OK, you’re back? Where were we . . .
In Harvey Milk’s campaigns for office in San Francisco, his stump speech and his conversations kept coming back to one word, a word sadly missing from much of our current political debate on Capitol Hill, a word so powerful it scares the GOP to death:
Hope.
Here’s the tail end of that speech:
And the young gay people in the Altoona, Pennsylvanias and the Richmond, Minnesotas who are coming out and hear Anita Bryant on television and her story. The only thing they have to look forward to is hope. And you have to give them hope. Hope for a better world, hope for a better tomorrow, hope for a better place to come to if the pressures at home are too great. Hope that all will be all right. Without hope, not only gays, but the blacks, the seniors, the handicapped, the us’es, the us’es will give up. And if you help elect to the central committee and other offices, more gay people, that gives a green light to all who feel disenfranchised, a green light to move forward. It means hope to a nation that has given up, because if a gay person makes it, the doors are open to everyone.
The alternatives to hope offered by the GOP are all too often fear ("be afraid of Teh Scary Brown/Gay/Poor people!"), callous indifference ("all you need to do is tug on those bootstraps a little harder"), denial ("what problem?"), or despair ("the problem is too big"). Sorry, but life is too short to live filled with fear and indifference and despair — and more and more people are catching on to that, Lou Dobbs, Glenn Beck, and Larry Kudlow notwithstanding.
I never knew Harvey, but I know a lot of folks like him — folks who give hope to those on the margins. An old speech teacher who saw the closeted gay kid, and helped him stand tall. Two gay ushers, quietly enjoying their 40 year relationship and gladly welcoming all kinds of people on the margins to their church. A lesbian nurse, who astounds homophobic patients her compassion. People who run soup kitchens, who teach immigrants about the US, who provide legal services to those without resources. Day in and day out, they work to give people hope.
And then there are the teens at Shawnee Mission East High School, who stood proudly against bigotry when it came to visit. That’s them in the YouTube above, produced by Thomas Hadden and Kyle Little.
This is Pride weekend in many parts of the US, and proudly embracing a vision of hope is a grand and glorious thing. Every Pride parade is evidence that Harvey’s vision of hope is contagious. Hope is spread by human contact, by rejecting fear and isolation in favor of compassion and celebration.
Imagine a Pandemic of Hope, spreading even to the halls of the Capitol.
But for this, you don’t have to imagine. All you have to do is look around, or maybe open a book, and then join in spreading the hope around. It might take a lot of phone calls, but sooner or later even Congress will get infected.



43 Comments





Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
don’t forget don’t-give-a-good-goddamn-edness (see “hunger can be a good motivator)
That’s not “I don’t give a damn” — it is a badly disguised version of the “fear” category. The state rep in question comes from a district in the suburbs and exurbs of St. Louis, and the language she used is straight out of the racist rants of those who fled St. Louis so that their taxes wouldn’t have to go to “those people” and their schools. Desegregation is a dirty word in her neck of the woods, and talking about the waste associated with more “free lunches and breakfasts” is pure racist code language.
Good morning Peterr.
Imagine a Senator Harvey Milk indeed.
I truly believe we are headed towards equality for all, but we have a ways to go yet.
I agree. It’s every day for as long as it takes. We made a slight move forward in Nov but nowhere near what is needed. This marathon is a bit longer than many thought it would be.
Never. Give. Up.
Obama ran on Hope and Change. I’m much more interested in actions right now.
Keep hope alive! I don’t know who said it first, but he or she understood humans well. Where there is no hope there is fear, and isolation and anger. Where there is hope there is love, and progress and community. Thank you for reminding us that once, in close proximity to the fearful Senator Diane Feinstein, there was a man who personified hope and love and progress and community for all Americans, gay and straight and those somewhere in between.
Why there isn’t a foundation or a national service award or scholarships given in Harvey Milk’s name is beyond me. Harvey Milk was a great and imperfect American in the spirit of Lincoln. Long may his spirit live and flourish.
Thank you for your generous remembrance of him, and the principles by which he lived his too brief life.
That’s why the actions of the kids in the YouTube are so important. It’s not just words, but how those words are put into practice.
It’s also why I think the work of Howie Klein, Jane, and others to create and build Blue America is so important. Congress is where so much of the work has to be done.
Speaking of hope I put this up at PUAC but appropriate here as well. We need more of this thinking.
Marathon indeed, we must remember we are trying to erase centuries of bigotry and it just may take a couple of centuries to truly have equality where color ,race, religion or even social strata means nothing. Where every citizen is cherished for who They are and not what they look like or how much money they have. Where all are treated equally in the eyes of the Law and by every man woman and child.
