Late reports from Rafah note that Egypt has closed the Rafah crossing into Gaza from fear that Israel is gearing up for new attacks.
Israeli attacks have not ended during the "cease-fire" period – the Israeli navy has continued shelling Gazan fishing boats and the coastline:
It’s barely dawn and the Israeli warships off the Gaza Strip coast are opening fire on the small Palestinian fishing boats a few hundred yards off the shore. The Palestinians pulling in their meager hauls from the cloudy, sewage-saturated waters try to ignore the incoming fire that splashes in the waters around them.
The Israeli ships enforcing a Naval blockage of Gaza have been firing on the fisherman every morning in an apparent attempt to keep them from getting too far from shore.
But this morning, Thursday, Jan. 22nd, the Israeli fire blasts through the morning all along the coastline. Then the Israeli fire gets closer to shore. By late morning, five Palestinians, including a little girl, have been wounded by the Israeli cease fire shelling.
In meetings in Egypt, Hamas has offered Israel a one year truce on the condition that the border crossing be opened. So far, Israel has refused to agree to the border opening and demanded that Hamas (Gaza’s elected government) not be allowed to manage the rebuilding:
"Any activity on the ground in Gaza, we will have to make sure it doesn’t fall into the hands of Hamas," said Welfare Minister Isaac Herzog, who has been charged with overseeing the delivery of humanitarian aid.
Israel’s outgoing Prime Minister Ehud Olmert said last week that "Hamas cannot … be allowed to lead the reconstruction process in the strip and thereby gain some measure of legitimacy.
Along with the back and forth on extending the precarious cease-fire, the Israeli government continues their plans to defend against war crimes prosecutions. The Israeli Cabinet is lawyering up.
Defense Minister Ehud Barak explained the decision to "provide full legal defense to any soldier" facing international war crimes prosecution by saying:
"The endorsement will ensure that since we sent out soldiers to carry out Operation Cast Lead, which was carried out exceptionally and by the most moral army in the world, the state of Israel, which sent the IDF on the mission, will give soldiers and commanders backing in the face of any external accusations or internal self-flagellation," he said.
But look more closely at this "most moral army:"
Ha’aretz reports that the materials the official IDF rabbinate handed out to forces during the attack on Gaza included such statements as:
The IDF rabbinate, also quoting Rabbi Aviner, describes the appropriate code of conduct in the field: "When you show mercy to a cruel enemy, you are being cruel to pure and honest soldiers. This is terribly immoral. These are not games at the amusement park where sportsmanship teaches one to make concessions. This is a war on murderers. ‘A la guerre comme a la guerre.’"
And in a Ha’aretz article suggesting that the IDF cannot claim to have "won the war" when there was no real "war", Reuven Pedatzur describes the Israeli ROE:
At the start of the ground offensive, senior command decided to avoid endangering the lives of soldiers, even at the price of seriously harming the civilian population. This is why the IDF made use of massive force during its advance in the Strip. As a Golani brigade commander explained, if there is any concern that a house is booby-trapped, even if it is filled with civilians, it should be targeted and hit, to ensure that it is not mined – only then should it be approached. Without going into the moral aspects, such fighting tactics explain why there were no instances in which there was a need to assault homes where Hamas fighters were holed up.
Other outcomes of this fighting method were the extensive damage and the deaths of many civilians. According to IDF statistics, almost two thirds of Palestinians killed were civilians.
Given the reports that have been published of the IDFs behavior in Gaza, the concern over war crimes prosecutions is not surprising – yet actual trials may be quite difficult to start as Fouad Riad, a former Yugoslavian ICT judge discusses issues here. (h/t markfromireland)
While Human Rights organizations explore how to bring charge, more reports of violations of international law are emerging as more foreign journalists gain access to Gaza. Just one example from the Toronto Star:
Abed Rabbo said he and other family members were in their home in a five-storey apartment building when Israeli tanks entered the area. A voice in Arabic boomed over a loudspeaker, advising residents to flee for their safety because the neighbourhood was to be attacked by Israeli forces.
