This morning the Lehigh Valley has been in the news because a former congressman, Club For Growth president Pat Toomey, has given Arlen Specter a pass in terms of his right flank. The somewhat demented Toomey, a right wing extremist who preceded Charlie Dent as PA-15′s rep, said he’s not going to primary Specter (and run for governor instead).
This morning we’re welcoming back a dear Blue America friend, Sam Bennett, who ran against Dent in the last cycle. Yesterday she told me that "After getting around 128,000 votes, which is significantly more than any other Democrat candidate has garnered in a congressional race in this district, it’s become clear to me that we’re moving things in the right direction." Sam spent $940,252 against Dent’s $1,736,715. He spent $9.63/vote and Sam spent around $7.37/vote.
Would more money have helped? "We had a lot of support from the national progressive community and we’re moving in the right direction in terms of votes garnered compared to the amount of money raised," she said. "but there’s a lot more work to be done." And as the vice-chair of the Lehigh County Democratic Party, there’s a lot Sam can–and plans to–do.
I would argue that in my district–and in others–that when we have well-entrenched incumbents who position themselves as "moderates," thru franked mail and campaign expenditures, despite having a very unmoderate voting record, they are thought to be "moderates" in the local voters’ minds. That becomes a particularly tough target for us as progressives.
So what I need to do, and what I’m going to do, working with others in my district is keeping that coalition together that worked on my race–feminists, Greens, unions, environmentalists–and forming a federal PAC and putting up our own blog. Right now the blogosphere in my district is uniquely dominated by the regressives not the progressives.
We need to turn that situation around and look for any opportunity we can to communicate to the voters at large and give progressives voices a place to be heard. It’s clear to me that to win this district I’m not the right candidate but I’m working hard with others and we’ve got at least one phenomenal candidate, and maybe two, so we’ll be working hard to make sure there is a great progressive candidate here.
In the meantime we need to continue getting Dent’s voting record out to the public on a regular basis and utilizing any communication methods we can to get that information into the voters’ minds.
There have been several contested votes in the House so far. Dent voted to sabotage the Paycheck Fairness Act with a parliamentary maneuver, although he later voted for it when it was clear it would pass. He then voted against the Lilly Ledbetter Fair Pay Act, something that would probably surprise most women in PA-15.
He voted for a failed parliamentary maneuver to sabotage SCHIP, twice and, then, as is his deceitful modus operandi he voted with the Democrats on final passage so he could tell voters back home he was for health care for needy children, despite trying to kill the bill twice on the same day he voted for it. He’s adept at putting up a confusing smokescreen as his voting record.
We’ve had tremendous success, particularly on the municipal level, in getting Democrats elected up and down the ticket elected for the first time. Our efforts will be coordinated with the Democratic Party, but also with the Greens, I am the first candidate that the Greens endorsed in a congressional race here. If it takes us two years, fine; if it takes us four years, fine. The key is a long term commitment.



93 Comments












Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Welcome Sam!
hello
Welcome back to FDL, Sam. Something I forgot to ask you yesterday. I know you’re committed to progressive values and ideals. The Pennsylvania Democratic Party, on the other hand, is a mixed bag. Some of the worst Blue Dog types in the Democratic congressional caucus are from PA. And in getting rid of Phil English, the state wound up with an anti-choice Democrat. Do you think there’s a chance that the Lehigh Valley could wind up getting rid of Dent but winding up with a conservative Democrat in his place?
Hey Howie!
Welcome back to FDL Sam!
Can we interest you in a state-wide run for the Senate against Snarlin’ Arlen? Please? Pretty Please?
Howie, great to be back at Firedoglake. To your concern — one of the reasons I’m putting my energies to making sure PA-15 turns blue is to ensure the values we truly represent here are represented in Washington. My fellow Democratic leaders here in PA-15 are all progressive. Our Democratic electeds in PA-15 are largely progressive. And with the help of progressives across the country — we can ensure PA-15 is represented by a progressive in Washington who will help President Obama move our nation forward.
Hi Sam,
Great idea keeping the heat on.
