Each week, Palestinians and international supporters gather in the West Bank town of Ni’lin to hold a prayer service and protest the building of the Israeli Wall. Yesterday, the International Solidarity Movement announced that Tristan Anderson, 37, from Oakland, CA was shot in the head by the Israeli Defense Forces with a high velocity tear gas canister and is, according to overnight reports, in critical condition at an Israeli hospital. Reports from the scene say that Anderson was standing far away from the wall, after the earlier protest, and not near anyone who might have been considered "threatening."
Jonathan Polack, a left-wing [Israeli] activist who is sitting by Anderson’s bedside at the hospital, said. . . that the protesters clashed with the soldiers, but noted that "the firing incident took place inside the village and not next to the fence. There were clashes in the earlier hours, but he wasn’t part of them. He didn’t throw stones and wasn’t standing next to the stone throwers.
"There was really no reason to fire at them. The Dutch girl standing next to him was not hurt. It only injured him, like a bullet."
Pollack, in an interview with KPIX TV in California later said:
Anderson’s skull was fractured and some of the bone fragments entered his brain, Pollack said.
Anderson underwent surgery to have part of his frontal lobe removed and it "went relatively well," said Pollack, who was at the Tel Hashomer hospital in Tel Aviv to monitor the surgery.
Video from the scene shows the serious injury Anderson sustained – (viewers will find this disturbing):
There is also a report of one Palestinian "wounded in the leg as a result of live IDF fire" and Ma’an News Service reports four Palestinians were wounded by rubber bullets as well.
The Ni’lin demonstrations are an attempt to stop construction of the Wall which is cutting residents off from their property. ISM notes:
Residents in the village of Ni’lin have been demonstrating against the construction of the Apartheid Wall, deemed illegal by the International Court of Justice in 2004. Ni’lin will lose approximately 2500 dunums of agricultural land when the construction of the Wall is completed. Ni’lin was 57,000 dunums in 1948, reduced to 33,000 dunums in 1967, currently is 10,000 dunums and will be 7,500 dunums after the construction of the Wall.
ISM updates can be found here.
Update via Ha’aretz
"He’s in critical condition, anesthetized and on a ventilator and undergoing imaging tests," said Orly Levi, a spokeswoman at the Tel Hashomer hospital. She described Anderson’s condition as life-threatening.
and from the Israeli group ATTW:
The impact of the projectile caused numerous condensed fractures to Anderson’s forehead and right eye socket. During the operation, part of his right frontal lobe had to be removed, as it was penetrated by bone fragments. A brain fluid leakage was sealed using a tendon from his thigh, and both his right eye and skin suffered extensive damage. The long term scope of all of Tristan’s injuries is yet unknown. It should also be noted that soldiers at the Ni’ilin checkpoint prevented the Red Crescent ambulance from taking Tristan directly to the hospital, forcing it to wait for approximately 15 minutes until an Israeli ICU ambulance (called by Israeli activists) arrived at scene, after which he was carried from one side of the checkpoint to the other. This, of course, is standard procedure – in the extremely rare cases where the army allows patients from the occupied territories to be transferred into Israel.
Amnesty International US notes that:
This Monday, March 16 2009 marks the 6th anniversary of the death of another US citizen, Rachel Corrie, who was crushed by an American made Caterpillar bulldozer while trying to negotiate with the driver not to destroy the home of a Palestinian pharmacist in the Gaza Strip. She was 23 years old.
Selise quotes Starhawk’s update via email here – please read.




35 Comments












Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
This is terrible, very tragic news. Honestly, there is just so much outrage one can take. What can we do?
We can do nothing until the corporate control of our media is lifted. We do not have a free press anymore, and news like tragedies like this one will not be communicated to enough people to drive change in our national policies.
I really wished I knew. We saw what happened to a potential Obama appointee who dared go against the bend-over-for-Israel conservative mantra.
We should cut off all support for them NOW-all they do is use us as a mother’s skirt to hide behind while they do whatever the hell they want AND recieve money and support.
