Nearly four years to the day after the passage of the controversial economic stimulus bill that defined President Obama’s first months in office, few economic experts or policy makers deny that the bill has been vastly successful.
Currently, the unemployment rate hovers at 2 percent or lower, a far cry from the 7.6% of four years ago. Household income has risen approximately 450%. Consumer confidence is at an all-time high, and Wall Street continues to break records and defy the gloomy expectations of the recent past. The buoyant public mood has extended even to far more personal areas. According to a recent Washington Post/ABC poll, 78% of Americans report that the burgeoning economy has resulted in their enjoyment of "frequent and spectacular oral sex."
But what was it, specifically, about the 2009 "stimulus package" that has led, inevitably, to such triumphant results?
According to a consensus of top economists, the reason the bill was so effective can be traced to a single source: the decision to strip the bill of $98 million in funding for ensuring that school children receive adequate nutrition.
"Boy, is my face red on that one," concedes rueful Nobel Prize winning economist Paul Krugman. "At the time, I admit, I thought that this sort of aid to schools, and to states, needed to be in the bill because it would be quickly spent and thus provide actual stimulus. In my defense, in those days the now-obvious relationship between young children eating garbage, and recovery from an international economic catastrophe, was not properly understood."
Krugman says he is "grateful" that the decision was made to kill the wasteful spending on the frivolous issue of child nutrition, as opposed to more immediately stimulative measures as making sure the so-called "Alternative Minimum Tax loophole" did not close its powerful jaws on earners in the top American income percentiles, a group for whom the AMT had never been intended to apply.
"Look, I was wrong," says Krugman. "I guess I was just in a hurry or something. Fifty lashes with a wet noodle."
On the other hand, those responsible for killing the child-nutrition spending are basking in well-deserved kudos. Among these are former Maine GOP Senator Susan Collins, who now hosts the popular NBC game show "So You Think You’re Bipartisan."
Interviewed in her gold-plated trailer on a Hollywood lot, Collins snorts as she recalls the smears directed at her during the ferocious partisan debate of the period. "You would have thought that just because the math didn’t add up, that was the be-all and end-all. What these people, these sarcastic bloggers, failed to appreciate was the awesome, restorative, mystical power that is unleashed when American Senators come together in a spirit of comity, a shared willingness to fuck over poor people’s youngsters. But it is that spirit that saved us, in the end."
Nebraska’s Ben Nelson agrees. A fellow member of the bipartisan "Gang of Four," a group of moderate Senators who were key to eliminating the provisions of the stimulus bill that would go directly to states and working Americans, in 2010 hit the bestseller lists with his memoir, Thank God Your Kid Died of Scurvy. "We trimmed the fat, fried the bacon and milked the sacred cows," said Nelson, "and we ate that delicious bacon and washed it down with the nice, fresh milk. We make no apologies for the ‘No Child Left Behind without Ingesting Asbestos’ program we implemented instead. That ended up feeding children and saving on wasteful abatement contracts in one fell swoop."
"My only regret," mused Connecticut Senator Joe Lieberman, "is that we couldn’t get rid of that $500,000 cap on executive reimbursement for firms accepting federal funds. If we could have killed that, why, nowadays, I bet the rate of Americans receiving fantastic oral sex would be in the high 80s."
"Of course," Lieberman went on, sensuously caressing the dangling flesh of his neck, "on that note, those of us in government who have long championed bipartisanship have always appreciated the efforts of the press in this particular regard, and are glad to note that interviews like this typically have a happy ending."



117 Comments












Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
I can’t think about Joe Lieberman and oral sex on the same day. My poor mind is broken.
i wanna picture of collins snorting thers – maybe that will get her in line
Digg it.
dugg and thanks for opening it ratfood
Where do I get the Waders to keep the shit from between my toes and up my ass??
/s
Send this to Krugman. Right now. I am certain he could use the laughs as he cries.
Freaking thersday. Epic post.
Evening…
I feel really really tired. I have never digested so much bullshit in so short a period of time.
Damn 2-Year-Old has lost his bottle, refuses to be consoled without it. Hold on.