Good Luck!
(PA 6)
Thanks PA-6 ….yours is another important district that is ripe to turn blue. Jim Gerlach and Charlie Dent are two of a kind — in fact my guy is so UNmoderate, he makes Gerlach look like a tree hugger!
Any chance there will be a progressive running against Snarlin’ Arlen in 2010? To be honest, I’ve been happier with Casey than I thought I’d be when he ran. He’s been a real moderate, rather than a wingnut who the media calls a “moderate Democrat” like Ben Nelson, Blanche Lincoln, Mary Landrieu and Mark Pryor. But I’d love to see a progressive leader replace Specter. Are there any on the horizon in Pennsylvania politics?
HI dakine01! I’m very flattered. And yes, we can take the Senatorial distict here in PA. My thinking as a party leader, let’s do everything we can to turn PA from a battleground state to a sure blue performer — to that end, I think I’m best used as a leader behind the scenes to make that happen — will I be running again? ABSOLUTELY! But this cycle, I want to roll my organizer sleeves up and do everything I can to make the right outcomes occur.
Do you think Democrats have a good shot in taking back PA-15 in 2010 because of demographic changes or for some other reason?
Do we have talent here in PA that can make a successful run for Senate — I say yes. I’m interested: who do your readers think out there in PA of current electeds and leaders has the right progressive stuff?
Howie, regarding PA-15. We have a terrific combination of factors to make this ripe for the taking: 1) ever growing D registration — currently standing at over 30,000 more D’s than R’s. 2) one of the strongest concentrations of union members, retirees in the country 3) STRONG green party and environmentally concerned. All we need to do is get Dent’s voting record to stick to him — the voters here don’t know HE IS NOT A MODERATE.
What are the greatest challenges to the local economy? My sister lives in your district, she is seeing a lot of unemployment.
Howie, I also want to take a moment to thank firedoglake readers and the Net Roots community — they were a force of nature in my race that assisted us in getting my race and this district on the national radar screen. Many, many thanks to all — impressive the power that individuals can make through net roots action.
http://politicalticker.blogs.c…..tv-anchor/
Old news?? Viable?
The only real liberals in the state’s congressional delegation are Chaka Fattah and Robert Brady… maybe Allison Schwartz. Do any of them have what it takes? I keep hearing Joe Sestak and Patrick Murphy being mentioned as possible contenders but they’ve been kind of disappointing as congressmen, although Sestak far less so than Murphy. Are there other electeds in the state would be better bets for progressives than the congressionals?
JJ- yes, old news. Matthews took himself out of the race
PA-15 was shielded from the worst of the economic hits and only now is feeling the effects. It has done a great job of reinventing itself in the aftermath of the demise of Bethlehem Steel and Mack Truck changes. But now here like everywhere else we are back to the mantra we lived by after Bush Sr. left office — “It’s the Economy, Stupid..”. PA-15 and the nation is terrifically positioned to be the alternative energy manufacturing powerhouse of the world — ushering in an economic boon not unlike the IT boom of Clinton’s administration. And PA with its failing infrastruture is ripe for the kind of public works projects President Obama envisions.
Howie, regarding potential Senatorial candidates — Schwartz is terrific but has done so exceptionally well in Congress, she might not want to run for Senate again. We’ve been hearing about Murphy and Sestak’s interest in the Senate — but nothing is confirmed. What is needed is a candidate that can capture the national imagination the way Casey did against Rick S. Challenge — Arlen is the closest we have to a moderate R in PA and has alot of support in Philly — a critical voting block for us.
I think if we can work together to win PA-15 and PA-6 and deliver 2 more D’s to the PA delegation — that positions us well for a strong Senate outcome.
JJ — many were looking to Matthews as our answer to Al Franken.
Regarding potential other PA Senatorial — the Governor’s race is hot here and we have a deep bench of Democrats vying, some genuine talent here. Don Cunningham, PA-15 County Executive who led Bethlehem as Mayor out of its post Bethlehem Steel crash, is very politically capable.
