Back in November of 2007, I wrote a piece about a speech Mario Cuomo gave to the Federal Bar Council in which he praised lawyers in Pakistan for marching in the streets to preserve the rule of law in Pakistan. He encouraged American lawyers to be as diligent in support of our own rule of law here in the US.
At the time, the outcome in Pakistan was unknown. Would these lawyers loose their licenses and livelihoods for daring to oppose the government? Would they loose their freedom and be imprisoned? Would they lose their lives? Or would they eventually be intimidated into silence?
Well, now we know how the story turned out.
The Washington Post is reporting:
[T]he Pakistani government announced early Monday morning that it would restore the former chief justice of the Supreme Court and a group of other deposed judges in a major capitulation to opponents.
The Pakistani government tried to stop the latest protest march, attempting to bottle up marchers at their starting points, as well as erecting barricades at their proposed destination to keep marchers out.
[A] broad coalition of opponents who demanded the reinstatement of Pakistan’s independent judiciary and threatened to march on the capital, Islamabad, until Chaudhry was brought back.
The decision marked an extraordinary victory for Pakistan’s legal community, which has been agitating peacefully for the judges’ reinstatement for the past two years,
I like it when the good guys win. I like it even more when lawyers turn out to be the good guys.
So, to my brethren at the bar far across the sea, I salute you. Well done.



14 Comments












Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Thanks LHP, for recognizing the courage of the Legal Eagles in Pakistan, who literally risked life and limb for their cause.
This was a pivotal win for Democracy, which the Pakistani populace so desperately crave.
Excellent!
Good for them. I want to march too.
Was it a typo that CA laid of 25,000 Teachers ?
Looks like all those Steroids really affected Ahnuld’s Brain …
on the general subject of the rule of law.. the Red Cross report on shrub’s secret prisons leaked today sounds almost inconceivably horrific.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/…..02724.html
people suspended by the their shackled arms, inquisition style, for days???? among other unspeakables…
One of the relevant points in all of this is the motivations of the lawyers’ revolt. Many were put in jail, beaten in the streets, etc. The biggest motivator for the lawyers was the removal of Chaudhry as Chief Judge.
Why was Chaudhry removed?
He had ruled, while Musharraf was still in power, that under the Pakistani law and its Constitution, people could not just be disappeared; could not just be sold off secretly to the US with no accounting.
So our commitment to torture; our Dept of Justice diligently making sure that cases like el-Masri’s and Arar’s get blocked; Obama’s current diligence in blocking the suit of the survivors of Dostum’s shipping container of death who then were handed off to US torture to force a false confession from them; our own determination here that we could round up and conduct torture experimentation on people sold to us in Pakistan and elsewhere – - we created the lawyers revolt in Pakistan.
By comparison, the lawyers in our own Dept of Justice have chosen a very different path.
So our torture policies both pushed lawyers and moderates in Pakistan into a loose alliance with some extremists and have contributed to instability in a nuclear power. And our torture policies have redefined the United States as a state sponsor of torture, still arrogantly asserting its ability to torture without consequence.
And it can.
Because the lawyers in our Dept of Justice are nothing like the lawyers in Pakistan. That is a hard and harsh revelation to have to accept.
Petro,
actually, it was 26,000 pink slips
And on to the Swat Valley?
… shakes head in disbelief …
8 – where the torturers make short, violent public spectacles of their depravity, as opposed to leaving them behind closed doors. Not great choices, are there?
Not usually, but closing down the Pakistani legal system and ending education for girls are surely worth protesting.
I have a post in the hopper on that. It’s so bad. Remember how Winston was tortured in Orwell’s 1984?
Well I think that was the training manual for what they did to the ghost detainees
Maybe we should pass the hat, buy some tickets, and invite some of these gentlemen to lead us in a march on Washington. The members of the Pakistani bar seem to have the starch in their shirts that so many of our home-grown leaders lack.
These incidents prompted a rather wonderful letter to the editors of the Times-Picayune by a lawyer friend of mine.
I can’t wait to see his reaction to this!
Thanks for posting it.