What the centrists have wrought
Thers good evening i hope you don’t mind if I link Krugman’s comment today. Haven’t heard a peep out of the big economic guns of the Whitehouse…what’s up with that shoudn’t Treasury and the Fed have some sage advise or is it just to hot in the kitchen?
hey thers – mighty fine post dood
i figure they are abstaining like that senator who wants to go to commerce
dood is turning out to be real supportive of pbo (/s)
Try Doan’s pills…we gaurantee results or your money back. Warning keep an extra roll around cause you never know when the stimulus will hit.
pbo?
president barack obama
my comment for Mr Krugman’s post: If you want to get a slightly different slant on this Wonderful comprise check out this Post http://firedoglake.com/2009/02…..le-senate-
moderates-illiterate-malnourished-children-are-keys-to-americas-future/
Besides a good laugh you will read some good snark!
not voting is the same as voting no when every vote matters
Gracias.
The absence of this “baba” is producing major ructions. Still, the kid is even now more mature than Lieberman…
Nah! I linked that post, after all…
hon, i hate to break it to ya, but that baba is more mature than leiberman
Hey, wait a minute! In 2013, do those greedy little bastard poor children get to eat ALL the garbage? WTF? Are their parents paying taxes at all, or are the rest of us gonna have to subsidize this entitlement?
Make #13 Carter’s little pills (laxative).
gonna have to make them work to pay it off – aren’t child labor laws all about making the little crybabies labor
I’d swear earlier in the week Judd indicated he would vote against it, in light of that maybe an abstention is the best we can hope for.
Maybe the goal is to remove one Republican from the Senate, then after the bill passes put the kibosh on his nomination… Just wishful thinking, unfortunately.
So what’s her name gets a shiny gold trailer, Joe Lieberman gets a Happy Ending, economy is going to be great not to mention our sex lives…
You know, the only way it could be better is to have a volcano toss. Or maybe institute a new kind of Lottery.
Oh good, Mom found it.
The kid leaves the damn things all over the house in the damndest places — under beds, and so forth. Then he demands they be found before he can be consoled. Very Senator-like behavior.
abstaining from voting is the same as voting no when every yes vote matters
When you can’t find the bottle just stick the nearest nipple in their mouth. It chafes a little but you’ll get used to it.
I understand the rich will be in dire straits once the liberals institute their garbage-redistribution programs. Damn liberals, STILL stealing from the (deserving) rich to give to the (parasitic) poor…
Krugman is getting an extra or third post in the NYT this week…They are fuming at the Times with this right of center move by the new administration. All the big city and state budgets are illegal. Krugman is really stepping out on this as is Rosen, Greenwald and others. It really is pathetic what they have “crafted”. Coal and Nuke funding what McInsane ran on. No foods atamps or atate relief wow. Where are the conference of governors on this…planned for the weekend? Wow.
Spares? G)
Thank goodness I have several superfluous ones, including on my ankle.
Just think: that $98 million stripped from ensuring adequate nutrition for schoolchildren was effectively used to pay the bonuses to just two or three of the Wall Street CEO idiots who got us into this economic mess. Multiply that by 200 and you get the amount of taxpayer money used to pay bonuses to all of these Wall Street idiots.
So we’ve paid bonuses way beyond a living wage to Wall Street to reward them for screwing up the country. But the “centrists” draw the line when it comes to spending 1/200 of that to starving kids.
“Centrists” my ugly pimpled ass.
This might be a good time to get a cat.
Obama and his “plans” taken to the cleaners by McConnell & McCain & Joe Lieberman, with a gigantic assist/wet kiss from actual Democrats™.
Who could have predicted…
Did Collins take his bottle?
Better look closely, one of those might be a pepperoni.
Come to think of it, 2 year olds have a wide stance…
Brilliant post, Thers.
It does cramp one up doesn’t it?
she only wants it if it has something to snort
You’d think so but Family Services frowns on people who make their pets nurse the children.