Sam with re-districting coming up in ‘10 after the census, what is the current make-up of the PA legislature? And how much longer does Rendell have in office? Is he term limited at all?
I guess I’m wondering about how things might look after ‘10 in case PA loses a seat. It’s always fun when incumbents from the same party get thrown together in a single district. (not)
Sam is Arlen’s health going to be a factor?
dakine01 — While I was in Washington for inauguration, redistricting was the buzz among the PA delegation. It’s coming. Rendell’s term is coming up — yes, term limited. And boy, wouldn’t he make a fabulous Senator! Back in the day when Arlen was still a D, he and Rendell’s paths often crossed.
We lost Joe Hoeffel back in the last redistricting — a GREAT progressive. He’s made a run for Senate and now is in a holding pattern as Montgomery County commissioner — another one to consider.
Is Cunningham thinking about challenging Dent?
Hi foothillsmike, thanks for joining us. We are beginning to regard Arlen as the Glenn Close (what WAS that movie with Michael Douglas?) of PA politics — you just can’t kill him.
Health might be an issue — but with Arlen, might not be.
Sam, I’m glad you brought up alternative energy. Is it just me or is alternative energy spending slipping out of Obama’s economic reform package? The words are becoming conspicuously absent in the political discourse. About 15 percent of the stimulus package is appropriated for infrastructure spending – of this portion – there has been no mention of wind and solar energy that I have heard.
People like you are needed to represent us so that we can direct our focus on alternative energy. What is your view?
Cunningham no — all his energies are focused on the upcoming Gov race. But we have several candidates interested, and one who is definately of Cunningham caliber.
However, if Cunningham is unsuccessful at Gov race (and I for one think he not only has a great chance there he’d would make an excellent Gov) the Senatorial might have appeal for him — and he’s been laying a statewide ground work that would be helpful.
Also in gov race is Allegheny county chair Dan Onnarato (sic) another young political talent who might look at the Senate race with interest.
Hackworth1 — I agree strongly that positioning our nation at the “bleeding edge” of alternative and retrofit manufacturing energy industry is essential. America is at its best when its innovating and creating new industries and market sectors — the Federal Government can play an essential role is constantly positioning us to be the international leader in the next BIG opportunity — and alternative energy is an exceptional economic opportunity.
Hey foothillsmike — I meant to say “you just CAN’T kill him” in reference to the unfortunately indomitable Arlen Spector.
I really don’t want to see him “killed” but in watching him during the Holder hearings he did appear to get fatigued as the day wore on. I was thinking maybe there were some rumors of his retiring.
You make it sound like there’s a wonderful bench of progressives in the Pennsylvania Democratic Party and you sound so optimistic! That’s good but I just keep thinking about Chris Carney and Jason Altmire and Kathy Dahlkemper, Tim Holden, Murtha, even Patrick Murphy… not a great bunch when it comes to progressive values.
Thanks for your answer. I agree and I anticipated that you would feel this way. Do you have a sense that alternative energy is being put on the back burner? I do.
Fatal Attraction is the name of the Spector Doppleganger Movie.
Understood — that’s why its SO important at the grassroots level here in PA we keep supporting and fielding progressives. My race for Congress was important for this reason — we demonstrated that a progressive (who isn’t a current elected and isn’t a self funder) can raise $, can build a coalition, can get more votes than any D has ever gotten.
If we recruit and cultivate and support progressives early in districts like PA-15 that are ripe for the picking, the net roots community can be a force for good. The work that Adam Green is doing in creating PCCC is a great example of the work we can do to get more progressives elected.
The progressives are there — we just need to empower them to overcome the challenges they face in districts like PA-15 and PA-6 against R incumbants.
OT
House Republican Leader John Boehner Weekly Republican Address
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XSwN-m9sAJM
he’s looking for feedback on the house republican agenda, comments open
Spector Doppleganger! LOL. Yes, it feels to me also as if it has been “back burnered”. Due I assume to gas prices plummeting down again…we must effect a way to keep the political pressure up on this issue so we don’t squander this opportunity. I read recently that Reagan took down the solar panels on the White House — let’s clamor for President Obama to put them back up — and serve as an example for all Americans on the critical importance of this.
