![]() |
|
Help me welcome Laura Clawson, senior writer at the AFL-CIO community affiliate Working America (and also front-page blogger on Daily Kos…shhhh. Don’t tell.). Laura joins us today for our discussion.
You’d have to be living in a cave, or in a willful veil of ignorance, not to know how people in this country are suffering in our broken health care system. If you have health insurance through your job, that’s one more reason to be desperately afraid of losing that job (with unemployment at 9.4 percent, no less;), if you get it as an individual or a family, you have to worry that your insurance company will find a reason to dump you the minute you need it most (whether you’re insured through your job or on your own, your health care costs are exploding. Then, of course, there are the 47 million people without insurance in the United States.
Blah blah blah.
But did you know that the lolcat community is suffering? If, so far, you’ve been able to push the health care crisis to the back of your mind and put off making your voice heard, how does it make you feel to see that Dr. Tinycat can’t get care because he’s out of network?
Let’s say you can ignore cases like this one from Nancy from Illinois, one of more than 26,000 such stories that poured into the AFL-CIO/Working America 2009 Health Care for America Survey:
As a melanoma skin cancer survivor, I am uninsurable—my risk is too high to be profitable for an insurance company. This means I am one job loss away from having no health insurance. As a 54-year-old, I am 11 years away from Medicaid eligibility. It’s enough to make me downright nervous. Meanwhile, costs for even those of us lucky enough to be insured are going up to cover the increasing numbers of uninsured. This is why I tell my children, at least half seriously, to emigrate if they have the chance—I fear government in the U.S. is too beholden to insurance interests and other corporate interests to be concerned with the welfare of American citizens.
Can you ignore this tiny pug pup being denied coverage?
If you’re a regular at the Lake, you’ve probably written to your elected representatives, made phone calls, taken action in other ways. But you probably also have friends and family who support real health care reform without taking that next step. Working America meets those people every day in our work on the ground in 12 states (and, like Survey USA, we find that people want real reform). In fact, our numbers are pretty much in line with theirs—when we talk to people on their doorsteps and ask them directly to take action, nearly two out of three write letters or make calls telling their elected representatives to support health care reform with a public option.
Just this Tuesday, Working America canvassers knocked on 200 doors in the small town of Delphi, Ind., where Rep. Joe Donnelly was planning a town hall meeting. They collected 150 letters addressed to Donnelly and to Sen. Evan Bayh. That’s an incredible result—and it’s also people who take the time to do something. More than that tell us they’re supportive but just don’t have time.
In addition to the phone calls we’re all making and the letters we’re all writing and the town halls we’re attending, we as a progressive movement fighting for real reform need to be targeting those people who are supportive but just don’t have time. And that’s the vein in which Working America started "I can has health care."
Because sometimes you have to try something a little different.
By now, a lot of people are a little numb. They’ve learned to tune out another sad story of a woman losing her insurance because her insurance company didn’t want to pay to treat her for cancer and dug up an old dermatologist appointment for acne that she hadn’t told them about when she purchased the insurance.
They tune it out because if they confronted it head on, they’d realize how scared they needed to be in our current broken system. And I’m sure we’re all familiar with that feeling, that you just can’t take any more bad news so you’re going to close your eyes and hope it goes away. Maybe if we put it in a new frame, get the element of surprise and maybe some laughter, a few more people will face up to just how important they know—buried somewhere in their hearts—health care reform is. And really, that’s how we build movements: A few people at a time.
So, please, send them on to your friends. You can see all our current lolcats and dogs and others here.
Related posts:
- Liveblogging the Obama Health Care Presser: Cost Control Up Front; Politics Pushed Aside?
- Mitt Romney’s Idea of Health Care Reform: Giving Big Insurance Whatever They Want
- The Political Time Bomb Inside Health Care Reform
- Funds Spent This Year by Health Care Lobby Would Have Insured All Who Died from Lack of Insurance
- Clergy Know About Health Care Rationing






Spotlight








Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Advanced search

Basically, like a lot of progressives in this fight for health care, we at Working America are trying to take every angle we can. Beating our heads against a lot of different walls at once, I guess you could say.
