When we have the USDA and FDA, why are we still dying from salmonella and risking brain damage from the mercury in foods known to be contaminated before they ever left the factory? How were industrial food megacorps and the Peanut Corporation of America able to get foodstuffs they knew were tainted past Federal food safety agencies?
The dirty little secret about America’s food safety agencies is that for decades leaders in both corporatist parties have been sacrificing our health and safety to the deregulation cult…and the banquet of campaign contributions the food megacorps serve up for complicit pols. The USDA (broadly responsible for meat and poultry) has authority over 20 percent of our food supply; the FDA is responsible for maintaining the safety of the remaining 80 percent of our food supply. And the Congresscritters and Presidents with the power to fund FDA repeatedly chose to starve the FDA of the resources required to protect us.
USDA has the resources to inspect meat and poultry plants daily, as required by law. In contrast, FDA, which regulates 80 percent of the food supply, inspects food facilities it oversees on average just once every 10 years. USDA employs more than 7,600 inspectors who are stationed in 6,282 establishments to carry out its inspection mandate. FDA, meanwhile, has fewer than 2,000 inspectors who are spread over 136,000 domestic food processors and warehouses.
Since 2003, the number of FDA field staff dropped by 12 percent, and between 2003 and 2006 federal inspections dropped by 47 percent. These declines in inspectors and inspections can be traced to an ongoing funding shortfall in the food safety program estimated in the hundreds of millions of dollars.
As CSPI testified to before the FDA Commissioner’s Consumer Roundtable in December 2000, FDA inspections had already withered on (what passed for) Clinton’s watch.
[T]he FDA analyzed one-fourth fewer domestic food samples in FY 1999 (9,000) than it did in FY 1996 (12,000). When the President’s Food Safety Initiative was first developed, FDA inspectors visited food plants on average once every 10 years. Unfortunately, following nearly four years of funding increases under the Food Safety Initiative, things don’t appear to be much better today.
FDA’s shrinking food inspection capacity under the free-trade Clintonistas extended the longer pattern of malign neglect for our primary Federal food safety agency. In the 25 years after 1972, inspections conducted by the FDA declined by 81 percent. Who cares? Well, only people who eat.
Foods regulated by FDA, such as fresh fruits and vegetables, seafood, milk, and eggs, cause the vast majority of food-poisoning outbreaks. Even though many people think that meat and poultry cause most foodborne illnesses, in fact over two-thirds of all documented outbreaks are linked to foods regulated by FDA.
In 2000 – before the Bushies began to sack the FDA – the CDC estimated food posioning from microbes alone sickened 76 million Americans every year: 300,000 were hospitalized, and 5,000 died.
The next year, when an insane ideology killed 3,000 Americans we declared war on the world. Yet when the insane “deregulation” ideology of the free market cult killed over half again as many Americans, it was just business as usual. What poisoned our body politic?
Paul Krugman looked at the whole rancid mess last year:
How did America find itself back in The Jungle?
It started with ideology. Hard-core American conservatives have long idealized the Gilded Age, regarding everything that followed – not just the New Deal, but even the Progressive Era – as a great diversion from the true path of capitalism.
Thus, when Grover Norquist, the anti-tax advocate, was asked about his ultimate goal, he replied that he wanted a restoration of the way America was “up until Teddy Roosevelt, when the socialists took over. The income tax, the death tax, regulation, all that.”
The late Milton Friedman agreed, calling for the abolition of the Food and Drug Administration.
Even deadly bacteria have to eat something. So too do useful idiots like Norquist and Friedman. Salmonella grows on peanut butter. The corporatists’ deadly war on goverment and public safety grew and thrived in the propaganda shops think tanks and astroturf “free-market” front groups filled with inquiring minds who just happen to reach conclusions that bring the greatest possible profits for the most reactionary forces in America. And the corporatist funding for the savants who’ve trashed our regulatory system (for food, finance, the environment, medical care…) is tax deductible. Such a deal!
The deal works so well that even though an FDA employee detected wide-spread mercury contamination in our food supply five years ago, she had to wait to break the news until she left the FDA. So for five years, the fact mercury contaminates nearly one-third of the supermarket foods containing corn syrup was a secret to us…but not to the high fructose corn syrup manufacturers or the FDA.
Not to worry. The helpful corporate servants at the Bushie FDA recently ruled that foods containing high fructose corn syrup can be labelled “natural”.
Bon appetit.
[photo credit: blue_j]




56 Comments





Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Digg the doc!
