It seems like only yesterday that right-wingers were condemning critics of a president as un-American, chanting "Proud to be an American," and branding as traitors to America those opposed to state torture. Today, they say their enemy is America. Oh yeah, and these are the same people who decried so-called "situation ethics."
Texas Governor Rick Perry got quite a bit of attention from his public flirtation with the secessionists during an Austin teabagging orgy. Just the week before, Perry endorsed the quirky "Tenth Amendment" movement and a states’ rights resolution. I say quirky, but 23 states have adopted these non-binding paeans to antebellum saber rattling.
Here’s a sample paragraph from the resolution adopted this year, by a vote of 43 to 1, by the Georgia State Senate:
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that any Act by the Congress of the United States, Executive Order of the President of the United States of America or Judicial Order by the Judicatories of the United States of America which assumes a power not delegated to the government of the United States of America by the Constitution for the United States of America and which serves to diminish the liberty of the any of the several States or their citizens shall constitute a nullification of the Constitution for the United States of America by the government of the United States of America.
Can you imagine what would have happened to the Dixie Chicks if they’d said something about nullifying the Union?
Near as I can tell, the beard these extremists are hiding behind is concern over the national debt and mythical tax increases. Nevermind that it was George Bush who took the debt to historic levels. All President Obama has done is cut middle class taxes and sent billions of dollars to the states in the form of an economic stimulus. Southerners, at least, ought to notice he sent the aid without the carpetbaggers.
To be fair, there were contemporary secessionists before Obama. Some don’t like the so-called "war on drugs," some are just anti-authoritarian. I can sympathize. The war on drugs has been a tragic failure, at least from a democratic, crime-fighting point of view.
And I don’t like authority much, either. I tend to agree with Jefferson. We could use a revolution every generation.
However, Federal authority and Union-wide efforts are necessary prerequisites of many things I do like, like Interstate Highways, the U.S. Post Office, a national defense, insured bank accounts, Medicare, Medicaid, Social Security, air traffic control, environmental protections, a common currency, etc., etc., etc.
The secession/nullification talk is not just anti-authoritarian, and it’s not confined to the South. Generally, Southerners like authority and hierarchy. They don’t mind somebody on top, as long as they can be on top of somebody else. Call it the Great Chain of Teabagging.
But people such as Gov. Perry, and the elite consultants behind the public hate-filled, secessionist comments of powerful right-wing officeholders and wannabees, are another story. They know exactly what they are doing. They are running their 2010 campaigns, and they are hoping they can drive a big anti-Obama, racist turnout in a mid-term election in which Obama won’t be on the ballot.
This cynical manipulation is so morally repugnant that it’s hard to find adequate words of condemnation. How do you say, "Go to Hell, but stay in the Union?"
These manipulators fully understand that the term "states’ rights" calls up images of lynching, of fire hoses and snarling dogs, of governors standing in the doorways of schools keeping children of color away.
Their coded message to the angry: We’ll take you back to those glorious days when most knew their place, and when we could punish the uppity ones without any old federal government telling us that we can’t.
You know, one of the old forms of violent, racist punishment that disappeared (not so many years ago) after passage of the Federal Civil Rights Act included driving a wedge in a tree stump, sitting a naked black man on the stump so that his testicles hung inside the wedged gap, then pulling out the wedge. A knife would be left behind to assist the victim in a necessarily self-mutilating escape. Another kind of teabagging, you might say. How dare the federal government interfere with a sovereign state’s right to turn a blind eye to such practices?
I know many conservatives are not full of hatred, are not racists, and just have different views about democracy and government. Still, do their more legitimate political aspirations excuse their alliance with those who hate and those who would manipulate that hatred in the pursuit of power?
No. Such was the famous Nixonian "Southern Strategy," and I know no better definition of "Un-American." I don’t want them to leave, I just want them to leave their hatred behind. The haters will not listen to me. But they might listen to those responsible conservatives whose legitimacy they skulk behind. Talk is not enough. It’s all too easy to say "compassionate conservatism," as we’ve learned. Responsible conservatives must repudiate the hate, reject the code words, turn the haters away from their rallies and leave them to their private hells with no false promises of aid, comfort, or a return to bygone days of wedged stumps and hanging trees.



63 Comments





Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Lord help us. I don’t see any conservatives left that use reason or compassion or thought.
