Here is our final whip count. For those who have been following, Barney Frank called me on Thursday June 4, after the Republicans said they would vote en masse against the supplemental. Barney told me about the Graham-Lieberman photo suppression amendment, which really wasn’t on anyone’s radar yet. Our first committed vote was Eric Massa, 11 days ago on June 5. He stayed true to his word despite the fact that Jim Jones and others were personally putting tremendous pressure on him.
By Monday the 8th, we had 12, but we lost 6 (as we knew we would) when the Lieberman photos came out of the bill. By June 12, we had 22. On June 13, we got hold of an internal Hill list that had the commitments that members had made to each other which gave us 32 — as you can see, 6 of the 10 defections came from from that list, so they were turning their backs on their colleagues to vote "yea."
By June 15, we had 36 of the 39 votes we needed. In the end we took 32, picking up 7 that people worked really tenaciously for days on delivering. Rahm and the entire White House staff would have been *ecstatic* at those 7 votes.
- Tammy Baldwin — Citizen Whip on June 9.
- Michael Capuano — June 12.
- Yvette Clarke YEA — Citizen Whip on June 9, also on internal Hill list.
- John Conyers — June 9.
- Jerry Costello YEA — internal Hill list.
- Peter DeFazio YEA – Citizen Whip, June 11.
- Lloyd Doggett — Committed on June 11.
- Donna Edwards — internal Hill list.
- Keith Ellison — Citizen Whip "no," then Citizen Whip "yes." Whips kept calling.
- Sam Farr — committed on June 9, went wobbly at the last minute, but came back after an all-out push.
- Bob Filner — Citizen whip on June 5, internal Hill list.
- Raul Grijalva — committed on June 9, also went wobbly there but came back.
- Alan Grayson– June 7.
- Luis Gutierrez YEA — internal Hill list.
- Jay Inslee YEA — Citizen Whip June 11.
- Steve Kagen YEA — internal Hill list.
- Marcy Kaptur — CQ Politics June 11.
- Dennis Kucinich – June 11.
- Barbara Lee — Citizen Whip on June 5.
- John Lewis NV –Citizen Whip.
- Eric Massa — June 5.
- James McGovern — committed on June 9, caught #rahmflu at the last minute, but recovered.
- Michael Michaud — Turn Maine Blue.
- Richard Neal YEA — Citizen Whip.
- Jim Oberstar YEA — internal Hill list.
- Chellie Pingree — Turn Maine Blue.
- Jose Serrano — internal Hill list.
- Carol Shea-Porter — internal Hill list.
- Brad Sherman — June 12.
- Jackie Speier — Citizen Whip, June 15.
- Pete Stark — Citizen Whip, June 11.
- Niki Tsongas — internal Hill list.
- Nydia Velasquez YEA — internal Hill list.
- Maxine Waters — June 8.
- Diane Watson — Citizen Whip on June 9.
- Lynn Woolsey — Citizen Whip on June 9.
Pickups:
- Mike Honda — Targeted on June 15.
- Zoe Lofgren — Targeted on June 16.
- Donald Payne — Targeted on June 16.
- Jared Polis — Targeted on June 15.
- John Tierney — Targeted on June 15.
- Peter Welch — Was pretty much a certain "yes," but then Green Mountain Daily got into the act. Go Odum.
I’ll have a lot more to say later, and a ton of people to thank–since some didn’t want to be acknowledged at the time I need to back and write up a comprehensive list. But I’m pretty sure it started with Bob Fertik emailing me and David Swanson that he was twittering progressive caucus members, and it quickly took on a life of its own.
But every single person who worked on this was inspirational, especially the people who made the Citizen Whip Count work (I think there were 1,200 or so of you). As I’m going over all the old posts, I am just incredibly excited and energized by what happened. We all knew we were going to "lose" eventually, but "winning" was never the goal.
Just remember:
They had to hold it open 10 extra minutes and after the Dems hit 218 and there were five GOP votes that scurried in under the wire.
We made the President of the United States himself whip to get the votes.
We tried to make the Dems fight like this when Bush was in office to stop funding the war, but they wouldn’t–so we did it ourselves.
I’m very proud to have worked with every single one of you. This was going to be a rout. They had to work for it.
Let’s do it again.



37 Comments












Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Why have we moved further right since Obama became President?
Not to be a pedant, but I think you meant it was going to be a “rout,” not a “route.”
Without exaggeration… this was awesome.
Especially in what it signals.
And you, Jane, were awesome too.
Jane and All. Thank-you! :) Magnificent effort and a formidable flexing of ‘people power’.. :)
This was a phenomenal effort, and just like when the netroots started mobilizing behind candidates things can only get better as the efforts are refined. Everyone made some noise, I’m guessing Obama’s crew are thinking long and hard about how much of a fight was put up by the “rabble”.
Obama said to make him do the right thing, and this is a big step down that road. Obama may find it easy to be co-opted (or not) by his foul money mongers, but they don’t have unfettered power so much anymore.
Absolutely let’s do it again ! Just warming up for the health care fight and it’s going to get ugly.
Because Obama was raised as a corporatist DLC type in fact if not in name. trained in the mindset that “compromising” with the Republicans was the only way for Democrats to ever win anything.
And now that the Republicans have veered so hard to the right that they have somehow driven the country over several cliff edges in rapid succession… Obama dutifully follows them. And so does his administration.
Learned a LOT. We always knew we were going to lose, so everything we got was a win. At first some tried to get the big groups in but halfway through typing up an email to one I went “fuckit, it’s easier without having to deal with them” — and it was. Would’ve been a liability.
Amazing work everyone – especially Jane who sure knows how to whip those votes!
Do it again – you bet!
