Today Citigroup lowered its rating on Wal-Mart from a buy to a hold because of the Employee Free Choice Act, "citing concern that legislation intended to make it easier for employees to unionize would raise the retail giant’s labor costs and hurt its competitiveness."
This is startling for a lot of reasons, not the least of which is that they’re downgrading the stock based on an assumption that a piece of legislation will pass that hasn’t even been introduced yet.
The Citigroup analyst, Debora Weinswig, said Employee Free Choice (EFCA) "could be a significant drag to earnings."
It’s hard to view this as anything other than a reckless and overt political act on the part of a company, Citigroup, that has made stupendously bad business decisions with dire economic consequences necessitating billions in taxpayer bailouts, at a time when the market can ill-afford it.
Even Bank of America admitted in an internal memo that increased wages for working people would mean "increased spending power of lower income consumers," which would mean that even if Wal-Mart was successfully unionized — a big if — they could make up the cost of higher wages with an increase in sales. Somehow that calculation didn’t enter into Ms. Weinswig’s extraordinarily premature analysis.
Blanche Lincoln has been one of the wobbly Senate votes on Employee Free Choice, and she’s pretty much a wholly owned subsidiary of Wal-mart. One has to wonder if this isn’t an overt attempt to influence her vote.
I asked Pulitzer-Prize winning former New York Times reporter David Cay Johnston, author of author of Free Lunch: How the Wealthiest Americans Enrich Themselves at Government Expense [and Stick You with the Bill], what he made of this announcement:
Citigroup’s comment fit with the same pattern we see in utility regulation. Just as state regulators are about to vote on raising electricity and gas rates, the bond ratings agencies come out with warnings that they’re thinking about downgrading the bonds. None dare call it "interference in the market."
If there is any company that could absorb this kind of hit in order to tank a piece of legislation that it has been mobilizing against for months, it’s Wal-Mart.
Taxpayers now own a huge chunk of Citigroup. We should be looking a lot more closely about how, and when, these ratings get made.
Update: Greg Sargent says that Burger King is getting in on the action, too.
David Cay Johnston will be joining us at 3:30 EDT on Thursday as part of our week-long series "No More Dough ‘Til We Know Where It Goes." You can send a note to Congress telling them what you think about the need for more bank bailout transparency here.



65 Comments





Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Jane, did you mean buy to hold?
– always startling to be reminded Wal-Mart comprises 3% of US GDP
yes
I’d recommend completely removing the “research” department from any financial corporation if I thought it would do any good. “Independent” research firms would end up with a few big customers and thus would taylor their research to satisfy those cutomers, just the same as if they were in house.
“Blanche Lincoln has been one of the wobbly Senate votes on Employee Free Choice, and she’s pretty much a wholly owned subsidiary of Wal-mart. One has to wonder if this isn’t an overt attempt to influence her vote.”
Blanche has always depended on the kindness of strangers…
Yup. Just like public accounting. The partner at Arthur Andersen who had Enron as his client was not going to walk away from a $52M annual billing. Hence, he buttressed his financial pronouncements with legal chicanery and issued the reports accordingly. Next thing you know, Arthur Andersen is out of business…
Why would anyone listen to the recommendations of someone speaking for Citigroup? I mean other than the folks in our Federal government who keep supplying them with cash to steal?
Every employee everywhere should be allowed to freely belong to a union to put a stop to their coercion by employers which has been going on since the first employer emerged from the cave.
And how is it that Citi is allowed to take OUR money and then turn around and sabotage us??
At the very least in order to avoid a conflict of interest no bank or company taking government money should comment on government policy good or bad. The fact that they are commenting against and their talking points are lies makes matters worse.
Wallmart is where low income workers shop give them more money they buy more. With the banks tightening up credit Wallmart needs its customers to have more cash on hand since they can’t finance impulse buys on credit like they used to..
Also Blanche how many families are on some type of public aid even though one member works at Wallmart full time? Just why should I pay taxes so WallMart gets cheap Wage Slaves!
Funny Rick Santelli never gets mad about corporate welfare.
:) Ummm, because our executive and legislative branches handed it to them?