So when are you thinking about bringing the next progressive candidate for the PA-15 congressional seat over to FDL to introduce him or her to us?
foothillsmike — We have been living with rumors of Arlen’s retirement for soooooooooooooooooooooo long. I think the biggest challenge is his relatively moderate R stance and his Philly support — makes him tough to dislodge.
Absolutely Howie — I’d be honored for FDL to meet the next progressive candidate running for Congress in PA-15. We are lining things up now.
Believe it or not, the blogsphere in this district is dominated by ‘regressives’ not progressives. So we are looking forward to getting our own progressive blog up “LV Blue Values” so we can get our voice and our values out there — and make sure local folks know exactly what Dent’s and other R’s voting records truly are.
Instead of tax cuts for no reason, why not tie tax cuts to home and business solar (and wind) installations. This way, we can call it a tax cut and get our alternative energy groove on at the same time.
I’m with you on that 100%. If we make it worth your average business and homeowner to invest in solar, wind etc through tax deductions, tax credits etc. THEY WILL. Americans might not naturally excel at sacrifice, but they shuuure do love a good deal — heck, look at all the folks that bought an SUV because they got a tax write off (TRUE!. Tax deductions and credits are quick and efficient way to get the ball rolling.
Do you already have a local blogger lined up? It’s quite a commitment to run a blog.
1980 Cowboy Reagan tearing down Carter’s solar panels was a giant wink and nod to Big Oil, Coal and the Nuclear power industries. These industries have ransacked us ever since. Now here we stand with our pants down around our ankles. You are right we need to press hard now. Currently low gasoline prices are only meant to fool us.
Another challenge we face in PA-15 is the local paper in Lehigh County (PA-15 is very UNjerrymandered with two counties Lehigh and Northampton predominating) that is so wedded to Dent, they allow themselves to be part of a Rovian cycle of Dent sends a press release, they write about it, Dent makes a mail piece out of it. “Half truths, lies and inuendos (sic)”. I often felt myself a character straight out of that excellent movie, “The Contender” when as a candidate for Congress here in PA-15.
Understood how time consuming it is to do a good job — but we are determined not to let the “regressives” continue to dominate.
What is the situation there regarding healthcare? I think it is going to be moving to the forefront soon on the national level. Have your Rs positioned themselves on it and is there an opportunity to get some positive PR for the Ds?
Absolutely — and this is an issue we have to MAKE an issue. If the lowered gas prices are meant to mollify and sedate — then we have to put the pressure on. Again, its a great economic opportunity we just can’t afford to squander.
Alls currently quiet on the western front on health care here. But you’re right its an excellent opportunity to set up the contrast between R and D. I’m curious post McCain — how the R’s are going to define themselves on this one.
Dang! I wish we had a Sam Bennett in my congressional district. I am stuck with Trent Franks.
Howie — remembering my first time on Firedoglake and the issues that came up. I was one happy camper to hear President Obama say that we can fight terrorism without sacrificing our principles.
Great ideas using tax incentives to stimulate the green energy business! Wish we could do the same with a predominately “tax exempt not for profit insulated from change” Health care system. Instead in Massachusetts they penalize the taxpayer who fail to buy costly health care insurance. Use the tax code like a gun against the citizen while Blue Cross Blue Shield is a tax exempt corporations receiving 1000’s of dollars a month and people still go bankrupt. “Relieving the burdens of government” I do not see it!!!
What a deal the “”life tax”"” in the bay colony. Government mandated Corporate servitude because you have a life? What would Jefferson say???
Hey AZMatt — I’d be honored to be your candidate. What’s the biggest beef you have with your current representation?
I saw were that comment has infuriated Bill O’Reilly. He is not bigh on principals I guess.
Howie — I should be up on this but am not, did Jan NOT get the Senatorial appointment to replace Obama?
Here in CO we have community, county and a state organization on health care (single payer). They include health professionals to unemployed. It is a hot topic and could prove beneficial for you to get organized on the issue.
