In keeping with a long-standing pattern, Bush repeatedly “admitted” that his “rhetoric” might not have been right (“Obviously, some of my rhetoric has been a mistake.”). All the deeds were fine; he just didn’t sell them well. For the Boy King, this has always been the PR presidency; he is now just more loose-lipped about it. Like with so many crappy, Peter-Principled CEO types, he has made the strategy the tactic.
In that vain vein, the most startling moment to my ear and eye was Bush’s perception of his failure to respond to Hurricane Katrina with anything resembling appropriate gravity:
Don’t tell me the federal response was slow when there was 30,000 people pulled off roofs right after the storm passed.
You know, I remember going to see those helicopter drivers, Coast Guard drivers, to thank them. . .
Wait, hang on—I just have to interrupt for minute: “Helicopter drivers?” “Coast Guard Drivers?”
I think we call them “pilots.”
OK, carry on. . . .
You know, I remember going to see those helicopter drivers, Coast Guard drivers, to thank them for their courageous efforts to rescue people off roofs — 30,000 people were pulled off roofs right after the storm moved through. That’s a pretty quick response.
Could things have been done better? Absolutely. Absolutely.
But when I hear people say the federal response was slow, then what are they going to say to those chopper drivers or the 30,000 that got pulled off the roofs?
Amazing, right? It doesn’t even occur to Bush that having to pull people off of roofs is wholly emblematic of the slow response. Last time I checked, the standard advice when faced with a big hurricane is not “First, get on your roof.”
As for the levees breaking, the floods, well, “no one could have anticipated. . .” except, well, um:
In the 48 hours before Hurricane Katrina hit, the White House received detailed warnings about the storm’s likely impact, including eerily prescient predictions of breached levees, massive flooding, and major losses of life and property, documents show.
A 41-page assessment by the Department of Homeland Security’s National Infrastructure Simulation and Analysis Center (NISAC), was delivered by e-mail to the White House’s "situation room," the nerve center where crises are handled, at 1:47 a.m. on Aug. 29, the day the storm hit, according to an e-mail cover sheet accompanying the document.
The NISAC paper warned that a storm of Katrina’s size would "likely lead to severe flooding and/or levee breaching" and specifically noted the potential for levee failures along Lake Pontchartrain. . . .
In a second document. . . a computer slide presentation by the Federal Emergency Management Agency, prepared for a 9 a.m. meeting on Aug. 27, two days before Katrina made landfall, compared Katrina’s likely impact to that of "Hurricane Pam," a fictional Category 3 storm used in a series of FEMA disaster-preparedness exercises simulating the effects of a major hurricane striking New Orleans. But Katrina, the report warned, could be worse.
The hurricane’s Category 4 storm surge "could greatly overtop levees and protective systems" and destroy nearly 90 percent of city structures, the FEMA report said. It further predicted "incredible search and rescue needs (60,000-plus)" and the displacement of more than a million residents.
So, that’s four days notice—or six days before those helicopter drivers got to work—but the “Hurricane Pam” simulation, that was done a full year before Katrina.
But why stop there? Bush was actually warned about the problem with the New Orleans levees over four years before Katrina; his response:
Funding for flood prevention was slashed by 80 per cent, work on strengthening levees to protect the city was stopped for the first time in 37 years, and planning for housing stranded citizens and evacuating refugees from the Superdome were crippled. Yet the administration had been warned repeatedly of the dangers by its own officials.
In early 2001, at the start of Mr Bush’s presidency, his Government’s Federal Emergency Management Agency (Fema) warned that a hurricane hitting New Orleans would be the deadliest of the three most likely catastrophes facing America; the others were a massive San Francisco earthquake and, prophetically, a terrorist attack on New York.
So, I guess, in a manner of speaking, his “response” wasn’t slow at all—Bush laid the groundwork for those wonderful rooftop photo-ops four years in advance.