In a number of European countries there are active movements calling for change – and we can join their voices by putting pressure on here. Most of our representatives have not heard a US based desire for change on behalf of the Palestinians – they need to know there is a force opposed to AIPAC. Work by folks like Jstreet really matter but so do our efforts to let our reps know we want something different.
thank you siun, i made an OT comment earlier when i read the email. here’s some more from starhawk (via email list):
Tristan Shot in the West Bank
By Starhawk
– As I write, my friend Tristan lies hovering between life and death in an Israeli hospital, shot in the head, hit with a tear gas canister at a nonviolent demonstration in the West Bank town of Ni’lin, protesting the wall the Israelis are building to isolate the West Bank.
Tristan is—I say ‘is’ because I don’t dare slip into ‘was’ for I fear that his hold on life is so tenous, a shift into past tense might tip the balance–Tristan is always there, at every demonstration, every mobilization, every fight for justice. He has always seemed fearless to me, with that young man’s confidence in his physical body that I now envy. He’s not so young—thirty-eight, still, I have twenty years on him and he seems young to me, strong, hardy, willing to sit in a tree for months to protect a grove of oaks at UC Berkeley, willing to camp out and show up early to clean out the convergence space, to eat bad pasta and dumpster-dived vegetables for weeks on end. Tall, slim, with dark eyes and olive skin, and a sharp, aquiline nose that starts off in one direction, then changes its mind and heads in another, he comes regularly to our rituals as well as actions, and helps build the North altar every year at the Spiral Dance. Softspoken, unassuming, more than anyone else I know he embodies a certain ideal of rigorous equality, never pulling rank nor trumpeting his considerable street cred, never asking for attention, simply showing up again and again and pitching in to get the work done.
Why don’t the Palestinians adopt the tactics of Martin Luther King or Gandhi? And the answer is simply this—they do. For the last six years, they have mounted an ongoing campaign of civil resistance against Israel’s apartheid wall, which snakes through the West Bank, confiscating Palestinian farmland without compensation, destroying the life and livelihoods of whole villages, literally setting in concrete the fractured geometry of Israel’s incursions, her illegal settlements that eat away the integrity of any potential Palestinian state. In the spring of 2004, when the army was just beginning to bulldoze olive orchards and scrape land bare, the villagers of Mas’Ha set up a peace encampment on the wall’s route, inviting support from internationals and Israelis of good will. I’ve written elsewhere about what it was like to be there, encamped in one remaining grove under a full Passover moon, the despair of the bulldozers and the slim hope watching young Palestinians and Israelis sit together around a fire, sharing smokes and stories.
http://www.starhawk.org/activi…..17;ha.html
and http://www.starhawk.org/activi….._last.html
For six years, the movement has moved, from village to village, following the path of the wall. Six years of sparse and tiny victories—here and there, the route of the wall pushed back a few meters—but in Palestine, even the smallest victory stands out because it is so unusual, so different from the expected course of events. Like starving people who survive on crumbs, Palestinians nourish their determination to survive on even the smallest grains of success.
Mostly, I think, the movement survives because, in the face of horrific injustice, people need to do something. The vast majority of Palestinians do not want to strap on a suicide belt or pick up a gun. Contrary to all the stereotypes and racist assumptions, they don’t want to kill, or be killed, for that matter. But they want to do something.
So they come to the wall. Children carry signs, women sit in front of bulldozers, men chant slogans and pray. Supported by a few internationals and a few determined Israelis, mostly ignored by the world’s media, they face tear gas, rubber bullets, real bullets, arrests and beatings. And if the demonstrations have not yet stopped the wall nor won over the hearts of Israelis, they have at least given strength to the hearts of Palestinians and those who continue to hope against hope for some ultimate justice.
For that, many have died. Tristan, young though he seems to me, has had more of a life than Arafat Rateb Khawaje, who was shot in the back by Israeli forces at a demonstration in Ni’lin on December 28, 2008, when he was only twenty two. On the same day, Mohammed Khawaje, aged twenty, was shot in the head with live ammunition. Brain dead, he lingered for three days until he died in a Ramallah hospital. And they, so young, still had more life behind them than Yousef Amira, only seventeen, shot with rubber-coated still bullets on July 29, 2008. And yet they, too, seem ancient compared to Ahmed Mousa, only ten, shot in the forehead with live ammunition on July 29th, 2008.
