Many of us were saddened – but not surprised at the report in the Guardian this week about the explosion of birth defects amongst children born in Fallujah in Iraq. Sky News has also been reporting about these conditions for the past year and a half, and their Lisa Holland wrote of her recent return trip to the Fallujah hospital:
There is no precise explanation as to what has caused the deformities and there are no figures to compare cases with those a decade or more ago as records were not kept during the time of Saddam Hussein.
All of our evidence is anecdotal, but repeatedly people tell us they believe the deformities must be linked to the heavy bombardment of Fallujah – a Sunni insurgent stronghold – by America in 2004.
People want an independent investigation into the impact of the kinds of weapons used – including controversial white phosphorus.
We can expect the same in Afghanistan where the same weapons are being used – and where extreme poverty and even fewer health resources are available. Just this week, Unicef reported that:
Eight years after the start of the international campaign to end Taliban rule in Afghanistan, more than half of all children under age five suffer from malnutrition…
The report shows that 59 per cent of Afghanistan’s children under the age of five do not get enough to eat, leading to developmental problems.
Or consider the report on the results of Israel’s Cast Lead attack on Gaza – where large amounts of American supplied White Phosphorous and other toxic weapons were used. Here’s Desmond Travers, a retired Colonel of the Army of the Irish Defence Forces, speaking to Ken Silverstein of Harpers about what he observed as part of the Goldstone investigation:
We were disturbed by the lethality and toxicity of weapons used in Gaza, some of which have been in Western arsenals since the Cold War, such as white phosphorous, which incinerated 14 people, including several children in one attack; flechettes, small darts that are designed to tumble upon entering human flesh in order to cause maximum damage, strictly in breach of the Geneva Convention; and highly carcinogenic tungsten shrapnel and dime munitions, which contain tungsten in powder form. There is also a whole cocktail of other problematic munitions suspected to have been used.
There are a number of other post-conflict issues in Gaza that need to be addressed. The land is dying. There are toxic deposits from all the munitions that have been dropped. There are serious issues with water—its depletion and its contamination. There is a high instance of nitrates in the soil that is especially dangerous to children. If these issues are not addressed, Gaza may not even be habitable by World Health Organization norms.
As Mousha Bashir or the Lebanese blog UrShalim asked after reading the Fallujah reports:
Will the UN or the USA or the UK ever acknowledge this serious problem in Iraq specifically in Fallujah, Basra, Baghdad and Al – Najaf? Will they implement the cleaning up of toxic materials that was used by the occupying forces to “bring democracy” to the people of Iraq? Was the use of Depleted Uranium and White Phosphorus, among other deadly and toxic weapons, necessary for the Birth of the “New Middle East”? Was it worth it? Just wondering…
———————-
Speaking of children, I wanted to add a personal bit of news here. My brother Jerid, who many firepups met during the Lamont campaign, has been involved for several years in working to help children in Nicaragua through his foundation, Fuel for Humanity. FFH works with the kids of Chinandega, Nicaragua where families try to make living at the local garbage dump. FFH programs have helped two of the local children go to college and one has just graduated and will receive help to go on to graduate school. They hope to add a third college student this year – and to also launch a similar program at an orphanage in Mexico.
Ok, so here’s the ask – Fuel for Humanity launched its holiday auction today and if you would like to donate items to auction or bid for some of the very neat things already there – or simply chip in a few bucks for FFH’s programs, here’s the link: 2009 Auction for Fuel for Humanity.



32 Comments





Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Good evening Siun. Any word on whether or not we used DU ammo in Falluga?
U.S. of A. Biggest govt sponsor of terrorism.
Good question Eureka … it’s my understanding that DU was used all over (and was during sanctions and the first war as well?)
Meanwhile, we’re donating 20 planes to the Afghan air force but promising no civilian aid until corruption is fixed … interesting contrast?
http://www.tradearabia.com/news/newsdetails.asp?Sn=INTNEWS&artid=170446
There’s an Afghan air force? Is there an Iraqi one? I thought the U.S. put the kaibosh on both.
Apparently they had a very strong air force that has collapsed over the years.
I remember touring the Marine Corps Museum at Quantico a couple of years ago and the tour guide said that Fallujah would go down in the Marine Corps history like Tripoli, Corregidor, and Khe Sahn — great battles won by the grit and fighting spirit of our American Marines. My mom (a Marine widow) took one look when Fallujah was mentioned and knew well enough to drag me away from the group, with a horrified look on my face.
This place will always be our shame, and the shame of the military. Anyone who knows the history of this battle, and the years-later collateral damage of these horribly disfigured children, knows America can never be proud of what we did there, Marine Corps mythmaking notwithstanding.
Very exciting about your brother’s work, Siun, thanks for bringing it to our attention tonight!
I thought the Afghan AF collapsed during the pre-9/11 period.
Oh Teddy … how awful to hear it’s presented like that!
Interesting that the U.S. marines have been reduced to glorifying the destruction of innocents as a major victory. Couldn’t have made it up better myself.
Thanks Teddy – Jerid’s done an amazing thing and I am a very proud big sis!