Carrying a white flag, Abed Rabbo and nine family members left their home, meaning to flee, but quickly confronted three Israeli tanks parked near their house.
"There were two soldiers sitting on one of the tanks," said Abed Rabbo. "They were eating chips. They looked at us. We expected them to tell us where to go."
But that is not what took place.
"Suddenly, by surprise, a soldier came out of the turret, out to his waist," said Abed Rabbo. "He got an M-16, and he started shooting at us. He shot the kids."
Hit were Souad, 7, Samar, 4, and Amal, 2, all nieces of Abed Rabbo. His mother – the girls’ grandmother – was also hit, suffering three bullet wounds. Her name is also Souad.
He said he and the other adults pulled their wounded family members back into their apartment building. By this time, the younger Souad was dead. Amal died about 10 minutes later, he said.
And while not a direct contravention of Geneva, Emad Jameel Qasim, zookeeper for the Gaza Zoo wants to bring charges against Israel for the cost of rebuilding this one, rare, bright spot in the lives of Gaza’s children:
A month ago, it was attracting families – he says the zoo drew up to 1,000 visitors each day. He points at the foot-long hole in the camel in one of the enclosures…. Around every corner, inside almost every cage are dead animals, who have been lying in their cages since the Israeli incursion.
Qasim doesn’t understand why they chose to destroy his zoo. And it’s difficult to disagree with him. Most of them have been shot at point blank range.
"The first thing the Israelis did was shoot at the lions – the animals ran out of their cage and into the office building. Actually they hid there."…
Inside the main building, soldiers defaced the walls, ripped out one of the toilets and removed all of the hard drives from the office computers. We asked him why they targeted the zoo. He laughs. "I don’t know. You have to go and ask the Israelis. This is a place where people come to relax and enjoy themselves. It’s not a place of politics."
When asked to respond to Israeli charges that Hamas was firing from "civilian areas", he says:
"Let me answer that with a question. We are under attack. There was not a single person in this zoo. Just the animals. We all fled before they came. What purpose does it serve to walk around shooting animals and destroying the place?"…



91 Comments












Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
It was no a war. It was a 22 day massacre. It was slaughter.
Thank you, Siun. Please Digg, friends.
Aloha, Laura and Siun… I’m sorry for being absent for so long…! :-(
Pure and simple, Laura…! 8-(
As the Israeli political figures who backed the Gaza war crimes “lawyer up,” one of the things they are asserting seems to be that as Gaza isn’t part of a nation per se, one cannot commit a war crime there, as such crimes are defined, when attacking it. Is there any validity to that assertion?
Laura, have you seen this petition?
http://psychoanalystsopposewar…..essionals/
ET – I’m not sure, I know Gaza since it is not “a state” cannot itself bring charges before the ICC.
Israel declaring a cease fire was just a polite way of giving Joe The Plumber and his fellow tired stenographers… I mean journalists, a reason to go home.
AND THE KILLIN’ GOEZ ON AND ON AND…
Citizen Siun and the Firepup Freedom Fighters:
Trials at the Hague for the entire corporate oil oligarchy: Bush family, Cheney, Wolfowitz, Rumsfeld, the entire leadership of the Likud Party and anyone and everyone involved with AIPAC.
KEEP THE FAITH AND PASS THE AMMUNITION, THE WE HAVE SEEN THE ENEMY AND IT IS ALL OF THEM!!
That’s right up there with the “illegal combatant” defense and the “Guantanamo Bay is not American soil” defense.
Citizen Edward Teller:
It isn’t an argument that anyone in the civilized worls will accept.
Palestine as a whole is state… Whether, Fatah will join Hamas in presenting a case is a whole ‘nother story…
True….. but we are dealing with lawyers, politicians, generals and arms dealers, so we’re more than a few miles from civilization.
What I found interesting was the IDF’s scrubbing of all news reports that referenced any actions conducted at the Battalion level and below, they couldn’t scrub ‘em higher because the press knew where and when the higher echelons were… Some serious fuckery considering this later report on the Politicos now lawyering up…! 8-(
They are taking the potential of trials very seriously – there was also a report that all IDF personnel have to check in before overseas travel in case they are already on a list of possible war criminals.