Just how many times have the Courts ruled, on the basis of the Constitution, that the federal Government has either violated individual or States rights? If each of these instances “l constitute a nullification of the Constitution for the United States of America by the government of the United States of America” then we are very much in trouble. Because that would give the Federal Government the opportunity to “NULLIFY”or suspend the Constitution [i.e. declare martial law] by actually violating the law.
Do these eedjits really think that the Constitution can be nullified by a violation of that document? NO! The Constitutional officers are still BOUND to enforce that document, it remains in force, and they must ACT to terminate their violation.
And if the Constitution, and the Bill of Rights and other protections embedded within it, are supposedly “nullified” then the only rights that the citizens of the states would have woukld be within their State Constitutions. These are much more subject to alteration by the whime of a simple majority and most don’t have many of the rights protected by the Constitution or Federal laws within them since these are duplicative.
Those rights and protections would be immediately lost if the Constitution is “nullified”.
Actually I don’t put this all down to racism. I have been saying for some time that there are those in America who look to the collapse of the Soviet Union with envy. The breakup of the United States would benefit the super-wealthy aristocracy of this nation in many ways.
First, the wealthy and powerful would become bigger fish in smaller ponds. I’m sure Governor Perry of the State of Texas would prefer to be President Perry of the Nation of Texas. Sarah Palin ALREADY thinks that she’s the Queen of the Nation of Alaska. Or Aliaskia, as she might say. And why be the 100th richest person of a big nation when you could be the wealthiest person of a small one?
Second, the collapse of the United States would lead to a collapse in law and regulation. Pollution limits? Gone. Taxes? Not for the rulers! Abortion? Illegal in the Kingdom of United Carolina, along with homsexuality. And minimum wage? Well, that assumes you’re willing to pay your employees at all… or that you are willing to treat them as free men and women. Return to slavery anyone? Who’s going to stop the Southern Confederacy from reinstating it? Does the Nation of New England plan to go to war to eliminate slavery over a thousand miles away?
Finally, MONEY, the root of all evils. The nationalizing of industries within these new nations would be followed, Russian style, with the redistribution of these resources to the political cronies of the new rulers. The very wealthy would be free to fix their wealth in stone, and return many of us to the role of serf or peasant.
Rick Perry simply voiced in front of the cameras what many rich people have been voicing in their smoky studies for the last few years. The Bush Administration has only encouraged the stripping of the flesh from the American carcass. This was never clearer than last September when the Wealthy realized that Palin’s selection meant McCain was going to lose, and that they’d better cash out their investments before the unknown quantity of Barack Obama took the reins of power. Since then the Wall Street aristocracy has secured its own interests without respect to the interests of the nation. They are ready and willing for the United States to collapse.
There are Americans who want America to collapse, for their own gain. We need to be honest and clear about that, and try to find ways to keep our unique nation alive. Or the United States will go the way of our 401K’s.
I don’t credit these people with freedom from racism, in fact I’m sure racism plays a part. But truly I think money and greed are the reasons why our nation’s butchers are sharpening their cleavers.
Consequences, constitutional or otherwise, are not the strong suit of these unhappy people. They can’t even think as far as, “Oh, no more mail service,” no more FDIC, etc. What’s so bad and irresponsible is that politicians who know better go ahead and empower these crazies.
No, it’s not all racism. But it’s a powerful factor. I also agree that the empowering of such insane schemers is a dangerous, dangerous game. No state could actually secede, of course. But even getting within a mile of such a brink could so disrupt the delicate balance of democracy that it tips into chaos.
Remember George Bush’s little quip about having a dictatorship as long as he was the dictator. That is the mentality of these stoopids.
I think in many cases that there is an underlying racism driving this. Some people will never reconcile having a black man in charge. For the Stoopid GOP they haven’t figured out yet that the numbers aren’t really very big for this.
Because it’s Sunday, and on the heels of Peterr’s post, your comment inspired me to look up this, from wikipedia:
In Genesis 18, God informs Abraham that he plans to destroy the city of Sodom because of its wickedness. Abraham pleads with God not to destroy Sodom, and God agrees that he would not destroy the city if there were 50 righteous people in it, then 45, then 30, then 20, or even ten righteous people. The Lord’s two angels found only four righteous people living in Sodom, including Abraham’s nephew Lot and his wife and two youngest daughters. Consequently, God destroyed the city.