I want CIti to give us a refund
Just a reminder to Citigroup:
Per 18 U.S.C. sec. 2331, one could quite easily construe these actions as being terrorism.
The definitions:
Do these pronouncements appear to be intended to intimidate or coerce a civilian population?
Do these pronouncements appear to be intended to influence the policy of a government by intimidation or coercion?
Do these activities occur primarily within the territorial jurisdiction of the United States?
Is market manipulation an action dangerous to human life which is in violation of a state or federal criminal law?
I can see that a very easy argument can be made that the answer to all of these questions is “yes”.
Just a reminder, Citi….
What is the interest rate being charged to CITI for TARP funds. Why don’t we raise that interest rate like CITI did to its customers.
We have been losing the class war to these Shock Doctors for thirty five or more years running, largely without a fight. One doesn’t have look far to realize these corporations have looted entire nations and tortured, starved and killed their working class for far less than what’s at stake here in the USA.
And why on earth would any “investor” pay any attention to a single bit of Citigroup’s advice?
Perhaps we should have a calling plan for Debora Weinswig. It’s not just pols who should be responsible to “the people.”
AND THE KILLIN’ GOEZ ON AND ON AND…
Citizen Hamsher and the Firepup Freedom Fighters:
Between the “rule of law” fantasies and the process oriented wonkery that passes for progressive politics I am about ta pop my last brain cell…take every one of the bastards into receivership, take whatever assets remain or follow the blood trail of the derivatives to get to anythin’ left of the equity they stole and shut the bastards down.
I have been sayin for too long now that this slow 2-step that Gaithner and Summers are doin’ is simply a holdin action until all the losses are passed down to the taxpayer and none of the crooks who brought us this mess will feel even a pinch. Find the money that was stolen and tax it back into circulation and stop the subsidization of the losses so the rest of the rich bastards file bankruptcy. And send every CEO who sat thru this extortion scheme to Leavenworth…now THAT’s what I would call “the rule of law.”
KEEP THE FAITH AND PASS THE AMMUNITION, HAVE YA HAD ENOUGH YET??!!!
This Wal-Mart downgrade is completely political, and is about stopping EFCA.
The target is the two Democratic Senators from Arkansas, Pryor and Lincoln, who previously said they’d support EFCA but are now wavering.
as i noted earlier, this is starting to piss me off big-time. that was O/t but I can say it now. w e’re talking people who used to support EFCA wussing out. I expect to hear Blanche bring this up. Grrrrrrrr.
I really don’t know what to say about Blanche, except to say I doubt she will support EFCA, and what’s desperately needed is a primary challenge from the worst State D party (Arkansas) imaginable.
The only threat Blanche has at this point is from Karl Rove Republican,Tim Griffin. Yes, THAT Tim Griffin.
And I also expect Mark Pryor will not support EFCA… unless he can do a one hour Lieberazation on the meat of the bill.
Citizen JoelBuck:
The only way Lincoln and Presser get pressured is to have a couple a Senate heavywights have a sit down with ‘em and show ‘em jest how the game is played when yer in the majority…and One Hung Harry Reid isn’t a “heavyweight”.
Landrieu and Spector, too.
http://online.wsj.com/article/…..77531.html
Maybe more.
these INCESTUOUS companies are as fake as a wrestling tag team……seems they ALL sleep together however
It is puzzling why Reid remains Majority Leader.
the meme needs to be
WHY DO MILLIONAIRE Senators and Reps not support EMPLOYEES OF AMERICA????
Pryor just won reelection (unchallenged by anyone in primary and faced no republican in final) last November… Blanche is up next… a primary challenger needs to step up probably no later than early Summer ‘09, if they want to have a fighting chance.
How does Citi rate companies that have lost 95% of their stock value, have to take tens of billions in multiple bailouts from the government, and still remain essentially bankrupt? Inquiring minds would like to know.
why do WEALTHY POLITICIANS hate america and itS WORKING people
RICO!
Probably because everyone knows how easy it is to push him around. Better a total wuss than someone who has a pair.