This sort of truth-squading could be done with just about every response Bush gave in his presser. And it should be done, not just today, but for every instance of Bush legacy burnishing we will be forced to endure, push back on, fight, and re-fight for many years to come. Though it might be rare to see the burnishing this unvarnished, it has been made apparent from these instant re-writes on current events, through the neocons’ Vietnam revisionism, to the recent attempts to trash-talk the New Deal that nothing is safe or sacred.
Certainly not the truth.
. . . .
On a related point, nothing exemplifies just what a petty, egomaniacal, vindictive jerk this president was, is, and will always be than his treatment of Helen Thomas. Bush had stopped calling on Thomas long ago, the White House press office even tried to take away her front row seat—a “punishment” for asking tough questions—but to not give her the honor of the first or last question at his final presser was, to my mind, classless.



58 Comments












Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Firedoglake
Pathetic man!
Alcoholic.
This is pure alcoholic behavior, top to bottom. Whether he’s actually drinking now, I don’t know, but he’s an alcoholic who has never had any underlying treatment, and this is exactly what it looks and sounds like.
Never ending denial.
GTFO and Stay Gone!
Worthless cretin, he makes Gollum look sane.
Well, he’ll always be number one in our hearts.
;>)
Bush is to Classless what Helen Thomas is to Good reporting.
I was just thinking, I’d like to see Obama give Thomas the first question at his first presidential presser. That would say a lot of good things, and would be a great FU to the Bush Bunch.
You got that right!
My first, stunned reaction was that he was sloshed.
Don’t forget, Georgie boy, that your pals from gun carrying, black people killing, Blackwater were johnny on the spot in the swanky neighborhoods.
Fuckery.
Black people loot while white people take stuff to survive.
Fuckery.
make it stop, already.
the only time i want to hear this idiot speak, again, is in his trial.
New Orleans was set up to fail Hurricane Katrina as The World Trade Center Towers were set up to fail Bin Laden. The Bush Administration set up the USA to fail. It was not an accident that all these failures have occurred. Our governmental system has been made to fail by design by Reagan Walker Bush and and some Clinton.
Last ride on AF 1 …………………. check
Last presser ……………………… check
Last screw up ……………………..
Last wake up in white house …………
188 hrs & 59 min
Maybe there’ll be a rooftop rescue from the WH, just ahead of the angry crowds.
Dubya knows where his heart is. Its in his chest. He gestures to it as explains the challenges of dealing with changing people’s hearts. This is a sign of brilliance and eloquence.
I just got through reading the transcript of Bush’s presser. I liked the chopper driver comments. Here are some other “favorite” moments.
http://www.whitehouse.gov/news…..90112.html
I noticed Helen Thomas in her front-row seat and kept waiting to see if Bush would call on her. He called many names, but not her’s. I wonder if he feels more macho now for treating her as if she were invisible.
All his blather about welcoming differing opinions is painted as a black lie by his actions once again.
Bush must have one of those fun-house mirrors if he can look into it with pride.
Drunk, belligerent, obnoxious, racist, arrogant, awful.
How did we ever do this to the world?
I will NEVER forget an interview with an official in New Orleans who talked about his director of emergency services who hadn’t left the headquarters in a week after Katrina.
The director’s mother was in a nursing home.
She called him on the Monday and said that the water was rising and they needed help. He called FEMA, who said they were coming. He told his mom “They’re coming, Mama.” They didn’t come Monday.
She called on Tuesday. He called FEMA, who again told him they would go and rescue the people. He told his mom “They’re coming, Mama.” They didn’t come Tuesday.
She called in a panic again on Wednesday. He called FEMA yet again and they said they were going to rescue the people. He again told his mom “They’re coming, Mama.” They didn’t come on Wednesday.
She called again on Thursday, pleading for help. He called FEMA yet again and they, yet again said they would be there. He reassured his mom that they were coming. They didn’t come on Thursday.
On Friday, ALL of the residents of the nursing home drowned, including the man’s mother. FEMA never came.