The media is now allowed to id below Battalion with rank and first initial.
No. I hadn’t seen that, Siun. Stephen Soldz is someone I very much admire; I’m not surprised to see he’s part of this. Thanks for flagging it for me: I signed, of course. : )
The article in Ha’aretz on the materials the IDF rabbis hand out is pretty astonishing …
as is the Zoo story …
these are so shocking.
Killing the animals is nothing but bloodlust and is disgusting and sick.
Indeed they are. I thought what Gideon Levy had to say in the link you gave from markfromireland was spot on:
Killing caged animals. Killing a woman holding a white flag. Shooting children, picking them off one by one. And only Al Jazeera there to let us know day to day what was going on. I understand U.S. viewing of Al Jazeera has gone up massively. If y’all didn’t watch the Special they did on Friday: Gaza in Ruins, you can catch it by clicking on my name–it’s up at my blog, or dig through old Oxdowns for it….(but I bet you all have Al Jazeera on your bookmark bar, like me!)
Levy is such an important voice.
Israel is becoming the new Serbia. Aggrieved, isolated, self-justifying, and now vicious.
Let us hope that the pragmatic Israeli majority can regain control.
Is the shooting at the fishing boats a way to keep food away from the people?
This is the My Lai/Nam mentality of destroying a village to save it…
-As a Golani brigade commander explained, if there is any concern that a house is booby-trapped, even if it is filled with civilians, it should be targeted and hit, to ensure that it is not mined – only then should it be approached.-
By the way, over at TomDispatch is a sample of the book version of Waltz with Bashir, the graphic novel and film by Ari Folman about his experiences in Israel’s 1982 invasion of Lebanon. It is painfully riveting.
The public justification is to stop arms smuggling but since Gazan fishermen are already blockaded into a 3 mile range, the effect is to block food.
Hamas tried to hijack ambulances during Gaza war
(Please don’t shoot the messenger.)
I went to see Waltz with Bashir yesterday – strange experience.
Amazing animation and important film, esp for Israeli audiences – and yet … and yet …there is a distance and a focus on memory that left me disturbed. I need to think about it more and would love to hear other’s thoughts.
Ah. Despicable. But I meant if food can’t get in because of blockades, then fishing would seem one of the few available protein sources, so if the fisherman can’t fish because they’re getting shelled, then…
Yes. It has been an ongoing tactic. Along with diverting water and cutting off food shipments by road, Israel has been preventing Gazans from fishing. It is a multi-pronged genocidal campaign.
The IRC and other humanitarian groups have not reported this – they have reported continuous problems with Israel targeting ambulances even when the whereabouts were relayed by the IRC …
Note that the one informant quoted in that article is a Fatah loyalist who already has had problems with Hamas.
Do I think Hamas has clean hands – nope – and the accounts of informants, etc being killed sound likely – but the appearance of this story right now makes me very suspicious.
Somewhere, weeks ago, I read a review of it by a Arab woman (whose nationality escapes me right now–along with any other details). She, too, commented on its sense of distance, and on the feeling that it was more relevant to Israeli audiences. I am looking forward to checking it all, although I find the imagery haunting.
3 miles offshore blockade could put a dent in this extraction…! :-(
IIRC… Israel has no known reserves…
Outside of that region was what I was implying…! 8-(
Thanks again, Siun. I read your posts with my jaw on the floor. US collusion, this rare and frightening bipartisanship of our leadership, horrifies me. 400 children killed, 100 women. Military “pragmatism”???? And cronyism…. not leaving with Bush administration. Global cronyism.
Have we learned nothing from Iraq???? From Viet Nam????? So with all the “change”-speak, I’m feeling pretty disenfranchised and helpless still … our tax dollars helping to finance slaughter. US codependency. What about “tough love” and US doing an intervention, instead of the phosphorous fog of denial?
I’d recommend seeing the film – it is powerful and important.
I sat for quite a while when it ended – just rather stunned.
But it’s complicated – as are the events it depicts – and as is the Israeli view that it represents.