Because they think they need the money of the other millionaires, who are their soul mates, to wage campaigns. Little do they know, and we’re not telling them heartily enough, that their campaigns and the money will mean little or nothing if the workers who are being betrayed decide to vote as a block. Been a long time since that’s happened and they thought that unions were dead, so they have no compunctions about driving nails in the union coffins.
who wants to hear a good doggy love story? my friends ma fell down in the yard,over a railroad ty and broke her hip,she was all alone,and they had just put in sound proof windows…husband about 80 in the home napping….little dog goes apeshit crazy…running from window to husband barking like mad….husband finally goes to window to see wife on ground…………..CRITTERS ARE THE GREATEST
BUBBLE LICIOUS LIVING
Love those kinds of stories! Thx.
I’m pretty pissed off myself. One of the key irritants for me is the !%$#@&**$!! MSM. Obviously, Faux is a total loss. However, if CNN & MSNBC would simply do a little no-brainer reporting on a regular basis, they could move the ball. Instead, we get horse-race bullshit. A case of duct tape would be good. For starters.
Grrrrrr……
ARGH$%^&*!!
im not crazy about daylight savings
Hurt it’s competitiveness? Not hardly, IMO Wal-Mart is the closest example of a monopoly we might have.
Feb. 17, 2009:
*Wal-Mart has been one of the few bright spots in retailing as financially squeezed shoppers look for cheaper options and cut back to necessities during the recession. Its renewed focus on low prices as well as its push for cleaner stores and more compelling merchandise have allowed it to pull ahead of rivals like Target Corp. and Costco Wholesale Corp.
*Wal-Mart appears to be benefiting from the slew of store liquidations from the likes of Circuit City Stores Inc. and Linen ‘N Things.
*”Our performance relative to competitors has been exceptionally strong in the fourth quarter and throughout the year,” said Mike Duke, Wal-Mart’s new chief executive, in a pre-recorded call to investors on Tuesday. “We finished January strong and February is off to a good start,” added Duke,… http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/29233784/
One of richest families in the world(Christy Walton & family 19.2B, Jim Walton 19.2B, S Robson Walton 19.2B, Alice Walton 19.0B
http://www.forbes.com/lists/20…..ank_2.html ) can, IMO, certainly expect that earnings will continue to rise in relationship to the rest of the economy as workers lose more and more of their spending power and shop at their stores. Agree with an earlier point that “Card Check” appears to be bad thing for the Wal-Marts (Target, etc) but really, if passed, is a good thing for the Walton’s.
Me too…
peeps that dont have at least 1 dog are missing out BIGTIME imo
You mean where we trick ourselves into thinking we’re getting up at the same time when (as a matter of FACT) we’re getting up an hour earlier? If people want to get up an hour earlier, they’re free to do that. Why do I have to get dragged into it? Grrrrr…….
please ,please DONT HOLD YOUR BREADTH….GeneralElectric war machine owns NBC,CNBC,AND MSNBC
I simply am running myself ragged trying to accomplish everything in LESS time
argh@#$#$#$
Sounds like you’ve read ‘Deep Capture’ . . . fascinating read, full of econ stuff I never knew, aside from the drama. For instance, Gradient . . . the research firm that’s part of Jim Cramer’s naked short sell empire. *G*
That Twitt woman jane was on MSNBC with has bothered me for a long time.
I have four shih tzus.
arf
Citizen Badwater:
It is NOT puzzling as to why Reid is still leader, it is REAVEALING. I know that LBJ is chillin out in the last circle of Dante’s hell along with a Pope or two but maybe we could call up his spirit and give it to One Hung Harry in an enema…then sit Ms. Lincoln and Mr. Presser down with ‘im fer 15 minutes. I think we’d have a couple a real firm EFCA supporters.
Neither am I. As I recall, moving it up this damn early was the signal achievement of the fully-DeLay’d 109th Congress.
The regression of the American “elite” Part CMXVI
This comes from a 5th grade U.S. history class of long ago, courtesy Wikipedia:
And mind you Ford, as many know, was hardly a liberal sort. Just able, occasionally, to see what was dead in front of him.