With a broken heart,
Heather
Because just enough folks decided they’d like to have a beer with the Frat Boy that the SCOTUS could then step in and anoint him.
SWEET!
Pshaw – It’s a perfectly respectable Republican fun-house mirror.
;>)
Bush is headed to his version of heaven, a gated community in Dallas, a zoo for the rich. He will be a small man forever, having done little for his country except to waste its resources. I sure there is a small rock at Mt. Rushmore we can carve his likeness under.
Better yet he just thinks it is a roof top recue but actually the first leg on a trip to the Hague.
188 hrs & 49 min
Chopper “drivers”…Bush must’ve been thinkin’ “Hells Angels”. Someone definitely needs to do a brain scan on this guy. If he can’t come up with the word “pilot” there has to be some Alzheimers or other neurological problem going on here. The guy, after all, was a pilot. But perhaps it’s drug/alcohol-related damage to his long-term memory centers.
“…but to not give her the honor of the first or last question at his final presser was, to my mind, classless.” And yet, totally consistent – anyone who disagreed with him got cut off at the knees; anyone who was not a fawning sycophant was squeezed out. ‘Thrown under the bus’ was a phrase that we all learned a lot about. I think it completely consistent with his treatment of the Obama family in terms of their wish to take a residence within Blair House so that the girls could get settled in school. This is someone who has never in his whole existence behaved in a way to make anyone think that he cared what anyone else thought or felt – he has never had to face consequences for his actions or words. He’s been a stupid, incompetent jerk frat boy from probably the age of 12 onwards. He’s been protected, coddled, spoiled, and protected forever. And unfortunately, he will have gotten away with the past 8 years as well.
That was the director of Emergency Operations in Jefferson Parish. His mother was in a nursing home in St. Bernard Parish.
The nursing home owners were prosecuted for the loss of life in the nursing home. I am pretty sure this was the case. Those folks should have been evacuated, but that does not obsolve FEMA of failing to go and rescue those people when they said they would.
http://blog.nola.com/davewalke…..al_ba.html
{{{Speeew}}} ROTFL!
He does appear to be sloshing his words. And what a pathetic answer to the question of timelyness in rescuing the “30,000″ people from their rooftops. Where does the “30,000″ come from?
This idiot is in total denile.
Clueless in DC.
Gregg, thank you so much for listening to this jerk’s presser. I can no longer tolerate listening to his voice or the trash talk he puts out.
Thanks very much for the details. The horror of what happened and the note in his voice and tears in his eyes haunt me.
With gratitude and in sadness,
Heather
There is an incredible unreality about the Bush presser. One of the reporters even asked him about “Bush derangement syndrome” a term applied by Charles Krauthammer to Bush’s critics.
It breaks Godwin’s law but I couldn’t get the image out of head reading the transcript of a bunch of fawning reporters asking der Fuehrer in his bunker if he thought he had made any mistakes and how he felt about some of the language used by his deranged critics. It apparently has not entered the darkest dreams of these media saps that the President they have been so assiduously fellating for all these years is the worst in our history.
Yeah cause Plame’s shop busted his attempt to sneak them across the border.
New Orleans will never be the same. Many are still in post Katrina dismay. Breaks my heart to visit. Sometimes I want to go back to live there. Sometimes.
Gawd iz mah co-driver…
Helen’s still around and bush is gonna be gone…there’s a very small degree of justice about that.
Heee heee heee haaaa
And in terms of the decisions that I had made to protect the homeland, I wouldn’t worry about popularity. What I would worry about is the Constitution of the United States, and putting plans in place that makes it easier to find out what the enemy is thinking, because all these debates will matter not if there’s another attack on the homeland. The question won’t be, you know, were you critical of this plan or not; the question is going to be, why didn’t you do something?
The US has not been attacked by the bad guys since Septyember 11, 2001 because all they have had to do is sit back and watch us inplode from the inside. Yes, we have not been attacked again because of shrub. He led this great nation into moral, ethical and monetary bankruptcy.
