I went down to Bartle Hall Thursday afternoon to meet Eve (see some of her coverage here), but also to see for myself what the event was like.
As I walked up to and through the hall, what struck me most of all was the ordinariness of the people waiting to see a doctor or dentist. If you changed the venue from a cavernous convention center to a suburban medical office building, you wouldn’t think twice about most of these folks. The area that was set up as the “waiting room” for pediatric appointments reminded me of the doctor’s office that I take my son to — nervous kids, sick kids, crying kids, sleeping kids . . . just lots and lots of ordinary kids.
It was a slice of America, and not one that many folks in DC seem to be aware of at all — or if they are aware of it, they don’t seem to care about it.
You tell me which of those two is worse.
You can dismiss talking points and political debates. You can set your statistics next to mine and we can argue about them til the cows come home. But standing on the floor of Bartle Hall on Thursday afternoon, all that stood out were the people — flesh and blood people — in need of health care. People who look just like everyone else.
Aaron Barnhart is the television critic for the KC Star, and he got an invitation to tour Bartle Hall with an RN friend of his. He wrote this about the clinic on Thursday:
The Kansas City Free Health Clinic [the local sponsoring clinic] is one of the best in the country, according to Nicole Lamoreaux, director of the National Association of Free Clinics. That’s why they got the nod to organize the two-day clinic. “Even so,” writes [Alan] Bavley in today’s Star, “it has to turn away 200 or more patients every week.” The demand is just too great. Go ahead. Try NOT to politicize that statement.
This is the television critic, not someone on the political beat.
(I also remembered an earlier medical story by Bavley in the Star last October, and wondered if our local “concierge doctor” took some time off from his castle-based medical practice to help out.)
What I saw Thursday were hundreds of folks like the man left by the side of the road in the health care story Jesus told in Luke’s gospel. (Try NOT to politicize that story, either.) Political leaders have passed these folks by without offering help, as have business leaders, insurance companies, and many, many others with power and clout. It’s not just Blanche Lincoln and Mike Ross who need to hear this story, but lots and lots of folks in DC and in boardrooms around the country. Thankfully, Rep. Emanuel Cleaver II represents Kansas City, and he gets it. (Then again, he’s a pastor, so you’d kind of hope he knew this story.)
My eight year old just popped in and saw me writing. “Whatcha doin’?” he asked, hoping to play a game or something.
“I’m writing about the people who were at Bartle Hall for a visit to the doctor,” I told him. He’d seen it on the news earlier, and I showed him some of the pictures online and told him some of the stories, like kids his age who had never been to the doctor or dentist because their families couldn’t afford it.
He looked at me very solemnly and said, “That’s just Not Right.”
I could hear the capital letters in his voice. “No,” I said, “it sure isn’t.”
When I grow up, I want to be as wise as my kid.



31 Comments












Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Let’s hear it for the kids. Thanks for your piece. Ive been reading the lectionary about “hope & rejoice” and thinking how much we need the message in these times of cynical debate and disillusion. Yes, cheer the kids. Thanks again.
Thanks peterr. An experience like this can lead to a child growing up vowing to make things different. Worked for me.
Peterr, I’m glad you went to see this. We do need eyes to witness what is going on and to pass the word. Thanks for your post.
I’m interested to see the degree/extent of media coverage and grateful for your references. Was there more?
Just finished “The Hole in our Gospel” by Richard Stearns.
He states that in a part of the Bible, Ezekiel, that the reason Sodom and Gomorrah were destroyed was not because of out of control debauchery like many “modern” preachers/deacons/priests would have us believe, but, because of a disdain for the poor. Heck, the US needs change. Though really good at specialized services, plastic surgery, the US system really sucks at basic services, like controlling potential epidemics. Perhaps, this time, the offending sites (the village) will die from a scourge.
and me, an atheist. heh, heh.
Your post simply highlights that issue in a different way. Thanks.
Everytime I see one of Eve’s videos and hear from her this AM at PUAC that she is struggling to get into the Christmas spirit because of her participation, I have a good cry. Bless you Eve. And bless all of the “little people” who matter not to the Village.
“Jesus wept”
Eg, just wanted to wish you all the best. It was your warm welcome that led me to delurk here at FDL. For ((quakergirl)) and (((katymine)) and others too numerous to mention, All the Best.(((Eg))
“
This past year I was sicker than I have ever been in my life. (allergic drug reaction) The only treatment physicians could offer was to treat an endless range of symptoms that kept cropping up for months out of nowhere. For over two months, I thought I might not make it at various points when one thing or another took hold of my body. I have major medical with a large deductible, but my insurer picked up about 40K in tests and ER care. If I hadn’t been insured or had access to specialists I don’t think I would be here today. When I watch these clinics on TV and see people just like me with only one differing element (lack of insurance) in their lives, I wonder how many people have not made it because they did not have medical resources. When our politicians choose deliberate blindness to the facts, we have to expose their callousness and greed so that they can never serve again. That is the only way to change the system. We have to re-instill real shame into the system.