Grover likes food that is still ALIVE!!
You don’t say!
Hey Doctor.
Dugg. Thanks, Teddy.
I was also disturbed to read that the FDA’s inspections in Georgia, and about 49 other states, are contracted to the states. This puts the inspections that much closer to influence peddling and corruption than they should be; food companies’ managers and owners are just as likely to be big political contributors on the local level, and much better known for that as well.
It all stinks.
Obama needs to fix it.
Thanks, Teddy!
AZ Matt, I just hope people hide their kittens when Grover’s hungry.
I guess I should go wash the dishes in the sink.
Maggots are more his style.
dugg! i did NOT know that products with corn syrup can have mercury contamination. off to follow the link.
We don’t seem to have the hang of preventative anything.
Yet another reason why I am finding it better and better lately to eat lower and lower on the food chain. Raw, unprocessed, organic, nothing whose container lists polysyllabic and unpronounceable words. Cheaper in the long run, too.
We do good in preventing health and safety. Grover is filling up his bathtub!
Dugg. It’s hard to try to get in the mind of someone who doesn’t care about other human beings, isn’t it?
Bushie loves his peanut butter and jelly sammiches. Mail him peanut butter. Better’n shoes….
Mega corporations can’t be trusted to monitor their own compliance with safety regulations? Who knew?
Now, now Prairie Sunshine – we must be of good wishes and great cheer.
Put the peanut butter IN the shoes.
There ya go…
Hey, Frank’s got Rich-y goodness up now at the NYT. It’s a beaut.
So sorry to go OT, kirk, but lookie:
Who says Obama’s not speeding? At least on this.
Such a departure from the norm, too. Self-reporting has worked so well for
minerals royalties…uh…fisheries….er…oil and gas royalties…uh….endangered species protection….uh…..er…finance, by golly!
Oh, wait.
The mercury in food products (high frucotse corn syrup shows up in all sorts of processed foods) is bad enough.
The FDA’s sitting on the news for five years is a whole ‘nother level of bad.
I’ll fill up his bathtub….
On a totally unrelated topic, did you know botulism is caused by a totally natural biological toxin? /s
Have you any stats for the years 2000 and on that would shed light on the overall effect of reducing inspections?
What makes it worse it that, like shipping inspection, the Bushies have allowed food safety inspection to be contracted to private firms hired by the manufacturers. Private firms have precisely no incentive to find anything which would cause manufacturers to see them as troublemakers and not hire them.
Nothing like 100% Natural!
Did you know that the Texas peanut plant was certified organic by the State of Texas?
Thanks for this, Dr. Kirk…I think.
The whole mercury in HFCS thing is stunning. Now all those industry-sponsored commercials saying how “oh, no, it’s natural just like sugar” are making more sense. I had some idea of the issues around metabolism/obesity, but up to .5 ug of Hg per GRAM of corn syrup? Are you fu**ing kidding me? I hope all those anti-vaccination parents who are so worried about autism from thimerosal have been just as careful about their food and beverage choices!
What a forking nightmare.
FunnyDiva
Coal slurry waste!War profiteering!Yep.
My local co-op has bulk organic peanut butter (smooth and of course crunchy) for $5.29 per pound. Documenting the ingredients at every step from field to processor in this short food chain seems to do a lot to help maintain product safety.
Some folks I know with a big demand for “nut butters” buy bulk nuts and make their own. Just from watching, it seemed like one heck of a lot of mess and trouble, but it was also kinda cool to know it was possible. (and to be fair my friends were not operating kitchen equipment in the strictest sobriety. yes, i was shocked, shocked…)
“the FDA’s sitting on the news for 5 years is a whole ‘nother level of bad”
You aren’t kidding.
Peanut Corp’s CEO deserves to be in front of Congress on his way to jail, but so do the FDA Mucky-mucks who actively suppressed these findings.
But, oh well…it’s only food, right? I mean, it’s not like it’s a diet drug or other pharmaceutical or anything, right?
FunnyDiva
Bird shit is natural. It’s organic. Ick…
When the foxes are guarding the hen house…..
I used to make peanut butter, cashew butter, almond butter. Just put it in the food processor…but how do we know the nuts are safe at this point?
I just ordered a bunch of seeds to plant a garden for the first time in 20 years. Looking forward to the food.
If the thimerosol in vaccinations is not a problem, then why did the illustrius Judd Gregg sneak a protection into a law that had nothing to do with vaccines that basically makes it impossible for anyone to sue Eli Lilly & Co for thimerosol damage?
