so.
Is there no end to the abuse and ignominy Americans will allow themselves to be subjected to?
Yeah, boy howdy! That solidarity, that shit is soooooo overrated!
Good plan! Move to the right!
Wow. Gregg. beautifully written and very powerful post! Thank you!
I feel like a war horse who has grown old in the traces.
But at least I’m not alone
Just got up and checked what’s happening on the lake. Great post, a mirror of my sentiments. Reaching for the bellows to keep the fire of my hope alive. It feels like we are being led by anchors straight down. A nice missle strike on (probably another wedding party) Yemen with another “30″ dead, and its instant kharma/blowback over Detroit for Christmas. My ruck is packed, my boots by the door as I ready to once again walk off into oblivion as I did forty some years ago (literally, not metaphorically). I feel impotent to find answers for the problems of society en masse and am sorely tempted to go back to hunting solutions for my individual life and my family, migratory hunter/gatherer or? As Ishmael (Daniel Quinn) suggests. But I keep thinking back to the Hopi prophesy and their exhortation that “we are the ones we are waiting for”. I keep hoping that all us folk can come together and somehow push back and resist the grouping of dominators who threaten us and all life. Firedoglake continues to be the most likely venue I’e seen for a real and positive change to start. Here’s to our climb out of this dive in the new year.