Very good questions – I think we all need to remind our politicians that we do not support these policies. There’s a feeling that crossing Israel is political death … we need to make it clear we feel differently.
The Irsaelis suspect the fishing boats to be involved in arms smuggling.
Sorry Didn’t see that the question had been answered
I encourage everyone to see this video from The Palestinian Think Tank. I really makes a very important point.
http://palestinethinktank.com/…..holocaust/
thanks siun.
i just got back from a trip to california. a new friend (not jewish) with whom i’d never talked politics drove me to the airport. when i told him how upset i was about what was happening to the gazans, his response was that i believed the propaganda. i was stunned.
on the way home on the plane, the man i was sitting next to, who was jewish (as i am) said the same thing. i asked if maybe it was him who was believing the propaganda. he didn’t seem to believe the gazans were short of food and water. turns out he’s a lawyer and used to get rapists off by blaming the victim. he stopped doing that when he realized these men wouldn’t change and were raping again. it’s hard not to notice the parallels.
it’s amazing and frustrating to me that the mainstream media has been so very successful. in my own little bubble with my progressive friends, i just assume people at least know more or less what’s happening. however, that’s clearly not the case.
it’s time to stand for peace.
Kinda over the top and just more propaganda.
greenwarrior … we are talking industrial strength kool-aid out there. I relate.
Siun @37 … time to make my nighttime phone messages again to Congress. One Voice At A Time. Thanks for the inspiration, Siun and fdl!
How does that theory fly when nobody can get in or out of the territory? Are submarines supposed to be involved?
The smuggling theory goes: Iranian arms are sent by ship to Egyptian waters, offloaded onto small craft, and these boats transfer their parcels into the fishing boats.
“Demographers predict that within ten years Arabs will outnumber Jews in Israel, the West Bank and Gaza. Without a separate Palestinian state the Israelis would have three options, none of them good. They could try ethnic cleansing, drive the Palestinians out of the West Bank, or they could give the Palestinians the vote. That would be the democratic option but it would mean the end of the Jewish state. Or they could try apartheid – have the minority Israelis rule the majority Palestinians, but apartheid regimes don’t have a very long life.”
“Unfortunately, and I have to say to you that apartheid is already in place,” Dr. Barghouti argued.”
http://www.cbsnews.com/stories…..age2.shtml
Right. But I’m asking when the small boats can’t get in because of the shelling, how does that theory fly?
What percentage of boats do you suppose are being shelled?
“CAIRO: Egypt has proof that the majority of weapons that are smuggled into the Gaza Strip come from Israel, said the general secretary of Egypt’s National Council for Human Rights Mukhlis Qutb.”
http://uruknet.info/?p=m51157&…..1&l=e
From the coverage Siun cites…
…I’d say the shelling is controlling ALL of the fishing boats.
..and the no files on Guantanamo detainees defense…
“when incoming legal and national security officials — barred until the inauguration from examining classified material on the detainees — discovered that there were no comprehensive case files on many of them.”
http://www.washingtonpost.com/…..02_pf.html
I doubt that Israel can do so, but that’s all I have for you. I’ve tried to suggest a plausable reason for the hostility to fishing boats.
It’s hard to believe that there’s any other reason. The dubious nutritive value of the fish in these waters isn’t worth the effort. Particularly not when the food being trucked in is immeasurably more important in feeding the people.
But I don’t really know and almost nothing done by Israel or Hamas seems to be too stupid or vile at this point.
Thank you for the link, kimmy. It is reasonable to think that what we see in these pictures is only a portion of the whole scene, much of which is probably still buried under the rubble.
If you’re new to the lake, I welcome you. We appreciate informative comments and links to pertinent matter; that way we all share our pieces of the puzzle and all have opportunity to grow. Please contribute often.
” It’s a ceasefire: just not on the beach, not in your home “
http://www.freegaza.org/en/hom…..rdpresscom
I understand the trucked-in food is far too little to properly feed the people, and does not arrive reliably. So while the fishing proceeds may indeed be meagre — I’m no expert on that, nor on any of this — I can certainly understand the need to keep at it.
