The House passed the badly needed Credit Card Holders Bill of Rights yesterday, but they passed cramdown, too. We successfully fought off the efforts of the Mortgage Bankers Association, the American Bankers Association and other lobbyists to work through Ellen Tauscher and the New Democrats to tank it, but that just means the banks shifted their focus to the Senate, where they were wholly successful. And they plan to do the same thing for the Credit Card Holders Bill of Rights.
Next up, after mortgages, credit cards. Next week, the same bankers get to come in and see how much might and power they have in the Senate when it comes to credit card reform. And the question we’re going to face, is whether or not this Senate is going to listen to the families facing foreclosure, the families facing job loss and bills they can’t pay, or whether they’re going to listen to the American Bankers Association, which has folded its arms and walked out of the room. Well, I hope that we have the courage to stand up to them.
Well, I’d be pleased as punch if the Senate Democrats did stand up to the banks, but I seriously doubt that’s gonna happen. One out of eight people in America is going to lose their homes. They could have moved to stop that, but they didn’t. That’s the lobbying power of the FIRE industry.
According to Center for Responsive Politics Executive Director Sheila Krumholz:
"Even though some financial, insurance and real estate interests pulled back last year, they still managed to spend more than $450 million as a sector to lobby policymakers. That can buy a lot of influence, and it’s a fraction of what the financial sector is reaping in return through the government’s bailout program," Krumholz said.
Other financial institutions were pushing hard for money from the government while putting less money into lobbying itself. Citigroup decreased spending by 10 percent between 2007 and 2008, from $8.5 million to $7.7 million; Wells Fargo spent 37 percent less, from $1.9 million to $1.2 million, and mortgage lender Countrywide Financial put in 47 percent less, from $1.3 million to $706,000. Instead of hiring lobbyists, many financial institutions seem to have been relying on their industry representatives to sway Congress for them.
Business and real estate associations and coalitions were among the organizations that ramped up their lobbying expenditures the most last year. The National Association of Realtors increased spending by 25 percent, from $13.9 million to $17.3 million. The American Bankers Association spent $9.1 million in 2008, a 47 percent increase from 2007. Other industry groups to spend more in 2008 include the Private Equity Council, the Mortgage Bankers Association of America and the Financial Services Roundtable. The U.S. Chamber of Commerce remained the #1 spender on lobbying in 2008, spending nearly $92 million–more than $350,000 every weekday, and a 73 percent increase over 2007–to advocate for its members’ interests. Pro-business associations as a whole increased their lobbying 47 percent between ’07 and ’08.
"Entire industries are sinking right now," Krumholz said, "so companies seem to be leaning on the associations that represent them in Washington to push for rising-tide policies that will lift all their boats. In times like these, the companies whose dues support these industry groups are expecting results."
Let’s just be clear on this: money that went to banks through TARP was used to lobby these Senators. TARP recipients simply hid behind lobbying organizations like the MBA and the ABA who did the dirty work of screwing mortgage holders out of badly needed relief to the benefit of the banks, once again.



36 Comments












Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Truly the US congress believes in ‘No Bankster Left Behind.”
The rest of us? Not so much.
Why do I think the Banksters would be pushing and shoving the women and children away from the lifeboats on the Titanic?
So file a class action: Here’s my thoughts
http://agonist.org/synoia/2008…..ry_lawsuit
I dont think any of this will change until there is either a reversal of Buckley v Valeo, or a constitutional amendment that relegates lobbying to a lesser-protected form of speech akin to commercial speech. True, TARP recipients hid behind the MBA et. al, but the larger point is that the MBA et. al. are hiding behind the First Amendment, or, more precisely, using the First Amendment as a sword to kill economic justice. That is the lynchpin for the whole shebang.
Until that changes, Congress will continue to be a subsidiary of the banksters and the rest of the majority shareholders of Corporate America, including fossil fuel, agribiz, HMOs and all the rest of it.
Alas, 1 in 8. A likely prediction today. The banks will fail first though. If people use their leverage, they can probably end this nightmare and insure the collapse of the persons and institutions that caused the matter.
Thanks Jane.
We should seriously consider a primary challenge for any Dem that votes against the Credit Card Holders Bill of Rights. I am not that keen on this approach other than when the person is well and truly and thoroughly beyond acceptable as was (and is) Lieberman with regard to foreign policy. This vote would mean that they are available for purchase and cannot be trusted on anything.
Thank you for the post, Jane. I am so sick of these forkers–vote out (nearly) every incumbent in Congress and start over!
Nationwide Revolt. A respeced progressive leader needs to step forward and name the month when ALL AMERICANS will withhold mortgage and credit card payments. Rinse and repeat until Congress responds.
Refusing to pay taxes is not an option, because the federal government happens to have an army. Banksters, not so much.