Transit trashed, children trashed, schools trashed, getting a start on energy chopped, aid to states, not much. What is it about this bill that is better than doing nothing? Why run up an even bigger national debt to shovel yet more money into the pockets of people who do not need it and will not spend it? I want to see a few progressive Democrats in the Senate with the courage to vote against it.
Umm – I’mm sorry, but I gotta ask.
Are you related to the Octuplet family?
Thanks Kirk
i’m sure family services will be eliminated – who needs those commie liberals whining about the needs of whiny kids
About time, they’ve been overstaffed and over funded for so long now…
So that’s why my parents chased out the goat whenever the doorbell rang!
that’s not shit, that’s your share of the stimulus package. enjoy.
Well, we have a lot of roadkill around here – dogs, jackrabbits, cottontails, prairedogs, snakes in the summer, so that should help out with the free school meal programs. Of course it is better to get them as fresh as you can.
that wasn’t just a goat – she was your naaaaanny
That’s right. Investing in shovel futures as we speak.
No, just bog-Irish. “Here comes another one, Deirdre!”
Lucky you, at least you had an animal with (only) four legs.
the rethugs are just finally coming cleana about the type of country they want to live in: one where crumbling and privatized schools are just places for religious indoctrination, where millions are homeless, scrounging for food in dumps, where the sky is hidden in coal dust, and where children starve quietly in the shadows. They have now finally made their vision for America clear, and we thank them for their honesty. This is the real face of compassionate conservatism.
Very well said, thank you.
I think transit was left intact. The hungry children will get to watch the fancy maglev train go speeding by.
I used to think they saw 1984 and had found their template. But I was wrong – they saw Brazil.
The Beatles – Help!
Help I need somebody…help me if you can I’m feelin down.
OOH Suz cracked a very funny.
help schmelp – pull yourself up by your bootstraps
we cut off your bootstraps? well, hell, son, grow another pair.
compasionate conservative
There is no-one to blame for this mess other than the president.
Has a candidate in history EVER won the presidency and then handed over his power to the party he defeated?
This is utterly insane. Democrats have the Executive and Legislative branches, and the losers are setting the agenda. Now we know who really lost the election, don’t we, … yet again. (By the way, did you know the Republicans have some good ideas?)
Play hard to get with Obama, and he will give you the shirt off his back to get your approval.
Let the word go forth from this time and place, to friend an foe alike …
Kumbaya, Kumabya, Kumbaya.
I’m into war surplus hip waders
The point is, will the stim, as constituted now, work?
If it doesn’t, who is most responsible – the Dems, who never gave the country the 96% tax cut stim the Gopers wanted and are insisting the country needs, or the Dems who didn’t have enough steel to let the real experts guide them?
That is the narrative the Goopers have setup, and the Democrats have played right into it. Beautifully played.
yep brazil comes to mind. Complete with feral and hungry children, dying infrastructure, environmental despoilation, bloated corporate welfare infrastructure, militaristic civil service, state-subsidized idle rich, imaginary teruhrist bogeymen and state sanctioned torture. Rethug paradise.
Help Me Help me I’m down please help me get my feet back on the ground… Apple 1965…44 years later…
Help Me Help me I’m down please help me get my feet back on the ground…
for clarity, we’re referring to the terry gilliam dystopia film, not the country
All right, I’m fighting a cold, & it’s winning. Night mes amis.
take your cooties to bed – g’nite thers
Yes, and I’m waiting for a bill to arrive, the cost of my surveillance to whatever agency feels due.
Help me get my feet back on the ground…and I do appreciate you being round…
Can someone have the Beatles call Obama and sing this song to him and the first family?
Call Inspector Clueso I am sure he can get to the bottom of this. The Pink Panther inspector. maybe this is just a comedy of errors. Or a nightmare that will go away when we awake?
Too painful – hitting the sack.
Keep well pups.
If Krugman is correct, the stim should be 2 tril. Triming it, and making it less stim bang for the buck will make it work less, perhaps far less than it should have.
Obama’s first decision, to bring the Republicans into the process may have already steered on the track of a feckless presidency.
Power only respects power. Obama never learned that, somehow. The War Criminal Bush knew it instinctively.