And let’s call the folks who stood firm and thank them – and then tell them we expect them to stand up for progressive policies everyday.
Congratulations everyone – especially Jane!
My freshman Congressman was not on the list, but I called him anyway. His staff was very pleasant but said he would be voting for the funding. At least he heard my concerns as well.
Eli is upstairs at the Mothership!
The War On Marriage Claims Another Victim
You rock the house, Jane Hamsher.
Bullseye, thank you.
Seconded.
This was a big, tough deal; Rahm will not forget who wound up where, and we should be sure to remember who stood with us.
Comletely agree.
/mumble
Lacy voted Yea. Boeing desperately needed that money judging from husband’s alarm.
/mumble
very good idea.
Absolutely. Jane Hamsher shapes democracy (again!).
Thank you, Jane. You’re right. This was fun, let’s do it again … and again …. and again until they know.
Well played.
Are ya happy ya beat the hippies, Rahm? Are ya?
Whatta punk.
If Rahm’s true to his son-of-a-bitch nature [as we all know he is], he’s gonna have a L-O-N-G memory about this.
We can take it [I’m assuming, Jane, that you can]. It’s the Congresscritters I’m worried about.
I second the motions above to tell those who withstood Rahm’s entreaties and stood with us how much we appreciate them.
And it might not hurt to mention, somewhere down the line, Rahm’s willingness to “go dirty,” by offering to not compete against Republicans, in order to win their votes. That’s certainly a “change” in the idea of “bi-partisanship,” but not one I can believe in.
Thanks Jane! We may not have won this round, but it felt really really good to have finally gotten their attention. We couldn’t have done it without you!
Thanks Jane. This kind of action is really needed.
I’m so pissed at my Rep, Earl Blumenauer from Portland, OR. He plays progressive, but only on the safest issues, and gets elected time after time in this very blue district.
I am proud of our newbie, Jackie Speier, for voting to keep her campaign promises, esp. given that fellow locals Nancy Pelosi and Anna Eshoo voted “yay”. That’s some peer pressure. Perhaps there is a newbie v. incumbent trend? probably wishful thinking on my part.
I’m disappointed with the Floridians Wasserman Schultz and Wexler. WTH?
You got that right.
Jane, thanks for getting Zoe Lofgren. I hope i helped in some small way.
The part that sucks is we lost and I refuse to buy into the “We knew we were going to lose,” statement. I play to win and I hate losing.
Next time around, we need twice the pressure as we had this time. We need demonstrations in front of congresscritters’ offices and we need to let them know we want the goddam war to end, NOW!
Money ONLY for withdrawal. Just GTFO.
Millions of Americans are grateful tonight that the supplemental passed. You did a great disservice to Barack Obama in this effort. Trying to high jack Democracy doesn’t work.
Jane – when the first roll call was put up, Peter Welch was shown as a “yes” vote. The final roll call has him down as a “no” vote. I’m going to place a few calls today to find out if this was indeed correct, and if so, why did Welch switch his vote. The cynic in me thinks that Welch changed his vote only after he saw that passage was secured.
Jane,
Remember when we had a debate over a series of posts about doing more? You promised me to be patient, that FDL would “do more” to affect legislative change.
I am humbled by the depth of this effort. You. Kept. Your. Promise.
Thank you. Thank you very much.
Certainly do it again. It’s better than nothing, but in its present form it probably won’t be effective. The vote was close only because Repubs opposed the supplemental for reasons having nothing to do with opposing the war. Take my representative, Himes, Please. He ran as an anti-war candidate and owes his election to that position, yet he was for the supplemental from the get go. It’s bad when you find enemies on your side and supposed friends against you. Something happens to progressives on the way to Washington. Don’t know that this will do anything about that.
Add me to the Amen Corner for Jane having done a wonderful job on the Supplemental.
And I would add that I was focused on the Members of the Hispanic Caucus. One interesting facet in all of this was pretty much representative of all the others.
First, the senior staffer had not had the opportunity to speak to the Member over the weekend. And on Monday, the Member had not made a decision, and thusly, was in meetings and therefore, I could not talk to the Member directly. As such, the story goes like this: After the initial denial, the Member did sign the pledge back in 2007; Bush reached a compromise and which was to pull our troops out of Iraq in 2011; Obama is maintaining that ‘compromise’; And thusly, the Pledge is no longer applicable or valid.
And more to the point, the senior staffer is not being permitted to ‘comment’ for ‘attribution’.
However, its been my experience and followed by my expectation, that one or two members of the Hispanic Caucus are vying for ambassadorships. Moreover, should the ambassadorships be extended, it will be quite easy to connect the dots, starting with the vote on the supplemental and on to the award of an ambassadorship position. Thus, leaving the Legislative for the Executive, opens the door for a greater opportunity for financial success in the future.
Jaango
We didn’t elect Obama to have him act like Chimpy McClusterfuck.
And, it still passed.
jane, you’re a fuckin’ hero.
And even though i am furious at my congressman, Chaka Fattah, I think we sent a message yesterday. And i hope we continue to keep sending messages until A)we either get what we want, B)someone[s] in congress loses his/her/their seat to a progressive primary opponent, or C) all of the above.
I’m gonna listen to the Supersuckers fight song today, cus a lot of these motherfuckers just realized for the first time what Steve Gilliard used to say: WE FIGHT BACK.
Peter DeFazio voted for it after saying he would vote against? This is one mind numbing act of treason. I hope that I am misreading the list, because he was the least likely, behind Dennis Kucinich, to change his vote to kill people.
I hope I am wrong, am I? I can’t follow the list as there is no mention except the Yea, please tell me I am wrong. Oregon deserves far better.
via http://www.house.gov
The Roll Call in black and white:
http://clerk.house.gov/evs/2009/roll348.xml