Of course, public financing of elections would go a long way to help the situation.
Do we have any leaders to intervene before the race for the bottom is finished?
Does Obama get a chance to veto this legislation?
Hope so.
Why do you need a leader? We do it ourselves or it won’t get done.
Good thought.
It’s free speech at it’s finest.
1)commit massive fraud.
2)take a reward from the peoples government for doing so.
3)buy the most influential voice/lobby in DC.
repeat.
Rewarding the banksters… while the working stiffs get a choice between indentured servitude or tent city.
Campaign Finance Reform. Sorry to keep beating it, but I see it as the only drum that will work.
The problem is too systemic. Our only solution is a grassroots movement to elect representatives who, whatever other positions they hold, are firmly committed to CFR.
You want a revolt? You want revolution? Here’s how you do it in a democracy. Spend 10-12 years electing candidates committed to CFR. Populate the Congress with a two-third majority of people who recognize the caustic role of corporate money in Congress.
When you have the numbers you introduce the legislation. You allocate an inflation-adjusted fixed sum of public money for campaign funding for all qualifying candidates. You pass the bills and get them signed into law and if they are vetoed you override the veto.
And then you have your Congress back.
Otherwise as recent history including this topic demonstrates, everything we do will constantly be controlled by corporate interests, and we never will have a representative democracy again.
Don’t think so. Don’t forget SCOTUS held money talking is a first amendment right. I’m not sure we have 10-12 years and I doubt it could be done if we did. Maybe representative democracy isn’t the way to go. Maybe electronic democracy will be better, but I wouldn’t hold my breath. We don’t seem to be of a mind to do anything.
For those of you that missed Moyers “The Best Way to Rob a Bank is to Own One” I highly recommend it.
William Black was involved in the S&L resolution and thinks our present course of dealing with the banks is completely off course. And the fraud, well, let me quote him from the transcript:
WILLIAM K. BLACK: “The FBI publicly warned, in September 2004 that there was an epidemic of mortgage fraud, that if it was allowed to continue it would produce a crisis at least as large as the Savings and Loan debacle. And that they were going to make sure that they didn’t let that happen. So what goes wrong? After 9/11, the attacks, the Justice Department transfers 500 white-collar specialists in the FBI to national terrorism. Well, we can all understand that. But then, the Bush administration refused to replace the missing 500 agents. So even today, again, as you say, this crisis is 1000 times worse, perhaps, certainly 100 times worse, than the Savings and Loan crisis. There are one-fifth as many FBI agents as worked the Savings and Loan crisis.”
So the DoJ needs to ramp up and we’d better build another wing at FCI Danbury! Otherwise the future is just more of the same.
Aren’t the FIRE interests shooting themselves in the foot by abusing debtors?
One in eight is millions of people. Perhaps twenty to thirty million homeowners. Can they really afford to kick so many people to the curb? Maybe with TARP and other taxpayer funded support they can. Still it doesn’t seem to be the best route for any of the interested parties.
Black! The new Pecora.
Connect all the dots to reveal all the criminal banksters. The overlord of Goldman, JP Morgan Chase, Exxon Mobil, the Federal Reserve, The Treasury, The IRS, etc, is all the same individual…and the overlord of us all.
Can you identify him?
http://oxdown.firedoglake.com/diary/3820
It’s time to name names.
http://plungerspeaks.blogspot.com
seriously? Never happen. Now the interest charged on credit cards used to send people to jail. Back then they called is Usury and it was a crime. I wonder when that changed.
Are there any Hoosiers out there who can think of a primary opponent for Bayh? We’ve got to get that dolt out of the Senate. In some ways he’s worse than a Republican.
As the senator told ED,”the banks own the senate”
WOW!!,who knew?
Pityful to say the least.
Had to look Pecora up. Musta been sleepin’ that day in school!
This is why the craptastic TARP should have been a package deal.
Bailout + relief for homeowners (i mean renters from banks) + real reform of the banking system from top down
Seriously which of the three have we gotten so far? Only the free money for the fraudsters and the bailout kings of Wall Street.
Below, link to the video of stunning waste by the greedy banking oligarchy.
A pile of money is more important than humanity.
In Sacramento, people are living in tent cities.
kidbuck makes an excellent suggestion in the comments included below.
New Homes Demolished in Victorville, CA
by CalculatedRisk on 4/30/2009 08:49:00 PM
Hat tip to several – thanks! Note: Victorville is east of Los Angeles at the southern edge of the Mojave desert.
See video here: http://www.calculatedriskblog……le-ca.html
kidbuck (profile) wrote on Fri, 5/1/2009 – 12:37 pm
Why not just give them to returning vets from Iraq and Afganistan, that would be an honorable thing to do, and a pretty good way of saying thanks to those who put their butts on the line for us (regardless of how stupid the overall mission was to go in to Iraq in the first place)
Because our vets deserve better. Why not put Paulson, BB, and Lord Blankfein in these trash heaps?
