In 1968, not long after the assassinations of Martin Luther King, Jr. and Bobby Kennedy, Louis Armstrong went to the ABC Records studio to record “What A Wonderful World.” It was written by George David Weiss and legendary producer Bob Thiele (Coltrane, Mingus, Gillespie). Armstrong hoped the song would lift spirits a bit after the tragedies of that year.
ABC Records Sales Manager Larry Newton hated the song. He showed up at the studio demanding an end to the session. He raged so that Thiele finally shoved Newton out of the studio door and locked it behind him. Newton pounded on the door and continued to scream that the recording session stop.
Not a bad allegory. Today’s Republicans are enraged about the health care reform proposals. Certain of their divine authority but locked out of the White House and reduced to minority party status in the House and Senate, they pound their fists on the door and shout ridiculous things into the air.
Republicans are the Mr. Newtons of America’s debate over health care reform, which is, after all, just an effort to make the world a little more wonderful. Call it Newton’s Law: When something wonderful falls from a tree and bumps a selfish grump on the noggin, it will be mistaken for a falling sky.
In his anger, Larry Newton made sure “What A Wonderful World” wasn’t promoted in the U.S. It became the biggest selling single of 1968 in England. It was a hit throughout Europe. Still ABC balked, and U.S. sales lagged. Armstrong kept singing it, though, and people loved it. If you didn’t notice, the YouTube video above has been viewed more than 18 million times. Recorded by many artists, billions have enjoyed it, countless millions paid money for it. That Larry Newton, he knew a loser when he heard it.
A word about the song: It’s magic comes from the depth of Armstrong’s performance. It celebrates life, but it’s bluesy. Armstrong’s voice carries with it the knowledge of why we sing such songs. Life is not always wonderful, and Armstrong reminds us of the tragic as he sings of the blessings.
Larry Newton seems to have been afraid that the song would bomb, or maybe he was just mad that he wasn’t in charge. Today’s big Newtons, the Republicans, just can’t stand the idea that people can work together to take care of one another. They dislike Social Security because it works, not because it doesn’t work. But it violates their hierarchical, authoritarian worldview. In their orderly universe, a few of the Elect are supposed to rule over the many un-Elect, who falter because of their own shortcomings. Giving them a hand up the ladder is immoral. It violates the all-against-all ethic.
They are also threatened when the light of the wonderful penetrates the Hobbesian gloom, which they use like B-movie horror masters to keep us quivering in our seats. The contemplated reforms in health care are going to give citizens more freedom, help them become better educated by eliminating persistent childhood illness. Reform will create more opportunity. New, hopeful entrepreneurs will be free to leave stultifying jobs in big corporations they stay in now because it’s the only way they get health insurance for their families.
For Republican horror movie moguls, this is like turning the lights on the Frankenstein’s Castle. What, they worry, will they do if the people are less anxious and afraid?
In a sense, the tables are turned. When health care reform turns on the lights, it’s the gloomy ones who become afraid. Isn’t it wonderful?



61 Comments












Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Glen,
That is a wonderful comparison to draw.
Dems= party of hope and thankfulness
GOP= party of negativity and despair
You were being subtle with your parable, I’m kinda hitting folks on the head. I lack your finess this Sunday
Ah, Glenn, you’re a romantic. Thanks for the vid.
Who doesn’t love that song?
With so much angst, especially on a Sunday Morning, I appreciate the smile. Nice, even with the context of Republican horror movie moguls.
Still I still see skies of blue….and it is a wonderful world. Just got to see it.
Lovely, Glenn. Some people just look – others see. Big difference.
You got it. The Right draws all of its energy from fear. Without fear, they have no pitch.
That song has a special meaning for me. The day after the OKC bombing a radio station played it and it went virol. I lost several close friends in the bombing as well as numerous aquaintances. The only thing between the blast and my wife was the south side of the Murrah Federal bldg. It was a very somber time and that song brought a special meaning to it.
That is a big difference — between just looking and seeing. And the Right doesn’t just fail to see, it opposes seeing altogether.
I thought this song had always been there, forever.
Maybe it had been, but it went unsung…
Thanks so much for this, I sure needed the lift.