And that is just the body count of one village, one year. I grieve for Tristan because he’s a friend. I know him, I have marched with him shoulder to shoulder, sat in meetings with him, shared laughter and gossip and disbelief at the amount of liquor those British activists could put away. I feel for him in a way I should feel, but can’t, for those who are just names on a list to me.
But I know that others do. Some mother grieves for Ahmed Mousa and will never fully recover from his loss. Some brother mourns for Khawaje, some father cries and rages over Yousef Amira’s grave. Multiply that grief a thousand, thousand times and it explodes in rockets and suicide bombs. Yes, I also grieve for the Israeli victims of those bombs and rockets. But they cannot be stopped by walls, by land grabs and humiliations and injustice piled upon injustice, nor can they be silenced by the shrill voices who brand every critic of Israel an enemy.
Only justice can end the violence and bring peace and security to Palestinians and Israelis both. And it is time—it’s long past time—for the clamor of international voices to demand real justice, for the continued violence now jeopardizes all of us.
So, here’s what you can do. First, if you like most people are confused by the whole issue, educate yourself. Read a book—like Jimmy Carter’s Israel: Peace, Not Apartheid which is about as fair and balanced a recent history as you’ll find anywhere. Read my own website, Starhawk.org—on the Palestine page. Read the Israeli peace bloc—gush-shalom.org, or the reports from the International Solidarity Movement at palsolidarity.org. Or read “Start here” on the Jewish Voice for Peace website http://www.jewishvoiceforpeace.org/.
Speak out: Contact your representatives and demand a full, impartial investigation not just of Tristan’s shooting but of the ongoing Israeli violence against unarmed demonstrators. But more than that, speak out on the issue. We have a new administration in office, a man who I believe is a genuinely good man with a nuanced understanding of the issue. But Obama is also a pragmatist who is not going to sacrifice the rest of his agenda on the rocks of this issue. For him to intervene effectively, to demand real concessions from the Israelis and push for a true resolution, we need to build a clamor that is too loud to be silenced by the pro-Israel lobby.
So—write him a note. Go onto his web page and send him a note. Do this often!
http://www.whitehouse.gov/contact/
Support groups working for justice and peace—like the International Solidarity Movement, like the many groups working on campaigns for divestment or boycotts of Israeli goods. Jewish Voice for Peace always has a good list of things to do. United for Peace and Justice has taken good stands on the issue and often has campaigns to join. http://www.unitedforpeace.org/
Al Awda is a national Right to Return campaign: http://www.al-awda.org/
Oberlin Students for Justice in Palestine has a great page of links: http://www.oberlin.edu/stuorg/sfp/pages/links.html
We’re in a new era now—and public pressure may actually do some good. It’s time for all of us to stand behind those who stand unarmed at the wall. If we do, even the small things that we can do with little risk, they will mount up like grains of sand until they shift the scales and bring about real justice, true security, and honest peace
Siun is quoting Ha’aretz and a radio station in California,both reporting on something that happened yesterday and far from here. Not a free press?
oops. sorry siun – my comment had too many links or was to long. my apologies.
Does one CA station where the victim was from really disprove his point? Ha’aretz is an Israeli paper. Will we hear about this from the NY Times or the Washington Compost? Of course not.
Thanks so much Selise! I’ll add a link to your info from Starhawk as an update!
Sorry gang but the issue here is not so much “free press” as the need for a dramatic change in policy. For example, the NYT had the story as well:
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/03……html?_r=1
f neither paper covers the story, I will retract my scepticism and admit the point.
it’s not up on her, starhawk’s, website yet, so i copied and pasted the whole thing. but i expect it will be soon.
Digg It
No. When reporters can report openly from war zones without fearing losing their jobs for offending political groups back home, then we’re closer.