Who are the people talking about class warfare. Walmart, notorious for it’s employee abuse, could suffer a little loss in profit if they are forced to listen to employee concerns. Meanwhile, the vulture class from WS, are fearful that they may lose a little income stream. Screw em.
Also, United Technologies announced they were cutting 11K + jobs. Bet their stock has gone up. Wall Street is not for America all they are for is more money.
Can’t find out how citi rates other companies I think you have to have a stock buying account for that
http://www.google.com/finance?q=NYSE%3AC
Citi’s google finance page shows no P/E price per earnings ratio the car companies stopped showing that awhile ago. Also they are loosing money but they are claiming a certain amount of debt.
I think if we new the real numbers Citi’s debt would be bigger.
The unions have already spent about half a billion dollars lobbying for the new legislation, she said. Interesting way to end the article. How much money has the other side been spending against the new legislation?
ihad 2………..i love me some Shytzies
The reason that Citi has no P/E listed is because there is no E. AFAIK, that was part of one of the deals they made with the government: that there would be no dividends.
Yo Citizen Norske:
I like the way you think.
Pass the 50cal…
Let me get this straight… Citicorp’s so reckless they’ve flushed their shareholders into penny stock holders. They’re so broke they can’t even borrow credibility…and some gits in the bankster/stockster rackets are still gonna listen to them? With a ship full o’ fools like these, no wonder capitalism’s sinking.
WRT Burger King – they were caught last year doing black ops (threats, spying, and villification) against organizers and students supporting the Coalition of Immokalee Workers. Burger King was too damn cheap to pay a whole extra penny per pound of tomatoes, and too damn weak to stand the pressure. With a record like that, who’d listen to these con artists this year?
Oh – of course – the con artists who pretend to value companies – and just happened to give blue ribbon ratings to the biggest frauds on Wall Street.
Uh – these sociopaths really expect that anyone else still believes their con games?
CitiBank’s conclusion is right on the mark, though the analysis is for shit. It’s on the mark because higher wages do mean lower profits. It’s as simple as that, though often forgotten. It’s full of shit in that the wages have virtually no impact on Walmart’s ‘competitiveness.’ The competitiveness thing is usually a crock. It’s not that some other firm is going to outcompete Walmart in the mall wars; it’s that Walmart owners are going to have to live with smaller profits, which in principle, though at present surely not in practice, means that some other firm with ‘competitive’ profit rates will get the capital and the capital gains.
Once you see this shell game for what it is, you can never go back.
Bingo. The only question is whether you want to live with a kept woman (or man, as the case may be), or go into the spot market for the service of prostitutes.
52 was to you
Tell the Insurance Companies Tuesday – It’s Time to Go
March 9, 2009, 8:34PM
Why in the world are we allowing the perpetrators of the health care crisis to set the terms of the debate on how to clean up their mess?
Join nurses, doctors, and health care activists Tuesday for a day of calls in Congress and a protest against the insurers as we convey a different message.
1- A national call-in day to Congress. Remind the legislators that we need more care, not more private insurance. Urge them to make sure single payer/Medicare for all is a central part of the health care debate. Ask them to support HR 676, the bill to expand and upgrade Medicare to cover everyone. Find information for your US Representative and Senators at http://www.votesmart.org.
You can also send them your insurance bill or your insurers’ letter of denial for needed care to help them recall why we need to get the insurance companies out of the way. For information on how to fax your insurance bills, sample fax cover sheets, and sample telephone scripts, please visit http://www.healthcare-now.org/campaigns/call/
2- If you’re anywhere near Washington Tuesday come join us for a protest outside a national conference of AHIP, America’s Health Insurance Plans, the industry’s lobbying arm and chief voice in the media. 11:00 a.m., Ritz-Carlton, Washington D.C., 1150 22nd Street, N.W.
3- You can also contact the new HHS Secretary-designate, Gov. Kathleen Sebelius. In addition to congratulating her on her nomination, let her know you support for HR 676 and single-payer national health care. The office of HHS can be reached toll free at 1-877-696-6775.
Anyone who follows the national healthcare discourse might well conclude that the foremost task is to draft a plan that appeals to the insurance industry, along with the drug companies, and the other corporate lobbyists.