Foothillsmike, I think the song was written and performed with just such tragic moments in mind.
In one form another, the song has been there forever, hasn’t it?
That dark side does lose its force when people just laugh at it, a favorite Ray Bradbury theme.
Holy crap-Larry Newton HATED the song? Makes you kind of feel sorry for ABC records of the late 60′s to have such a clueless exec working there. When (I’m A) Girl Watcher by The O’Kaysions is your most notable product of the era, it proves you are devoid of creative ideas.
Things we love ending up usually tugging on our heart strings.
((Mike))
This seems to be a really good Sunday School Lesson, and I am not even a religious believer. Right on Brother.
I was just in a discussion about this. If you have a moment, Ruth, could you expand a bit on the Bradbury angle. I am most interested.
Really hard to imagine the sort of psyche that could hate “What a Wonderful World,” isn’t it? But then, the entire Right Wing movement hates the song, figuratively speaking. Makes one feel sorry for them, sort of.
So true – this is why progressivism must be populist. One can not successfully argue that we are all in this together, that we are all fully human, while also arguing that the little people are fools and do not know what is good for them. All of us perform poorly when we are fearful – and we all do better when back lit by the light of the wonderful – by hope.
This is why I have such faith in the power of face-to-face contact – grassroots mobilization – as a mechanism for change. By engaging each other, we see others as fully human and engage our own humanity more completely. They may have the power of fear (and of monetary resources) but we have people power – hope, optimism, (not to mention music.)
Really? I wasn’t aware. Got a link? Or a reason why you said that.
This was the theme of ‘Something Wicked This Way Comes’,
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Something_Wicked_This_Way_Comes_(novel)
I’m a working musician Glenn and I just learned this song last week and have been performing it out. It’s a song that must be sung by a person who is in the autumn of their years…sounds pretty good solo acoustic too-I’m gonna release it on my next live CD I think. Yea, what’s not to hate about these lyrics…friggin republicans
I see trees of green, red roses too
I see them bloom for me and you
And I think to myself what a wonderful world.
I see skies of blue and clouds of white
The bright blessed day, the dark sacred night
And I think to myself what a wonderful world.
The colors of the rainbow so pretty in the sky
Are also on the faces of people going by
I see friends shaking hands saying how do you do
They’re really saying I love you.
I hear babies crying, I watch them grow
They’ll learn much more than I’ll never know
And I think to myself what a wonderful world
Yes I think to myself what a wonderful world.
You have it exactly right, including an understanding of real, face-to-face, interpersonal relationships.
That could stand as the first principle of democracy. Well said.
Be sure to tell us how to access your music. Mp3s online? CD sales online?
It’s a song that must be sung by a person who is in the autumn of their years…
I don’t get this comment, either. I must be stupid or disconnected today.
I’m just so tired of gross generalizations.
I have to disagree with this comment.
ps, when my youngest sister got married, a long time ago, my other sister did a slide show of wedding shots and childhood pictures and put it to this song. It worked then. And, at that point, no one of us sisters were in the autumn of their years.
There are young people today who understand some things.
A working musician who just learned that song? ‘Nuff said.
Thanks, Ruth.
Get off of my lawn!
/snark
yea well find me a song released in the last year worth doing…
http://www.jimdibattista.com/music-group-18.html
So Not My Job.
(I could though…) Check out some of Cat Stevens/Yousef Mohammed’s new stuff. Get with it brother.
PS, I’m new to you so you don’t know I have a B3 in my livingroom.
PPS, Nice comeback.
I didn’t read the comment as implying that younger people couldn’t understand the song’s sentiments. The song’s about the power of human love even in the presence of adversity, after all.
Saved that. thanks.
Right. I was off point.
He said It’s a song that must be sung by a person who is in the autumn of their years…
And, I was trying to say BS!
Yea I’m a grandpa now 5 times over and I see how smart my kids and grandkids are and see my 5 year old grand daughter doing homework on a computer makes me think of them during that “they’ll learn much more, than I’ll ever know” line. That’s what I meant Demi…also I have people requesting Cat Stevens and never once has anyone anywhere asked for a Yousef song…
Well, I think that old Churchill saying that a person who’s not liberal when they’re young has no heart, and a person who’s conservative when they’re old has no brain does need serious contesting!! I’d say a person who believes that has neither. Take that, Winston!