Would you settle for four conservatives with reason and/or compassion? How about one? I’m not holding my breath either.
I covered this exact topic in my best channeling of the spirit of driftglass: http://broadwaycarl.blogspot.c…..acism.html
I just finished reading a dual biography of Linoln and Douglass. I was struck that something about the south has remained the same since Civil War times–the same deafening shouts, the same implied threats of violence, the same racism….the whole south is not this way of course, but a sizable minority is. How can they not change?
As always, thank you Glenn.
There are times I think the South really did win the war. Dham them.
It’s been heartbreaking to see the racist teabaggers on parade this week.
I predicted just after the election that racist voices might grow louder while their actual numbers shrink. I hope I was right, but I’m not certain. The American system seems to have to tough resistance to real extremism. It can be somewhat heartening to think that the anti-communist panic of the late 40s and 50s — even when combined with a post-nuclear understanding that we now had the absolute power to destroy ourselves — was contained by a rather bland Eisenhower who had the courage to warn us about the “military-industrial complex.” On the other hand, maybe I’m just an optimist.
Extreme Shock Doctrine so to speak?
Sorry was meant to reply to albatross
Yes, they would have become Guantanamo Chicks.
Does anyone else but me see the timing of Perry’s comments and Obama’s recent decision to release the torture memos as something other than coincidental? The fact that this is coming from Texas is not coincidental, either.
That is a great book, by the way.
The South? I dunno. At bottom is a strong, inherited worldview that embraces authority and hierarchy. Mixed in is the inherited post-Civil War feeling of impotence. It must be added that the South has no monopoly on racism.
“Can you imagine what would have happened to the Dixie Chicks if they’d said something about nullifying the Union?”
One of the reasons that I love the blogosphere is that every once in awhile somebody just absolutely nails it with an insight that perfectly captures the state of of our political/media culture. Glenn, you just provided us with a classic. Thanks !
i remember talk about red state / blue state secession here at fdl when bush was president. is it possible that it has more to do with the frustration with one’s party being out of power than it does with racism?
… i’m probably influenced in this by the really massive racism and bigotry i witnessed among Democrats in MA after 911. i seriously doubt the desire to invade and bomb would have been so widespread, intense and acceptable if OBL had been hiding out in London instead of among brown people, muslims, who we don’t know and who don’t speak english…..
I agree with you, Glenn. They are in full panic mode and have to shout louder as their numbers fall. It doesn’t seem to hold much appeal to Americans so it’s not helping their cause – whatever that is. The messages were very confused at the tea bags parties and it just looked pathetic and silly.
Thanks, eagleye. You know, the Chicks used to play as a team in a local (Austin) trivia contest held at a local family pub (a placed named for the owner’s mother). There was a great, warm feeling of simple human solidarity in that place. When the Dixie Chicks controversy happened, the juxtaposition of the two worlds — the gross sphere of political manipulation and the more human sphere of simple togetherness — was always on my mind.
interesting idea, thanks.
Selise, I do think the various motivations are, as always, complex. However, I also think I’m right about the goals of those Republicans who would exploit those whose feelings of powerlessness drive them to extremes. The Rs and their consultants want to motivate a racist vote next cycle. It is a fundamental strategy.
bruce fein?
so long as that hypothesis is untestable (if i’m wrong about that, would love to know how you would test it), i think we have a responsibility to work at fighting confirmation bias and group think.
What is the upside for the goopers in these tea baggings? is there any? It gives Perry an opportunity to bond with extremists, but what’s the upside of that? Are there enough of these idiots in the Texas Gooper party to win him the nomination? I wouldn’t have thought so.
Strangely enough, rather than reaching out toward the middle, the goopers are spending all their energy stroking the idiots who have nowhere else to go. They must be expecting a VERY low turnout election- or they’re all afraid of being primaried by morons.
I don’t think that one can compare bloggers getting frustrated and advocating splitting the country with an elected governor saying that in public. Apples and Oranges I’d say.
When the going gets tough, peoples underlying fears, or weakness (and strengths) come out?
It’s the McCain/Rumsfeld Doctrine: You campaign with the wedges you have, not necessarily the wedges you need…
that wasn’t my comparison – it was why does talk of scession resonate with ordinary people?