In my life I have found that if you hold preconceptions of some one because of some preconceived bias you loose the opportunity to meet someone who may enrich you life in ways you can never know if you don’t open your mind & heart and embrace that person’s uniqueness. You truly will miss out in the joy of knowing another!
We are truly much more alike than we are different.
There’s no such thing as a stranger, it’s just a friend you haven’t yet met.
AND THE KILLIN’ GOEZ ON AND ON AND…
Citizen Peterr and the Firepup Freedom Fighters:
With regard to the the “Feinstein problem”, this is jest indicitive of the overall problem of the political structure of the state of California…the entire state is fucked politically and jest removin’ a senator or two or gettin an entire new congressional delegation won’t save the state from the hell that awaits it in the next 5-10 years. Our national political structure suffers the same problem of diliberate gridlock but the genius of the tripart system is that an executive with a national political consensus behind him (from the people) can break thru the carefully built firewalls to change.
Feinstein must go and the country will be better off for it but that’s jest the beginnin’ for the people of California…I think California may breakup before they can get their shit together out there. (And before any of you sunshine chauvantists freak out, I lived in california for about 8 years and have an undergraduate degree from UC Irvine.)
KEEP THE FAITH AND PASS THE AMMUNITION, THERE IS NO COMPROMISING WITH FASCISM!!
I couldn’t agree more! Of course there is then after that first meeting that you find that person is closed or incompatible and is then is someone you may not want to have as a friend, but if you don’t at least try you will never know and miss so much in life.
I always wondered about that Milk/Moscone/Feinstein thing.
Speaking of Imagining, imagine a Congress not beholden to the Military-Industrial Complex?
Citizen Southern Dragon:
Bless yer romantic Dixie heart there Brother Dragon…I need the reminder that we are all in this shit together even if it’s deeper for some of us than others.
And your point is??
Those parts of Prop 13 that require a 2/3’s super majority for new taxes and a budget need to be changed to maybe just a 60% percent to enacted new taxes/budget.
I also think gerrymandering in all states need to go, districts should be based strictly on geographic locality not some meandering stretches of populations based on where your party members live. It is just begging for corruption when the incumbent Knows they are safe because of the way the boundaries are drawn in smoke filled back rooms.
How’s retirement Norski??
Was it Franklin who said, “We hang together or we’ll hang separately.”?
Amen, nahant, and beautifully put.
There’s a petition in the works in FL to do away with gerrymandering in the state constitution. It’s really pathetic and so overtly rigged here. Four years ago Hometown Democracy started gathering sigs for another ballot initiative to allow citizens a voice in how their communities were developed. The developers fought it from day one. Got the legislature to pass a law that people could refute their sigs on petitions, hoping enough would do so to keep HD off the ballot. FLSC on the 19th ruled the law was unconstitutional and the 711,000+ sigs were certified on Monday the 22nd. It’ll be on the ballot in 2010. The folks here are tired of the corrupt Rethugs driving the state into a ditch then trying to cover it with shit.
See the movie Kassie, truly enlightening. Feinstein is truly part of the problem both in California and Washington, I truly have no respect for the woman she is part of the Biog moneyed cliche who have a strangle hold on our government.
Here is a way we can all start to make the changes to take our government back and make it for the People!
Visit Youstreet here and sign up: http://youstreet.org/
“Sunshine chauvantists”?? Come on Norske, be nice! But it’s certainly true that Prop 13 has hurt us in a lot of ways.
Gerrymandering is just wrong, and it’s been taken to obscene extremes. Honest redistricting would go a long way towards good government.
I had moved from CA when 13 went on the ballot. It blew my mind it passed.
The one part of Prop 13 I do agree with is on property taxes only rising by a max of 2% per year based on your original price and not willy nilly as the county sees fit, especially here in California where property values have risen so steeply. Before Prop 13 many older folks were taxed out of their life long homes in their golden years when they most need to live in their homes of many years.
The county should never be able to tax people out of their homes period, it is wrong on oh so many levels!
Boy do I love EDIT!!
Isn’t it interesting that changes to the system are all based simply on “honesty?”
Mine too. I certainly never thought it would hold up in court.
IIRC that was the biggest selling point of 13: gramma won’t be taxed out her home.
Citizen SouthernDragon:
Yes that’s attributed to Gentle Ben Franklin…but sometimes it seems that the country has got a bad case of diarhea and all we got is pay toilets.
as if we can trust the political parties to be honest, especially when it comes to holding on to power.