“Beginning in late 2000 the Israeli military began a campaign of intimidation and harassment against the fishing boats that ventured near or beyond a 6 nautical mile limit. No formal notice or explanation was ever given to the Palestinians. Instead the regulation was written and enforced by Israeli machine guns and water cannons. At least 14 fishermen have been killed by the Israelis, over 200 injured and numerous boats damaged or impounded.”
“WHY?”
“In the late 1990’s the British Gas Group (BG Group) discovered a vast deposit of natural gas under the waters off Gaza: Over 1 trillion cubic feet equal to 150 million barrels of oil was estimated to be there. “
http://www.freegaza.org/en/hom…..s-deposits
That’s very interesting, thanks, but what’s the point of keeping Palestinian boats off the waters above the NG deposit? What’re they gonna do, blow it up? Drill for it from fishing boats? I don’t think so, so I don’t get the connection.
The UN was estimating that 70% of Gaza’s population is dependent on food aid. That’s not a tenable situation. The fish are coming from water into untreated waste is continuously dumped.
The whole damned thing has to change. And the only initiative being shown is in thinking up new ways to kill grandmothers and babies.
BBC has refused to air adds asking for humanitarian aid for Gaza. Why?
Isreali seige is designed to make Hamas supporters turn to the Palestinian authority under Fatah. No Fatah no food, water or medical. The Isrealis that were living in Gaza and some of Fatah supporters are colaborating with IDF. All creating the Big Brother fear factor. The neocons fear factor. Fear Fear Fear a social disease. Again Roosevelt said “The only thing you have to fear is fear itself”.
Gaza is way beyond fear..terror is the consciousness, desparation and sickness over lives taken, property destroyed and freedom lost.
The state of Isreal, the Jews in general and the USA are all sadly a party.
40 years of peace protest against war and inhumanity. Shouls we reexamone what exactly humanity is. And human rights?
You left out the Arabs part in shaping the misery.
Ah yes. Well, they do the great majority of the dying.
I read his comment as not excluding Arabic (is that really what you meant?) responsibility, but that the US is aligned with either party.
Too true, but’s that’s something we all do.
I was mostly pissed at his saying ” the Jews in general” and was offering a chance for him to modify.
Not from enemy attack.
We (and I mean Americans) lack the vocabulary and phraseology in a historic sense to manage how we talk about this conflict, and this region. We constantly trip over our Johnsons both in speaking and writing about it, and in interpreting what is spoken and written.
I’m probably in EPU-land, but CBS 60 minutes has a great segment on the West Bank and what it means for peace prospects
Hmmm,I can do the math. 100/1.
Does anything I’ve said make you think tht I approve of anyone’s dying from violence?
No, nothing, sorry if I gave you that impression. I consider the casualty ratios critical to any discussion of the situation.
Big time agreement.
Cool. The numbers are very important. It’s my hope that it’s going to cut the legs from under the supporters of the violence.
For no very great reason, I feel that Obama is going to give a really big pull on the Israelis’ leash.
Beyond no more bombing sprees; the West Bank settlements have to stop. No more stealing the land, the tres, and the water.
I am happy to explain my view. Zion is the home state of all jews as declared by Isreal. If your state commits genocide that action reflects on judaism in general. AIPAC certainly has no quams that I have heard them express. Part of the problem with this war on Palestinians in general is the blinders as was the problem with the holocaust…people smelling other peoples bodies being burned and not voicing outrage.
But then I am secular and a peace activist. I will not be silent those that are silent have a part in the crime. I hope that explains my position better. And thank you for asking. We all need to take a stand against war crimes, genocide and torture no matter who the victims is. Africa is stellar example of the world turning their back. Peace.
Peace to you, also.
You should consider again. Israel does not speak for the Jews. Nor is Israel home to even half of them. And you should probably consider that each Jew speaks for himself.
Are you a peace activist who knows no Jews to share your activism?
Are you a peace activist whose country speaks for him?
Or are you a peace activist who speaks for himself and does not care to be spoken for “in general”?
Thank you once again, Siun.
And I thank you for before.