It’s a sideshow to draw attention away from this-
top ten states federal dollars paid and least back-blue states
top ten states least federal dollars paid and most money back-8/10 are red states.
kinda blows a hole in their whole platform.
http://taxfoundation.org/taxdata/topic/92.html
i just wrote a diary about it.
(first heard of it on hardball)
Not sure which hypothesis you are referring to.
Also, I sure agree about our responsibility to guard against “groupthink,” especially which such thinking objectifies and dehumanizes Others. And I agree that the post-9/11 America was much marked by race-based fear.
was predicted by the ratchet effect in 2005:
a possibility to consider…
At least, “when the going get’s tough,” there’s a certain vulnerability which can be and is exploited. And these moments can also be positively transformative.
AND THE KILLIN’ GOEZ ON AND ON AND…
Citizen Glenn Smith and the Firepup Freedom Fighters:
What we are seein’ in the sucessionist rants and the attempts by the fascist minority in Congress to completely stop the Unites States government from enacting legistalation to redress greivences, provide for the common defense and extend actions to promote the common good, is nothin more than the last battle of our Civil War. Had Radical Reconstruction not been dismantled in 1877 and the old slavocracy not re-infranchised by the Northern banks to act as overseers of a colonial economy, we would not be going through another “nullification crisis” in our national politics. The entire complex of political ideas that arose out of the contradiction of slavery in the original Constitution and that was kept alive and legitimized by “states rights” arguments for limited federal government after the Civil War, should have and would have been irradicated by finishing Reconstruction.
We should not be surprised that there is no longer anything that resembles a “conservative” politics in America…the connection between American conservatism and John Adams and the great New England federalists has been severed and what is left is the nexus of ideas that represents American fascism and has it’s intellectual orgins in the articulations of John C. Calhoun and Henry Clay. We are paying the price for not salting the earth of the old Confederacy and for not extinguishing the “culture” of the Old South after 1866.
What is different this time is that the anti-democractic political movement is financed by American banking power and the oligarchy.
KEEP THE FAITH AND PASS THE AMMUNITION, FASCISM WILL NOT GO AWAY BY ITSELF!!
I need to make something clear right now..if any congress people or committee even dare try to provide health care for the poor and sick and lame citizens I will consider it a high crime against Amurika and help to desolve this rabid socialist marxist government. lol
Racism runs deep in some quarters ,even 140 years after the civil war there is a deep seated hatred among some people.
I don’t think it’s all racism. If Hillary Clinton had won, the results would be exactly the same. The Republicans can’t stand losing. When they do, the take their ball and go home.
masaccio is upstairs!
Wall Street Journal Commenters Think $250K a Year Isn’t Taxworthy
I think so too. I think it’s why we have to keep our eyes on the positive progress also, even if they are baby step moves. But, folks seem to gravitate to the horror stories more often. Human nature maybe.
sorry i wasn’t clear. i meant, in general, the central role of racism in why talk of secession resonates.
thanks very much for the comment re bias and the Other.
Glenn,
I thank you for this post from the bottom of my heart. You have the courage to tell the truth. See, I’m a black 50+ year old female who has lived in GA all of my life. Racism is still alive and well in GA. It permeates the entire state, from border to border. Of course, it’s not always overt, but used in subltle ways. One example was Nov.5, 2008. The atmosphere in most places was absolutely funereal. The people I work with (at a school) went into a deep depression for a period of several weeks. Some of them stopped talking to blacks on the job and were saying negative things about Obama in front of the students. Some of the white students were pulled aside and consoled by the white teachers because McCain lost. Some of the black students told me about the negative comments that were being spouted about Obama. Now, these folks go to church twice during the week and on Sunday and profess to be spirit-filled Christians. A woman who works in the cafeteria, with whom I thought I had a friendly relationship, shunned me after Nov. 4. She looked at me as if she was ashamed to know me. She and the other teachers in the building didn’t stop once to think about how that made the black teachers feel. The only reason I can think of is that, although we all are similarly educated, they somehow feel they are better than I am. I knew after the election that there is no post-racial America, though I really wasn’t expecting one, especially in the south. My daughter has been dating her boyfriend (he’s white) now going on 3 years. He told her recently that black people voted for Obama only because he is black. She was very upset about it and came to seek my advice. I told her that if he devalues her opinion and choices (he didn’t vote at all), to give him the old heave ho, and to call him out on his covert racism. I told her to tell him that she didn’t know that he harbored racist feelings toward blacks, and that since she is black, he must feel the same way about her. I also told her to call him out on the idea that he felt that she was not capable of making an informed decision. She confronted him and he apologized. I told her that if she doesn’t get this aspect of the relationship straightened out now, she’d have trouble with him in the future. These are just a couple of examples of hidden, or unconscious, racism that you find in the south. I guess I should have known/suspected how my white co-workers felt when I saw them with copies of THE PURPOSE DRIVEN LIFE. Go figure. I don’t have time for their shenanigans. Im living my life.
