RNC Chair Michael “Mad Rhymes” Steele:
"With over 5,000 absentee and military ballots still left to count, this race is far from over. We are confident that the Republican advantage in these absentee and military ballots can put Jim Tedisco over the top, and the Republican Party will do everything in its power to make sure all lawful votes are counted."
"We are proud of Jim Tedisco and his campaign. Together, and in partnership with the Tedisco campaign, the New York Republican Party, the Republican National Committee and National Republican Congressional Committee went toe-to-toe with the Obama Democratic machine that looked invincible in the Northeast just a few months ago and showed that our party can and will be competitive in areas of the country where our party hasn’t won recently."
"President Obama, Senator Clinton, Eliot Spitzer and Chuck Schumer all won this district, and a Democrat won the last two congressional races. The fact we are in a dead heat race in NY-20 means we are making progress as a Party standing firm for fiscal responsibility."
And, Glenn “Wrap-Master” Reynolds:
APRIL 1, 2009
THE EMPEROR HAS NO COATTAILS. “The left-leaning media and blogs are declaring it a huge defeat for the GOP. Considering it was their seat they were defending and Obama apparently has no coattails, that’s some unique spin.” I expect it to be widely repeated, though.
I had to leave the date in there (as it is—bolded—in the original post) because this is an April fools’ joke. . . right?
To recap:
• Eight weeks ago, Democrat Scott Murphy was a complete unknown in this district.
• Jim Tedisco, on the other hand, is an upstate institution.
• Republicans outnumber Democrats in NY-20 by a three-to-two margin—some 70,000 votes.
• Prior to Kirsten Gillibrand winning in the Democratic Sweep Year of 2006, this district was in Republican hands for seven terms. In other words, since being redrawn as a safe Republican district in 1992, until the Gillibrand win, it was always represented by a Republican.
• After weeks of hemming and hawing, Tedisco came out against the Recovery Act, declaring that his candidacy was all about standing against the president’s agenda.
• The RNC went all in on this one. I only wish I had time to grab all the clips of Republicans declaring this either a referendum on Obama or a referendum on Michael Steele’s leadership of his party. Plus the parade of luminaries (such as they are) that went up to campaign and fundraise for Tedisco. . . oh, and then there was the requisite noun-verb-9/11 ad. . . I could go on.
To quote Josh Kraushaar and Charles Mahtesian at The Politico:
There’s no winner yet in the Upstate New York special election, and it might be mid-April before the race is settled. But a few things are clearer after Tuesday’s contest, none of it welcome news to the Republican Party.
. . . .
Republicans made this race a referendum on President Barack Obama, his stimulus plan and big government policies. But voters divided almost exactly down the middle, showing almost no sign they wanted to brush back the new administration. And this is precisely the kind of place where it would have been obvious had voters been so inclined — a Republican-leaning, small-town district that voted for Obama in 2008.
. . . .
[I]f the party can’t win with a [70,000 voter] head start. . . on the heels of the AIG bonuses furor and a massive expansion of federal spending, where can it win?
For that reason Republicans bet heavily on the race, with Republican National Committee Michael Steele pumping money and resources into the district, and the National Republican Congressional Committee pouring in $818,000 on top of that. Their efforts were aided by conservative groups, led by the National Republican Trust PAC, which spent an additional $819,000.
Now for the no-April-fooling part:
Republicans are still all-in on this race. The motion filed on behalf of Tedisco, reported here yesterday, was not your average, run-of-the mill, protect our candidate’s butt sort of petition. This motion tried to preemptively block certification of Murphy, should Tedisco’s opponent come out ahead. The judge spotted some of that language, and crossed it out, but he didn’t spot it all. The badly drafted motion also tries to constrain recount monitors to members of the Republican Party or “conservative.”
None of that will hold up in court, I expect, but it will have to be challenged in court. . . and therein you see the Republican’s “electoral” strategy.
Need proof? Jeremy Jacobs highlights a GOP fundraising email that went out this morning:
“Democrats have almost succeeded in stealing the election in Minnesota and seating Al Franken,” wrote Guy Harrison, the National Republican Congressional Committee’s executive director. “We cannot allow them to manipulate electoral results to seat another tax-troubled liberal.”
The e-mail indicates Republicans are gearing up for a legal fight over the election results, and suggests the party will pursue a more aggressive legal battle than in Minnesota. In that contest, Coleman was initially up after Election Day but Franken was able to overtake his lead in the recount and legal process.
The Franken-Coleman race is not the exception, it is the rule.
