I almost spilled my coffee at the headline in the Washington Post this morning: Vatican Archbishop Issues Apology. The archbishop in question is Raymond Burke, formerly of St. Louis and now head of the Vatican’s version of the Supreme Court. Burke is famously blunt and willing to horn in on whatever is going elsewhere — which in part is what got him his post in Rome.
So of course, the Post headline is wrong. Burke, apologize? Please. Dick Cheney will apologize before that happens. But here’s the story, in three acts.
Act One: The "Gotcha Video" — Yesterday Randall Terry (of Operation Rescue and Terry Schaivo fame and recent Catholic convert) held a press conference to broadcast an interview he had done with Burke a couple of weeks ago in Rome. As the National Catholic Reporter says to lead off their story:
Archbishop Raymond Burke, the former St. Louis prelate who now leads the Vatican supreme court, has called on parishioners to pressure reluctant bishops to withhold Communion from Catholic politicians who back legalized abortion.
He also said President Barack Obama "could be an agent of death" if his support for abortion rights becomes a model for leaders in other countries.
The archbishop made his highly unusual comments to anti-abortion activist Randall Terry in a videotaped interview that Terry showed March 25 at the National Press Club in Washington.
"It is weakening the faith of everyone," Burke said. "It’s giving the impression that it must be morally correct to support procured abortion."
Act Two: the Non-Apology Apology — After news of Terry’s press conference got back to Rome (I’d say it took five minutes), Burke realized that these videotaped comments are not going to go down well in the US, especially among the bishops. He then issued a statement of his own:
“. . . I was never informed that the videotape would be used as part of a campaign of severe criticism of certain fellow bishops regarding the application of Canon 915 of the Code of Canon Law.
“If I had known what the true purpose of the interview was, I would never have agreed to participate in it."
[Burke] then said: “I am deeply sorry for the confusion and hurt which the wrong use of the videotape has caused to anyone, particularly, to my brother bishops.”
Shorter Burke to the bishops: "I’m sorry the words I said got back to you. I meant to scold you behind your backs, not to your faces."
Act Three: Tune in Next Week — And why did this happen yesterday? Because Kathleen Sebelius is having her confirmation hearing to head HHS next week.
The Catholic anti-abortion crowd is putting on the full court press, and they’re using every tool in their box to pressure the hierarchy. They took liberties with Brownback last month to get folks riled up about FOCA, they got Sebelius’ own bishop to attack her earlier this month, and now they are messing with one of their staunchest and most powerful allies, Raymond Burke, to pressure McCarrick and Mahoney.
If I were a Catholic bishop (like that’s ever going to happen!), I’d be thinking, "With friends like these . . ."




46 Comments





Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
The Vatican just needs a really good PR man to get out front on these things. Somebody like Michael Steele to usher in the era of hip-hop Catholicism.
So will the Vatican expell the US Ambassador to the Vatican – since it would seem he is a representative of an “agent of death”? Will the Pope deign to even meet with Obama, or Hillary Clinton…since they are “agents of death”?
And if the Pope has such a gripe with Catholics representing ALL their constituents…then why not simply issue a ban on Catholics being involved in politics in the United States (or any other Representative Democracy with people of diverse faiths). Limit Catholic Representation to dictatorships, since it’s clear that the Catholic dogma cannot mesh with politicians ever having to espouse non-Catholic positions on such issues as condoms, contraceptives, abortion, stem-cells, brain death, etc. I was about to say “war” but the Pope has never condemned people for supporting wars like Iraq in the same way he has other issues. Killing a blastula is apparently weighted more than ending the life of an adult with a family dependent on him/her. I guess it’s a matter of “innocence”. The whole “original sin” stuff must flood in on one at the moment of birth.
If I were a cynical person, I might conclude that the pontiff’s recent anti-condom tour of Africa makes him an “agent of death.” Fortunately I’m not cynical…
These guys are really trying to compete with the fundies on who can get back to the 10th century the fastest. At least they’re smart enough to reject the Rapture. I’d prolly look good in one of those fancy outfits with the big hats an’ shit, too. Oh well.
Never happen the Catholic hierarchy is steeped in Dogma. Funny thing though a few centuries ago abortion was allowed by the Church! What fucking hypocrites they should read their own History, the things they just might find out about themselves!!
I do admire the head wear. Heck, you could hide a small choirboy in there.
Guess condom use is a sin too. Wonder if we are going to be hearing condemnation if you believe the earth is not flat too.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/africa/7947460.stm
There is no hypocrisy, the concept of “papal infallibility” offers blanket immunity.
LOL.
Ah but he supposed to be infallible only in matters of the Church. But really they changed the laws of the Church to suite themselves. Just like when they banned women from being “Leaders” Priests in the fourth century!