Welcome to the Lake, and thanks for all of your efforts.
Although at times I’m sure it must feel like banging your head against a bunch of walls.
Probably gonna require some more banging, too.
It’s 11 years away from Medicare not Medicaid.
Yep. Nobody I’ve talked to is ready to quit.
So you were in my neck of the woods? I know Joe Donnelly, I keep trying to figure out a way to nudge him in a more progressive direction, especially on an issue like health care.
Thanks for this report Laura.
I personally wasn’t in Indiana, but we had a canvass team there — I know some of our people went to his town hall and I believe they managed to ask some questions and talk to him afterward, including giving him the letters from Delphi residents.
Indeed it is. I unfortunately don’t have access to fix it — and since it’s in the blockquote I guess that’s what the survey respondent said.
Good to hear. I hope we manage to apply enough pressure to get him to break with his blue dog colleagues. IMO, Bayh is completely bought and paid for, but I still have hope for Joe.
many are aware that this support does not translate to a watered-down, defective by design, postponed ‘public option’ that kicks in conveniently after the election cycle of 2012.
and it shouldn’t. Like Bush speaking of Iraq and 9/11 in the same breath, but not explicitly linking them, there are those who like to cite high favorability ratings for major reform that would hurt the corporations that have been such generous donors to so many Democratic pols, and then try to elide this into support for whatever plan emerges from the nasty sausage making going on right now in D.C.
but, they are not equivalent.
Mr Bruce wants helth kare too
Hi Laura. TomP here (it was already used on firedoglake.)
Just want to tell you that you do great work.
I’m more hopeful. They say Feinstein will support public option.
It would be so good to have Obama and progresives together with 50 sentators (Biden can vote tiebreaker) and no more bs coops.
We need a coalition for change and the blue dogs will fight us all the way.
Mr. Bruce is awesome! Sending him to Christian Norton, our online organizer who developed our lolcats…
Hi Tom! Good to see you here.
I very much like the idea Jane and Kagro have been pushing that you name the public option, not the whole health care reform bill, after Ted Kennedy. Make it clear that a strong bill is what you do in his memory. That thought makes me more hopeful today as well.
I agree. That is a great idea.
The attempt to coopt Kennedy’s memory by Republicans or Baucus to provide cover for coops must be combatted, and that is the way to do it.
Laura,
Why aren’t we getting more people with real horror stories into the town halls? Aren’t moments like the one that showed Coburn as the insensitive ass he is helpful to our cause?
It is time to say no compromise, we want Medicare open to all. Call Medicare for all (paid by fair premiums, with subsidies available for private insurance as well as Medicare via a insurance exchange) Teddycare as suggested up thread.
Keep the mandate, so that healthy young people have to buy health insurance, no free riders. Give the free market absolutists a choice, the invisible hand will assure that the most efficient and innovative pans win.
Good question. I saw that Coburn segment. Major Asshole.
But wait: He’s a doctor. He must know all about this stuff, right? He’s been on The Front Lines. (With his hand out…)
I don’t know. We know that public sentiment is with us, and a whole host of pro-reform groups are working to turn people out. My own theory is it’s partly about who’s being covered by the media — the screamers are more sexy and exciting for tv coverage, you know? When I read reports from Working America staff and others I know who are going to town halls, it definitely sounds like the crowds are a lot more evenly balanced than you’d think from following traditional reporting. But evenly balanced is still not the clear majority in support we see in polling, so…I don’t know.
That’s Senator Asshole, ShotoJamf.
Funny thing about MDs: typically they don’t know the economics of the macro situation all that well. Physicians focus on the individual patient, the system has to focus on the whole population.
Why isn’t the fact that there is so much profiteering through the health industrial complex the reason it costs so much?????????????????