Roland Burris is the Junior Senator from IL, sorry to say.
Can I just say…you f’n Rock!
And yes, The Contender is a great movie that everyone here should make sure they see. We got yer back, Sam!
I live in a part of his district he has never visited to my knowledge, the Hopi Reservation in northern Arizona. This area doesn’t fit into the white conservative demoographic that he loves around Sun City and Lake Havasu City.
2005 GDP % health care 16.4 per capita $6,697.00
2005 GDP % energy 8.0 per capita $3,552.00
Together 24.6 % of GDP No liberty lost here…. right!!!!
You got it — our tax code represents a massively efficient mechanisms to motivate citizen behavior on a large scale. No accident we have one of the highest rate of charitable giving in the world — it’s tax deductible!
I feel we need to simply federally require everyone to have insurance — heck every car has insurance — and then if you can’t afford it, you get the same plan sitting members of US Congress enjoy. At the same time, put a nurse practioneer and dental hygenist in every school in America, and at least guarantee the upcoming generation receives the cheapest most efficient health care treatment — preventive health care. We spend more per capita on health care than any nation in the world — so $ isn’t the problem — allocation is. And we spend LESS on preventative care and more on ADMINISTRATION than any nation — and that needs to be flipped.
Jan would have been wonderful — not only a great progressive but one that also goes out of her way to help candidates. She was great in my race.
Thank you Sam!!! I do get it!!!!
Sam,
This is from the Think Progress blog. It gives you an idea that Bush is the new Reagan for these guys. Link
Ya, I really could do without Franks.
Am I right AZMatt — that you did add another D to Congress in AZ, a gal from a reservation herself? If I’m on the right track, I was very impressed with her very quiet but real commitment and passion when I met her in Washington.
So my life is treated like a car! Poor analogy Sam. Does not hold water how about using tax code to change behavior of health care corporations?
Insulated from change by virtue of tax exempt status?? Bullshit!!
I know. :( I was really rooting for her. But with Blago – no one really knew what to expect(well I didn’t)
And AZMatt — sad that any Congressperson hasn’t visited any part of their respecitve districts. Founding fathers wanted Congress to be the voice of the people — not laden with careerists, but rather with ordinary folks who would manage the purse strings of our tax dollars. Sad he’s a no show out your way.
Ann Kirkpatrick fo AZ-1. Her district surrounds this part of Franks’ district.
First of all… my name… sorry, but what can I do? My parents, ya know.
Anyway, you’re a reliable yes on Employee Free Choice Act, right? Can’t emphasize enough how important this is to so many of us.
Beside President Obama stated in Las Vegas!!!” Health care reform:
…it not about forcing people to purchase something they cannot already afford!! It about making a system cost effective. Mandated health care is government imposed corporate servitude period!!!
Sam do you know the percentage of corporations in the health services that are listed as tax exempt public charities?????
did King say “till of leadership”? Did he mean tiller? What’s a till ?
He goes where the money is. Hopi Reservation is a poor place financially(45 to 50% unemployment) but very rich culturally. He does have on his congressional website a link to a missionary group from California that has done things on Hopi but nothing links to anything actually on the Hopi.
How about the % of corporations listed as “not for profit” but very profitable in the health insurance industry??
THat last was to Sam at 67.
Hello, Sam — it’s wonderful to hear that you’re committed to organizing your CD for progressives, but I’d really hoped you would run against Dent again.
About the Senate: who is the progressive candidate that Casey beat in the primary in 2006? I recall folks around here being quite taken with him, but his name escapes me now. Would he be up for another run?
Thanks again for your terrific 2008 campaign, and please thank your family for the many sacrifices they made, often unsung. The families of candidates really undergo a lot of pressure, and I know it’s hard on them when their candidate loses. Hope yours are all well.
Maybe he meant swill of leadership. *g*
maybe he’s a dim bulb
Beerfart Liberal — great name. In a nod to that slice of me that is Scottish/Irish I was named “Siobhan” — everyone hear thinks I’m a Syrian guy until they meet me.