Dems moving toward the center on some issues certainly make the goopers position on- say- gun control- seem mainstream—but I don’t see how that explains the value to goopers of this mad romp with their craziest constituency. That totally NEGATES any centerist appearing advantage they might have gained and makes them appear to be whacky radicals.
Very sad stuff. Stories like yours point to the sad reality we live in. It’s important for us to realize where we still are. I think you gave good advice to your daughter. Avoid much sadness later.
Race is certainly a major factor in the gooper hatred of Obama….many believe that he is determined to give away their money to blacks.
Racism is certainly at the heart of much of this anger, as are various inchoate cultural animosities. This is clearly a regional and class based antagonism. God am I glad I left Oklahoma more than 20 years ago.
PS…I’d like to think that people where I live, Los Angeles, CA, are more evolved, but, alas, they aren’t. My white sister cohabits with a Pakistani Muslim and she is confronted with bigotry many times when they go out to restaurants. :(
I think the motivations are various, but not complex. I just heard George Will pedanticize that the protestors were decrying the third great wave in governmental expansion, following the New Deal and the Great Society. The ones I observed would have only heard of the New Deal or Great Society if those terms were mentioned on publications near the grocery store checkout line. I think it’s about as complex as the fact that the protestors never applied themselves in life, failed to accomplish anything, have no hope of getting parts in a remake of Deliverance, and think it has to be somebody else’s fault.
I admire you for staying in the south. I’m white and I couldn’t stay. I knew that I would have to keep my mouth shut or be shunned so I left. I am so sorry that you and your fellow teachers were treated that way. Old racism dies hard but it will die. Live your life to the fullest and forget, if you can, what others think.
I’m humbled by your writing, and by your success at living the truth of your life. I really hope other visitors to FDL read your heartfelt comment. It is more important for them to see this through your eyes than it is for them to get a glimpse, however empathetic it might be, of my much more abstract description.
I think there is much danger in the “post-racial” world myth. It disguises the racism and hatred that is still very much alive.
thanks.
it isn’t just the south. i’m in ohio.
and the same thing goes for women.
white male supremacy, be it in the workplace or at home.
same thing.
a man the other day on the radio said he wishes we could all go back to when moms were at home making lunch for their kids. the host of the radio show is a woman and she agreed with him. she runs the station. i don’t think she realized what she was agreeing to….and yep, you could bet a nickel his views of obama would go along the same lines. they do. he is a regular caller, content to stay in the 50’s.
Worse, content to stay in a mythic 50s that never existed. The one that did exist was far more oppressive, scarier, uncertain and full of dread, despite the great economic expansion then underway.
thank you so much for your comment.
All of us operate within a Story that explains our world to us.
For 70% of US, we hold our beliefs as ‘good enough’ to explain our situation, but leave open the possibility that things might change in our circumstances and neccessitate a ‘makes sense’ adaptation.
However, 30% of US lack the facility to change beliefs under all but the most extraordinary circumstances.
These people are ‘trapped’ inside literally held belief systems about the way things are and ought to be – blacks are inferior, only our ‘heritage’ is true, etc, etc.
As the actual circumstances of daily life begin to separate away from their strongly held ‘beliefs’, they choose to retain holding-on to the beliefs rather than accept the reality of the factual changes – this is a form of mental derangement.
Most of the 30% will carry their delusions far, far, far into denial – concocting evermore ridiculous explanations to account for the inadequacies of their beliefs (Obama is not a citizen, we surround them, they want to put us in labor camps, etc).
However, given enough time and some moral leadership from within their own group, they can change and adapt – but that won’t begin happening until the 70% of US take charge and firmly establish the Factual Reality of Our Present Situation as the Basis for Our Action.