And not even the new rule.
It is true that this race, as it stands at this writing, is too close to call. The raw vote has Murphy ahead by several dozen votes with close to 6,000 absentee ballots still to be counted.
The Republicans are now clinging to those absentee ballots. . . and to the overseas ballots yet to arrive. . . the overseas and military ballots. Why the additional distinction? Because Republican lawyers and spokes-folks have been making it all day. Why? It might just sound good, but my guess is that they recall how military ballots became a wedge issue, a productive R talking point, during the 2000 Florida recount.
Like I said: the rule, and not a new one.
All of which is to say that the race isn’t over, and races, in general, if at all close, will not be over on election day for many election days to come.
* * *
Cillizza is reporting that Democratic assessments of the distribution of absentee ballots has Murphy winning by 210 votes when all the counting is done.
That’s still a narrow margin, so that likely means a legal battle. If you want to help, here is an Albany Project Act Blue page.



16 Comments












Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
They spin so hard, they hurt themselves. Idiots.
It would be wonderful if Teh Disco ends up losing by the exact number of people in his immediate family, since none of them could vote for him — since he doesn’t even live in the district!
Right round,baby, right round.
(in keeping with Teh Disco theme)
New York Law allows abesenee ballots so long as they are mailed by election day. (there are osme time lines about how long after election day they must be recieved by, but I don;t want to go that far into the weeds).
Anyway, there will be more absentee ballots coming in over the next couple of days. 10,ooo absetee ballots were mailed out to voters
Teddy,
That would be a delicious irony.
As I often point out, irony is my favorite form of humor.
Which is now going right round my head.
Thank you very much -NOT
Every time someone mentions Teh Disco my earwig starts with Donna and Barbra singing “Enough is Enough.” Guess that sums up the goopers as well.
aaa, teh disco. “Smoke on the Water” was a hit during the disco era, and as such, considered a disco hit. It’s nice to have your ears full of the same song for hours. Takes your mind off your troubles and gives you reason to cause mayhem.
I thought candidates had coattails in elections in which they were…. um…. candidates. Never heard of coatails 4 months after an election.
I understand what you’re saying, Gregg, but the seat was held by a Democrat prior to the special election. I wouldn’t call it a big win for either side. I’m not a NYer, though, so maybe I don’t understand the lay of the political land there. I’m always surprised to hear that conservatives of any stripe live in NY state.
DISCO IS DEAD
tsdisco is just on life support right now
Kirsten Gillibrand, while she may have D by her name – is a Blue-Dog style Dem. As is the D running this time – Murphy. This district is gerrymandered so that there are 70,000 more R’s then D’s registered.
And after all that – yeah, Gillibrand had it – but she only won 5 months ago – hardly an incumbent with coattails. Anyway, she wasn’t running.
Re-read the post and think about it. The Repubs apparently lost this one. It IS a big deal.
pardon my cut/paste from one of my posts about the race yesterday, (regarding murphy being a blue dog):
in a perfect world, a liberal progressive would have been preferable. in this district, they can’t afford to be so choosy…
“Voters in New York’s 20th district – a sprawling, largely rural district encompassing all or part of ten counties…”
http://www.ruralvotes.com/thebackforty/?p=727
“In the district, Republicans lead Democrats in voter registration by a wide margin — some 67,500 as of November 2008. And, according to the Almanac of American Politics, this area has been Republican territory since the birth of the party. George W. Bush won here by 7 and 8 points in 2000 and 2004.”
http://realclearpolitics.blogs…..-district/
if you look at the map of ny 20 greg posted up top – you will see it spans the horse country elites of saratoga & rhinebeck, as well as huge spans of farming country. thats a pretty wide expanse of republican “types” to try to appeal to if you’re a dem.
btw – there were others who were more liberal that took some steps to run when gillibrand was appointed senator, (not my 1st choice – but a better one then CK i think), but didn’t end up running for various reasons. (one was a female attorney).
having another republican congressperson from nys will not only hurt in washington – it will hurt us here in nys, where the repubs have had a stranglehold on the state legislature for years & we only recently got a dem majority.
teh te-disco lawsuit is just so pathetic.
Tried and failed to repair your second link.
But this may be the one.
yep thats the one – thanks lurkingmod :)
Isn’t it Spring Break? I wonder how many of those absentee ballots might be students at Renssaeler, Empire State, and other colleges in the area?
And anyone know what the break on the absentee ballots was in the Fall ‘08 election was for NY-20?