I am trying to resist letting my buttons get pushed about this. If I spoke frankly about who and what, you might not be so pleased. But there is a time and a place, and dragging our less-than-100 year involvement into a two thousand year old clusterfuck is, or should be an embarrassment.
But we do understand this together, and you are most welcome.
Again the silence has been deafening. And I have a nieghbor who is for peace he is jewish, been to Jerusalem, is traditial in his jewish upbringing. My family did a lot…Millions of dollars of business with jewish rag merchant in the clothing markets. I have a lot of people of jewish faith that I have discussed this disaster with some are part of the National Lawyers Guild.
Now would you like to tell a bit about yourself, your ties and what you have done to further the peace process. I started in 1968 with Sufis, Jews, Bhuddaists, Yogas and practiced with them in an effort to tolerate our differences. There were Viet Vets in the groups as well…all centered around an organic lifestyle. It was a learning experience most folks are sheltered from. The CNN story of what the Settlers are doing with IDF backing is stealing…they call it a gift from GOD. What a bonch of wonks. The ten commandments…”Thou shalt not steal”. Lying scum the hypocricy of Isreal is so thick you can slice it.
You are wrong. Stealing is illegal it is a crime and should br punished and the victim restored their property. In a society where there is rule of law that is what occurs.the only conclusion that can be drown is Isrealis are a crime cabal opperating under the guess of religious righteousness.
macaquerman – imploring you now to ignore comment #79. It is bait and disgusting, and you should not bite at it.
A lot of things can be double talked and justified. Plausible doubt or explaination can be raised.
But killing the zoo animals is just plain thuggary. It speaks volumes to me. Whatever in me that was neutral is now mad as hell that we are supporting this.
Want to turn America against you, go killing a bunch of helpless animals.
Can someone explain again to me, just what our national interest in Israel is? And don’t give me this only democracy in the middle East bullshit. It’s not and so what?
And as for a two thousand year old cluster. It hadn’t been a cluster fuck for 1600 years. The Western world made it one 60 years ago, for some reason that I’ll be damned if I can understand.
More like 80 years ago, but you get my point.
Correct me if I am wrong, but the sons of Abraham and their decedents have contested this for much longer than America has been populated by Europeans.
(To risk an attempt at injecting a touch of levity:) I think you mean descendants, not decedents?
Funny! And yes.
*hangs head…*
Thanks again. There was a locked unit in one of the hospitals in which I used to work. I guess one has to be careful here also.
You’re pretty good with an injection.
No mistake, we have fundamental disagreements as to responsibility and culpability, intent, victimization, etc. But hurling trash at each other has gotten those 2 sides exactly nowhere. I don’t see solutions in continuing it here.
Job one, in my opinion, is for a straight-up realistic look by our representatives, and the only way that happens is we either compel or replace them. We are either honest brokers or we are not. And right now, we are not.
The US government ceased being any kind of broker when Clinton left office.
I harbor hope that Obama will seek to restore some kind of balance to US policy.
From the link originally provided:
“On 11/8/99 Chairman Yasser Arafat signed an agreement giving BG Group 90 percent interest and 10 per cent to Consolidated Contractors Company, an Athens based Palestinian entity connected to the PLO.”
“A final allocation of the rights continues to be contested between BG Group, Israel, Egypt and the Palestinians in obscured ongoing negotiations.
The Israelis began their program of killing and harassing the Gazan fishermen only after the discovery of the natural gas deposits. It is a reasonable assumption that the two events are linked: That the Israelis are asserting control over this resource valued at over 4 billion dollars; And that they are intent on denying any benefit to the Palestinians regardless of who controls Gaza.”
http://www.freegaza.org/en/hom…..s-deposits
There were two soldiers sitting on one of the tanks,” said Abed Rabbo. “They were eating chips. They looked at us. We expected them to tell us where to go.”
But that is not what took place.
“Suddenly, by surprise, a soldier came out of the turret, out to his waist,” said Abed Rabbo. “He got an M-16, and he started shooting at us. He shot the kids.”
If this is true. I don’t understand it, unless the soldiers were total psychopaths.