Now Obama has to put on his hair-shirt. Indeed, a sad beginning, but Obama has certainly brought change to Washington – namely that the winners are the losers.
The Dems should make their best pass at a good stim bill, anf let the Repugs do a filabuster, and tape every second, and denounce them as traitors.
That’s what Bush would do.
g’nite sunny
Confederates, not Republicans. Copperheads, not Blue Dogs.
Let’s get this straight.
That’s what Bush
woulddid do.There.
eated
In the early 1930’s we had Hoovervilles. Now we can have Collinsvilles, places where people go hoping for some scraps for their kids. In empty lots and dusty fields, our foreclosed and unemployed neighbors will set up the blue plastics tarps that have come to represent people with little or nothing. Parents will lay awake at night from the cramps of hunger, having given what crumbs they had to their malnourished children. Every morning they will stand by the gates and doorways of foreign owned companies hoping for a days works, for a few euros to be able to buy one more day of food for the family.
Soup kitchens helped in the 1930’s but in Collinsvilles there is no relief because the spare foodstuffs have gone to make bio-fuels, ensuring that the energy companies control life within the country. The Army is hiring but only the young, moldable minds from the Christian charter schools that know what best for Christain America.
The Joe Arpaio’s now sweep through the Collinvilles on round-ups of whoever they want to round-up. No reason need be given. Control of the population has meant that ideas aren’t tolerated, only the ruling class doctrine.
Who knew what the results would be of the compromise.
Congress feared Bush. Obama is already being treated like a petty annoyance with his Kumbaya strategy.
I sent hundreds of dollars to Obama, worked for 8 weekends before the election for THIS ?? The Republicans have some good ideas???
WTF? Is this guy so naive to think he can get his political enemies to help Obama have a SUCCESSFUL PRESIDENCY? HE’S NUTS, if he thinks so.
why are they called collinvilles – in so cal, they are called bushville
Motor heads…Eat the rich? Too toxic…Tax the rich the son of a bitch OOps forgot the bleep. Some times metal is so appropriate.
Eat the rich. No barbeque sauce would cover that taste.
Great post indeed.
Obama knows the deal – if he didn’t on the 20th, he surely does now.
It’s what will he can summon, and at what cost, that will determine what happens. He has a lot of folks around him who know the same, and he must now delegate the task to them. And, he must get out on the road, and hit it hard. Right now.
We are waiting to be turned loose, and the only shame in that is that we are waiting, I suppose.
Oh, I just wanted to acknowledge Sen. Collins since she crafted this piece of crap. I know others helped but… .
That was to Suzanne @ 80
thanks…. makes total sense (duh!)
Have to admit I thought BO was a LOT better at playing the game, and his ‘advisors’ – what’s up with that? They are gonna give IL a worse name then Blogdovichy did. Even as a whack job, he’s got the nads. Maybe a new ‘advisor’ for BO?
With all due respect, NO WAY.
I have done all that I am going to do for Obama. I have removed myself from ALL Obama and Dems mailing lists. No more phone calls on cue, etc.
If he wants any now support from me, he can kiss my tush, like he does TO Republicans.
Then I’ll see what he is offering me. Right now, all he has done for me is take from me, and give it to Republicans.
wow. that spells out the conservative agenda pretty succinctly.
17 days in. That’s pretty quick.
This is from the US Conference of Mayors, you can see what projects your city or town might have ready for us of Stimulus money: MainStreet Economic Recovery
50% of enrollment in our grade and middle schools are qualified for the school lunch program.
Maybe we should do what the Panthers did feed them ourselves and kick the repules back to the place they came from. These kids come to school hungry…Obama and Emanuel…wow just wow..they were working in Chicago Obama for a non profit. But hey the Charter school funding stayed in the fucking bill. Food for the Neocons kids…let the rest starve. OMG this is so over the top. In the inner cities the alternate source is dumpsters as the groceries quit leraving imperfect produce out. Gaza?
Link of the Day. Thanks.
Hey, Obama won’t defend the Constitution, he’s naming government haters like gregg to his cabinet, and he’s giving away half the stim bill to Repugs, all for his KUMBAYA ego?