Am glad that you survived and are able to tell the story. Are you free of the problems now? I remember reading a few years ago that we have lost our ability to feel shame and that’s why we are in such trouble. That would certainly apply to the powers in DC.
Do thieves and hypocrites even know shame? Our ruling elites have more in common with the royal court of Louis XVI than the citizens of the nation.
The local media on this has been pretty good, both in print and television. Before the event took place, the local news outlets were publicizing it to alert those who needed it on how to take part, and also to help the planners recruit volunteers. During and after the event, they were watching and reporting on it as well.
“He looked at me very solemnly and said, “That’s just Not Right.” “
out of the mouths of babes
If there is any major media coverage they will likely spin it as just another example demonstrating that the “system” works and America’s “compassionate” nature.
I wonder how many conservative wingers assisted in this clinic.
My nephew’s 27 year old friend died of MRSA ,because of lack of insurance . By the time he went to the ER he was so sick they could not save him . Had he been insured he would have seen his doctor , and he would likely still be here today.
I think Harvard did a study and found that over 40,000 Americans die annually because of a lack of health insurance. Social Darwinism would seem to have found a place in the United States.
It was a slice of America, and not one that many folks in DC seem to be aware of at all — or if they are aware of it, they don’t seem to care about it
The latter. Not just the R’s either. Talkin’ to you Obama.
As an historian of revolutions, I was thinking about the court of Louis XVI this morning. The word I remember most from Gildea’s exhaustive history was “Venality”. An apt phrase for today’s courtesans.
And of course we will “Let them eat cake” vis a vis the human right to healthcare.
if they are aware of it, they don’t seem to care about it.
You tell me which of those two is worse.
The fact that we have allowed all of this to occur seems to me the worst of all things. Where is everyone?
Even with insurance, the costs of the copays and deductibles can bury you. In this day and time who has an extra $500 or $5000 lying around to pay the hospital before the insurance part kicks in? And every January your deductible zeros out again. With a chronic illness it is a never ending cycle.
There was a very good piece on Moyers last night about some pockets of activism; then, in the 2nd half Zinn was pretty optimistic on the topic.
The efforts may be incipient, but the conversation was focusing on what is happening, including that people are very angry.
“That’s just Not Right”
When exactly do we begin to shed this wisdom? Our kids know how it should be done, and we did, once upon a time, too.
I wish I could say that a national letter writing campaign to Congress from kids would be an eye-opener for them, but I’m afraid the kids would be too discouraged and disappointed to see that they don’t seem to care. We need their generation’s enthusiasm and clarity now more than ever.
Are there more clinics planned? Haven’t read about any yet. My concern is that the prez and the Congress will just think that the clinics are working well and let the private sector take care of the problem.
Here’s their web site
http://freeclinics.us/
thanks.
aw shucks
:)
RECONCILIATION
Sometimes I think we should stop donating to political parties, to any politicians, or for lobbying our so-called “representatives” and “senators” in Congress, and simply donate to the organizations that hold Health Fares.
Just think how many more people could be treated if we did! We keep donating to political parties hoping to make some fundamental change. What is clear is that it is not going to happen.
I hope Obama sees this and weeps! He owns it now.
Personally, I think it’s just about time to render some TLC to our “Louis XVIs” in the form of a good old-fashioned revolution. Heck, it would even be in keeping with what our founding fathers had to say about the treatment of despots.
Despot: Dictator, Autocrat, Overlord, Oppressor, Bully.
–Oxford Dictionary of the English Language.
These miscreants certainly fit that description.
Dear Peterr, your child sounds like he’s old enough to watch To Kill A Mockingbird with you. It set my personal path on a social justice tangent when I was a slip of a girl.
When did Noblesse Oblige die? And why wasn’t there a funeral for it? Or, at least a memorial service? (Maybe we could have one here in a thread some day.)
I spend a fair amount of time (while knitting) reading older literature and watching the films and mini-series that they inspire, Jane Austen especially.
It was considered very bad form in those days to have a sick person resident in your home and to leave them only to the care of servants. The personal touch was considered required.
And those who had means had a regular routine of visiting the poor and the sick to take them food, fuel, and perhaps medicines, too.
Can anyone at FDL imagine any but a very small handful (from both chambers combined) doing anything along those lines? I know that I can’t, and I have a really good imagination, too.
Tweeted and Facebooked, Peterr, and I would have recommended, too, if this post had needed it.