AP’s latest: http://www.google.com/hostedne…..gD96TQI8O0
They are worried about offending AIPAC – that’s their entire problem. Makes me sick.
As far as I know, reporters continue to go to war zones. I don’t hold the view that everything is wonderful, but I’m not sure of what you’re saying.
The restrictions I’ve most noticed have been government impositions.
If I’m even more ignorant than I suspect, help me out.
Blue America is upstairs with Gordon Smith of North Carolina (not Oregon)
I wonder what Chuckie Schumer (D – Tel Aviv) has to say about this incident.
Schumer, Lieberman and McShame are waiting for their instructions from the Israeli spin machine
Siun, thanks so much for calling attention to the IDF’s ongoing carnage in the Occupied Territories.
Any act of war against civilans is repugnant. This one echoes even more strongly because I know the victim. Tristan’s an amazing activist: one of my favorite memories of him when he took advantage of a brief march during the Biodevastation 2004 in SF to scoot under a bus full of delegates and u-lock himself to the underside. He kept the blockade going for two hours, which was the best fixed blockade of the whole protest.
I’m hoping for the best – but the projectile that hit his skull with such force as to shatter the orbitofrontal bone and rip away the brain’s covering carried kinetic energies so great that they certainly caused extensive neuronal shearing. Together with the destruction of Tristan’s right frontal lobe, the result is a very grave prognosis.
Another human tragedy from the IDF’s savagery. How many billions will America’s government send off to the IDF this year – and why are we paying for the aggressors in Israel’s brutal religious apartheid sttate?
Hear, hear, Kirk. I quite agree with you. And thank you for that vivid picture of Tristan Anderson. Hoping for the best, in spite of the news….
Thanks for this post, Siun.
how eloquent, while reading some parts it reminded me to share this-
sting-with ruben blades
they dance alone
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a_jDiDya5j4
-released 20 years ago. and it is still going on all over the world.
i can’t count how many times this song has healed me. first thing i put on when i hear news like today. sometimes i put on the spanish version, hits just as deep.
here is a live version in spanish in argentina for amnesty international concert with peter gabriel
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H1jslyzgXOk
forgot the lyrics (the floodgates are open)
http://www.absolutelyrics.com/…..nce_alone/
They Dance Alone – Sting
Why are there women here dancing on their own?
Why is there this sadness in their eyes?
Why are the soldiers here
Their faces fixed like stone?
I can’t see what it is that they despise
They’re dancing with the missing
They’re dancing with the dead
They dance with the invisible ones
Their anguish is unsaid
They’re dancing with their fathers
They’re dancing with their sons
They’re dancing with their husbands
They dance alone They dance alone
It’s the only form of protest they’re allowed
I’ve seen their silent faces scream so loud
If they were to speak these words they’d go missing too
Another woman on a torture table what else can they do
They’re dancing with the missing
They’re dancing with the dead
They dance with the invisible ones
Their anguish is unsaid
They’re dancing with their fathers
They’re dancing with their sons
They’re dancing with their husbands
They dance alone They dance alone
One day we’ll dance on their graves
One day we’ll sing our freedom
One day we’ll laugh in our joy
And we’ll dance
One day we’ll dance on their graves
One day we’ll sing our freedom
One day we’ll laugh in our joy
And we’ll dance
Ellas danzan con los desaparecidos
Ellas danzan con los muertos
Ellas danzan con amores invisibles
Ellas danzan con silenciosa angustia
Danzan con sus pardres
Danzan con sus hijos
Danzan con sus esposos
Ellas danzan solas
Danzan solas
Hey Mr. Pinochet
You’ve sown a bitter crop
It’s foreign money that supports you
One day the money’s going to stop
No wages for your torturers
No budget for your guns
Can you think of your own mother
Dancin’ with her invisible son
They’re dancing with the missing
They’re dancing with the dead
They dance with the invisible ones
They’re anguish is unsaid
They’re dancing with their fathers
They’re dancing with their sons
They’re dancing with their husbands
They dance alone
They dance alone
the israelis are reponsible for on the u.s.s. liberty in 1967 by the israeli air force and navy. there was never any accountability; oh, excuse me, they admitted to an unfortunate error. that cost of lives of 34 american sailors, and nearly 200 wounded.
they are not an ally. this country serves as their fucking puppet and pay billions in support for the effort. scratch that — congress and the media are their puppets — the people have no say in the relationship.