You might almost conclude that they own the building. Or maybe they’re just paying the rent.
As the Washington Post reported Sunday, in data compiled by the consumer advocacy group Consumer Watchdog:
Health insurers and drug makers have showered members of the 111th Congress with millions in campaign contributions over the last four years, with a special focus on leaders who will play major roles in shaping health-care legislation….
The health-care sector has long ranked with financial services and energy interests as one of the most powerful political forces in Washington, and it spent nearly $1 billion on lobbying in the past two years alone.
The third highest beneficiary in the Senate is Sen. Max Baucus, who as head of the Finance Committee has made himself a kingmaker in the healthcare discussions.
The same Max Baucus who tells every audience that will listen that single payer is off the table and we need a “uniquely American solution.”
CitiGroup. Who listens to anything those idiots have to say. With their history of business decisions anything they are for a smart person would be against.
In Florida, groups organizing for tomato pickers’ rights say they might have been spied on and vilified online by the fast-food conglomerate Burger King. The Fort Myers News-Press traced threatening emails directed at the Coalition of Immokalee Workers and the Student/Farmworker Alliance to Burger King’s corporate headquarters in Miami, Florida. We speak with the reporter who broke the story and with the coordinator of the Student/Farmworker Alliance who says he received a call from the owner of a private security company posing as a student.
—————–
Keeeeeeeeeeeeeeeerist on a cracker,that is one of the poorest sections of Fla,did some clinic work there
No profits explains that also:)
Ithink Burger king deserves a new nickname or jingle to commemorate the tomatoe picker baiting in perpetuity.
sadlyyes, thanks for that promo. I am sending my letter of denial to Congress. Can you believe I am denied for seasonal allergies and borderline osteopenia? Incredible.
“There is another war being fought in America today, a secret war that has devastated the economic world and wrought even more destruction to the American social world. This is the undeclared but ongoing war between American business entities and any kind of organized labor (Unions). It is a war in which business has taken defacto control of the White House, by successfully plotting the rigged presidential elections in 2000.
The roots of this war can be found in the militancy of the American labor movement back in the late 1960s and early 1970s when a series of wildcat strikes did great damage to the corporate system and threatened to unleash more strikes from far stronger unions in the future. Business regrouped and managed to elect presidents, like Ronald Reagan, a former labor leader himself who, for money, influence and perks formed a strong anti-union movement in the higher reaches of the American government.
Aside from a flood of governmental orders and court assisted anti labor rulings, the most potent weapon in the business arsenal was the concept of out-sourcing American jobs to much safer foreign countries, countries that did not have labor unions in any form. Factories were emptied of American workers and the work was parceled out to foreign countries like China, India and Indonesia. But by shipping an enormous number of jobs to safer, and cheaper, foreign labor markets, business created an enormous vacuum in American society. Youths, straight from high school no longer could get well-paying jobs in American industry because most of these jobs, with attendant union membership, were now outside the United States. None of this outsourcing was an accident and although the Republicans occasionally were here to bemoan the loss of jobs, they never made any effort to prevent the flow of jobs away from this country. Bush and his people were squarely in the pockets of both militant Israeli and wealthy American business power groups and one of them shouted “squat”, George Bush ran into the corner of the Oval Office and squatted like a toad. Another part of this warfare was to tacitly allow an enormous number of Mexicans to pour, unhindered, into this country where they could be used as cheap, unreported and untaxed labor. Occasional raids were permitted but the millions of cheap and, most important, non-union, workers ensured that the day of the American labor union as an economic and political force was over, at least during the terms of Republican presidents.
Bush and his far-right thugs may be gone but the anti-labor policies and practices remain. Unless and until they are stopped and, more important, reversed, the economic picture in America will be bleak and wintry indeed. Businesses who have emptied their workplaces and stuffed their pockets should be heavily taxed along with all of those American businesses who have moved to foreign countries to reduce their taxes. They seem interested only in enriching themselves at the expense of the American people and if this policy of greed and secret control is not stopped abruptly, there can only be more economic and social destruction!”
Source: Bradley Moscrip
http://www.b.moscrip@yahoo.com