The costs are inflated ENORMOUSLY by everyone in the game taking PROFIT (making out on misery)
Hi Labor Women! I negotiate public sector CBO’s here in California and neither the employer nor the employee can continue to afford double digit increases in premiums. Employers are scaling back on coverage to just employees and the co-pays, perscriptions and declines in network providers is awful – don’t get me started on brokers. We have had SB840 (Keuhl) pass both houses twice and both times vetoed by Der Gropenfuehrer. It will return this sessionas SB 810 (Leno) and is comprehensive, single-payer and uses the 30%-plus admin fees to cover the uninsured. There is simply no role for the insurance industry. When I have tried to get the employers to urge it’s passage, they simply cannot bring themselves to do despite the Lewin Group’s (yes, that Lewin Group) report that such adoption would generate over 20 BILLION in savings in the first year alone. Your thoughts?
In my hast to post I failed to mention that the cost spirals bear no relation to either the consumer price index or the cost of living increases. Thus, instead of economic improvement, the working men and women I am proud to represent are sliding rapidly into the lower economic levels. When I ask them if they ever in their wildest dreams imagined that they would be earning less than they did years ago – the answer is an unequivalble NO!
While I agree with the concept, I would hope it would be improved.
I’m not sure but it seems a lot of folks aren’t aware of how inadequate Medicare is.
Plain Medicare covers no drugs, no Doctor’s visits, and only 80% of the stuff it does cover. So one stay in a hospital, with a bill of $100,000, and you’re left with a bill of $20,000.
Now there are supplements for Medicare, but they aren’t free (meaning part of your Medicare benefit) and the drug coverage is NOT great (it’s better than nothing though).
Fact is, while I support single payer, and support the concept of “Medicare for All”, I would hope Medicare would be improved in any effort like that.
the lack of the ability to answer the point I raised is itself an answer.
really, good luck trying to raise grassroots support for a nebulous, undefined compromised plan written largely by lobbyists from the affected industries.
On the other hand, Nicholas Kristof says our health care system is fit for animals. http://tinyurl.com/ndkl6o
You’re right. Plain vanilla Medicare isn’t all that and a bowl of chips. But supplemental policies are available and tend to be reasonably priced. Beyond that, universal Medicare would be a damned sight better than anything currently being proposed.
Good afternoon,Ms. Connell:
Would you happen to know if Rick Berman is behind a lot of this anti-health care reform, the way he has been ,along with the Chamber of Commerce, lobbying against EFCA?
“…it’s partly about who’s being covered by the media — the screamers are more sexy and exciting for tv coverage, you know.”
This is an important point you make.
So, how to get News coverage?
Perhaps a few thousand people in the Streets outside of the White House when Obama and everyone else returns from vacation. A little Shock and Awe? Many legislators (even on the left) have been hoping the Public Option noise will just go away. Its why they tossed the bone of CIA memos before they left the Hill. It’s time to turn up the volume… before they do name a wishy-washy, no PO bill after Ted Kennedy.
Why is AFL-CIO uninviting single payer advocates from their events?
http://www.davidswanson.org/node/2053
Good news!
A spokesman for Sen. Mark Warner (D-VA) confirms to me that Warner would vote for a health care bill with a public option. “It’s not a make or break thing–he wants to see a health reform bill that contains costs, and if it includes a public option…he would vote for it.”
http://tpmdc.talkingpointsmemo…..-costs.php
Gee Whiz, that is strong language… not. Again, strikes the tone of appeasement. Public Option should be “A make or break thing,” if he wants his constituency to remain in place.
Cost controls are a perfectly reasonable objection to the Public Option. And if that objection can somehow be discredited, there is no reason the likes of Warner and others should not come on board. There was a great article in the New Yorker regarding Cost Control in June 2009:
http://www.newyorker.com/repor…..ct_gawande
Hey Gitcheegumee!
welcome to the thrilling discussion where the visitor from Kos haughtily ignores everyone who is off message!
Err, sorry. I stayed around for about an hour then had to step out. Just checking back now…
I don’t know about Berman himself, but the Wonk Room just had a post on some of the connections between anti-HRC and anti-Employee Free Choice groups.