Kirk, how tragic. And this is the question that needs to be asked and asked and asked. I am calling Congress about the mind-numbing denial and minimization of Israel’s behavior to the Palesintians. I am so angry at my own senator Schumer over the Chas Freeman swiftboating (bleeechhhh) and have communicated that.
Selise.. thank you for the moving letter and for the advice for action. I will spread your rich inspiring and action-specific comment among my network and save it to structure my own activism.
Siun, thank you for the posting yet again.
The film clip shows at least two gas canisters fired into a small clearing. The first, when Tristan and one other person were there. Hardly a useful target for crowd-dispersing gas. The second, after half a dozen or so medics gathered to treat him, a kind of entrapment that, again, was not designed to disperse a potentially dangerous crowd, but to prevent one from gathering to aid a wounded observer. The motivation for this use of gas was not control, but intimidation.
World Jewry owes much to the state of Israel. Its government of the day? That depends on what is does, just as with Bush and Obama here.
And this is also a time to remember Tom Hurndall, the young British photojournalist killed in 2004 by an IDF sniper while wearing an orange waistcoat and helping Palestinian kids to escape gunfire in Rafah, Gaza
Thank you for the very proper reminder …
I saw a mention that 412 Palestinians have died just this year during these nonviolent anti-Wall demonstrations … sadly, as Starhawk says in the wonderful letter Selise passed along, we only know them as names on a list.
Thanks for covering this Siun.
The ISM flickr photostream has pictures of the kind of projectile that has destroyed Tristan’s frontal lobe (what wasn’t already removed in surgery this morning).
Before firing
After firing
I’m not a religious man, but my prayers go out to this person.
He was there doing something for a good cause.
Enough of violence in this world!
There are still a few hours left to vote in the Progressive Alaska Poll:
It must come down to the scale of human faces,human empathy and opening of hearts.
Those who have been attacked,killed or had loved ones taken away to either not return or return broken and crushed again must be seen on scale of humanity.
What has befallen Palestine must be understood as being more than about where the boundaries are,who is on what piece of land or who is able to build or able to tear down. Who can inflict suffering or impose humiliation. Israel cannot/will not succeed on these terms of inhumanity.
This human scale is taken out repeatedly in this epoch of super weapons and brutally contrived means of suppression being used against unarmed and innocent civilians.
One would have hoped President Obama would have demonstrated this scale of human empathy upon becoming the American President on Jan.20th,2009 and condemned Israel for this ongoing brutal occupation conduct and for what Israel unleashed on Gaza last December 2008.
He has not. It is a basic failure of human empathy.
Perhaps this incident of an innocent American being severely harmed by the IDF will prompt President Obama to find his human heart.
Unless and until many human faces and hearts are put on this infamy that has fallen on Palestine at the hand of Israeli occupation and expansive militarism little more will be possible other than more of what has now befell Tristan Anderson.
President Obama. SoS Clinton. Profiles in political courage are called for here and now.
Not political cowardice. Not this numbing moral indifference.
AIPAC must be curbed in WashingtonDC.
TelAviv made to reset Israeli criminal conduct in West Bank and Gaza. American fairplay and even handedness being subverted by undue TelAviv influence and perverse policy formulation sway must end.
TelAviv is entitled to reasonable American support. Not this rabid one sided pro TelAviv policy perversion WashingtonDC is empowering and has implemented for far too long.
Israeli/Palestinian conflict today directly a result of American failure to curb TelAviv and give Palestinians reason to not distrust or despise American diplomacy.This going back thirty years. How many more Palestinians,Israelis and indeed Tristan Andersons must suffer for this?
I’m very proud of some of the comments made here, but hoo boy! Have we got some bloodthirsty people out there!