Love your allegorical mind, Mr. Smith. I also love this song, brings a tear each time I hear it. At each of my parents’ memorial services, this song was sung by a dear friend who invited the audience to join in.
Demi, more coffee for you, my friend. /Harrumph.
I can’t speak for the intelligence of your audience members. Sad, in the autumn years.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zfgdqk0QXm0..Roadsinger…he was Colbert…that old guy.
Also,
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gf_TkzVPGtE ..Maybe There’s A World…
A song about the search for peace.
All under Yousef Islam at youtube.
I think Whitman had this song in mind when he said he heard America singing.
Nice.
Glenn, What, if any, were the negative consequences for Larry Newton?
Did he go into the cookie business?
I am sure it would have been kookie.
I guess you caught the “big Newtons” pun. Sorry for that. :)
Great song, great post, always look forward to your Sunday morning thoughts, Mr Smith. Thanks.
You’re darn tootin!
well I DO play in a bar demi to a bunch of drunks so whaddaya’spect? “hey man can you play Brown Eyed Girl?”
I like fig newtons!
And Glenn’s posts, my Sunday sermons.
Totally forgot that line!
Hubby plays the b3, I play the flute, and yes. Flute goes well with Van.
yup….Moondance
I also can do that Ian Anderson humming/blowing thing.
Ok now you’re getting me turned on…
You have a new fan. I just listened to “Save the Last Dance for Me,” and it’s just perfect.
It really is a wonderful world….
It was a hanging curveball right in my wheelhouse Glenn-I hadda swing…
Wacky how it comes around, eh?
*** I meant that sound that is synonimous with Jethro Tull.
Still, and all, an interesting thread.
From you need coffee to hummmmm.
It is a wonderful world. I’ve got a garden digging project that involves a pick axe, so maybe I will make another cup of coffee.
PS….nobody scares me. Ha!
Well done Glenn, well done. I haven’t enjoyed a post as much in a while, at least one that leaves me tapping my toes and hummin’ a tune.
Born in 1957 seventh of eight and of parents who started having kids at age 29…I was singularly of true depression era ‘rents growing up in the sixites.
My dad (b. 1917) loved his jazz. He grew up dancing around to big bands’ cover bands playing off on the piers off of Lake Erie near Ashtabula, Ohio.
thanks for listening Margot and sorry for highjacking your thread Glenn
Music is never a bandit.
And, with that thought at least, Churchill was thick as a brick.
I hope you take a moment to check out those Yousef youtubes. They really are good. Inspirational. Ideas we can all share. With or without coffee.
I was a fan of Cat Stevens, and it’s time I gave Yousef’s newer music a listen.
I think of it more as the cockroaches scurrying into the wall cracks after flipping on the light switch.
Also reminds me of this video by Devo:
http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x1bply_devobeautiful-world_music
Here’a a very moving Peter Gabriel song inspired by 9-11:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bbItz_NAIEs
It was only one hour ago
It was all so different then
There’s nothing yet has really sunk in
Looks like it always did
This flesh and bone
It’s just the way that you would tied in
Now there’s no-one home
I grieve for you
You leave me
‘so hard to move on
Still loving what’s gone
They say life carries on
Carries on and on and on and on
The news that truly shocks is the empty empty page
While the final rattle rocks it’s empty empty cage
And i can’t handle this
I grieve for you
You leave me
Let it out and move on
Missing what’s gone
They say life carries on
They say life carries on and on and on
Life carries on
In the people i meet
In everyone that’s out on the street
In all the dogs and cats
In the flies and rats
In the rot and the rust
In the ashes and the dust
Life carries on and on and on and on
Life carries on and on and on
It’s just the car that we ride in
A home we reside in
The face that we hide in
The way we are tied in
And life carries on and on and on and on
Life carries on and on and on
Did I dream this belief?
Or did i believe this dream?
Now i can find relief
I grieve
- Tom
ps. Gabriel’s bass player strangely resembles G. Gordon Liddy. Weird!