As crazy as it seems, We have to move forward, first, before they will abandon their burning belief abodes, and even then there will be Haters who will never accept anything other than their static literal truth, come Hell or high water.
yep.
but if you think you’re the rooster of your own coop, and content to keep your head in the sand, that’s the kind of thing you embrace. oppression.
in your house and in your government.
If you want to elaborate some day, and I hope you do because you’re right, please consider the title, “The Rooster’s Coop.” Yours wins best metaphor of the thread award! Though, I’d be careful about rooster-heads-in-sand mashups. :)
According to the Georgia Senate resolution, George W. Bush has already nullified the Constitution, by his Executive Orders.
Is there anyone who is in a position to point this out to them, and ask them what they plan to do about it?
Selise…I can understand this perhaps coming from the grumbling of a disaffected mass. But it’s actually being fueled by their leadership. I don’t recall any Democratic Governors, Congressmen, or even State level Legislators stating that “California should secede”. Yet these “10th Amendment Nullification” amendments are popping up everywhere…and are being pushed by prominent people within the Republican Party.
In addition…I can’t recall anyone suggesting that Bush’s violation of the Constitution NULLIFIED it? What that would mean would be that once the Supreme Court overturned a single Federal action as Unconstitutional they have “decided themselves out of existence” since the Constitution, which is their basis for existence, no longer holds.
These Amendments are simply illogical and utterly Unconstitutional.
Does a police department violating the law nullify that law? Does it nullify the City Charter? These people are loony!
thanks!
yeah, my mind is in the tea river gutter. you should have seen what all i had to delete from my oxdown diary. good stuff too. just came streamin’ out of me. obliquely. when i read it i said, ooops, can’t write that one. ooops. wow. can’t do that one either. scary. i’ve turned into a subliminal potty mouth.
here’s another one from the other day—though clean—
just because you can write a letter doesn’t mean you have something to say.
said to a talk show host who said something about people dialing the phone to call him. ha.
see my comment @29.
Get hold of Reunion Without Compromise by Michael Perman one of the seminal books on the confederate strategy to obstructing Reconstruction from 1865 to 1868. As you read it you’ll find yourself inserting names of current GOP obstructionists for the names of the southerners, Like South Carolina governor, Benjamin Perry, who were determined not to go along with any policy that came from Congress or from the Republicans, especially those damned Radicals who were pushing for punishing the south.
It worked for them then and they’ve never changed their ways. Either give us what we want or we’ll collectively hold our breath and bring this union down.
And they refused then to agree that what they had done was unconstitutional or treasonous. They wrapped themselves in the flag and stated they were only trying to protect the constitution from those who would act against it.
The scary thing about waxing nostalgic for the fifties is taht vision of America really didn’t exist.
Stephanie Kuntz (?) in her book The Way We Never Were shatters many of the old memories we have. For instance, how many women actually were stay at home moms? Who were all those women who were teachers in the schools, and the cafteria ladies, and the school nurses, and the secretaries in all the offices throughout the country? These were jobs, many of them, which would have allowed a woman to work outside the home while still being home when the kids got home from school.
Looking at labor statisitcs from the same decade, there were more women employed at part-time jobs than most of us realize.
What I’m saying is the thing we yearn for falls into that category of being a dream. I remember living in what I thought was a luxurious home that my young wife and I rented in North Carolina just before I left for Vietnam in 1969. When I returned to that place after 6 years it turned out to be a shack, a real hovel. Yet my wife and I both had visions of it being a beautiful place. Maybe it was the blinders of young love.
thanks. the guy who said it isn’t in the real world.
and the ‘hovel’?
i think that it was a place of your own.
and a lot of things can fall into disrepair in 6 years and neighborhoods can change a lot in 6 years. and you measure things differently than you did 6 years ago, even measuring from today. could be a lot of things why.
I hate the bailouts and now the fat cats are sponsering their methods to regain their power. If we ever allow the GOP to get back into office we will become the most brutish corporate empire on the face of the earth. We will become a police state as well. Obama needs to rid himself of the bad guys in office now. I hope they haven’t already corrupted him. They are trying right now. The protests need to remain focused on the bailouts not the taxes. The rich need to be pinatas and we should shake all the wealth that the lobbyists stole from the wage slaves. Housing and health are human rights for all people all around the world. If you don’t like that then you can move to an island with right wingers and try your economic values on each other.