Yes, so 12 Democratic members of the Senate voted with all the Republicans. The potential for 12 defectors from the opposition party seems unlikely. So, where’s the party whip? Out to lunch too often? Where’s the beef?
Thanks, Jane. Happy May Day
We pretend to vote. They pretend to get elected, and represent the interests of their constituents.
Only, the voters aren’t their constituents. http://www.ritholtz.com/blog/2…..are-state/
All 12 senators need to be primaried. Their acts need to be before the US now in MSM.
Elliot Spitzer was going public with all 50 state Attorney Generals were going after unfair banking practices. The next day his call girl scandal was public.
Gov. Blago was going to stop using Bank of Ammerica because of the way they treated workers in Ill. The next day his problems were public.
Both investigations used illegal wire tapping.
I am so fucking sick of these Democrats. They have no balls, led by the Senate Majority Leader who is absofuckinglutely useless. Unfortunately, I live in Texas where we are represented by even worse Republicans. It is a shame that we can’t elect some Progressive Democrats in some of these states. I certainly hope Adm Sestak runs for the Senate in PA and wish some Progressive would be able to run against Harry Reid. It would be nice to have a Senate Majority leader who could get the Dem’s in line, but guess that is just wishful thinking.
Splendidly done again. The problem is it’s just so damn depressing. Obama was not my first choice I hoped Gore would put aside his pique and run, still in thinking about it I don’t think it would be any different. The bottom line on this is we are screwed and getting screweder every day and there isn’t a fornicating thing we can do about it. I live in Nebraska home of that worm Nelson and the foam at the mouth right wing bozo brigade. But ya know the senators that are supposed to be progressives are just as bought and paid for, and I sure didn’t see the chosen one spending any of his political capital on this. The people he picked to run the bailout… well the less said the better. My best guess is it’ll have to get really bad uber mega bad for anything to be done.
I don’t need the government to protect me from credit card companies. If you don’t like the terms, don’t borrow the money. If there’s anyone in America that doesn’t know that a credit card is a small step up from a loan shark, they have their head in the sand I guess. Easy credit made this nation great, hell anyone can get a credit card, and it will make this nation great again. I remember the days when I had to go to the back and beg a banker for a lousy $1000 loan, and they were (and still are) A HOLES. I remember my Dad went for a loan once for a Cadillac and the banker said he would only make a loan on a Buick, the prick, because it was his opinion that no one should spend that kind of money on a car.
I’d much rather get my loan from a credit card than a banker.
Now if I was the King of the World things would be different, but I’m not, so I have to live in the world the way it is. No matter how bad a Democrat is, a Republican is always worse. Politics is about the lesser of two evils, and it was ever thus and will ever be.
I don’t think a lot of people are aware of the fact that when a home in the area that you live in is taken in foreclosure it affects the value of ALL the homes in the area.
The market value of your home can drop as much as 10% overnight if your neighbors house is taken in foreclosure.
“I got mine” isn’t going to cut it this time around.
If more homeowners knew about this threat to their largest investment they might not be so complacent, get off their duffs and call their congress-critters!
I lost my home six months ago. I tried to hold on and waited for over a year for “help” from Congress. It is never going to come. I had lived in that house for fifteen years. I ahd a fixed rate low interest loan. I was never once late on a payment until the bank suddenly declared I had a $12000 “escrow overage” and raised my payment by $500/month. I tried everything to find out what the hell they were talking about and just got one story after another.
After a year, I finally decided I cannot make that payment and I cannot afford a lawyer and gave up. I was so tired of fighting and I was tired of being hurt and angry all the time. I uprooted my son from the only home he’s ever had. And to be honest, I am relieved to be out of the whole goddamned mess. I am better off even though I have nothing to show for $1000/month for 15 years. I am becoming sane again. My son is in a better school. The house I rented is okay and 45 miles closer to work.
But…I’m saying don’t expect this congress to do anything to help you when you need it. They are not there for you, they are there to make money and they know who has it and who doesn’t. It doesn’t matter which party they are in. Even if they have to take it from you and give it to the bankers, so the bankers can give a little tiny bit back to congress.
I do not believe one cent of my money ought to go to help a bank. I’ve already given all I had. My children should never have to have any of their money go to a bank. I’ve given enough for all of us.
But, fair isn’t part of the plan. The banks intend to suck every drop we have and they will still be hungry for more. And Congress is always there to insure the banks get fed. Today I read that banks are giving less of our money to Congress, but not much less something like $10 million this quarter. And that is a decrease. They take it from us and spread it around.
PSA
Instead of grease, Congress would like you to call their cut of the bailout cash “retention bonuses”.
:)