I’ve suffered through 8 years of hell, and this guy wants to forgive and forget.
F**K him !!!
I know. I can’t believe it either.
This was posted over at Kos by Meteor Blades It comes out of Pat Leahy’s office.
He hasn’t matched-up politically. Yet.
And seeing as that we’re ’stuck’ with him for the next 4 years, and knowing that we’d have to push him (he never claimed to be Liberal or Progressive), we have our work cut out for us. But does know he didn’t match-up.
Habst du Hunger? Eat dirt.
I left out he wants to send my tax money to phonies like “Rev” Jakes, who has multiple Bentley class “wheels’?
And religious outfits can discriminate against non-believers or guys in hiring.
Yeah, that’s some change I can believe in.
newt,
come sit by me, please.
I don’t know what you mean about match-up?
Hi Chris!
No one said it would be easy.
Indeed, they did not.
Stop paying taxes. A Tax strike will drive a stake through this foolsihness.
How to do this? Fill in a W4, write “exempt” on line 7, sign and hand to your payroll dept.
You can put the taxes you should pay into a savings account.
This has consequences.
obama is not a progressive
i keep telling myself this
I think he imagined his stim would get an easier time of it. Sure, they would chip away at it, but it’s nearly half what it needs to be, Democratic messaging handed the political initiative over to guess who – effing Joe Lieberman (and for anyone who thinks Susan Collins is any kind of force behind this, remember who her friends are).
Obama’s political dogs couldn’t hold a candle to a well-oiled, well-schooled, well-practiced Gooper force. He simply didn’t have the right pols in the right place at the right time.
Amen. And I wish Lieberman every failure possible.
we all knew what obama was about. Post-partisan, radically centrist. This was never a secret. The only ”betrayal” is in our minds. For exactly these reasons I didn’t support his primary candidacy at all and for that endured much ridicule and avuse in progressive fora, including this one. but I also recognize now that he is he best president we could’ve gotten, and he’s a heckuva lot better than the alternative. So sorry, I can’t agree with you. We have to fight for what we think is right and speak up for the agenda we want him to embrace, but like it or not, the country’s future lies with him and with the party.
a cartoon to cheer us up is upstairs
Yep. But it really, really sucks.
Supporting Obama was my way to make sure McCain Palin stayed away from the WH.
My work is done. If he’s not a progressive… I know he never claimed to be one, but he also was basically an atheist. When he found politics, he also found Jesus. How convenient was that. He can also find liberalism in the same way … if he needs to.
Nice touch, the double spacing that is, great example of wasting time and energy.
When you play the bipartisan card you give up a lot of political tools…weapons if you will…then you do your political battles with your hands tied behind your back.
The under class can survive when the economy is roaring and there is plenty around. When there is no spare change stuff in the dumpster or cans to recycle they are screwed.
It wasn’t easy to fight the primaries. It wasn’t easy to fight the neocons with their fear. These are viscious mfer make no mistake the neocons don’t take prisoners. This is for keeps. It is unbelievable that policies to protect tortuers were announced yesterday. Iran: Biden is already rattling sabers…yet another war? WTF. The treasury and fed run by Wall Street crooks that got us a world wide recession. On and on and on and they own the third rail of politics. No this is not kumbaya this is class warfare and PBO is on the wrong side now. Someone said he should be on the road now…why not he sent RE to put the shiv in our side.
Yes that is what happened to the state taxes when property tax rolls shrunk due to lowered property values, It is a big hit and the repukes are laughing all the way cause government services are cut deeply.
This is a carefully engineered attack on the middle class.
I tried a variation of that during the Bush Hell. Wound up paying penalties, and have to make quarterly payments now.
The little guy, they squash! The big shots who don’t pay? Appointed to office.
I like coming here for the thoughtful, non-knee-jerk analysis that classic liberalism has always been noted for.
Well yeah, but I didn’t expect him to name all these Republicans to his cabinet and Conservatives as his advisors without even squeezing in ONE progressive anywhere!
I say, sir.
This post is quite extraordinary. Even if it does include a sordid reference to the supple neckflesh of Rape Gurney Joe.
Quite extraordinary indeed.