Depends on what you use it for. If you use it to keep a banana fresh, no problem. If you use it to keep YOUR banana fresh, better start with the Hail Marys.
As a recovering Catholic, I find myself wondering whether the catholic church isn’t somehow in league with the world’s population of psychologists and psychiatrists….
Let me see if I got this right:
1. 9 year-old girl raped by her stepfather – ostrasized by Church for having abortion of twins that may have killed her in childbirth.
2. Mother excommunicated for supporting daughters abortion.
3. Doctor’s excommunicationed for performing abortion on 9 year-old.
4. Step-father who raped 9 year-old girl NOT excommunicated.
Roman Catholic Church’s outlook on “LIFE:” PRICELSS!!!
If I were Roman Catholic, right now I would tell the Pope and the Church to go fuck themselves! I’m going back to being a Druid!!! (It’s ok, there are no women involved, and apparently sex among church men, and especially alterboy’s, is ok – so fucking themselves is probably in the Bible, or some shit).
Don’t aboblish religion! Its own stupidity will hasten its death!!!
Interesting. I had to endure a car ride with my ex boss who went on a rant that 40% of the hospitals in the NYC metro area are run by the church and are about to be closed and have their operating licenses revoked because they will refuse to perform abortions there.
He blames this on the Obama administration enacting liberal pro abortion policies and jamming it down all the catholic hospitals which are doing such good work and will be forced to murder or be shut down.
YIKES!
Isn’t that when you run a long way and try to catch the balls but never do?
Are you suggesting that instilling a deep-rooted sense of guilt in young children isn’t nurturing?
not at all.
I turned out just fine.
Really.
heh.
I’ve seen them completed on rare occasions.
This probably qualifies as a Hail Mary too.
is a prelate someone whose not going to be on time, ahead of time?
Yup!!!!
It is not a bishop’s business or a priests my relationship with God.
I’m angry at the hypocrisy of the Catholic church.
Where are they on the issue of the death penalty?
Oh, that’s right. That is an acceptable republican backed issue. So it’s OK.
War, again, done by republicans, OK.
This is my fave.
So – do all of the attendees of Notre Dame’s Commencement Address get ex-communicated, or just a few extra centuries in purgatory?
The suggestion that it was a stepfather causes problems because divorce is not sanctioned unless the man can show republicam party affiliation
whoa – is that for real?
WOW!
Yeah. Triple A game last year. Climb the wall, catch the ball. No biggee.
Nah, they’ve done away with Purgatory, unless they bring it back for the May sweeps.
SHIT! She sure showed them up!!!! LOL
my cat can do that, while chasing a fly (of the buzzing variety).
pretty amazing feat for a human.
I guess realistically, the left fielder didn’t have a shot at it. They sometimes get a little touchy about non-players touching the ball while it is in play. I can recall a certain Cubs/Marlins game when folks really got their knickers in a twist.
Nah, they’ve done away with Purgatory…
Rut-roh.
I was always kind of a fan of the Purgatory gray area. If they get all black and white about stuff, my natural optimism becomes somewhat guarded.
Yep, she had one at the end of BOTH legs.
I suspect with sufficient financial inducements, your loved ones could still get you sprung from the Bad Place.
Isn’t the separation between church and state supposed to work both ways?
I’m not religious so these kinds of intrusions seem very bizarre to me. What’s next? Burning at the stake for not using the Church approved brand of toenail clippers?
Hard enough to get some people in the U.S. to admit that it even works one way.
sshhhh – if ya keep spreading that one around, AIG is gonna come up with a new product.
My guess is she plays on a girl’s hardball team. Maybe fast pitch softball but her reaction was more in line with the speed of a hardball. Great fuckin’ catch, whatever.
Can I wear it as an article of clothing…while having a co-ed wrestling match?
Can I go OT? Michelle Bachman has introduced a bill that would ensure that the US dollar cannot be replaced by another kind of currency. Huh? Cause…why?
Amazing what you can do with digital manipulation ;-)
Cause…why?
because she is “Michele Fucking Bachmann, bee-yatch”?
no disrespect intended toward you.
It was originally intended for a Gatorade Commercial…note all the product placements. There is some question amongst Ad people whether or not the producers surrepticiously released a “shelved ad”…or whether it was really a Gatorade effort at a viral campaign.
http://www.snopes.com/photos/a…..llgirl.asp
I pointed out that this could be a big dosappointment to those that wnat a return to the “Cross of Gold”…allowing gold and silver as legal tender, again!
What am I gonna do with all those “Ron Paul” dollars, I saved up!
Buy stock in AIG – excuse me, AIU. :)
now I’m bummed.