Employee Free Choice Act is HUGE. I’m a beyond solid supporter. My district has one of the highest concentrations of labor retirees and members in the country.
If putting more money in the hands of ordinary citizens is the backbone of the American economy — what could make more sense than making sure workers have the representation they need to ensure working families have a fair share of the wealth they help create. Statistics show that businesses that take care of their employees outperform those that don’t. It just makes good business sense.
Sam………. any response Sam???
yay!!! great to hear not only a reliable vote but a strong supporter. (btw,this is great howie–meeting these progressives from all over the country. love it)
Teddy — many thanks and especially for recognizing my family. My husband Martin Ulloa Estrada, was fantastic and my daughters Emma and Rachael gave up their summer and the fall after college graduation to help with their little brother David. Not to mention my mom and Dad who were terrific also.
Regarding my candidacy — what’s missing in my district is strong cohesive leadership focused on the task of turning this district blue. NO candidate can do it themselves. I think that I can help us achieve stronger outcomes by organizing so the next candidate doesn’t have to do it all by themselves.
My bottom line — win this district. And if that means being a leader supporting the next progressive — I’m up for that. But don’t worry, I WILL RUN AGAIN!
Thanks so much for joining us today, Sam, it’s great to see you again and learn about your plans for your district. Hope you and your family continue to be well.
And I hope you will be patient with a couple folks who want you to address issues in their own states. We have a lot of pent up energy, always looking for solutions.
Appreciate your being here – please feel free to drop by later on for comments and questions, as we hold the comment section open for 24 hours.
James, sorry about that, lost the thread — a recurring subject of local discussion is our local non-profit hospital (we have three in the district) that has reported hundreds of millions of dollars in black ink.
Clearly, huge work to be done to preserve our status as having the finest hospitals and specialists in the world but gain HUGE lost ground in preventative care for ALL.
JJ — you familiar with France and Netherlands systems? Interesting. My understanding is that France has a parallel public and private system (and consistently ranks #1 by WHO) and Netherlands is a highly regulated 100% private delivery system.
You are right, government has an important role to play to ensure right outcomes from health care insurance industry and hospitals. Deregulation has been debunked.
Yay!
Thanks Sam.
Thanks to all FDLers. An honor to be with you Howie. I look forward to future conversations and working together to turn PA-15 blue.
Warmest regards,
Sam Bennett
President Obama stated in Las Vegas!!!
“Health care reform is not about penalizing people for failing to purchase costly health insurance they already cannot afford. Its about making health insurance efficient and affordable.”
I submit until tax exempt status is revoked in the health services, cost will never be controlled! The use of tax credits and incentives is well established as a mechanism to effect change desired by policy makers in many industries. But if you have no tax liability as in the health services you are in effect subsidized by the taxpayer already, and incentive and credits are useless as applied to insulated tax exempt corporations in the health service industry!
To bad i cannot deduct my premium to a tax exempt HMO w/not for profit status, when I do not need the service for 24 consecutive months. Quite a contribution I’ve made in premium payments with no need for service Aye!!!
Chuck Pennachio is the college professor progressive who challenged Casey in 2006. He and another Democrat couldn’t keep Casey from getting 85% of the vote in the primary, per wiki.
Thanks for your time today, Sam — please keep us up to date on your efforts to turn PA-15 true blue!
To0 life Sam, not corporate servitude!! :)
JJ — thanks for your clear positions on this issue. I agree that we need to be unwavering in ensuring right outcomes — regardless of the siren call of those that would stand to lose $ — our citizen’s health and well being must be the last word. Period.
It speaks to the “general welfare” of the republic and its governed as stated in the preamble of our constitution. Thank You Sam and good luck!!
Late to the party again, and here’s the funny thing. I was one of your supporters, Sam. I think you guys need to do a better job of outreach.
Case in point – I’ve written several articles on my blog about your campaign, the first of which I e-mailed your office about. Didn’t get one hit from your people. Every article I wrote about you garnered a visit from the House of Representatives. Guess how that was. Your opponent did a better job of seeing what was written about you than you did.
For your next campaign, you should hire someone who can do Internet outreach.