Citizen nahant:
But that was the whole idea behind Prop 13, more than anything it pumped up the real estate bubble that made the large land holders and financial speculators richer and they never had ta pay a dime in increased taxes …the windfall was spead through the entire middle class of California beginnin’ in the mid 70’s and the citizenry didn’t realize that the oligarchy was stealin’ the state treasury while everyone else floated on top of the inflated housing values.
And there’s the rub, non?
oui
I do believe you are correct!
But I feel strongly that the local governments were going way to far in raising the local property taxes at times it seemed just so that the old folks would have to move. But under Prop 13 neighborhoods are more stable as us older folks are not be taxed out of our homes. I do know as our home has risen greatly in value and if we had to pay current market values in property taxes we would be forced to sell, just when we need to have the most stability in our lives, so we have a home to live in and not some apartment as I had earlier in life. We have earned that stability and the county/state has no business in taxing us out of our home! If the county could still do that our state’s fiscal health would be worse off as many elders would have to rely on State money just to live on SS is never enough and the way 401K’s have tanked we still won’t be able to retire the way we thought we could anyway.
That is the down side Norski… OK so those who DO have large landholdings and based on Their income you raise their property taxes by a larger percentage. I know I know it is not perfect but… We must let the older folks stay in their homes. Or maybe just exempt the primary residence from raising so fast???
It was all the nasty consequences of 13 that never got any press. FL has a cap the yearly increase on homesteaded property taxes and that particular legislation didn’t have a lot of shit attached to it. The legislature came out with it’s version of 13 last year. Once the housing bubble went kaboom the folks who voted for it realized what they’d done. We’re still trying to get that remedied. Sorry ass excuse for a state legislature we’ve got.
Here it’s no greater than 3% on a homesteaded property, what you’d call primary residence. When you buy a home in FL as your primary residence you apply for a homestead exemption, which subtracts a set amount from the assessed value of the home. Year before last they raised it to $50K from $25K. The increase was one of the selling points of whatever amendment number it was, equiv to your prop number. On the ballot in 06.
I have read a little about that SD, at least here the county has to lower taxes if the value goes down below the assessed value. We fortunately haven’t lost any value and because We went Solar it has only increased in Value compared to my neighbors. It also doesn’t hurt that our home is just 1/4 mile from Atherton, the most expensive town in the country, 3.2 mill for a starter home there!!
We do love our Solar Power, we can run everything at once during the day and the meter still goes backwards!!
Citizen nahant:
It’s simple, at least for California: get rid of the property tax and bump up the income tax on the top end and increase the sales tax on “luxury” items and financial services.
The imbalance in incomes and the public debt are so bad right now that only confiscatory taxation through progressive taxes and targeted sales and use taxes will give the people of California a fightin’ chance.
Wow, Peterr, what a powerful imaginary you’ve posted. Took my breath away right at the outset of your post, that one did.
The problem is that if anyone (including an older person) wants or has to move, property taxes on the new house are reset to 1% of current value, defined as sales price. So even if one wanted to move to a house of the same or lesser value, taxes would go up exponentially. Prop 13 assumed that incomes would go up at an equal rate, a singularly false assumption. Also, I believe that since commercial properties change hands less frequently, the tax burden has shifted disproportionately away from business to residential property owners.
nahant, perhaps you could do an update with links back to your series.
I’m sure the pups would really appreciate it and you might just spur a few on to making the transition. I’m envious myself but don’t have the means right now to do it. Aside from the investment in the system itself, it would also require the removal of a row over waAay overgrown hemlocks. (I do love the hemlock but these guys are 50 years old and have outlived their usefulness as a screen between.) properties.
I have been mulling just that over. As for cost We used http://www.Solarcity.com and they have a lease program where there is nothing down and based on the size of the system you start paying the lease when the system has passed all inspections and is online! Solar City has been great, the installers , management and people on the phone have been warm and very friendly. They all go out of their way to make sure you are happy and are getting what you are paying for. We don’t owe PG&E anything in fact we have almost a $1,000.00 credit with them and pay them nothing including all the natural gas we use!! I couldn’t give a better recommendation for any product/service I have ever purchased. You can see our results here.
As you can see we generate almost 60KWH per day!!
You are so correct about the transfer of revenues from commercial property owners to new buyers of residential houses. In fact, I’ve heard of leases up to 7 layers deep, written so that a mini-mall or executive park doesn’t change legal owners, and thereby increase taxes. Very few commercial properties have changed hands since Prop 13 passed, though they have been transferred via long-term leases many times. Although sold as a benefit for grandma, Prop 13 instead benefited the multi-millionaire owners of commercial properties throughout the state. Who could have seen that coming?