What I love is that FFH brings great resources direct to kids, opening new options for them in ways too often missed by the usual aid. Giving kids cameras and asking them to document their own lives, introducing them to computers and the internet, all open eyes and futures but on the kid’s own terms.
Siun wrote:
Do you have evidence white phosphorus is being used in Afghanistan? It certainly should not be.
I love your mother. Second time I’ve said this.
Siun, good work. Good for your brother too. It would be interesting to learn about the environment in which you guys grew up.
Terrific work.
There have been a number of reports on WP in Afghanistan … including one in which US forces admitted a young girl was burned.
A few links here:
http://www.hrw.org/en/news/2009/05/08/afghanistan-nato-should-come-clean-white-phosphorus
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2009/may/10/afghanistan-attacks-phosphorus-investigation
We were blessed with parents who made sure we noticed the world – and thought for ourselves. It was … invigorating.
My mom still volunteers at her local soup kitchen one day a week while my dad was a Debs/Thomas style socialist who gave me a subscription to the Catholic Worker when I turned 12. Jerid and I were very lucky in our parents.
Well, the entire museum glorifies war, it’s the Marines’ museum — and warmaking is their thing. You’d never send a Marine to do anything but make war.
But I really couldn’t believe it was being discussed in this way. Since it was really the only thing I had personal knowledge of, from our Iraki compatriots and your work here, Siun, it made me wonder about all the other glorious battles we’d heard about thus far in the tour.
Good point about doubting other battles. Even I was not cynical enough to think of that.
Thank you Siun, for the post, for the info about your brother’s project (wow!) and for keeping at this, week after week.
We’re never going to win in Afghanistan if six out of ten children are so hungry their development is affected. Never.
Oh, if you ever need a dose of “even more cynical,” I’m right here, sister.
As many have asked in the past, what would a win look like? I really hate to think about it…. could be awful.
The only reason I check my cynicism is because real other people find it so offputting. Oh, and also because I find it so depressing. But it is usually right.
The Soviets “won” in Afghanistan by total war, i.e. every man, woman & child was a target in some regions. It was only the U.S. stingers that defeated the Soviets. As long as they had air superiority, they had control.
Which raises the issue of why the U.S. military is not as competent as the Soviets. U.S. shows no aversion to bombing innocents.
Admirable parents to be sure. You’ve both made them proud.
No, no Teddy. Marines do other things than war. They volunteer in schools, they help with wildfires, they really do what is needed. When they are assigned to war, that is what they must do, but don’t sell these guys and gals short. They contribute immensely in proportion to their incomes.
(Which is another point that makes me cringe.)
Jane’s up with more of the amazing Pharma talking points story upstairs.
And I’m off to watch The Prisoner!
“The answer is blowin’ in the wind.” Yes, in general DU has been used all over Iraq. I read somewhere it is in virtually all artillery munitions, even for rifle bullets. Got to get rid of that stuff somehow, ya know? If not, we’d have to bury it somewhere, like Utah/s. We’ve used hundreds if not thousands of tone of it since the first Gulf War.
From the FAIR website:
We Think the Price Is Worth It
Media uncurious about Iraq policy effects—there or here
By Rahul Mahajan
Lesley Stahl on U.S. sanctions against Iraq: We have heard that a half million children have died. I mean, that’s more children than died in Hiroshima. And, you know, is the price worth it?
Secretary of State Madeleine Albright: I think this is a very hard choice, but the price–we think the price is worth it.
–60 Minutes (5/12/96)
Then-Secretary of State Madeleine Albright’s quote, calmly asserting that U.S. policy objectives were worth the sacrifice of half a million Arab children, has been much quoted in the Arabic press. It’s also been cited in the United States in alternative commentary on the September 11 attacks (e.g., Alexander Cockburn, New York Press, 9/26/01).
But a Dow Jones search of mainstream news sources since September 11 turns up only one reference to the quote–in an op-ed in the Orange Country Register (9/16/01). This omission is striking, given the major role that Iraq sanctions play in the ideology of archenemy Osama bin Laden; his recruitment video features pictures of Iraqi babies wasting away from malnutrition and lack of medicine (New York Daily News, 9/28/01). The inference that Albright and the terrorists may have shared a common rationale–a belief that the deaths of thousands of innocents are a price worth paying to achieve one’s political ends–does not seem to be one that can be made in U.S. mass media.
george:
The gap between how most Americans view our nation’s foreign policy and how it really functions instead makes the Grand Canyon look like a crack in the sidewalk. Even worse, only a tiny percentage of us give a damn at all. We live in a pop culture, celebrity saturated world. The deformed children in Fallujah next to Sarah Palin and Balloon Boy? Right. Hell, every single day more than 18,000 children aged 5 years and younger die from starvation. Every single day.
That’s 6,800,000 dead children every year. When’s the last time you came across that in the mainstream media?
I meant, the answer (to your question), literally, is blowin’ in the wind.
The Albright quote is one we should never forget.
Agreed. So callous, so dismissive of the lives of thousands of innocents. I hold Medeleine Albright in the same regard as I do Barbara Bush.
Siun, thanks once again. You always raise the consciousness with your shares and open the heart. You and your brother are such role models. Thank you.