Good job, shrub.
The double entendre here is wonderful. Bushco has worried about the Constitution. They worried over how they could disregard it while concurrently avoiding prosecution and impeachment.
We, The People, Some of Us, worry about the abuses that our Constitution has suffered and we worry if Obama and the new Congress will care to repair the damages.
Bush alludes to his Domestic Spying, Torture, withheld Habeus Corpus, Secret prisons, Extraordinary Rendition, Yoonitary Executive Powers – all unconstitutional.
Does Dubya he mean to say that the Constitution should be disregarded so that these methods can continue? That would be the only interpretation that makes any sense. The Constitution impeded Bush’s Torture Toolkit.
Chopper “drivers”…Bush must’ve been thinkin’ “Hells Angels”. Someone definitely needs to do a brain scan on this guy.
I think it is an indication that despite his attempt to portray himself as relaxed both with his exit and his legacy he was highly stressed by both. Well, that and that he is an idiot.
Let me clear that up for you. He SAYS he no longer drinks.
Pictures all over web show him drinking and articles point out that he is/was drinking alcohol at functions all over the world.
Then there’s this…………….
Do the math.
I think he’s a loadie from WAY BACK.
he has never had to face consequences for his actions or words
Absolutely correct. This is a defining best definingdescription of shrub I’ve ever heard/read in the last 8 years.
I’ll be using it often. Thanks!
Hopefully President Obama will call on her first during his first press conference. In a perfect world FOX News would be banished to the hallway.
Why all the long faces?
That should be just about the last time I have to see, hear or read much more of anything that inarticulate clusterfuck of mish mash has to say,except, Guilty, your Honor.
Dream on – expect him to say everybody made me do it your honor.
188 hrs & 26 min
Thanks for nothing Jesus for sticking us with this cretin.
It was interesting that the Bush presser was on ALL the national and cable channels BUT my local Faux…… couldn’t get away from him…… except with the off button….
“I haven’t denied anything.”
;>)
Ah!
Hello katymine!
I missed your greeting the other day.
George Bush Doesn’t Care About Black People
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2elYnsqG-MM
Last time I heard “reconstruction” of New Orleans was considered a great opportunity for Chimpy and his friends. And how many public schools are there in New Orleans now compared with pre Katrina? Here’s an absolutely glowing review of charter school biz from the NYT. I can’t help but think Shock Doctrine.
But it seems those subject make chimpy squeamish. Luv the non-sequitur, from New Orleans to Obama.
Actually, the impression I’ve been getting is that faux noise *isn’t* getting their usual access; hope that’s really true.
Including this one, clearly.
IIRC, didn’t one of the guys doing the rooftop rescues end up getting reprimanded by the CIC’s military?
I take it back – now that I’ve done “teh google” it appears there were 2 and they were “counseled”
http://articles.latimes.com/20…..na-copter8
And assigned to a kennel instead of rescue missions – not that being demoted from flying rescues to scooping poop should in any way be deemed a retaliation.
There are guys who deserve a medal
Yes, Bush has no right to be “indignant” at criticism of his handling or mishandling of New Orleans.
How does he say this with a straight face?
@54 was not a snark. Chimpy is really despicably cavalier about loss of life and property.
you know that book “Moby Dick”?
well, Old Captain Ahab hated that whale for a buttload of reasons the least of which was a lifetime of hatred. well, what we have here is Ahab Junior. he hates the whale because the whale’s always been hated – he’s got nothing invested in it. it’s a knee-jerk media hatred that has nothing to do with Joe’s Experience. he hates the media because it’s the great white whale – he’s supposed to hate it. it’s expected of him.
they don’t make “American Heroes” like they used to!
Good job – I remember that story now.
Bush failed to mention how, whenever his plane came within 100 miles of NOLA, all helicopter rescues and other airborne relief activities had to come to a halt for security reasons.