And by sneak – I really mean that. It did not appear until after the conference committee report – which means that neither house voted on it – in fact it had been voted OFF that bill twice, and off at least three others. Gregg has not copped to the thing – but he was working on it and the trail leads to him.
Oh, and if it really is harmless – why did they remove it anyway?
Thimerisol IS mercury – and at the standard vaccination rate – tiny children were receiving ten times the FDA’s ’safe’ dose for a 150-lb adult – in every single shot.
Hmmmph.
Oh, and by the way – thimerisol is STILL in flu shots.
And now they are recommending flu shots for tiny babies every year as well.
Insobriety is often cited as a contributing factor to the indiscriminate dispensing of nut butter(s).
Here’s food net (CDC): they collect some stats. As GI (gastrointestinal) infections are so common and have such common symptoms (diarrhea, vomiting, nausea) that many (most?) mild cases are unreported, iirc finding good overall data on all food poisoning (not just reportable bugs)
kirk, the last two links in your article aren’t working for me. the last one takes me to page not found. the next to last one takes me to an oxdown diary on the stimulus package.
Yay, it is a nightmare. More on this soon…
The fact MSM have sat around with impacted microphones on this amazes me even more. For local news, this is “scare the crap out of the moms and keep them tuning in for days” ratings candy. High fructose corn syrups in ketchup and almost any processed food with sweet flavors. Like, say ketchup.
There are ratings to be had here.
ruh ro. be right back.
Call the linky doctor!
The Lurking Mod is responsible for this terrible oversight and begs forgiveness.
Will repair if possible.
Here’s the final linky [h/t grist]
Here’s the next to last linky. That’s an abstract: here’s the article (PDF).
Thanks, greenwarrior. SOrry for the glitch.
Hey, it was a good glitch (is it named Glenda?) [btw, it was prolly my doing..or not doing].
Anyway, it goves me an exuse to burden the servers’ hamsters with a morsel from the PDF.
Remember, the FDA sat on essentially identical tests for five years (the FDA reearcher who’d been squelched repeated her work after rettirrement).
…and rat poop is o.k. for kids to eat.
Anything for a filthy dollar.
The glories of capitalism.
*g*
Betcha then that’s where Laura’s peanut butter and jelly sammiches for Bushie began.
Oh, the irony.
Yep.
Shock capitalism at the table.
New post up by Jane–>>
Jumping in without reading thread first so apologies if already covered —
The FDA has an *interesting* publication titled
The Food Defect Action Levels – Unavoidable defects in food that present no health hazards for humans
One example (and sorry that the format doesn’t translate well):
If you’re interested in starting a diet, reading this little jewel should throw ya off yer appetite for a goodly long time.
oops.
I don’t doubt you, but if you see this and could share a link that would be great… the news that the plant was certified organic deserves more attention.
Thanks for edumacating me.
How nice to know insect filth and rdent hairs are merely aesthetic concerns.
I’d love to see the Federal authors try that framing from behind a truck stop lunch counter.
A thing of beauty is a joy forever…….one of his very, very best.
Epidemiology is the study of diseases in populations of humans or other animals, specifically how, when and where they occur. It is humongously more effective to limit the causes of diseases with testing than to trace the origins backward as the diseases are unreported or the causes are not identifiable. Criminal behavior awarded by profits.
I am happy to live in Canada. But we have our own problems. The government is trying everything they can to stop small food suppliers such as independent butchers and bakers. These are the people I want to do business with.
Norquist is public enemy No. 1. He’s the father of “Death to America by 1000 tax cuts.”
I cringe every time I see the commercial stating fructose is the same as real sugar and is fine. Brainwashing the masses was what the neocons under George Bush did so well!
Raw organic vegetables, if anything, has a greater likelihood of being contaminated with pathogens than nonorganic food because manure is used more by organic growers than by conventional growers. Organic food is lower in pesticides of various kinds, but not in pathogens. And washing in disinfectant doesn’t do a whole lot of good because it turns out that the bacteria are also inside the fruits and leaves where the disinfectant doesn’t reach. If you are paranoid about Salmonella, then cooking or irradiation are your only options.
(: As for those of you who don’t understand the free market, we don’t need inspections because the free market is self-regulating. Didn’t you know that? Haven’t you been listening? In this case the consumers that patronize producers of contaminated food die which means that the producers have fewer customers. It’s simple if you know how to look at it from a Republican viewpoint.:)
Just like financial firms and their auditors.