Glenn Greenwald got an email this morning:
Sent: Monday, May 4, 2009 9:10:55 AM GMT -02:00 Mid-Atlantic
Subject: Your "Izzy" AwardMr. Greenwald:
It has come to our attention that on March 31 you accepted an "Izzy "Award from the Park Center for Independent Media, named for I.F. "Izzy" Stone. You called Stone an "independent" journalist. However, as you must know, I.F. Stone has been exposed as a Soviet agent. This identification is based on information in the Venona World War II-era Soviet spy cables that a Soviet intelligence officer named Vladimir Pravdin had recruited I.F. Stone but that Stone had to be paid. Now, the May issue of Commentary is reporting additional evidence. See http://www.commentarymagazine.com/viewarticle.cfm/
special-preview–i-f–stone–soviet-agent-case-closed-15120I am preparing a story about Stone and would like your comments and about receiving an award named for a Soviet agent. Are you considering disavowing or giving back the award?
Thank you in advance.
Cliff Kincaid, Accuracy in Media
Glenn responds:
Sent: Monday, May 4, 2009 9:33:54 AM GMT -02:00 Mid-Atlantic
Subject: Re: Your "Izzy" AwardTwo of the most extremist and discredited entities in the United States are Commentary Magazine and Accuracy in Media. Someone who is smeared by those two groups immediately has their credibility enhanced. Don’t you have Barack Obama’s birth certificate to hunt down and Hillary Clinton’s sex life to sniff around in?
Izzy Stone was one of the only journalists in America to challenge the government’s lies about the Gulf of Tonkin incident, to oppose the Vietnam War from the start, and to relentlessly highlight the pernicious poison of the McCarthyite witch hunts, which are alive and well in the marginalized and irrelevant fringes of the Right, such as Commentary and AIM.
There is much dispute about what Stone thought in the 1940s and early 1950s, but what is not in dispute is that in one of his earliest newsletters, he wrote: "Whatever the consequences, I have to say what I really feel after seeing the Soviet Union and carefully studying the statements of its leading officials, this is not a good society and it is not led by honest men" and "nothing has happened in Russia to justify cooperation abroad between the independent left and the Communists." Those anti-Soviet statements resulted in the loss of numerous previous supporters, a courageous stance that dishonest propaganda rags like Commentary would never take.
A publication with some actual credibility, Columbia Journalism Review, conducted a comprehensive review of the evidence and thoroughly debunked these falsehoods.
The fact that Stone is being smeared by the likes of the consummately chicken-hawk, nepotistic, bloodthirsty Podhoretz family and the truly deranged, sex-obsessed, conspiracy-monger Cliff Kincaid will make me place my Izzy Award on an even more prominent shelf in my office.
Glenn Greenwald
I’m sure that in the interest of fairness and accuracy, they’ll be running Glenn’s response in its entirety.



63 Comments





Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Hee Hee Hee.
Gotta love the trolls, doncha?
Nice smackdown Glenn.
Greenwald has set an excellent example on how to respond to the Kincaid’s of the country.
In your face, Kincaid! These McCarthyite motherf*s need to be slapped down, and hard. They should go back to composing 1950 cigarette jingles. It’s the only decade they seem to be at home in.
Why does Cliff Kincaid hate America?
One of Glenn’s best.
Speaking of cigarettes, last night I was channel surfing for something mindless, but flipped thru the cspans in the process. On one was a panel on torture. One participant was making the hypothetical that if torture was OK to save lives, we should have tortured the cigarette execs to find out how much they knew about the health-damaging aspects of their products. Would have saved a lot more lives than post-9/11 torture. Now, while I am not in favor of torture for any reason, the idea of doing it to tobacco execs has a certain appeal.
I know a lot of Native Americans who would cringe when this group is refered to as AIM.
Yeah, right. To wit:
I just finished reading the transcript of a interview Dan Abrams did with Ashcroft and Gonzales. I could only wish Dan had been as aggressive in his questioning as Glenn would of been. I highly rec. reading the interview at The DailyBeast but not without going farther and reading the entire transcript on Dans twitter page. Hopefully you have a strong stomach. I fully expect this to make bigger news in the next day or two. http://www.thedailybeast.com/b…..back/full/
Specter pulled a reverse Lieberman with a double twist but entered the water on his belly.
Gave away some Paul Robeson and Cosmonaut Volkov tomato seedlings this morning to unsuspecting co-workers. Now they have Soviet tomato agents in their own homes, bwahahahaha.
Nice cutting edge stuff from Kincaid. Guess there is nothing important going on in today’s world. Perhaps his next expose will be on the leftist leanings of Saint Ronny Reagan in the same era. These people are hopeless.
He needs to take diving lessons from Suzanne, who always dives into the Lake, no matter how many twists and flips, forwards or backwards, without a splash.
can’t . . . stop. . . . laughing
thanks for this Jane
Glenn flipped them the bird.
was in such a hurry to read Glenn’s response, didn’t realize the writer was truly deranged, sex-obsessed, conspiracy-monger Kincaid his own self – more guffaws !
Izzy Stone was one of the only journalists in America
to challengewho would have challenged the government’s lies aboutthe Gulf of Tonkin incident9/11, to oppose theVietnamIraq War from the start, and to relentlessly highlight the pernicious poison ofthe McCarthyite witch huntsdomestice spying…So are they going denounce the Kristols and Podhoretz…who espoused essentially the same values in the 1930’s and ’40’s? These Jewish immigrants from the USSR and Eastern Europe also were once hard-core Marxists, then flirted with Trotskyism. Likely, if one looked through old Soviet files, might also be tainted by contacts with agents of the USSR. After all, wasn’t Norman Podhoretz’s sister a hard-core Marxist?
There are two major difference between Stone and those Neo-Cons. One is that Stone denounced the Stalinist methods…while the Neo-Cons have embraced them. The second is that Stone never lost his values for the common man, Podhoretz and his crew saw that power and influence required them to align with the wealthy Conservatives.
Podhoretz, who in the 50’s and early 60’s had friends the likes of Norman Mailer and Alan Ginsburg was denounced by them when he tried to convince them to become agents of a police state.
Cliff Kincaid has an astounding capacity to deny truths even when the evidence is shoved right in front of his nose. For instance, in this article Kincaid states “An FBI document on the official FBI website explicitly identifies [Kathrine Ann] Power as a Weather Underground member. He links to this FBI website which states: “Photo of Katherine Ann Power was removed because she was inaccurately associated with the Weather Underground.”
When informed of his error, Kincaid refused to correct his article, stating “I’m not wrong”.
His capacity for delusion is mind-boggling.
you will of course be denounced as a rabid anti-semite for pointing out the inconvenient truths :D
As Atrios has pointed out:
“Mess with Glenzilla? Not wise.”
Immediate identical reaction! Thanks for posting! Thank you Jane and Glenn!
Hooray for Glenn.
Where do we line up to moon Kincaid? I’m in!
Wow, what a great way to start a Monday! Thanks, Jane.
Since the Rs have nothing else maybe they are looking for a new McCarthy. A Commie under every bed! Perhaps we will all get to do the duck and cover again except the Rs will be using men’s room stalls. They are just so absurd.
Give it a rest, conspiracy troll.
Ummmm….I don’t get it. Are you saying Glenn is wrong and Kincaid is right? What is your source?
SIGH. This again. Go away.
I think she’s suggesting how Kincaid will edit Glenn’s response when he runs it…
Greenwald’s response to the knuckle-dragging Kincaid is just sweet.
That’s a very articulate response. I would have written “Suck my dick.”
You used to train diplomats in Bush’s State department, right? /s
Thanks. I read it several times and didn’t get that. Maybe I need more caffeine.
glen grows in stature each and every week, what an incredible resource
Fabulous. Thanks so much to Glenn & Jane for sharing! And congratulations to Glenn on his Izzy. Well-deserved.
The Constant Weader at http://www.RealityChex.com
Shorter Glenn Greenwald:
facts : neocons :: sunlight : vampires
My take was the same as yours…I was waiting to see the response, too.
As Atrios has pointed out:
“Mess with Glenzilla? Not wise.”
not on a dare.
Seconded.
Absolutely correct!
Oh, this is just delicious stuff. Thank you Jane. Glenn is a treasure. So are you. ;->
barbara.
Thank you.
Your reposting Glenn’s stuff.
I can read it just fine through the strike.
Please, post more like this.
Fundraiser concept: @GG, Jane.
Glenn, you ought to print off a few thousand copies of this to/fro, AUTOGRAPH them, and sell/auction them off.
I’ll buy one.
Pardon, you have a split infinitive in your first, last, and only partial sentence. Please resubmit corrected copy to unknown location. Thanking you for your patience and attention to this matter. I will consider your views when making my decision.
I know this is OT, but is there any chance another (wealthy philanthropist, fool and his money, etc.) nice fellow, like Ted Turner will come along and create a news network for the tube? It is about time, again.
Sounds good to me.
Never mess with Glenn! Love him. You too, Jane.
Late back to this. JimWhite was right. But perhaps I wasn’t clear. I figured this is how it would be edited to fit the far right moonscape.
Nevre ever happen, I would bet they won’t even mention his rebuttal!! Seems like more shoddy journalism from the ReichWing rags!
big grin here.
Glenn has become an icon of journalistic integrity and I admire him tremendously.
He is a model for us all.
Pure Greenwald Gold.
And he’s a really quick study. After receiving the email, It took him only 23 minutes to send out his response.
Wow! I wish I could write and think like that. If I could I wouldn’t be sitting here reading this, I would be out actually doing something.
We all have had moments I’m sure, where someone attacks you like that, and the response you come up with, much later unfortunately, is what you would have said if your mind worked like Glenn’s. Mine usually surfaces about a day or two later where I think to myself: “Dang! That’s what I should have said.”
Not so Mr Greenwald who is definitely on top of his game.
I got it the first time, thanks for that!
What is also interesting is how much the redacted parts can wholly change the perceived content WITHOUT actually changing the text.
Seconded.
It is always WAAAY too late when I come up with the right answer.
I thought Cliff Kincaid was the manager of The Partridge Family.
I think perhaps that MS.Molly was showing how “Commentary” might publish Glennzilla’s response. Lot’s of ellipses.
Why doesn’t Glenn expose Cliff Kincaid himself as the protege of M. Stanton Evans, a Birch Society deadender and McCarthyite himself? Glenn was too easy on Cliff Kincaid!
I am so grateful to be liberal. It is much safer to be on the side of folks like Olbermann and Greewald than with the brain dead opposition. Truth is a bright light that exposes the ideological idiots, and we need lots of light to clear away the last 30 years of stupidity.
sheesh – at least they didn’t mention the UFO’s this time, nor even opposable thumbs.
kudos to Glenn…a humorist, too!
I bet that sent the snivelling asswipe back to his comfort food (cheetos)! Bravo.
Woot! Good job, Glenn! Tell it!